Education in Divided Societies Network: the role of school collaboration in societies emerging from conflict

Lead Research Organisation: Queen's University Belfast
Department Name: Sch of Social Sci, Edu & Social Work

Abstract

Societies emerging from conflict, or conflict-affected, often find it difficult to secure peace: there may be challenges in dealing with the legacy of conflict and in finding a cohesive approach to building a better and safer future. In many of these societies school systems are also divided, or have become so, which appears to render the challenges even more difficult. The Education in Divided Societies Network (EDS-N+) project aims to use the transformative potential of collaboration in education to help address these challenges, with the foci of collaboration involving teachers within schools, teachers between schools from different communities, and teachers working across different jurisdictions.

With the support of the GCRF Development Award, we will begin co-constructing a strategic network of key educational stakeholders in Northern Ireland (NI), Lebanon, Jordan, North Macedonia, Bosnia & Herzegovina (BiH), and Kosovo, all of whom work on peace building through education. The network will eventually co-create and co-support projects and activities that seek to address these key challenges. It will look to connect learning and different systems of knowledge around the teaching of history and civics to inform pedagogical change and social empowerment. The EDS-N+ network will support opportunities for collaboration between local, national and international school networks to enhance the social impact of public education, and improve access to quality education for young people, especially those from lower socio-economic groups. Collaboration across the layered networks of educators will enable curriculum and pedagogical innovation to be explored in a joined-up way, providing spaces for dialogue where expertise and experience can be shared, new learning achieved, and educational and social goals pursued. The focus on the teaching of history and civics is important as these are areas of the curriculum that go to the heart of identity and social practice, while the focus on transversal competences highlights the wider educational environment and the experiential opportunities provided to students.

The opportunity provided by the GCRF Development Award will be used to address a number of priorities over two stages of work. In summary, the first stage will involve the wider project group meeting in order to enhance and finalise the full stage proposal in the light of feedback from the outline stage. We will also continue the process of team-building amongst the wider project group and begin the process of expanding the group. In the second stage, two further meetings will be held in the Middle East and South East Europe to which local ODA country stakeholders will be invited. We will start to build and scale wider networks of educators and policy makers, and begin discussions with stakeholders on the key needs and priorities within and across the two regions. During this phase we will also start developing plans for the implementation phase after the final decisions on GCRF Network Plus submissions are made.

Planned Impact

In the outline stage of the GCRF Network Plus submission we noted that the international nature of the EDS-N+ network made it essential that our impact strategy was cognisant of different cultural, political, and social facets, and that this required tailoring to local contexts in cooperation with local partners. The intention was that this would be informed by early stage discussions and scoping exercises, taking into account the varying policy contexts, needs and agendas of LMIC partners. The Development Award provides an opportunity to initiate this work before final decisions on the GCRF Network Plus awards are made. The Development Award, at this initial stage, will contribute to the co-design process of the EDS-N+ 'pathway to impact', and second, the Award will be utilised for scaling connections between different LMIC stakeholders, to enable effective and coherent implementation of the EDS-N+ 'pathway to impact' strategy.

The two primary groups of beneficiaries of the Development Award activities will be academics located in ODA partner jurisdictions and local stakeholders from ODA partner jurisdictions-that is, the Middle East and South East Europe. One of the key objectives for the Development Award is to explore ways in which resources and responsibilities can be shifted to colleagues in LMICs and help develop capacity in those jurisdictions, in line with feedback from the outline stage.

The Development Award will support three meetings: one of the wider project group members and two that will engage with local stakeholders in the partner regions. During these meetings, discussions will focus on the key needs and priorities in the ODA jurisdictions, the types of 'impact' that stakeholders hope to achieve, and explore the wider inequalities experienced within education in the partner regions (e.g. gender, ethnicity, language, ability, etc.)-we expect that these conversations will refine our Pathway to Impact and theory of change for the EDS-N+ network. Additionally, these meetings will provide an opportunity to lay the foundations for scaling the networks of LMIC stakeholders.

The two meetings in the partner regions will support team-building among the wider project group and include representatives from the NGOs that have already committed support for the project. This will likely be the first opportunity that the wider group will have had to meet and an initial priority will be to inform the wider team on initiatives and learning from each of the jurisdictions, with specific commissioned presentations on the education and policy contexts in the LMIC regions. Representatives from UNESCO and the Council of Europe (CoE) will also be invited to talk about their guidance materials on global citizenship and the framework for democratic competences, both of which are relevant for the EDS-N+ theory of change. This has the potential of exploring the implications of global policy frameworks across both LMIC partner regions and the benefit of connecting local LMIC stakeholders into arenas of international policy development.

One of the important aspects of the meetings will be to initiate discussions and collaborations between local LMIC stakeholders, who may or may not chose to participate in the EDS-N+ network. These potential connections will provide the building blocks of scaling up EDS-N+ activities in LMICs, as NGOs and other local LMIC stakeholders begin working together on commissioned projects. The regional meetings will provide an opportunity for local LMIC stakeholders to think about more joined-up and coherent delivery approaches that could reduce the cost of interventions and increase their reach-thereby enhancing local community outcomes and impacts.
 
Description The project aimed to develop a larger proposal focused on school collaboration across a range of jurisdictions. A series of planned in-country meetings would not take place as a consequence of the covid-19 crisis, but there have been regular virtual meetings. Three workshops were held virtually and four paper were completed. A proposal was submitted within the GCRF+ process.
Exploitation Route There are no good lessons emerging from this experience and it was necessary to restore good relationships with colleagues in Kosovo and Lebanon after the UK government's decision to cut funding for the GCRF+ programme.
Sectors Education

 
Description We have engaged with teachers in Lebanon to explore the impact of a series of school-based projects focused on the teaching of history. The goal was to expand their capacity as part of an on-going series of workshops in related themes. Other virtual workshops run through the project contributed to policy discussion on teacher education in Kosovo, the role of teachers in Northern Ireland and Lebanon during the covid crisis, and presentations of evidence of the impact of covid on secondary, teritary and adult education in Lebanon. It has also contributed to processes related to the formulation of education strategy in Kosovo. Since the last reporting period we have contributed to the development of a new education strategy for Kosovo. This is part of the on-going work to deal with the knock-on effects of the government decision to withdraw support for work under this theme.
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Education
Impact Types Societal,Policy & public services

 
Description Istanbul meeting 
Organisation American University of Madaba
Country Jordan 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution From August 4-7 2019 we held the first meeting of the GCRF Network Plus team through the Development Award in Istanbul, Turkey. They venue was chosen as it was close to the ODA countries participating in the project and avoided problems associated with visa permissions. The particiipants included seven colleagues from Queen's University; and one from: Birminghalm University, England; Notre Dame University-Louize, Beirut; Rochester Institute of Technology, Pristina, Kosovo; Violeta Petroska-Beska, University of St. Cyril and Methodius, Skopje, North Macedonia; and American University of Madaba, Amman, Jordan. The purpose of the meeting, as specified in the Development Award Proposal, was to met to finalise the details of the final proposal to be submitted for a GCRF Network Plus Award. The days of the meeting were used intensively to discuss the various isses related to the detailed proposal, with follow-up meetings conducted using email and skype. The proposal was ultimatelt submitted by the deadline, but it was unsuccessful. The Development Award Proposal had included funding to support two additional meetings, one in Beirut and one in Kosovo, and both of these are being organised as part of the conmtinuing Development Award work.
Collaborator Contribution Each of the research team members contributed to the discussion on the various parts of the draft proposal and responded to drafts which were ciruclated subsequent to the meeting.
Impact The primary output was a final proposal submitted for a GCRF Network Plus full award. The proposal was unsuccessful.
Start Year 2019
 
Description Istanbul meeting 
Organisation Notre Dame University – Louaize
Country Lebanon 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution From August 4-7 2019 we held the first meeting of the GCRF Network Plus team through the Development Award in Istanbul, Turkey. They venue was chosen as it was close to the ODA countries participating in the project and avoided problems associated with visa permissions. The particiipants included seven colleagues from Queen's University; and one from: Birminghalm University, England; Notre Dame University-Louize, Beirut; Rochester Institute of Technology, Pristina, Kosovo; Violeta Petroska-Beska, University of St. Cyril and Methodius, Skopje, North Macedonia; and American University of Madaba, Amman, Jordan. The purpose of the meeting, as specified in the Development Award Proposal, was to met to finalise the details of the final proposal to be submitted for a GCRF Network Plus Award. The days of the meeting were used intensively to discuss the various isses related to the detailed proposal, with follow-up meetings conducted using email and skype. The proposal was ultimatelt submitted by the deadline, but it was unsuccessful. The Development Award Proposal had included funding to support two additional meetings, one in Beirut and one in Kosovo, and both of these are being organised as part of the conmtinuing Development Award work.
Collaborator Contribution Each of the research team members contributed to the discussion on the various parts of the draft proposal and responded to drafts which were ciruclated subsequent to the meeting.
Impact The primary output was a final proposal submitted for a GCRF Network Plus full award. The proposal was unsuccessful.
Start Year 2019
 
Description Istanbul meeting 
Organisation Rochester Institute of Technology
Country United States 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution From August 4-7 2019 we held the first meeting of the GCRF Network Plus team through the Development Award in Istanbul, Turkey. They venue was chosen as it was close to the ODA countries participating in the project and avoided problems associated with visa permissions. The particiipants included seven colleagues from Queen's University; and one from: Birminghalm University, England; Notre Dame University-Louize, Beirut; Rochester Institute of Technology, Pristina, Kosovo; Violeta Petroska-Beska, University of St. Cyril and Methodius, Skopje, North Macedonia; and American University of Madaba, Amman, Jordan. The purpose of the meeting, as specified in the Development Award Proposal, was to met to finalise the details of the final proposal to be submitted for a GCRF Network Plus Award. The days of the meeting were used intensively to discuss the various isses related to the detailed proposal, with follow-up meetings conducted using email and skype. The proposal was ultimatelt submitted by the deadline, but it was unsuccessful. The Development Award Proposal had included funding to support two additional meetings, one in Beirut and one in Kosovo, and both of these are being organised as part of the conmtinuing Development Award work.
Collaborator Contribution Each of the research team members contributed to the discussion on the various parts of the draft proposal and responded to drafts which were ciruclated subsequent to the meeting.
Impact The primary output was a final proposal submitted for a GCRF Network Plus full award. The proposal was unsuccessful.
Start Year 2019
 
Description Istanbul meeting 
Organisation University of Birmingham
Department Birmingham University Imaging Centre (BUIC)
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution From August 4-7 2019 we held the first meeting of the GCRF Network Plus team through the Development Award in Istanbul, Turkey. They venue was chosen as it was close to the ODA countries participating in the project and avoided problems associated with visa permissions. The particiipants included seven colleagues from Queen's University; and one from: Birminghalm University, England; Notre Dame University-Louize, Beirut; Rochester Institute of Technology, Pristina, Kosovo; Violeta Petroska-Beska, University of St. Cyril and Methodius, Skopje, North Macedonia; and American University of Madaba, Amman, Jordan. The purpose of the meeting, as specified in the Development Award Proposal, was to met to finalise the details of the final proposal to be submitted for a GCRF Network Plus Award. The days of the meeting were used intensively to discuss the various isses related to the detailed proposal, with follow-up meetings conducted using email and skype. The proposal was ultimatelt submitted by the deadline, but it was unsuccessful. The Development Award Proposal had included funding to support two additional meetings, one in Beirut and one in Kosovo, and both of these are being organised as part of the conmtinuing Development Award work.
Collaborator Contribution Each of the research team members contributed to the discussion on the various parts of the draft proposal and responded to drafts which were ciruclated subsequent to the meeting.
Impact The primary output was a final proposal submitted for a GCRF Network Plus full award. The proposal was unsuccessful.
Start Year 2019
 
Description Virtual seminar on the teaching of history and civics in Lebanon and Northern Ireland 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact This was a virtual workshop involved teachers, members of NGOs and members of the project team in Lebanon and Northern Ireland to discuss comparative approaches to the teaching of history and civics in the two societies.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
 
Description Virtual workshop for teachers from Northern Ireland and Beirut on the impact of covid 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact A workshop for a group of citizenship education teachers in Lebanon and Northern Ireland who during 2019 in Lebanon and later in Belfast when the group shared their beliefs of an ideal citizenship educational experience and experiences trying to realise this in the classroom. This workshop reflected the way the world had been transformed into a more isolating place with the global COVID-19 pandemic. They met on 13 November, 2020, to share the challenges and opportunities this pandemic has brought during school closures and extreme health and safety measures. During each round, a teacher from Lebanon and Northern Ireland will shared their stories and held an open discussion.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
 
Description Webinar on Education during the recent crises in Lebanon: impacts and responses 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The webinar was held on March 30, 2021, in Beirut, Lebanon, and included participants from the United Kingdom and Kosovo. Five presentations were made on themes relating to the impact of the covid crisis on schools in Lebanon and research studies looking at the way schools responded to these challenges. Dr. Erik van Ommering, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam & Caritas Austria, acted as a discussant for the webinar.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Webinar: Promoting peace building thruiogh education in conflict afflicted societiesL exploring potentials in Kosovo 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact This was a virtual webinar held in Prishtina, Kosovo, and included participants from Kosovo, the United Kingdom and Lebanon. The keybote speak was Dr Saqipi, University of Prishtina, and there were nine other speakers from Kosovo and the UK. The first half of the webinar was devoted to academic presentations, and in the second half presentations were given by representatives of municipal authorities, civic institutions and thirsd sector organisations in Kosovo.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021