Elephant conservation and indigenous experiences in Cambodia: Shaping environmental awareness through participatory filmmaking with young people

Lead Research Organisation: University of Bath
Department Name: Social and Policy Sciences

Abstract

This project will deepen and extend the impact of our original research "Participatory Filmmaking and the Anlong Veng Peace Tours", which was a 'proof of concept' pilot developed and delivered through the Cambodia strand of the AHRC Network Plus grant "Changing the Story: Building Inclusive Societies with, and for, Young People in 5 Post-Conflict Countries". The follow on funding for impact will apply the successful methods developed during the original project in collaboration with two new Cambodian partners, the Bophana Audio Visual Center (Bophana) and Elephant Livelihood Initiative (ELIE), to extend the reach of the original project to address urgent challenges for environmental conservation and indigenous communities in Cambodia. In the original research, we found that participatory filmmaking could empower young Cambodians as agents and beneficiaries of change by encouraging ownership of Cambodia's histories of war and atrocity, and building dialogue and empathy across divided communities. In particular, we saw young people using their own films as grassroots advocacy tools as they disseminated them across and within their own networks. While the original research focused on issues of post-conflict reconciliation for younger generations in Cambodia, our findings highlighted important outstanding relationships concerning legacies of conflict, transitions from war to peace, and harms inflicted on the environment, particularly in terms of deforestation and wildlife loss. Thus, the primary aims of this follow on funding project is to deploy our successful participatory filmmaking methodology to encourage young people to take ownership and actively engage with conservation issues, and to amplify awareness of environmental challenges across communities.

Cambodia's forty years of conflict have left a legacy of environmental harms, including wildlife reduction, deforestation and the loss of cultural heritage informing locally grounded approaches to forest management. Cambodia's transition to peace and subsequent development has witnessed unsustainable environmental exploitation and widespread environmental harms. Deforestation during and after conflict has caused further loss of rare and endangered wildlife and wild elephant numbers, in particular, have sharply declined as a consequence of the loss of their natural habitats. Indigenous communities, who have close cultural and spiritual relationships to elephants, suffer particularly as a marginalised group within wider Cambodian society and subject to unsustainable development pressures affecting the forests that they reside in. Conservation practice around elephant habitats, and issues facing indigenous communities who live alongside elephants, therefore offers a key site through which to encourage active engagement with wider environmental and development challenges in Cambodia.

The project has been designed in dialogue with the Bophana Center and ELIE to complement each partner's strategic objectives. The Bophana Center is committed to training a new generation of young Cambodian filmmakers, while ELIE's mission is to conserve the natural habitats of elephants while providing support for indigenous communities around them. Through the recruitment of 12 young people, who will be trained in co-productive and participatory filmmaking methods, the project will deliver 3 films that can be used as advocacy tools, highlighting exemplary conservation practice, environmental challenges, and issues facing marginalised indigenous communities through field visits to ELIE sites. These films will be constitute the centrepiece of an impact and dissemination strategy that will raise awareness of environmental challenges through screenings in indigenous communities, screenings facing conservation practitioners, submission for international film festivals, and a social media training program for the young filmmakers to disseminate their films as advocacy tools.

Planned Impact

The project has been designed with our two project partners: the Bophana Audio Visual Resource Center and the Elephant Livelihood Environment Initiative. It is based on the needs and priorities within the communities that the partners engage to ensure long term and sustainable impact. The project aims to deliver three types of impact:

1. Shaping empathetic environmental awareness - the project is designed to generate high quality impact through the production of films that centre the voices of indigenous people and conservation practitioners to highlight environmental challenges. In doing so, we will produce films that can be mobilised as grassroots advocacy tools to raise awareness of environmental harms, such as deforestation, and the attendant loss of elephant and other wildlife habitats. Active engagement with environmental issues across communities will build empathetic relationships based on the recognition of shared concerns for development challenges. We have integrated a bespoke social media training program to maximise impact as we situate young filmmakers as agents and beneficiaries of change, who will 'multiply' the messages of their films within and across networks.

2. Demonstrating exemplary conservation practice and embedding conservation norms- our dissemination and awareness raising strategy is targeted at inculcating, embedding and promoting conservation norms at local, national and international levels. Films will highlight exemplary conservation practice and the importance of habitat conservation at screenings and dialogue events for indigenous and provincial communities, at screenings to targeted national and civil society stakeholders in Phnom Penh. The films' submission for screening at international events will further highlight the environmental and development challenges facing Cambodia to an international audience.

3. Building arts-led capacity - the project services the immediate need for increasing arts and filmmaking capacity. Firstly, in conjunction with our partner the Bophana Audio Visual Center, the project will help build a new generation of filmmakers in Cambodia, who can take authorship of urgent cross-community stories about environmental and development challenges affecting them. In doing so, the project immediately provides transferable skills and supports their longer-term employability. Secondly, through the deployment of co-productive and participatory methods, we will transfer new and innovative methodological approaches and skills to our project partners. These will be consolidated in a "making of" documentary and a briefing report reflecting on the strengths of co-productive and participatory approaches for awareness raising around social and environmental issues.
 
Title Dull Trail 
Description Blind in one eye and traumatized from years of war and American bombs, Mae Neng the elephant learns to accept the love of her kind caretaker Da Chroed in Mondulkiri province. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact The film has been disseminated at several events to indigenous communities and key policy stakeholders. These have included staff from: the Cambodian Ministry of Culture, the Cambodian Ministry of Environment, key donors including USAID, and diplomatic staff from the Swedish and British Embassies. The films have been published on DVD and allocated as resources for community and educational use at the Modulkiri Indigenous Documentation Center and the Center for the Study of Humanitarian Law. The filmmakers are currently undergoing social media training to amplify a further campaign around animal welfare, and environment and indigenous issues. Further screenings will be held for key policy audiences, including at the British Embassy in Phnom Penh. The films will be permanently embedded on project partner websites, including as an advocacy tool for awareness raising about animal welfare on the ELIE website. 
URL https://vimeo.com/488352126
 
Title Memories 
Description Directed by PAOV Theang, SAT Sreytoch, SOUS Sonan, 2020, 14mn 15s, Bunong and Khmer version with English subtitles As a matriarch in Mondulkiri province, Preng Chanthy strives to maintain the traditions of her indigenous community - including caring for the local elephants and brewing rice wine to offer to spirits - while passing her wisdom on to the next generation. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact The film has been disseminated at several events to indigenous communities and key policy stakeholders. These have included staff from: the Cambodian Ministry of Culture, the Cambodian Ministry of Environment, key donors including USAID, and diplomatic staff from the Swedish and British Embassies. The films have been published on DVD and allocated as resources for community and educational use at the Modulkiri Indigenous Documentation Center and the Center for the Study of Humanitarian Law. The filmmakers are currently undergoing social media training to amplify a further campaign around animal welfare, and environment and indigenous issues. Further screenings will be held for key policy audiences, including at the British Embassy in Phnom Penh. The films will be permanently embedded on project partner websites, including as an advocacy tool for awareness raising about animal welfare on the ELIE website. 
URL https://vimeo.com/488355447
 
Title My Home 
Description Directed by CHOUN Sopheana, MECH Choulay, YAM Sopheak, MEAN Sochetra, CHHEAN Pisen, 2020, 28mn 34s, Bunong and Khmer version with English subtitles Chheol Thouk never wanted to be anything else but a mahout and he roams the forest tending to his elephants. But the natural habitat in Mondulkiri province shrinking due to deforestation -- threatening the elephants, their ecosystem and Chheol's way of life. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact The film has been disseminated at several events to indigenous communities and key policy stakeholders. These have included staff from: the Cambodian Ministry of Culture, the Cambodian Ministry of Environment, key donors including USAID, and diplomatic staff from the Swedish and British Embassies. The films have been published on DVD and allocated as resources for community and educational use at the Modulkiri Indigenous Documentation Center and the Center for the Study of Humanitarian Law. The filmmakers are currently undergoing social media training to amplify a further campaign around animal welfare, and environment and indigenous issues. Further screenings will be held for key policy audiences, including at the British Embassy in Phnom Penh. The films will be permanently embedded on project partner websites, including as an advocacy tool for awareness raising about animal welfare on the ELIE website. 
URL https://vimeo.com/488357760
 
Title Participatory Film and Elephant Conservation in Cambodia - Project Reflections 
Description This film documents the development and progress of the Elephant Conservation project 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2020 
Impact The film documents lessons from the training and film activity on the project. It has been show as an introduction to the project films at several key policy facing events. 
URL https://vimeo.com/427963463
 
Title Participatory Film and Elephant Conservation in Cambodia - Project Reflections (2021) 
Description The film offers reflections on project progress as we move into a dissemination phase around the key project outputs. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact The film documents challenges and offers lessons around the implementation of participatory film initiatives in Cambodia 
URL https://vimeo.com/519923149?fbclid=IwAR2Yq3FgHjPdIXmgIu_ZIRguVv5iJOfAgJbUXpfynpnYzmgTfZEuHDWtL30
 
Description Despite facing significant disruption arising from the COVID-19 pandemic, the project demonstrated great potential in supporting work on environmental, conservation and indigenous issues in Cambodia and beyond. At the heart of the project was the aim of training teams of young Cambodians, in partnership with the Elephant Livelihood Environment Initiative and Bophana Center, to produce three documentary films about environmental and indigenous issues in Cambodia. We found that centring young people in the creative process has facilitated a powerful platform from which to produce films with strong messages around animal welfare, environmental protection, and the importance of cultural sensitivity and antiracism. The project has reached a critical phase as we turn to embed the impact of a) the participatory filmmaking methods deployed on the project and b) the potential of the films produced as advocacy tools.

We can reflect on several key achievements at this stage in the project:

- The films are a significant achievement because they have been produced within indigenous communities and through the local indigenous language. We have held three key screening events so far. A film premier was held in February 2021 in Putrom, Modulkiri (the locale that hosted field activity). This screening reflected and realised an ethical commitment of the project, in that indigenous communities should have ownership of the representation of indigenous issues. At a second screening in February 2021, which included attendees from USAID, the Embassy of Sweden, and local news organisations, the Cambodian Secretary of State for the Ministry if Culture remarked that the films represent "artefacts" that can themselves preserve and protect the language, culture and traditions of indigenous communities. We will continue to work with Bophana, ELIE, the Ministry of Culture to ensure that the films have a long term, sustainable and accessible presence for indigenous Cambodians.

- The films are methodologically important because they challenge the boundaries of 'insiders' and 'outsiders' that tends to be at work in participatory methods. Through ongoing project evaluation, the young Cambodians we trained in filmmaking reported attitudinal change as they learned more about and built relationships with the indigenous communities that they worked with. In turn, the strong environmental and animal welfare messages from the film were recognised to transcend local indigenous and Khmer communities, and have implications across regional and global contexts (e.g. deforestation was recognised as a local and global challenge). We will continue to work with the young people to enable them to champion the strong environmental and antiracist messages and work that is reflected in the films through further training in advocacy and campaigning.

- A third screening was held at with attendees from key stakeholders including Diakonia (Sweden's development service), Cambodian NGOs, and Embassy staff. The British Ambassador, H.E. Tina Redshaw, has requested a screening at the British Embassy in Phnom Penh. This shows the importance and potential of the films as advocacy tools that can amplify awareness around Cambodia's (and international) environmental challenges. Our project partners (ELIE and Bophana) are keen to continue using teh films going forward as advocacy tools, with ELIE embedding the films with a permanent presence on their website, and Bophana in dialogue with the Ministry of Education and Ministry of Environment around the prospective use of the films as educational resources. We will continue to work to multiply and expand dissemination of the films in these key policy circles and to wider public audiences (in March 2021 we began a programme of submitting the films to key international and policy facing film festivals).

- Finally, the bespoke training programme porvided to the young participants has been a significant success. Several participants now intend to pursue careers in documentary film. One participant has already successfuly secured small grant capture (Cambodia Media Grant) following her involvement in the project.

Our plans for dissemination and impact have been affected by the ongoing challenges around the pandemic e.g. we have principally been confined to online screening and engagement events, which makes attitudinal change among users and audiences harder to gaude. However, we will work to continue to embed impact, especially as restrictions ease, and have secured funding for subsequent events that target key user communities (e.g. indigenous heritage bodies and key public libraries in Cambodia).

We are confident that, despite the challenges of the COVID-19 crisis, our objectives have been substantively met.
Exploitation Route We hope our research will be of benefit to the communities with whom we are working and also to policy makers at regional, national and transnational levels.
Sectors Education,Environment,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

 
Description As of March 2023, the full impact of the project is being consolidated. From February 2020, we trained a group of 12 young Cambodians through a bespoke participatory filmmaking programme led by the Bophana Center, while providing accompany workshops and education on environmental challenges in Cambodia. This was followed by field activity and shooting over the summer of 2020, and post-production training in late 2020. The films were finalised in February 2021 and we engaged a wider dissemination strategy - principally through online screenings and events. We saw significant interest for uptake and use by the Cambodian government (Ministries of Education, Culture, and Environment), and Cambodian and international NGOs. We also engaged the UK DCMS in a briefing and screening as the UK government prepared for the COP26. We supported the young people on the project in anticipation of use of the films in campaigning and advocacy through social media training. As of March 2022, we had secured further funding to target key user groups through 2022 (public libraries and indigenous heritage organisations) to permanently install and make available our films for public and advocacy user groups. We have further built impact around the initial three project films, including dissemination (official selections) at the Cambodia International Film Festival and the proposed inclusion of the films in the Bangkok-UNESCO online repository of indigenous cultural materials.
First Year Of Impact 2020
Sector Creative Economy,Education,Environment,Government, Democracy and Justice,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal,Policy & public services

 
Description Cultural Heritage, Climate Change, and Human Rights
Geographic Reach Multiple continents/international 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
 
Description Cambodia Media Grant
Amount € 1,500 (EUR)
Organisation Ministry of Foreign and European Affairs 
Sector Public
Country Luxembourg
Start 02/2021 
End 12/2021
 
Description Elephant conservation and indigenous experiences in Cambodia: Shaping environmental awareness through participatory filmmaking with young people (University of Bath Impact Fund - £4703.16)
Amount £4,703 (GBP)
Organisation University of Bath 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 01/2022 
End 07/2022
 
Description More-than-human: Contesting the exclusion of ecology in peacebuilding and transitional justice
Amount £60,000 (GBP)
Organisation Independent Social Research Foundation 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country United Kingdom
Start 02/2023 
End 02/2024
 
Description Bangkok UNESCO audiovisual archives with wiki tools 
Organisation United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization
Department UNESCO Bangkok Asia-Pacific Regional Bureau for Education
Country Thailand 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution We are in dialogue with Bophana Audio Visual Center and Bangkok UNESCO to include the three project films in the Bangkok UNESCO Indigenous Audiovisual Archives
Collaborator Contribution Bophana have facilitated this collaboration through their strong existing relationship with Bangkok UNESCO on the Indigenous Audiovisual Archives.
Impact As this is a very recent collaboration, anticipate outcomes to follow in the 2024 submission
Start Year 2023
 
Description Bophana Audiovisual Center 
Organisation Bophana Audiovisual Resource Center
Country Cambodia 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution UK Investigators briefed Bophana staff at key stages on project development, methods training, and research on environemental and conservation issues in Cambodia
Collaborator Contribution Bophana have been a key partner on the project, overseeing the practical training of young filmmakers involved.
Impact Project films: My Home, Dull Trail, Memories; Project reflections. The collaboration is multidisciplinary as it involves social science, ecology, and film and media practice.
Start Year 2019
 
Description Elephant Livelihood Environment Initiative 
Organisation Elephant Livelihood Environment Initiative
Country Cambodia 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution The films we have produced have raised awareness of ELIE's advocacy around forest conservation and animal welfare in Cambodia and South East Asia. Our project films will be hosted on the ELIE web pages going forward.
Collaborator Contribution ELIE staff briefed our participants on issues of animal welfare and hosted key field activities.
Impact The three key project films (Dull Trail, My Home, and Memories) were all filmed on site at ELIE's EVP sanctuary. The collaboration is multidisciplinary (film, ecology, sociology) and bridges research and practice.
Start Year 2019
 
Description Elephant conservation and indigenous experiences in Cambodia: Mobile Film Screening at Center for Khmer Studies, Siem Reap 
Organisation Center for Khmer Studies
Country United States 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution We worked with CKS to hold screening events to academics, students, and practitioners at the Center in Siem Reap.
Collaborator Contribution CKS hosted the event and facilitated invites to a diverse audience of academics, students, and practitioners.
Impact We anticipate further outcomes to follow for the 2024 submission
Start Year 2022
 
Description Elephant conservation and indigenous experiences in Cambodia: Shaping environmental awareness through participatory filmmaking with young people 
Organisation Center for Khmer Studies
Country United States 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Planned activities build on the GCRF project "Participatory film and elephant conservation in Cambodia" (2020-2021), which enabled young Cambodians to produce films exploring pressing environmental challenges in Cambodia. These include (and focus our impact strategy) on intersecting SDG challenges of deforestation, the loss of wildlife habitats and the experiences of stigmatised indigenous communities. The films produced represent powerful advocacy tools to address these. While the project has realised significant impact 'upward' to policy audiences and publics (films were used by the UK DMC to support preparation for COP26; film awards include "Best Environmental Impact"), work is required to embed and evaluate the impact of the project 'downward'. Proposed activities build two new partnerships with a) Center for Khmer Studies, a key academic and librarian user group and b) a key advocacy group, C ambodian Indigenous Peoples Organisation. Proposed activities: 1) screening events at CKS and CIPO to engage public, academic, and indigenous audiences living within 'at risk' forest areas. This will advertise the availability of the films in CKS and CIPO public library facilities (in areas home to a majority indigenous population) as advocacy tools for use by groups most affected by environmental challenges i.e. deforestation. These events will include 3) a survey of screening attendees to gauge attitudinal change on environmental harms, and to conduct "in reach" on the use of the films as advocacy tools.
Collaborator Contribution Center for Khmer Studies will host screening events to key library user groups (academics, activists, the public). Cambodian Indigenous People's Organisation will permanently install the three films produced on the project at archive and library spaces for indigenous communities in Eastern Cambodia, for ongoing use by indigenous peoples and school communities.
Impact Screening events will be held in May and June 2022. This is a necessarily interdisciplinary collaboration, enveloping arts led approaches to promoting lingustic and cultural heritage, environmental protection, and wildlife conservation.
Start Year 2022
 
Description Bath Minerva Public Lecture 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact I delivered the Minerva public lecture around a screening of the films.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.bath.ac.uk/events/elephants-and-environmental-activism-in-cambodia/
 
Description Documentary video produced by Bophana showing the living conditions of elephants and indigenous peoples 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Our screening events for the project "Partcipatory Film and Elephant Conservation" were covered in the Cambodian national press, raising awareness of the project and issues explored in our films.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.thmeythmey.com/?page=detail&id=100411&fbclid=IwAR2kyAw0TfqYWQEbv_k5s90w-755eeWuEdAO66hKw...
 
Description Film Screening - Modulkiri, Cambodia 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact We screened the three films produced on the project to approx. 120 indigenous community members and facilitated a Q&A discussion with filmmakers around local issues represented such as elephant welfare, deforestation, habitat loss. Local community members reflected on the importance of seeing their stories, issues and priorities acknowledged and represented in film.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Film Screening - Siem Reap, Cambodia 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Undergraduate students
Results and Impact We screened the three films produced on the project to approx. 120 academics and students at the Center for Khmer Studies and facilitated a Q&A discussion with filmmakers around local issues represented such as elephant welfare, deforestation, habitat loss.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Film premiere and community engagement - Putrom Modulkiri 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact We screened the three films produced on the project to approx. 120 indigenous community members and facilitated a Q&A discussion with filmmakers around local issues represented such as elephant welfare, deforestation, habitat loss.

Local community members reflected on the importance of seeing their stories, issues and priorities acknowledged and represented in film.

As a result of the screening, the films will be archived at the Modulkiri Indigenous People's Information Center.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Film premiere and policy stakeholder engagement - Phnom Penh 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact The Phnom Penh premiere was intended to present the films produced under the project to key policy makers. Cambodian Secretaries of state for the Minsitry of Culture and Ministry of Environment both attended - both commented on the importance of the films as records of indigenous culture and of the importance of awareness of environmental issues. Diplomatic staff from The British and Swedish embassies also attended.

As a result of the screening, further discussion will take place around the use of the films as learning resources by schools. Further screenings will now be held for diplomatic staff at the Swedish embassy and another screening held hosted by H.E. Tina Redshaw, British Ambassador to Cambodia, at the British Embassy.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Film screening - World Environment Day, Bophana Center 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Third sector organisations
Results and Impact I collaborated with the Bophana Center to
organise and speak at a special series of
online screenings and discussion events
promoting environmental documentary films -
including our Elephant Conservation films.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.facebook.com/watch/live/?ref=watch_permalink&v=169050695229897
 
Description Three animal conservation films by film students in Bophana 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact The Cambodian National People's Network (Cambodia's largest television network) produced a news segment covering the Participatory Film and Elephant Conservation project, raising awareness of the project and the issues explored in our films (deforestation, animal welfare, indigenous issues).
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=3992781100822794