Scottish Magazines Network: New Research Directions and Partnerships

Lead Research Organisation: University of Stirling
Department Name: English

Abstract

Sparked by Scottish International (Review) in 1968, a range of small independent magazines played a major creative role in Scottish literature, culture and politics over the next three decades. Fostered by the Scottish Arts Council, these titles featured (publicly subsidised) poetry and short fiction, and were the key venue in which writers, journalists and campaigners developed a shared agenda centred on Scottish cultural difference, literary revival and democratic dissent. Writing in Radical Scotland in 1983, George Kerevan noted that 'politics is no longer confined to the Establishment and Labourist agenda of economic tinkering. Cultural values represent a new Second Front'. The arena of this 'second front' was established - and gradually expanded - by titles such as New Edinburgh Review (from 1969), Chapman (1970), Crann-Tàra (1977), MsPrint (1978) and Cencrastus (1979). By the 1980s, these magazines had significant influence on the 'first' front - the field of electoral politics - in yoking together assertions of Scottish cultural identity and demands for constitutional change. Looking back, we can see post-1960s magazine culture as the laboratory in which the discourse and identity of the 'new' Scotland was experimentally debated, strategised and disseminated. These titles were also key sites of literary innovation, featuring work by every major and emerging Scottish poet of the period (Maclean, Morgan, Leonard, Lochhead, Jamie), short fiction by James Kelman, Janice Galloway, Iain Crichton Smith, and many others, and even the watershed of the modern Scottish novel, Alasdair Gray's Lanark. The same titles featured key essays and critical interventions by thinkers such as Tom Nairn, Isobel Lindsay and George E. Davie, influential debates on the marginalisation of women's writing, and were a key venue for the reassertion of Scottish folk traditions and the importance of Gaelic and Scots. Constant crossover between literary, cultural and electoral debate - from page to page and within the same article - is central to the interest and influence of these titles. To the extent that an earlier process of 'cultural devolution' paved the way for the new Scottish parliament in 1999, it can be directly witnessed in the writing, criticism and artwork of these magazines, and in the interpretive communities and political alliances which were formed around and through them.

The study and re-discovery of these magazines matters: first, because they are the 'missing link' in recent scholarship on Scottish culture and politics, the neglected arena in which movements for literary identity and democratic renewal intersect and interact. These magazines also answer the strong public appetite to understand the cultural and intellectual strands that helped to form today's Scotland. They had far-reaching impact in post-1960s Scottish literature, politics and cultural life, but they are seriously overlooked in histories and literary studies of the period. To address these needs, our network brings together four key groups:

- academic researchers (working in Scottish history, literature, politics, publishing)
- editors, contributors, and readers of our target magazines
- students, media and members of the public curious about Scotland's recent magazine heritage
- experts in restoring comparable magazines to public life through digitisation

The network will establish the resources and frameworks necessary to put these magazines firmly back on the map, potentially via a future digitisation programme (in partnership with the National Library of Scotland). Through our publications (including a taster 'megazine' reproducing the content and design of our target titles), we will boost the profile of these materials, stimulate new research directions, and consolidate the research field. Everyone interested in the intersection of cultural and political developments in recent Scottish history will benefit from this research and these resources.

Planned Impact

Impact I: Who?

Curators and Librarians: Graeme Hawley (Head of General Collections, NLS) and Dr Polly Russell (Lead Curator of Contemporary Politics and Public Life, British Library) have been closely involved in the formation of the network, and will participate in SMN events and discussion. Through focused discussion with researchers and digital humanists (Events 4 and 5), curators will gain new insights into the research opportunities and challenges (scholarly, legal, technical) of c20 magazine digitisation. Already, the process of devising SMN has benefitted both these organisations, e.g. the PI was able to pass new NLS legal guidance on evolving EU copyright directives to the BL's Spare Rib team.

Magazine Professionals and Media Practitioners: Nikki Simpson (International Magazine Centre) sits on the SMN advisory board, and will facilitate Event 3. Held to coincide with the Edinburgh International Magazine Festival, this is a public-facing workshop intended to engage magazine professionals and current media practitioners (editors, podcasters, journalists) with our research, and to involve these outlets in re-discovering our target titles.

Digital Humanists and Information Managers: Professor Lorna Hughes (University of Glasgow), Dr Sarah Ames (NLS) and Fredric Saunderson (NLS) are expert in pedagogical, technical, and legal frameworks of the digital humanities. They will benefit from the hands-on discussion of Events 4 and 5, as the aims and needs of researchers intersect with the (shifting) possibilities of producing digital scholarly resources, and also from hearing an insider's perspective on the BL's Spare Rib digitisation, a benchmark project for the sector.

Public engaged in Scottish culture and politics: The cultural debates and developments of our target periodicals are alive and kicking, and there is strong public interest in the 'backstory' of contemporary Scotland we can reconstruct via this independent periodical culture. Reaching and stimulating this general audience has been a central SMN objective from the start.

Impact II: How?

Public-facing Events: Events 1 and 3 are intended to directly engage the public, including magazine professionals and media practitioners, in the network's task of recovering and 're-circulating' these magazines and their stories.

FLYTE: A Scottish Megazine: Launched at Event 3, 1000 copies of this printed output will be disseminated as an introduction to the world of our target periodicals, including details of the SMN blog and events programme. We will distribute the publication at the Edinburgh International Magazine Festival, and with the assistance of our NLS partners and other contacts.

Exhibition at University of Stirling: Launched at Event 4, this exhibition will display magazines and related correspondence held by the Scottish Political Archive, focusing on the role of target periodicals in constructing a 1980s 'cultural campaign' for Scottish devolution.

Online exhibition via NLS: Launched at Event 5, this online exhibition (on the Google Arts and Culture platform) will showcase a selection of target titles in the NLS collection, highlighting common elements of design and production. As with the Stirling exhibition, the choice of titles for display will be shaped by public input via the SMN blog.

Network blog and social media: Events 1 and 3 will be promoted to the public via social media (Twitter and Facebook), and reports on the network's developing discussions will be posted to the SMN blog throughout the duration of the project.

Media participation: A number of Scottish media outlets participating in Event 3 - the Haverin' podcast, the Bella Caledonia blog, and the culture magazine The Drouth - have expressed interest in covering the network and its findings, with a view to boosting awareness of Scotland's modern magazine heritage and exploring parallels and lessons for today's independent cultural media.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Scott Hames (2022) FLYTE Magazine

 
Description The main results of this AHRC Research Network were:

1. Making new and strengthened intellectual connections among scholars interested in Scottish magazine culture, including new collaborations.

Our networking activity and the project blog/podcast succeeded in building new awareness, profile and research community for Scottish magazine studies. This activity helped to spark new collaborations across subject boundaries (e.g. history, literature, religious studies) and among early-career researchers previously unknown to one another. Today, these scholars are collaborating on new publications made possible by the network. With our partners, we have begun work on an edited volume that will consolidate Scottish magazine studies as a research field. We are also exploring a potential collaboration with a magazine archive based in Belfast. In June 2022 members of the network will convene a special panel on Scottish Magazine Culture at the World Congress of Scottish Literatures (Prague).

2. Creating new questions, frameworks and approaches for studying Scottish independent periodicals from the 1960s-90s.

This network has begun to generate a new agenda for reading magazines 'as magazines' in the Scottish context. It is doing so by connecting the work of Scottish historians (of literature, publishing, politics, print-culture) and the media/reading frameworks of specialists in periodical studies (on both sides of the Atlantic). In the light of Patrick Collier's work, we have begun to re-examine the questions and assumptions we bring to these materials, attending to the special position of the independent magazine within consumer culture, print media and civic life.

3. Establishing a foundational research resource on post-1960s Scottish magazines, serving scholars as well as students and the wider public.

The project blog includes profiles of individual magazines, essays comparing magazines of different periods, and personal reflections (including podcast recordings) from magazine editors, publishers and designers. Because many of its materials are only held in physical archives, this growing online resource is an invaluable starting-point for more focused research. The blogs themselves are excavating new knowledge about individual magazines (including several previously unknown to the project leaders), as well as new connections between magazinists, illustrators and figures in Scottish public life.

4. Renewing interest and public engagement with these magazines, while clarifying the opportunities and obstacles presented by digitisation.

We have begun the task of 're-circulating' these periodicals to new audiences, while collecting the memories and reflections of their original subscribers. The network has also engaged with current Scottish media practitioners to highlight the interest and lessons of these periodicals for today. We've sparked memories and posed new questions via online public events, the network blog, podcasts, and (soon) the printed project magazine 'FLYTE', showcasing the project and four of its key periodicals. Our interest in making archived magazines accessible to the public (online) is only heightened, and will remain part of our future thinking. However, expert advice from our network partners and guest speakers (including digital humanists, copyright specialists and the director of the largest in-copyright magazine digitisation undertaken in the UK) has highlighted significant challenges.

UPDATE MARCH 2023: via the publication of FLYTE, the findings of this research network have stimulated new research connections in the field of modern British history (via the AHRC Research Network 'Genres of Political Writing in Britain since 1900') and several publication projects currently in preparation (an EUP edited collection stemming directly from the project, co-edited with Eleanor Bell and the CI Malcolm Petrie, and a chapter in a planned edited collection stemming from the 'Genres of Political Writing' project, edited by Richard Toye and Gary Love). The Scottish Magazines Network is also involved in current plans to develop a new cultural magazine, in which it make take on a consultative or training role.
Exploitation Route Researchers in Scottish history, literature, publishing and politics can build upon the foundational resources and questions developed by this project. (Indeed: this work is underway: members of this AHRC network are currently producing a cross-disciplinary edited volume on Scottish magazine culture of the 1960s-90s, which aims to consolidate the research field.)

Our key partners, the National Library of Scotland, can better appreciate the research value of its magazine collections and their potential for public engagement.

Scholars exploring similar in-copyright material can learn, via our recorded events, about the challenges and possibilities presented by magazine digitisation.

Further collaborations with magazine archivists and researchers (within and outside the UK) are possible, and in one case in development.

UPDATE MARCH 2023: the public engagement activity of this grant has been extended via a new partnership with Edinburgh Central Library, with a planned talk/exhibition scheduled for Summer 2023.
Sectors Creative Economy,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL https://campuspress.stir.ac.uk/scotmagsnet/
 
Description In the past year a key publication of this award, FLYTE, has stimulated interest and debate among media practitioners in Scotland. The PI (Hames) has been invited to planning meetings related to the current state of the Scottish cultural media, and included in plans to launch a new magazine. The Scottish Magazines Network may take on a consulting or training role in the development of this new publication.
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Creative Economy,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal

 
Title Profile articles on individual Scottish magazines 
Description The primary materials of this project (Scottish magazines held in library archives) are not accessible online, so scholars have few means of discovering these materials or their research value (in a variety of fields). There was a need to make basic information about our research materials more discoverable and accessible to non-specialist audiences, both to encourage archival activity and to raise awareness of these magazines' value for cross-disciplinary scholarship. As a contribution to strengthening the research infrastructure in Scottish periodical studies, the Scottish Magazines Network commissioned a number of 'profile' articles giving a descriptive overview (1000-2000 words) of individual magazines, for publication on the project blog. These were paid commissions for ECRs, and unpaid for salaried members of the network. To date we have commissioned 11 research profiles of key magazines (including images and links to relevant interviews/recordings), with further titles planned. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact In our current phase of planning for an edited volume arising from this research network, a number of chapter authors have commented on the value of these profiles, which have introduced titles, contexts and connections of which they were not previously aware. North American specialists in periodical studies have also commented on the interest and appeal of these profile articles, as an introduction to the Scottish contexts on which the network is focused. 
URL https://campuspress.stir.ac.uk/scotmagsnet/profiles/
 
Description Partnership with National Library of Scotland 
Organisation National Library of Scotland
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The Scottish Magazines Network worked collaboratively with NLS partners (including curators and copyright specialists) to: - highlight the research value of NLS holdings in post-1960s Scottish cultural and political magazines - communicate to the general public the interest and appeal of these NLS holdings - explore the potential for making these NLS holdings accessible in digital form
Collaborator Contribution The National Library of Scotland provided support and guidance to researchers attached to the Scottish Magazines Network, assisting us with: - access to archival resources - expert advice on copyright - reprographic facilities for FLYTE magazine (a project publication that will emerge after this reporting period) Several elements of the collaboration we originally planned could not be realised for Covid reasons, including in-person events hosted at NLS and related exhibition activity (physical and online).
Impact In a sense, all the project's outputs and outcomes have been enabled by our partnership with NLS, because the library's archival holdings -- i.e. the magazines -- make possible all of our research activity, discussion, events, blogs, and eventual academic publications. More specifically, the project magazine FLYTE will be very directly enabled by NLS support when it appears later in 2022. This collaboration is multidisciplinary, drawing together members of the network (academic researchers working in Scottish history, literature, politics, publishing and the digital humanities) and library curators, digital specialists and copyright experts.
Start Year 2019
 
Description Contribution to research meeting on Genres of Political Writing in Britain since 1900 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact Gave an invited talk to a research meeting in Trondheim, Norway of the AHRC research network 'Genres of Political Writing in Britain since 1900'.

I was subsequently asked to contribute a chapter to a forthcoming edited collection on this theme, focused on Scottish print-culture of the post-1970s period.

This invitation stemmed directly from the funded activity of the Scottish Magazines Network.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://gtr.ukri.org/projects?ref=AH%2FT005734%2F1
 
Description Current Issues: Scottish Independent Media Then and Now 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact This online event invited the general public and contemporary media practitioners to learn about, and learn from, Scottish independent magazines of the post-1960s period.

The format of the event was three short talks followed by audience Q&A. It was promoted to the wider Scottish cultural public via a popular blog, in the following terms:

'What can today's Scottish media learn from the magazine culture of the 1970s-90s? And how should we interpret various shifts in the Scottish public sphere since that period?
This event brings together three speakers from Scotland's independent media, with direct experience of its evolution over the past few decades:

Mike Small - writer, researcher and editor (Bella Caledonia, Red Herring/Product, Indymedia Scotland)
Lesley Riddoch - journalist and broadcaster (Harpies & Quines, BBC Scotland, National)
Jamie Maxwell - journalist and editor (Politico, Foreign Policy, New Left Review)

Each of our guests has close ties to Scottish magazine culture, whether as editors of 1990s print titles (Red Herring/Product and Harpies & Quines) or as scholars of the 1970s-80s scene which included Question Magazine and Radical Scotland. As working journalists and sometime activists, they have observed at close quarters the transformation of the Scottish public sphere since devolution, and are well placed to reflect on the political, technological and economic contexts of these changes.'

A recording of the event was posted to the project blog.

NB this event substituted for our original plans to host a similar workshop at the International Magazines Festival (cancelled by Covid)
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://campuspress.stir.ac.uk/scotmagsnet/2021/10/06/scottish-independent-media-then-and-now/
 
Description Formation of the Stirling Magazines and Periodicals Research Group 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact In late 2022 the PI (Hames) of this award founded a new cross-disciplinary research group on magazines and periodicals at the University of Stirling.

The cross-disciplinary dimension of the funded research encouraged further collaboration with colleagues at my home institution, drawing colleagues from history, media studies and literature into a new grouping.

Our first event explored newspapers and periodicals held in the University's archive, and we plan to hold further talks and events later in 2023.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022,2023
 
Description Mind that Magazine? Public Launch and Discussion 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact This online event introduced the Scottish Magazines Network to the general public, seeking to stimulate their memories, reflections and questions about key Scottish magazines of the 1980s.

The format was two short talks by guest speakers followed by audience Q&A.

Speakers were Peter Kravitz, former editor of Edinburgh Review and director of Polygon publishing, and Glenda Norquay, Professor of Scottish Literary Studies at Liverpool John Moores University, who was a member of the Cencrastus editorial team in the early 1980s.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://campuspress.stir.ac.uk/scotmagsnet/2021/05/20/mind-that-magazine-event-2-digest/
 
Description SMN Project Blog/Podcast 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact As the extent and likely duration of Covid disruption became clear, this research network and its activity moved online.

The project blog was initially planned to share updates on ('in person') network activity (including public engagement activity), but soon became a primary tool through which networking and public engagement took place. The resulting blogs and podcasts are records of this activity, and also help to stimulate future interest and engagement.

There were several strands of this blogging/podcasting activity:

- we commissioned several (paid) blog posts from magazine editors and scholars reflecting on their experience in the world of Scottish periodicals, and used these blog posts to generate further interest in the network and its aims. Several of these blogs were branded as 'Mag Memories' to tie in with - and promote - our main public engagement event, 'Mind that Magazine?'.

- our four online events generated responses and questions from audiences, from which we commissioned further blog posts (including further 'Mag Memories') reflecting on Scottish magazines and their significance.

- as it become clear that videotaped in-person interviews with magazine editors would not be possible, we conducted remote interviews (over the internet) and released podcast recordings via the project blog (and other podcast platforms, promoted via social media). We have so far released 4 podcasts, and hope to secure funding to continue this activity.

The resulting blog/podcast is now a significant research resource, a record of public engagement activity, and a stimulus to further research, networking and public engagement.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021,2022
URL https://campuspress.stir.ac.uk/scotmagsnet/