Understanding Displacement Aesthetics and Creating Change in the Art Gallery for Refugees, Migrants and Host Communities

Lead Research Organisation: University of Manchester
Department Name: Arts Languages and Cultures

Abstract

There are 70.8 million forcibly displaced people in the world today (UNHCR Global Trends in Forced Displacement, 2018). Refugees, migrants and asylum seekers are at the forefront of international politics as populations defined by 'crisis', while the UN and humanitarian agencies attempt to bridge gaps in national policies on aid and resettlement. Visual and craft artists have played an historically important yet lesser-studied role in UN and humanitarian welfare programmes, in art therapy, and in communicating human rights. However, refugees and migrants can also be represented as nameless human flows and passive recipients of aid, which may strain both refugee and host communities. Significantly, the art industry and art galleries encounter parallel problems in aestheticizing the experience of people affected by war and displacement. While art asserts a powerful role in challenging hostile representations of refugees and migrants, in reality opportunities for refugee artists and curators in mainstream gallery culture, and opportunities for interpersonal dialogue and intercultural exchange with host communities remain limited.

Understanding Displacement Aesthetics proposes a timely reappraisal of this field of vision by historicising the humanitarian aspirations of art and craft, and analysing the impact of artistic responses to displacement and refugees. It investigates how 'displacement aesthetics' emerged after 1945 in both the practice and exhibition of art and craft, UN-sponsored welfare programmes in Europe and Palestine, and international art museums. The research seeks to understand the relationship between the uses and practice of art, the influence of and resistance to cultural stereotypes, art's interplay with humanitarian sentiment and action, and the political categorisation of refugees and migrants. Seeking to understand and utilise this history, the project identifies how displacement aesthetics continues to operate in the current refugee crisis in the international art world and in grass-roots artistic initiatives in Greece, Palestine, Australia and the UK. Crucially, this project seeks to move beyond a focus on tropes, by amplifying how art practices can enhance the potential and resilience of refugee communities.

The ambition of the project is, therefore, to transform displacement aesthetics by bringing together academics, artists, curators from migrant and refugee backgrounds together with the internationally renowned arts NGO In Place of War, and two leading art galleries in the UK, Manchester Art Gallery (MAG) and the Whitworth Art Gallery (WAG). The research addresses the ambitions of creative artists and curators, who, as migrants and refugees, face particular career barriers, and yet can be obliged to focus their practice on their outsider identity. A programme of inclusive, co-designed art projects will facilitate art-making, participatory exhibitions, and create a community 'welcome space' as a permanent infrastructural change in Manchester Art Gallery. These projects will generate research data to evaluate how effectively art museums can support refugee/migrant artists and communities and build solidarity across communities.

The project is led by a team of experienced scholars in the cultural history of war and displacement (PI), art history and contemporary art (CI), cultural theory and resilience studies (RF), and participatory art methods (team). Distinctively, these senior academics are also experienced curators, and the CI is also a practising artist, who will co-design the impact projects in partnership with MAG, WAG and the NGO In Place of War in collaboration with local participants in Manchester. This is an exceptional opportunity to catalyse the history of displacement aesthetics and make sustainable changes that benefit local communities, while advancing approaches to collecting, curating and representing art.

Planned Impact

The research will underpin three initiatives in Greater Manchester evolving from the collaboration of the academic team with refugee/migrant artists and curators, local communities, the internationally renowned arts NGO In Place of War (IPOW), and the curatorial and learning engagement teams from Manchester Art Gallery (MAG) and the Whitworth Art Gallery (WAG). This work follows on from prior collaborations, research-based exhibition projects and the PI/CI's network Visual Art, Humanitarianism and Human Rights. It also makes critical use of the academic team's additional expertise as exhibition curators [PI/CI], international artist [CI] and cultural producer [RF], and their track record in working collaboratively with artists, communities, museum professionals and educators. The creative and gallery projects outlined below will also produce key data for analysis in the published outputs.

Impact Project 1: In Place of War (IPOW) project with artists and curators from refugee/migrant backgrounds based in Greater Manchester. The academic leads will work with arts NGO, In Place of War, and institutional partners the Whitworth Art Gallery and Manchester Art Gallery, to tailor a programme that draws on their expertise, the research into refugee arts initiatives and the ambitions of refugee/migrant artists and curators. Initial research and co-design will provide skills development, networking and mentoring by artists and gallery professionals, studio space, and career opportunities for participants. A Certificate of Participation will be provided by the University of Manchester. It leads into two co-designed art projects:

Impact Project 2: A permanent change by transforming the Grand Tour gallery into a 'Welcome Space' in Manchester Art Gallery (MAG): the academic team will research the historic and contemporary collections of MAG, identifying artists who have experienced conflict and migration, and works pertinent to the cross-cutting themes of journeys, home, belonging, family, and humour. Workshops will be held with refugee/migrant artists and curators, artists from the IPOW project, and local Manchester host community participants, to shape the Welcome Space and build bridges between constituents. An artist will be commissioned to visualise the stories uncovered in the research, and a designer will oversee the creation of this new, permanent space at MAG. Their collaboration with the research and education teams will produce data for the project monograph and other publications. This project presents a unique opportunity to apply research for a permanent and sustainable impact that benefits all of Manchester's communities, and to study the evolution and evaluate the impact of such a major infrastructural change.

Impact Project 3: An exhibition at the Whitworth Art Gallery (WAG): Academic research into the historic and contemporary collections of WAG in relation to displacement, refugee/migrant art and experience will complement the research at MAG. Drawing on this research, new, updated entries for the Emu digital database will be co-created by researchers and curators. Over the course of fieldwork, the team will research additional historical and international loans of art works (from Europe, Palestine, Australia, the UK and USA) for the exhibition. Responding to the academic research, museum curatorial and education staff will collaborate with a commissioned artist to run a set of participatory art workshops with the IPOW refugee/migrant artists and local communities. The resulting exhibition will examine the history, practice and major aesthetic themes in displacement art and craft, challenge its history and practice, while providing a platform for refugee/migrant artists, seeking to explain but also challenge common assumptions about displacement and refugees arising from this visual history (such as the use of humour in art).

Publications

10 25 50
 
Title Curated Exhibition 
Description C. Lionis acted as Lead Curator, Carving the Negative, with TELOS projects at K-Gold Temporary Gallery, Lesvos, October 2021 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact Building networks with artists for the Displacement Aesthetics projects; building international networks for national project; learning with and from young emerging artists in sites of crisis at the frontier of refugeedom in Lesbos, Greece. 
 
Title Rethinking the Grand Tour 
Description Collaborative intervention in the Manchester Art Gallery permanent space. With curators, research team, and a group of artists from backgrounds of forced displacement. 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2022 
Impact The impact is still to be measured through visitor data and it is an ongoing process of change. The intervention --changing the space and using collections differently, and changing the way works are written about in the data base - has helped the gallery think about how it needs to change its processes and infrastructure. 
URL https://manchesterartgallery.org/event/rethinking-the-grand-tour/
 
Title Traces of Displacement 
Description The Traces of Displacement exhibition uses the Whitworth's collection to address one of the major humanitarian concerns of the 20th and 21st centuries - forced displacement. In tracing displacement within the collection, a partial, fragmentary, and yet compelling set of stories is emerging from academic and community collaboration. Traces of Displacement uncovers stories of persecution, creativity, and resilience, and the experiences of artists and makers who were displaced in their homelands, forced to flee, survived, and even thrived in exile. Artists from the collection include Raisa Kabir, Tibor Reich, Bashir Makhoul, Otti Berger, Cornelia Parker, Cecily Brown, Ana Maria Pacheco, Frank Auerbach, Max Ernst, Dusan Kusmic, William Holman Hunt, James Mcbey, Francesco Simetti, Frank Brangwyn, Edward Ardizzone, Edward Bawden and Theodore De Bry, Clare Leighton Hope, Ian Rawlinson, and Oskar Kokoschka amongst others. 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2023 
Impact Institution - changing the way they do collections research and curate exhibitions with intensive community involvement. Curating - changing the perception of emerging artists, recognition of skill and expertise, and perceptions and decisions around 'artistic quality'. Public - There will be a public programme; feedback wall for comments - impact still to be measured. 
URL https://www.whitworth.manchester.ac.uk/whats-on/exhibitions/upcomingexhibitions/tracesofdisplacement...
 
Description The project has had a significant impact in understanding the complex processes of making change to a permanent gallery space. This includes how we work within the institution, and how collaborative processes between different sets of gallery workers (curators, conservators, learning leaders and other teams) and external actors such as researchers and artists, or communities with keen interests in the cultures and collections that are represented in the museum. Working policies will also be augmented through this project and follow on activity to learn lessons from the processes. The public programme of artist events is also helping to bring out further impact on health and well being of gallery visitors, and to engage new conversations around home, belonging, culture and creativity across different communities in MAnchester. The project has also assisted in enhancing training and career opportunities for artists and cultural producers from backgrounds of forced displacement.
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Creative Economy,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal,Policy & public services

 
Description Manchester Art Gallery and the Whitworth Art Gallery 
Organisation Manchester Art Gallery
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution The Displacement Aesthetics Project (DAP) team are working with both institutions very closely on several projects. 1) CASE in place of war (IPOW) creative entrepreneur programme --we have gathered the group of artists from backgrounds of refugeedom and forced displacement - this group also provides us also with interview data for our book. 2) Investigating collections, developing curatorial ideas, community co-curation project developed with Manchester Art Gallery staff 3) Investigating collections, developing curatorial ideas, fostering community co-curation with the Whitworth Art Gallery This work is ongoing throughout the duration of the project.
Collaborator Contribution Manchester Art Gallery is an official partner providing in-kind support, including staff time and other resources ina. Letter of Support. One of our impact projects is with this institution. Similarly, the Whitworth Art Gallery is a collaborator on one of our impact projects. The director of both these art galleries is Alistair Hudson, and he has oversight of both these projects. This work is also linked to the CASE programme with In Place of War, details of which are on the other list of partners. The two institutions are providing space for CASE, space for exhibitions, staff time, exhibition resources, etc Manchester Art Gallery has signage up in its Grand Tour space indicating this AHRC funded project is signalling a process of change.
Impact Still under-development on both projects. We are documenting the process of change. The process itself is about infrastructural and cultural change within the organisations ---such as in how people work together, and how we work with communities.
Start Year 2021
 
Description Rethinking the Grand Tour creative collaborators 
Organisation Manchester Art Gallery
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution We collaborated with the curators and a group of artists from backgrounds of forced displacement as well a s Cultural Producer with experience as a queer curator of colour. The team worked together for many months, mining collections, and forging new practices of change the permanent space of the gallery.
Collaborator Contribution We recruited the people involved and facilitated all the meetings and. workshops. We pitched the ideas to the entire gallery teams and Director. We liaised with all partners to ensure the project moved forward. We wrote object labels for the intervention.
Impact The most important output was changing institutional practices in the process of making a permanent gallery change to a space (not a temporary exhibition) . It also brought audiences and artists into the gallery from marginal backgrounds who may not have otherwise.
Start Year 2022
 
Description Traces of Displacement Exhibition Focus Group 
Organisation Whitworth Art Gallery Manchester
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution DAP team facilitated collaboration between creative practitioners in Manchester, with curators, conservators and the Whitworth ARt GAllery collection. This resulted in professional opportunities for the group to extend professional networks and exhibit their work.
Collaborator Contribution 6 creative people with backgrounds of displacement acted as advisors in a focus group (Start Oct-end February 2024) that helped shaped the exhibition and included creative work of their own to add additional interpretation. They also will worked with a legal expert to develop data visualisation around displacement for the exhibition. The group enhanced the interpretation of the exhibition content.
Impact The exhibition Traces of Displacement at the Whitworth Art GAllery opens in April 2023 and runs for one year. There will be a public programme as well. ANd a public feedback wall.
Start Year 2022
 
Description 'Therapeutic Aesthetics. Displacement Aesthetics: Art and Crafts in post-war DP camps' 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact UKRI funded seminar series --New approaches to Medical Care, Humanitarianism and Violence during the 'long' Second World War, 1931-1953.
Colonial and Transnational Intimacies: Medical Humanitarianism in the French external Resistance' (AH/T006382/1). Organisers: Raphaële Balu, Marie-Luce Desgrandchamps, Laure Humbert, Bertrand Taithe.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://research.manchester.ac.uk/en/activities/new-approaches-to-medical-care-humanitarianism-and-v...
 
Description Artists for Artists peer to peer mentoring programme 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Peer to peer mentoring workshop over 1 week of workshops led by Advising Artists Radio Alhara, Lydia Ourahmane, Katarina Zdjelar and guest-lectures by Hiwa K, and a suite of international artists. Research data feeds into Lionis monograph and project book.
is an international pedagogical program run by artists. The guiding ethos of AfA is that care, community, exchange, and solidarity are each central to the art-making process. AfA aspires to contribute to the development of early-career artists from diverse geographies, with a focus on the global south. A fundamental aspect of Artists for Artists is the AfA Micro-Grant, a peer-to-peer (P2P) support-a form of educational and economic solidarity. Moving away from traditional transactive models, AfA generates seed-funding through enrollment donations and redistributes them as Micro-Grants to selected participating artists through a P2P voting system.

With a select a group of ten early-career artists for a five-day online program between February 10-14, 2022. AfA introduced Participating Artists to methods, practices, and cultures of collaboration, cooperation, and co-imagining. They accessed three online workshops, six lectures, and AfA's broad international network and activities. All participants are automatically eligible for the AfA Micro-Grant.

The workshops address the nexus between language and displacement. A shorthand of subjectivity and power, language repeatedly emerges as central to contemporary political activity. Embodiments of movement, memory, exchange, and knowledge systems, our languages float, and our tongues are shorthands of subjectivity and power. Entitled Language Is Never On The Ground, the fourth AfA online edition engages artistic practices that examine themes including language as an impediment, sound as a measure of displacement, voice as survival, and acoustics as somatic memory.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL http://www.afamasterclass.org
 
Description Comedy in Crisis Conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact C. Lionis, 'No 'local informants' Here: Humour and the Commodification of Suffering in Contemporary Art', Comedy in Crisis Conference, Birmingham City University, January 2022
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Humanitarian and Conflict Institute online Research Seminar paper - Displacement Aesthetics: Art and Crafts in post-war DP camps 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Paper and panel discussion Therapeutic Aesthetics
New Approaches to medical care HCRI AHRC online seminar series

PI - Displacement Aesthetics: Art and Crafts in post-war DP camps
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL http://www.colonialismandtransnationalintimacies.com/seminar-series/
 
Description Language is Never on the Ground 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact A shorthand of subjectivity and power, language repeatedly emerges as central to contemporary political activity. Embodiments of movement, memory, exchange, and knowledge systems, our languages float, refusing to rest on any one ground or singular culture. Voice, phonetics, and acoustics are never bound temporally or spatially.

The sounds of dissonance and displacement have become an increasingly central concern for contemporary artists engaged with mobility, migration, and placemaking.

Entitled Language Is Never On The Ground, the 4th online AfA edition focuses on the notion of displacement. It engages artistic practices that examine themes including language as an impediment, sound as a measure of displacement, voice as survival, and acoustics as somatic memory.

The Language is Never on the Ground will include online workshops led by Advising Artists Radio Al Hara, Lydia Ourahmane, and Katarina Zdjelar and guest lectures by a suite of international artists including Hiwa K.

A group of ten artists will be selected for a five-day online program and introduced to methods, practices, and cultures of collaboration, cooperation, and co-imagining. They will:

Attend small-scale workshops led by the three international Advising Artists.

Attend lectures on artistic practice and related thematics.

Be eligible for the AfA Micro-Grant.

Be connected to AfA's broad international network and activities.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.afamasterclass.org/language-is-never-on-the-ground
 
Description Rethinking the Grand Tour Public Programme at Manchester Art Gallery 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact A Touch of Identity, through Persian Rumi poetry, dance and visual art
with Mahboobeh Rajabi
Sunday 16th April (2-4 pm)
Dance performance, poetry and visual art session exploring identity and using Rumi's poetry to help participants shape their own visual art and poem.

Nostalgia in memory
with Khalda Alkhmri
Saturday 11 March (1-4 pm)
Artist talk and painting workshop relating to memory and moving away from homeland.

Heritage, Identity and Culture
with Kofo Kego
Saturday 13 May (12-4 pm)
Two-part workshop celebrating Nigerian identity, heritage and culture, and looking at how Aso Oke was made and used in the past and in present day

This programme has been developed by three of the participating artists and supplements their intervention in Rethinking the Grand Tour. All events take place at Manchester Art Gallery
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://manchesterartgallery.org/event/nostalgia-in-memory/
 
Description Source Magazine: Thinking through Photography, exhibition review 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact C. Lionis, 'Whose Land Is It?', Source Magazine: Thinking through Photography, exhibition review (non peer reviewed)
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Workshop Rethinking Art Galleries: Interventions, Collections and Communities 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Third sector organisations
Results and Impact Rethinking Art Galleries: Interventions, Collections and Communities with Brook Andrew (University of Melbourne); Ruth Edson, Clare Gannaway, Hannah Willamson (Manchester Art Gallery); Ruba Totah (The Palestinian Museum); Chrischene Julius and Mandy Sanger (District Six Museum); Chiara de Cesari (Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam); Bhavani Espathi and Jordan Rowe (Museum Detox); Americo Castilla (Fundacion TyPA); Alice Procter (Uncomfortable Art Tours); Salma Jorge and Sarah Fortmann-Hijazi (Multaka Tours); and Julie Trebault (Artist at Risk Connection)
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022