Historicising Natures, Cultures and Laws in the Etosha-Kunene Conservation Territories of Namibia

Lead Research Organisation: Bath Spa University
Department Name: Sch of Writing, Publishing & Humanities

Abstract

How can conservation of biodiversity-rich landscapes come to terms with the past [Vergangenheitsbewältigung], given historical contexts of extreme social exclusion and marginalisation?

How can key biodiversity areas whose global value rests on ahistorical ideas of Nature resist an uncritical presentism, to be better understood as entangled with diverse human histories and values?

How can conservation policy and practice recognise deep cultural and linguistic differences around 'the nature of nature'?

Our research responds to these questions through a cross-disciplinary humanities programme analysing dynamic dimensions of conservation territories in the Kunene Region of the former German colony that is now Namibia. Kunene's Etosha National Park and neighbouring beyond-Etosha conservation designations are home to diverse indigenous and marginalised peoples. Our research team of three women academics in Germany, the UK and Namibia has a combined 50+ years of ethnographic, archival, oral history and livelihoods enquiry in Etosha-Kunene. We propose a new collaborative three-year programme of six intersecting work packages (WPs):

WP1 on 'Historicising Socio-ecological Policy in Etosha-Kunene' offers a detailed discourse analysis and history of public conservation policy affecting natures and peoples associated with the region, interrogating shifting influences, interests and governance technologies;

WP2 on 'Comparative Indigenous Perspectives' assembles our long-term research in the region into a new comparative analysis of indigenous Khoe, San and Himba-Herero understandings of natures-beyond-the-human, drawing on current theories in the anthropology of nature;

WP3 on 'Making Identity and Indigeneity in Etosha-Kunene' explores how indigenous identities are made, focusing especially on how distinct and intersecting 'Khoe' and 'San' identities have been present(ed) in ethnographic, linguistic, conservation and legal discourse;

WP4 on 'Spatialising Coloniality in Etosha-Kunene' (re)traces the thought and practices of selected colonial European actors from the mid-1800s, bringing their written narratives into conversation with indigenous interlocutors inhabiting the same places and spaces (see WP2);

WP5 on 'Collecting, Curating and Returning Etosha-Kunene Natures' investigates how the natures of Etosha-Kunene have been both represented and shaped by natural history collections of specimen-artefacts assembled by the (mostly male) European actors we study in WP4;

WP6 focuses on public engagements, via a mobile exhibition, a website, and a series of workshops sharing and further exploring issues arising in WPs 1-5.

In sum, we offer a multivocal and radically historicised analysis of Etosha-Kunene that contributes new thinking on coloniality, indigeneity and 'natural history'. Our aim is to support conservation laws and praxis to more fully recognise the diversity of pasts, cultures and natures constituting this internationally-valued region.

Planned Impact

Our research to historicise natures, cultures and laws in the high value conservation territories of Etosha-Kunene is designed to generate in-depth knowledge regarding changing conservation policy and its socioecological impacts. Through our multifaceted public engagement strategy (see Pathways to Impact statement), we intend to contribute beyond-academia understanding that is helpful to policymakers, conservation practitioners, local stakeholders and visitors to these conservation territories. Our broad communication strategy will include diverse learners and stakeholders - from schools to local natural resources management institutions - to help deepen understanding of interrelationships between nature conservation in postcolonial circumstances and the colonial contexts shaping the natures thus conserved. We especially intend our project to benefit the indigenous interlocuters engaged with in our research, so as to enhance diversity in the knowledges, narratives and values recognised as relevant to environmental conservation policies and proposals.

In responding to these intentions we will engage in a series of impact-related activities as mechanisms for how our intended beneficiaries may access and benefit from our research. These include:

- Collating and sharing our research activities, findings and outputs through a project website (provisionally www.etosha-kunene-histories.net) and bespoke social media accounts.

- Organising and hosting a workshop at the mid-point of our project that brings together researchers and stakeholders in Project 04 'Future Conservation' in CRC 228 "Future Rural Africa" (see https://www.crc228.de/projects/project_a04/) at the University of Cologne who are studying the similarly scaled-up conservation area of Kavango-Zambezi (KAZA) Transfrontier Conservation Area (north-east Namibia). This event will enable us to maximise possibilities for co-learning and will be designed to encourage pathways for multi-way learning through including conservation practitioners, policymakers and local stakeholders in Namibia.

- Creation of a mobile public exhibition in year 3 that is both physical and online, combining and juxtaposing content from across our research and accompanied by an accessible explanatory booklet available in print and online. This exhibition will take place in Namibia and will constitute a focus for public engagement and outreach, to especially local communities in and around Etosha-Kunene, schools in rural and urban settings and third sector organisations. Its purpose will be to both communicate findings from our research regarding changes to and impacts of conservation policy in Etosha-Kunene, and to receive additional perspectives from varied visitors to the exhibition.

- Production of accessible locally printed publications including:

i. an accessible locally printed policy-oriented publication detailing the chronology and analysis of Etosha-Kunene conservation policy pursued in WP1, developed and shared with stakeholders and policy actors through the Ministry of Environment and Tourism's Nature Conservation Board, of which the Namibian Co-I is a member. This publication will complement a publicly accessible online policy chronology that will be updated throughout the course of the project;

ii. compilation of an annotated and illustrated 'catalogue' of selected natural history specimen-artefacts and the circumstances of their collection combined with mapping of their provenance in Etosha-Kunene, building on the research developed in WPs4&5. This publication is intended for a range of audiences, including policymakers, relevant third sector organisations, communities and schools/students.

- Production of a professional film and additional moving image film installation(s) to be used in multiple engagement pathways - from broadcast on national TV in Namibia to installations in our project exhibition - so as reach both new understandings and new audiences.
 
Description We have focused on literature review and historical mapping research, partly to build a strong foundation for our research and partly as a response to reduced travel possibilities linked with the COVID-19 pandemic. We have established a project website including information and outcomes for all six project Work Packages (WPs): see www.etosha-kunene-histories.net. We also gained formal Research Approval from the Namibian Commission for Research, Science and Technology (NCRST), following detailed scrutiny of our project by the Research and Ethics Committee of the Ministry of Environment, Forestry and Tourism (MEFT). Several key outcomes are listed below.

WP1. "Historicising Socio-ecological Policy in Etosha-Kunene". We have developed a new periodisation for the historical framing of environmental concerns and the evolution of conservation policy in Etosha-Kunene (WP1) which currently splits our historical and archive literature review into six periods, as follows:
1. pre-colonial to 1884;
2. 1884 - 1907, colonial reorganisation prior to gazetting of 'Game Reserve no. 2';
3. 1907 - 1958, Game Reserve no. 2 / Etosha Game Reserve & 'Kaokoveld' Native Reserves, prior to the extension of the western park boundary along the Ugab River in 1958;
4. 1958 - 1970, Etosha Game Reserve extends to the Atlantic Ocean in west, prior to the creation of 'Damaraland' & 'Kaokoland' homelands when Etosha National Park (ENP) was reduced in size;
5. 1971 - 1997, fenced and reduced size Etosha National Park, establishment of tourism concessions, communal area residents alienated from wildlife;
6. 1998 - present, CBNRM / communal area conservancies established alongside tourism concessions and Etosha and Skeleton Coast National Parks.

Our full chronology is available as an iteratively updated literature review on our project website at www.etosha-kunene-histories.net/wp1-historicising-etosha-kunene.

We are currently pursuing additional threads of research for this WP:
a) The Namibian PI (Lendelvo) is leading on interview-based research with stakeholders to understand the uptake of a 'landscape approach' to conservation in Etosha-Kunene (and beyond) and its drivers. A series of interviews have been carried out and are being transcribed and analysed;
b) To maximise synergies between the past work of the three Principal Investigators across our Etosha-Kunene study area we have commissioned a report by Namibian scholar Dr Elsemi Olwage to provide a synthesis of the prior work through the study area by the three PIs. This report is nearing completion and will be added to our project website when finalised;
c) To support understanding of colonial impacts on and reorganisations of people prior to the establishment of Game Reserve no. 2 in 1907, the UK PI (Sullivan) has commissioned specialist transcriptions of a series of texts in the National Archives of Namibia that document a hitherto poorly researched event - the Grootberg Uprising which took place in 1897-1898. These transcriptions have been finalised, and checked translations in to English are underway. The events documented in these texts are illuminating with regard to the establishment of a colonial police and military presence in the north-west, as well as the historical depopulation of the area to the south-west and west of present-day Etosha National Park through deportation of several hundred inhabitants of the area. These events are referred to today in oral histories by elders of the area, and historical archive research can help with clarifying the trajectory and details of the events. In March-April 2023 research filming will take place to re-situate these events in the landscape;

WP2. The UK and German PIs published book chapters bringing together work for our second Work Package on "Comparative Indigenous Perspectives in Etosha-Kunene", namely: 'Densities of meaning in west Namibian landscapes: genealogies, ancestral agencies, and healing', by Sian Sullivan and Welhemina Suro Ganuses; and 'Hai?om in Etosha: Being-in-relations and "cultural maps"', by Ute Dieckmann, for publication in Dieckmann, U. (ed.) 2021 Mapping the Unmappable? Cartographic Explorations with Indigenous Peoples in Africa. Bielefeld: Transcript (https://cup.columbia.edu/book/mapping-the-unmappable/9783837652413).
Partly as a response to COVID-19 related travel constraints, Sullivan is working with Namibia specialist film-maker Oliver Halsey on a series of oral history films drawing on footage filmed by them in 2019, as a means of generating in-depth material that can be drawn on for the comparative work comprising this work package. They have previously collaborated to create "The Music Returns to Kai-as" (https://vimeo.com/486865709) as part of the AHRC Future Pasts project that Etosha-Kunene Histories builds on. They are currently finalising Lands That History Forgot: 3 Journeys with ?Ubun, ?Khao-a Dama and Purros-Dama Elders in 2019, and will screen the film with those involved in Sesfontein in April 2023.

WP3. "Making Identity and Indigeneity". WP3 aims for a more theoretical contribution on how identity categories are constructed, negotiated and modified. In preparation for this contribution we have paying close attention to how the diverse peoples of our study area were written about and encountered in historical texts, and including this material in our Chronologies for WP1. We intend to draw on this review in developing future outputs for WP3.

WP4. "Retracing and Spatialising Coloniality in Etosha-Kunene". We have completed significant work to map the journeys of key colonial actors through our study area from the mid-1800s onwards. The narratives of a number of these colonial actors have now been now spatialised (mapped) and written up/annotated: see https://www.etosha-kunene-histories.net/wp4-spatialising-colonialities

WP5. "Collecting, Curating and Returning Etosha-Kunene Natures". The UK Principal Investigator (Sullivan) has worked with collaborators in Save the Rhino Trust, the MEFT (with appropriate line management permissions) and Flora and Fauna International on an historical paper analysing past distribution and colonial-era hunting of black rhino. This historical research on past distributions of black rhino through our study area and beyond is being drawn on by Namibia's Black Rhino Custodianship Programme that seeks to re-establish viable populations of this species throughout its former range. The research has been written up as the following report: Sullivan, S., !Uri?khob, S., Kötting, B., Muntifering, J. and Brett, R. 2021 Historicising black rhino in Namibia: colonial-era hunting, conservation custodianship, and plural values. Future Pasts Working Paper Series 13 https://www.futurepasts.net/fpwp13-sullivan-urikhob-kotting-muntifering-brett-2021 ISBN: 978-1-911126-18-8.

WP6 Public Engagement. We have produced several accessible policy-oriented publications and have fostered public engagement where possible, for example through blogs and webinars: see narrative impact. A major element of our proposed public engagement is a project workshop which took place on 5-6 July 2022: see https://www.etosha-kunene-histories.net/post/workshop-programme-with-abstracts. Because of COVID related travel restrictions the workshop was held online and brought together researchers and conservation practitioners with diverse perspectives on environmental and conservation concerns in our wider study area. Entitled Etosha-Kunene Conservation Conversations: knowing, protecting and being-with nature, from Etosha Pan to the Skeleton Coast, the workshop aims to provide a platform for a conversation on conservation policies and practices in 'Etosha-Kunene', taking historical perspectives and diverse natural and cultural histories into account. We are now working on an edited volume from the workshop.
Exploitation Route Overall we intend our research to bring more historical and ethnographic detail to matters of concern regarding environmental and conservation policy in our broad Etosha-Kunene study region. We hear from personal communications that our chronology and mapping datasets for our 1st and 4th Work Packages are being drawn on by other Namibia researchers. Our research is currently being utilised in various ways by Namibia's Ministry of Environment, Forestry and Tourism and to support conservation initiatives in the wake of COVID-19.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Environment,Government, Democracy and Justice,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL https://www.etosha-kunene-histories.net/
 
Description Our research has had a range of impacts to date, for example: 1) Our paper drawing attention to the impacts of COVID-19 and associated travel restrictions on communal area conservancies (Lendelvo, S., Mechtilde, P. and Sullivan, S. 2020 A perfect storm? COVID-19 and community-based conservation in Namibia. Namibian Journal of Environment 4(B): 1-15. http://www.nje.org.na/index.php/nje/article/view/volume4-lendelvo; also summarised as a widely read Conservation Namibia blog run by the Namibian Chamber of Environment: see 'Communal Conservancies Cry for Help to Survive Coronavirus "Perfect Storm"', 10 July 2020, http://conservationnamibia.com/blog/b2020-cry-for- help.php) has been used as a baseline of discussions by the Namibia Association for CBNRM Support Organisation (NACSO) regarding the effect of COVID-19 on conservancies. It also forms the basis of discussions of the Conservation Relief, Recovery and Resilience Initiative led by the Ministry of Environment Forestry and Tourism with different stakeholders. Funding has subsequently been allocated to the Multi-Disciplinary Research Centre at the University of Namibia to scale up the assessment among conservancies of the effects of COVID-19, and regarding how the relief package contributed to resilience among conservancy communities. Recently the paper was referred to by Minister of Environment, Forestry and Tourism in his Foreword to the State of Community Conservation in Namibia Annual Report 2020, published in late 2021. Hon. Minister Pohamba Shifeta writes: "[a] study on the [pandemic] situation led by the University of Namibia described this pending disaster as a 'perfect storm' that threatened rural livelihoods and Namibia's conservation record". 2) all three Principal Investigators (UK, Germany, Namibia) for Etosha-Kunene Histories contributed to an Open Access volume called Negotiating Climate Change in Crisis (Open Book Publishers 2021 https://books.openbookpublishers.com/10.11647/obp.0265.pdf), published in time for the 26th Conference of Parties to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (COP26) held in Glasgow in November 2021. The volume was co-edited by the project's UK Principal Investigator (Sullivan) who applied for and was granted an additional research grant of £5,000 (around N$101,500) from her university (Bath Spa University) to support the production costs of the volume. Negotiating Climate Change in Crisis brings together scholars and environmental activists from around the world to ask pressing questions about how the climate crisis is conceptualised and responded to. The book includes a Section on Namibia as a 'climate change frontline chapter', promoting the work of the three Principal Investigators and their collaborators. In total the three Principal Investigators for Etosha-Kunene Histories contributed six chapters to the volume, drawing on different aspects of their Namibia research. The book has been endorsed by the Hon. Heather Mwiza Sibungo, Deputy Minister of Environment, Forestry and Tourism, Namibia who wrote: "This book presents perspectives from the Global South, highlighting voices from communities and sharing their daily lived experiences of climate change. These voices are often missing from international platforms such as COPs. The contributions included in the book are valuable for countries such as Namibia and others where the impacts of climate change are severe. Namibia strongly advocates for knowledge production regarding climate change and its impact on livelihoods, the coping mechanisms of vulnerable communities and their capacity to adapt." The book and individual chapters have been downloaded in many countries around the world and was launched through an online international webinar, at which three University of Namibia authors presented their work, available to watch on youtube at https://youtu.be/Zs8bonySsnI or via the link at http://www.openbookpublishers.com/product/1488. 3) following a request by the Deputy Director, Wildlife Monitoring and Research, Ministry of Environment, Forestry and Tourism, the UK Principal Investigator contributed a report to enhance information regarding cultural histories and heritage for the new Management Plan for the Skeleton Coast National Park (2020/21 - 2030/31): Sullivan, S. 2021 Cultural heritage and histories of the Northern Namib: historical and oral history observations for the Draft Management Plan, Skeleton Coast National Park 2021/2022-2030/2031 Future Pasts Working Paper Series 12 https://www.futurepasts.net/fpwp12-sullivan-2021 ISBN: 978-1-911126-17-1. The report makes some suggestions for understanding the Northern Namib as a remembered cultural landscape as well as an area of high conservation value, and for protecting and perhaps restoring some access to sites that may be considered of significant cultural heritage value. Such sites include graves of known ancestors and named and remembered former dwelling places. The aim of the report is to contribute to a diversified recognition of values for the Skeleton Coast National Park for the new Management Plan that will shape ecological and heritage conservation practice and visitor experiences over the next 10 years.
First Year Of Impact 2020
Sector Communities and Social Services/Policy,Environment,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal,Economic,Policy & public services

 
Description Impact of COVID-19 on conservancies
Geographic Reach Africa 
Policy Influence Type Implementation circular/rapid advice/letter to e.g. Ministry of Health
Impact This research has been drawn on by the Namibia Association for CBNRM Support Organisation (NACSO) regarding the effect of COVID-19 on conservancies. It has formed the basis of discussions of the Conservation Relief, Recovery and Resilience Initiative led by the Ministry of Environment Forestry and Tourism with different stakeholders. Funding has subsequently been allocated to the Multi-Disciplinary Research Centre at the University of Namibia to scale up the assessment among conservancies of the effects of COVID-19, and regarding how the relief package contributed to resilience among conservancy communities. Recently the paper was referred to by Minister of Environment, Forestry and Tourism in his Foreword to the State of Community Conservation in Namibia Annual Report 2020, published in late 2021. Hon. Minister Pohamba Shifeta writes: "[a] study on the [pandemic] situation led by the University of Namibia described this pending disaster as a 'perfect storm' that threatened rural livelihoods and Namibia's conservation record".
URL https://www.nacso.org.na/sites/default/files/2020%20State%20of%20Community%20Conservation%20Report%2...
 
Description HEQR Seed Funding
Amount £5,000 (GBP)
Organisation Bath Spa University 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2021 
End 08/2021
 
Title Multiple online maps spatialising literature review 
Description A series of maps that spatialise literature review underlying Future Pasts research, supported by 'Historical Sequences of References to Peoples and Places of West Namibia' at https://www.futurepasts.net/timeline-to-kunene-from-the-cape 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2019 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact This online literature review and the spatialised reading of texts has contributed to requests for expert testimony regarding specifically Damara / ?Nukhoen and ||Ubun histories and concerns in national and international policy discourses regarding indigeneity, marginalisation and cultural landscapes in west Namibia (for example, i. Sullivan, S., Ganuses, W.S., |Nuab, F. and senior members of Sesfontein and Anabeb Conservancies, Dama / ?Nukhoen and ?Ubun Cultural Landscapes Mapping, West Namibia, in progress report to Namidaman Traditional Authority, Sesfontein. Bath: Future Pasts, 6 August 2019; ii. Sullivan, S. and Ganuses, W.S. 2020 Understanding Damara / ?Nukhoen and ?Ubun indigeneity and marginalisation in Namibia, pp. 283-324 in Odendaal, W. and Werner, W. (eds.) 'Neither Here Nor There': Indigeneity, Marginalisation and Land Rights in Post-independence Namibia. Windhoek: Land, Environment and Development Project, Legal Assistance Centre. ISBN 978-99945-61-58-2). It has also informed the development of a new collaborative research project with the University of Cologne and the University of Namibia - 'Historicising Natures, Cultures and Laws in the Etosha-Kunene Conservation Territories of Namibia' (AH/T013230/1) 
URL https://www.futurepasts.net/maps-1
 
Title Publicly Accessible Online Chronology 
Description For our first Work Package "Historicising Socio-ecological Policy in Etosha-Kunene" the UK and Germany PIs (Sullivan and Dieckmann) have created a publicly accessible online chronology of writing about our study region, to which we are adding as we work on the project. In compiling this detailed chronology we have developed a new periodisation for the historical framing of environmental concerns and the evolution of conservation policy in Etosha-Kunene. This periodisation currently splits our historical and archive literature review into six periods: 1. pre-colonial to 1884; 2. 1884 - 1907, colonial reorganisation prior to gazetting of 'Game Reserve no. 2'; 3. 1907 - 1958, Game Reserve no. 2 / Etosha Game Reserve & 'Kaokoveld' Native Reserves, prior to the extension of the western park boundary along the Ugab River in 1958; 4. 1958 - 1970, Etosha Game Reserve extends to the Atlantic Ocean in west, prior to the creation of 'Damaraland' & 'Kaokoland' homelands when Etosha National Park (ENP) was reduced in size; 5. 1971 - 1997, fenced and reduced size Etosha National Park, establishment of tourism concessions, communal area residents alienated from wildlife; 6. 1998 - present, CBNRM / communal area conservancies established alongside tourism concessions and Etosha and Skeleton Coast National Parks. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2020 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact We know from personal communications that this detailed chronology is being accessed and drawn on by Namibia researchers. 
URL https://www.etosha-kunene-histories.net/wp1-historicising-etosha-kunene
 
Title Spatialising Coloniality in Etosha-Kunene 
Description As part of our 4th Work Package we focus on detailed review and mapping of a series of journals and journeys from 1850 to 1925 by colonial actors who played a large historical role in creating the later impetus for protecting Etosha-Kunene species and spaces. This dataset is constituted by an online map and annotated texts of these journeys, all linked at the URL below. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2020 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact We know from personal communications that this iteratively updated dataset is being drawn on by other Namibia researchers. 
URL https://www.etosha-kunene-histories.net/wp4-spatialising-colonialities
 
Description Gobabeb Namib Research Institute 
Organisation Gobabeb Training and Research Centre
Country Namibia 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Gobabeb Namib Research Institute is a research organisation located in west Namibia. Members of the Future Pasts project gave a number of presentations at the Centre (by Rohde, Sullivan and Hannis - see 'public engagements'), and Rohde and Impey developed a research project in collaboration with a specific programme of research being developed by Gobabeb and partners (see collaboration entry entitled 'FogLife'). By invitation by Gobabeb's Director, Sullivan also contributed material for an entry on indigenous harvesting practices for !nara (Acanthosicyos horridus) for a 2014 text for policy makers on commercialised plant products in Namibia (see narrative on 'impact'). In recent visits to the Centre (by Sullivan in March 2018 and by Sullivan and Hannis in September 2018) presentations delivered have included 'Tasting the lost flute music of Sesfontein: histories, continuities, possibilities' (Sullivan with Welhemina Suro Ganuses, Sept. 2018), ''Exploring multispecies interactions through seed gathering from harvester ant nests: contemporary and historical practices by Damara / ?Nukhoen in west Namibia' (Sullivan, Sept. 2018), '"Our hearts were happy here": recollecting acts of dwelling and acts of clearance through mapping on-site oral histories in west Namibia' (Sullivan, March 2018) and 'Mining the Namib coast: nature, capital and history' (Hannis, Sept. 2018). In 2018 Sullivan became an Associate of Gobabeb Namib Research Institute.
Collaborator Contribution Gobabeb contributed a formal endorsement letter for our research early in 2014 to add to our research permit dossier for submission to the Ministry of Home Affairs. Specific support by Gobabeb for the research being developed by Rohde and Impey regarding repeat landscape photographs and sound ecology is detailed under the entry 'FogLife'. Sullivan has been supported to gain Ministry of Environment & Tourism research permits through her involvement as a co-investigator in a research project led from Gobabeb (see below).
Impact Sullivan has become a co-investigator to contribute ethnographic and oral history dimensions to a cross-disciplinary research project led from Gobabeb (Principal Investigator Dr Gillian Maggs-Kolling) called 'The significance of the Namib Desert endemic !nara (Acanthosicyos horridus) as a keystone species in ecology, phenology, culture and horticultural potential'. In 2021 this research formed the basis for an invitation from the Deputy Director of Wildlife Monitoring and Research, Ministry of Environment, Forestry and Tourism - MEFT, to contribute a report on the Cultural Histories of the Northern Namib to support the new Management Plan for the Skeleton Coast National Park, published as: Sullivan, S. 2021 Cultural heritage and histories of the Northern Namib: historical and oral history observations for the Draft Management Plan, Skeleton Coast National Park 2021/2022-2030/2031 Future Pasts Working Paper Series 12 https://www.futurepasts.net/fpwp12-sullivan-2021 ISBN: 978-1-911126-17-1
Start Year 2014
 
Description Save the Rhino Trust (SRT), Namibia 
Organisation Save the Rhino Trust (SRT)
Country Namibia 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Save the Rhino Trust is an NGO that has been operating since at least the 1990s in the southern Kunene region of our study area. Its trackers and staff members have an immense wealth of knowledge of this area and the organisation currently employs a key field assistant / translator (Welhelmina Suro Ganuses) with whom both Sullivan and Low have worked in the course of conducting ethnographic research since the early 1990s. For Future Pasts Sullivan has formalised an arrangement to second Suro from SRT for assistance with periods of ethnographic field research as part of Future Pasts. This is part of a developing collaboration to draw out elements of cultural landscape relationships that have been obscured by contemporary conservation and tourism concession designations, and that are relevant to the areas that SRT currently works in.
Collaborator Contribution SRT is providing logistical (e.g. possibility of camping at times at SRT base-camp) support as well as releasing one of its staff members to work with Sullivan as a field assistant for Future Pasts research, as well as sharing knowledge regarding Damara cultural landscapes and key informants.
Impact Currently this collaboration primarily relates to field logistics for ethnographic components of our research in southern Kunene Region. This is a key element in making possible academic research outputs from this part of the project. At the same, it is intended that through generating 'outreach' documents and other routes for local uptake of research material, routes towards broader impact of the research will be fostered through this collaboration. SRT staff are also now contributing material to Future Pasts Working Papers, with collaborative papers in development.
Start Year 2013
 
Description University of Namibia (UNAM) 
Organisation University of Namibia
Department Department of Geography, History and Environmental Studies
Country Namibia 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We approached UNAM for official endorsement for our research in 2014 and discussed the content of our research with the Head of the Dept. of Geography, History and Environmental Studies, Dr Martha Akawa, who in 2017 visited Bath Spa University as a visiting lecturer for the Association of Commonwealth Universities summer school hosted by the university. In 2018 UNAM became an institutional member of the GALA (Global Academy of Liberal Arts) network, led from Bath Spa University. Dr Selma Lendelvo, Head of the Life Sciences Division of the university's Multi-disciplinary Research Centre, will make a short research visit to Bath Spa University in 2019 at the invitation of the GALA network and Future Pasts.
Collaborator Contribution The Head of the Dept. of Geography, History and Environmental Studies at UNAM contributed a formal endorsement letter for our research early in 2014 to add to our research permit dossier for submission to the Ministry of Home Affairs. In 2019 Dr Selma Lendelvo, Head of the Life Sciences Division of the university's Multi-disciplinary Research Centre contributed a supporting letter for a Ministry of Environment and Tourism research permit for Sullivan and field research team.
Impact UNAM has becoming part of the Global Academy of Liberal Arts (GALA) (http://gala.network/), led from Bath Spa University.
Start Year 2014
 
Description Climate Change Book Online Launch 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Online launch for the Open Access book "Negotiating Climate Change in Crisis" co-edited by UK Principal Investigator Sian Sullivan and with contributions to a section on Namibia by the German project PI Ute Dieckmann and Namibian Co-Investigator Selma Lendelvo and colleagues. The online event was attended by multiple people around the world and is available to watch on Youtube and via the publisher's website at https://www.openbookpublishers.com/product/1488
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://youtu.be/Zs8bonySsnI
 
Description Conservation Namibia blog, summarising Lendelvo, S., Mechtilde, P. and Sullivan, S. 2020 A perfect storm? COVID-19 and community-based conservation in Namibia. Namibian Journal of Environment 4(B): 1-15. 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact In responding to the unprecedented impacts of COVID-19 on the community-based conservation contexts of our broader study-area, the UK PI (Sullivan) and the Namibian Co-I (Lendelvo) collaborated to bring to publication a rapid off-site (i.e. telephone) survey of the responses of communal-area conservancy members and managers to COVID-19 travel restrictions. Published as a peer-reviewed article in the Namibian Journal of Environment, the paper was also summarised for the Conservation Namibia blog run by the Namibian Chamber of Environment.
See Lendelvo, S., Mechtilde, P. and Sullivan, S. 2020 A perfect storm? COVID-19 and community-based conservation in Namibia. Namibian Journal of Environment 4(B): 1-15. http://www.nje.org.na/index.php/nje/article/view/volume4-lendelvo and Conservation Namibia blog, 'Communal Conservancies Cry for Help to Survive Coronavirus "Perfect Storm"', 10 July 2020, http://conservationnamibia.com/blog/b2020-cry-for-help.php
The paper and blog have been widely read and this research is now informing an up-scaled survey led by Namibian environmental policy organisations on the circumstances of communal-area conservancies across the country. For more details see 'narrative impact' section.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL http://conservationnamibia.com/blog/b2020-cry-for-help.php
 
Description Etosha-Kunene Histories blog 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact New blog created at https://www.etosha-kunene-histories.net/news to share news and updates about our project. 11 blog articles published so far. Readership and engagement growing.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022,2023
URL https://www.etosha-kunene-histories.net/news
 
Description Hunting Africa 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Sullivan, S. 2022 'Hunting Africa': trophy hunting, neocolonialism and land. The Land Magazine 31: 22-27, 58, https://www.thelandmagazine.org.uk/articles/hunting-africa-trophy-hunting-neocolonialism-and-land
Discussed/referenced in online media:
Media: Kukura, J. 2022 The greatest misconception about trophy hunting in Namibia. Wild Things Initiative 26 August 2022; https://wildthingsinitiative.substack.com/p/the-greatest-misconception-about; Kukura, J. 2022 George Monbiot's defence of trophy hunting makes no sense. Wild Things Initiative 29 August 2022 https://wildthingsinitiative.substack.com/p/george-monbiots-defense-of-trophy; Keeling, T. 2022 The future for Namibia's desert lions looks extremely bleak. 18 September 2022 https://www.thecanary.co/feature/2022/09/18/the-future-for-namibias-desert-lions-looks-extremely-bleak/
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.thelandmagazine.org.uk/articles/hunting-africa-trophy-hunting-neocolonialism-and-land
 
Description Research paper media report 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Information-awareness generating media report and interview regarding broad issues linked with researcher positionality in conservation research explored in Koot, S., Hebinck, P. and Sullivan, S. 2020 Science for Success - A Conflict of Interest? Researcher Position and Reflexivity in Socio-ecological Research for CBNRM in Namibia. Society and Natural Resources https://doi.org/10.1080/08941920.2020.1762953
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021,2022
URL https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2021-10-18-a-question-of-bias-trophy-hunting-is-a-contentiou...
 
Description Research paper media report 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Information-awareness generating media report and interview regarding broad issues linked with CBNRM (Community-Based Natural Resources Management) and trophy hunting enterprise in Namibia: Cruise, A. Trophy hunting elephants: New study highlights tensions in commodifying wildlife for community-based conservation in Namibia. Journal of African Elephants 8 April 2021.
Article builds on information and perspectives in published research in Hewitson, L. & Sullivan, S. 2021 Producing elephant commodities for 'conservation hunting' in Namibian communal-area conservancies. Journal of Political Ecology 28: 1-24. https://doi.org/10.2458/jpe.2279
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://africanelephantjournal.com/trophy-hunting-elephants-new-study-highlights-tensions-in-commodi...