Donbas in Focus: Visions of Industry in the Ukrainian East

Lead Research Organisation: University of St Andrews
Department Name: Sch of Modern Languages

Abstract

The history and heritage of industrialization can evoke conflicting emotions for local communities. While past industrial achievements can be a source of community identity and pride, the environmental impact of industrialization and the socio-economic challenges of de-industrialization can also affect negatively the lives of local residents. Regeneration projects have tended to focus on adaptive re-use of industrial heritage objects, as museums, tourist attractions, galleries, and community spaces, in an effort to revitalize economically depressed areas and strengthen local communities. Less attention, however, has been paid to the intangible heritage of industrialization: the culture, values and relationships that exist in communities that were invested materially and symbolically in industrial production.

Donbas in Focus: Visions of Industry in the Ukrainian East explores the ways that Donbas, a heavily industrialized region in Eastern Ukraine, was depicted in photography and film across the twentieth and twenty-first centuries and asks how these processes continue to resonate in the region's political and cultural landscapes today. Situating the Donbas case in a comparative research frame, it questions established notions of the region's post-Soviet specificity, highlighting common challenges and experiences in post-industrial regions and communities across the UK. While a number of recent studies have begun to address the question of Donbas's cultural construction through word, image and social practice, there is no one single-authored volume in Ukrainian, Russian, or English that engages with the politics of visualizing industry in the Ukrainian East and the ways these politics have informed the cultural myth of Donbas across the Soviet and post-independence eras. A study of this kind is now more urgent than ever given the ongoing conflict in Donbas, in the context of which marked tendencies to "Otherize" the heavily industrialized region have emerged. By drawing parallels with the cultural construction of (post-)industrial regions across the UK, the project will contribute valuable new perspectives to the debate about Donbas identity politics, shifting the focus away from questions of ethnolinguistic identities, which have dominated Ukrainian public discourse and international media coverage of the conflict, to discuss the dynamics of power that shape and inform (post-)industrial regional subjectivities and experiences.

Donbas in Focus has the following component parts: 1) a monograph, the first sustained study of the practices and traditions of visualizing industry in Donbas, from the late-Imperial period to the present day; 2) a co-edited volume of artwork, photography, and critical essays reflecting on the critical-creative potential of industrial history and heritage; 3) a series of three industrial archive workshops, stimulating new forms of creativity around established industrial heritage collections and building the knowledge, capacities, and networks of professionals working with these resources; 4) a schools photography project, working with young people in the West Lothian area to develop a new body of photographic work that engages with the (post-)industrial landscape; 5) an exhibition of project photography and creative work that will tour the UK and Ukraine; 6) a radio broadcast for BBC Radio 3; 7) a project website.

Planned Impact

Non-academic beneficiaries of the research include:

1) Museums and archives. The project will benefit Gwent Archives, Ebbw Vale Works Museum, Redhills: Durham Miners Hall, Durham Mining Museum, Durham County Record Office, West Lothian Archives and Museums Services, Linlithgow Museum, and the Museum of the Scottish Oil Shale Industry, all of whom will contribute to the industrial archives workshop series. The workshops will model new forms of creative engagement with industrial heritage and will stimulate discussion about how to reach new public audiences, including difficult-to-reach constituencies (such as teenagers), effectively. The workshops will build professional networks and capacities through mobility and exchange, hopefully leading to ideas for collaborative projects and future funding bids. Local community participation at the workshop will provide museums and archive staff with an opportunity to engage potential new users and depositors;

2) Artists and creative practitioners. A primary aim of this project is to challenge established stereotypes of post-industrial regions by encouraging interactions between artists and local communities with first-hand experience of post-industrial transformation. The six artists participating in the workshops will work in a sustained way with industrial heritage collections, innovating their own creative responses to the materials and supporting workshop participants with their creative initiatives. As a result of participation in the workshops, artists will build their professional portfolios and benefit from networks with academics, museums, archives, international partner institutions and public audiences. While most of the artists have been involved in projects relating to industrial and post-industrial themes before, not all have had the opportunity to engage communities in participatory art initiatives. The workshops will therefore provide an opportunity for artists with experience in this area to mentor early career colleagues in publicly engaged forms of creative practice;

3) Schools and schoolchildren. The schools photography project will provide schoolchildren with an opportunity to build practical and creative skills around photography and broaden their understanding of their local history and environment. The Skillswork sessions and field trips will allow students to develop relationships with artists and photographers, stimulating creativity and confidence. Schoolchildren will be empowered to create new visual narratives of their communities that will be exhibited internationally. The schools photography project will be co-designed with teachers and schoolchildren to maximize participant investment in the initiative;

4) Public audiences. The project aims to change public perceptions of the cultural potential of post-industrial regions by exhibiting new forms of creativity emerging from these communities. An exhibition of project photography and creative work produced by professional artists and community participants at the industrial archive workshops and schools photography project will be exhibited in dedicated venues in Ebbw Vale, Durham, West Lothian, Lviv and Kyiv. The exhibition will be accompanied by project talks and contextualizing information to facilitate public engagement with the topic. Project partners will promote the exhibition through local networks and media to maximize its reach in the local community. Opportunities will be sought for further dissemination of project outputs through local networks and institutions (e.g. follow-on exhibitions across Donbas through the Gurtobus, community culture bus project run by IZOLYATSIA: Platform for Cultural Initiatives; integration of project materials into Shale Trail interactive database).

Publications

10 25 50

publication icon
Donovan V (2021) Donbas in Family Photo Albums: Interview with Vadim Lurie in Region: Regional Studies of Russia, Eastern Europe, and Central Asia

publication icon
Donovan V (2021) Introduction in Region: Regional Studies of Russia, Eastern Europe, and Central Asia

publication icon
Donovan V (2022) Archives At War in Tribune

publication icon
Donovan V (2023) A Letter to My Friends in Mariupol in Kajet Digital

publication icon
Donovan V (2021) Slavic Studies Goes Public: Who? What? Why? Where? When? in Modern Languages Open

 
Title Ecology on Camera 
Description Drawing on archival photography digitized through the Un/archiving Post/industry project and informed by AHRC funded research, this co-curated exhibition explores ecological and environmental issues around industrial and post-industrial transformation in the Ukrainian East. The exhibition was produced in Ukrainian and English. The Ukrainian version was exhibited at the "Poruch" veterans centre in Kramatorsk from January 2022 until the beginning of the war in Feburary 2022. 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact The exhibition has improved public understanding of the ecological and environmental impact of industrialisation and post-industrial transformation in the Ukrainian East. It has attracted considerable media attention in the Ukrainian press and events, including an online exhibition opening discussion and debate, have been coordinated around the exhibition. The "Poruch" veterans centre is a busy community hub with around 1-50 visitors per day. The exhibition was open for around a month and was visited by approximately 900 people. The impact of the exhibition has been impacted by the outbreak of war in Ukraine in February 2022. Since 2022 the exhibition has been reproduced online and has been used in teaching in the environmental humanities and East European studies. 
URL https://ecology.lvivcenter.org/en/index.html
 
Title Exhibition of work emerging from Un/archiving Post/industry Summer School at the Pokrovsk Local History Museum 
Description An exhibition of works created by artist residents of the Un/archiving Post/industry Summer School in Pokrovsk. The Summer School was funded by the GCRF and House of Europe and informed by AHRC-funded research. The exhibition took place as part of the Zalizniak-fest in Pokrovsk in September 2021. 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact - following the exhibition selected artists (Oleksandr Kuchynskyi, Anna Pylypiuk, Elias Parvulesko, and Clemens Poole) were invited for two-week residencies to continue work on their projects. The exhibition and follow-on residencies raised the artists profiles, helped them to build their professional networks, and provided them with financial support for the development of new creative work. 
URL https://www.lvivcenter.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/pokrovsk-final-ukr.pdf
 
Title Mariupol Memory Park 
Description "Mariupol Memory Park" is a digital collection of articles, essays, creative writing, artwork, film, and audio-stories, co-edited with Nychka Lishchynska and Diána Vonnák and (realised with support of the UKRI Arts and Humanities Research Council and Rosa Luxemburg Stiftung, 2022), [published online] 33% contribution; 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2022 
Impact Mariupol Memory Park has disseminated knowledge about the diversity of cultural life in the occupied city of Mariupol among English-language and Ukrainian-language audiences. It has attracted international media attention and has formed the basis for public engagement events in the UK, EU, US, and Ukraine. The project has shifted public understanding of the political and cultural identity of the city which Russia claims to be an integral part of the "Russian World." 
URL https://www.mariupolmemorypark.space/en/
 
Title Places We Love: Art and the Ukrainian East 
Description Places We Love: Art and the Ukrainian East features the work of four contemporary Ukrainian artists: Viktor 'Corwic' Zasypkin, Masha Pronina, Oleksandr Kuchynskyi and Darya Tsymbalyuk. Ranging from photography to montage to painting, these works provide insights into industrial heritage, pre-war cityscapes, the violence of military incursions, and the multiple lives and loves of the Donbas region. Donbas (Donetsk Coal Basin) is an industrial region in the east of Ukraine, which since 2014 has been partially occupied by Russia, and where war has been ongoing for eight years. Places featured in this exhibition are dear to the artists. Many of them are now being destroyed by the Russian military. Artworks will be on display in The Garden Bothy and The Pergola. The exhibition is accompanied by a weekend print sale, with all proceeds going to Ukrainian artists. Places We Love has been organised by the Centre for Contemporary Art in collaboration with the Centre for Russian, Soviet, Central and East European Studies and the Centre for Art and Politics at the University of St Andrews, and kindly hosted by the St Andrews Botanic Garden. The exhibition is co-organised by Catherine Spencer, Darya Tsymbalyuk, Victoria Donovan and Kate Cowcher. Places We Love has developed from the book Limits of Collaboration: Art, Ethics and Donbas (Kyiv: Rosa Luxembourg Stiftung, 2022), written by Victoria Donovan and Darya Tsymbalyuk with Dmytro Chempurnyi, Viktor 'Corwic' Zasypkin, Oleksandr Kuchynskyi and Katerina Siryk. 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2022 
Impact The exhibition broadened public understanding of the cultural contexts and creative life of the Ukrainian East. It introduced visitors (around 500 over the course of two months) to a selection of artists from the region responding to conditions of deindustrialization, socio-economic transformation and war. The exhibition enhanced the professional portfolios of the artists involved and financially benefitted them since posters of their works were sold at the event. The exhibition launched at the time that Ukrainian refugees were beginning to arrive in Fife and a number of families visited the event. Ukrainian refugee families left messages expressing their appreciation of the exhibition, how they had felt welcomed and recognised through the artwork on display and the events accompanying the exhibition. 
URL https://centreforcontemporaryart.wp.st-andrews.ac.uk/exhibitions/
 
Title What Does Post-Industrial Look Like? 
Description We are often presented with a dichotomy when it comes to the post-history of industrialization. Celebratory industrial aesthetics dominate heritage representations of industry, while depressing post-industrial visions, including post-apocalyptic "ruin porn," reign on Instagram. This collection of works is concerned with the way nature redefines industrial spaces after humans abandon them, and how humans return to find meditative solace in these landscapes. The exhibition includes photography by Martyna Krupa and Mykhailo Kulishov. Martyna Krupa is a photographer based in West Lothian, Scotland. She was a participant at the schools photography workshops on the bings (oil shale spoil heaps) of West Lothian, Scotland, that took place in July 2021. Mykhailo Kulishov is a historian, geologist, and photographer based in Bakhmut, Donbas. He is the curator of the http://donmining.info archive, a rich repository of historical and visual sources relating to the industrial history of the Donbas region. 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact Since the exhibition went live, the gallery has had about 400 visitor sessions and over 2000 minutes of engagement. he most popular visitor locations worldwide are in the UK and Ukraine. The most popular cities in the UK are London, St Andrews and Dundee. There are also multiple visitors in Livingston, Stirling, Nottingham, Cambridge, Birmingham. The most popular cities from which visitors have engaged in Ukraine are Horlivka and Kiev. People have also used the app from several other countries in Europe, including Russia (Ukhta), Portgal (Lisbon), Germany (Munich), Poland (Katowice). There are also people connecting from various other countries and cities around Europe in smaller numbers. In North America the most popular region is Toronto, followed by California. In Africa the most popular regions are South Afria (Johannesburg) and Nigeria (Lagos). In Asia the most popular regions are South Korea (Seoul) and India (New Delhi). There have also been visitors from Australia (Adelaide). 
URL http://energyethics.st-andrews.ac.uk/galleries/
 
Title What Is A Bing? 
Description What is a bing? Icon or an eyesore? Spoil heap or an archive? In July 2021, a group of young people met to walk, collect, photograph, and make art on West Lothian's oil shale bings. Bings are vast heaps of shale waste or blaes produced through the oil extraction process. Shale was deep mined in West Lothian then "baked" in huge furnaces (retorts) to extract oil. Once the black sludge oozed out, the pink crumbly waste shale was taken to a nearby dumping ground in a trolley (hutch), winched to the top, and tipped over the edge. Repeated for more than a century, the trolleys and trolleys of waste shale rose up to form this process resulted in twenty-seven bings rising up on the landscape of West Lothian, comprising some 300 million tonnes of shale waste. Local opinion about the value of the bings remains divided: for some they are eyesores, a depressing reminder of West Lothian's post-industrial struggles; for others they are cherished components of the local reality, viewpoints in an otherwise flat landscape, and sites of rare flora and fauna. Together with participatory artist and photographer Lisa Fleming and a group of young people from West Lothian, we set out to think about the bings creatively: What role do they play in local imaginations? To which futures do they belong? The group put together an exhibition at the Wee Museum of Memory at Livingston Centre that comprised archival photography, painted shale and other found objects, and cyanotypes created during the workshop. Archival photos hold special significance for local communities, as they are interwoven with the family histories of many living in West Lothian today. The cyanotypes that we hung on the walls reflected on something rarely thematised in connection with these landscapes: the idea of the post-industrial sublime. The bings' rich biodiversity - a result of the neutralising retorting process -- is featured in their work in dreamlike form. At the heart of our exhibition is a group of people who came together after being in isolation to connect with each other and with the landscape. We hope that our collective work inspires more people to visit the bings, to learn about their history and heritage, and to engage with them in new, creative ways. Artworks created in July 2021 were on display at the Wee Museum of Memory in Livingston Centre between September 2021 and January 2022. 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact - one of the young people who took part in the Schools Photography Project and exhibition went on to do an internship at the Museum of the Scottish Oil Shale Industry in Livingston; she is now considering a university degree in museum studies or curatorial practice; - one of the young people who too part in the Schools Photography Project was invited by the organisers to exhibit selected works from her contribution in a virtual exhibition "What Does Post-Industrial Look Like?" at the Art of Energy Galleries at the University of St Andrews; the exhibition raised the individual's profile and helped to build her professional CV; she is currently studying on an art foundation course at West Lothian College. 
URL https://www.livingmemory.org.uk/westLothian.php
 
Description The project discovered and achieved the following as a result of work funded through this award: (1) a body of knowledge (including 1 co-authored book, three special collections, and six peer-reviewed articles) on the industrial history and heritage of the Ukrainian East, also known as Donbas, questions of heritage management and manipulation, and the role of the industrial past in forming community identities and politics. This work situates Donbas in a comparative research frame, drawing parallels with the cultural construction of industrial regions across the UK, and contributing valuable new perspectives to the debate about Ukrainian identity politics. The research shifts the focus away from questions of ethnolinguistic identities, which dominate Ukrainian public discourse and international media coverage of the war, to discuss the dynamics of power that shape and inform regional subjectivities; (2) the advancement of thinking and methods in the public, civic and engaged humanities, realised through community workshops, public lectures and ECR workshops, and publications in leading journals in the field, including Modern Languages Open and Canadian Slavonic Papers; (3) the fostering of interregional, intersectoral dialogue between museums professionals, archivists, educators, creative practitioners, and the general public, including Ukrainian refugee communities, around questions of engagement with industrial history and heritage; the creation of new thinking and creativity around questions of industrial heritage preservation, community engagement in connection with these legacies, and heritage futures; (4) creation of two new research networks with international partners ("5am. 24.02.2022. Testimonies from the War," a international consortium project to document the humanitarian disaster resulting from Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine, with Center for Urban History of East Central Europe, Lviv, University of Luxembourg, and Polish Academy of Sciences; and "An Ostroh Academy-University of St Andrews Partnership for Advancing the Public Humanities and Building Cultural Resilience in Ukraine," with Ostroh Academy and Center for Urban History of East Central Europe, Lviv).
Exploitation Route - the project's findings have been cited in a "Summary Note" prepared by the SSRC Conflict Prevention and Peace Forum on mass violence and heritage preservation, which was circulated around senior United Nations policy makers in 2023; this note may help develop new policy around heritage preservation during wartime;
- the teaching materials created through the project on the contribution of British capitalist investment and labour migration to the industrialization of the Donbas region, Ukraine, are available through the online People's Archive Wales; to date these materials have been downloaded for use in classrooms 1052 times;
- the creative and community engagement methods modelled in project workshops with industrial heritage collections have fostered new thinking and practice around questions of how to manage industrial legacies and how to engage local communities in conversations about the future of these archival collections;
- project publications on decolonial epistemologies, collaborative methodologies, and new approaches to Area Studies research have been featured in leading publications in the discipline of Soviet and post-Soviet studies, stimulating new conversations about ethical research methods and socially responsible scholarship.
Sectors Creative Economy,Education,Government, Democracy and Justice,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL https://donbasinfocus.wordpress.com
 
Description - the research has contributed to international policy making (United Nations) around questions of heritage preservation during mass atrocities; - the research has contributed to curriculum development at British high-schools, contributing to efforts to foster critical conversations around questions of British managerial colonialism, transnational processes of industrialization and de-industrialization, and environmental politics; - the project has fostered new conversations among researchers, heritage practitioners, creative communities, and civic activists in Ukraine about the value of industrial history and heritage. These conversations are happening at a time when the country's heavily industrialized eastern Donbas region is partially occupied by Russian forces and questions about the cultural value of that region and its role in Ukrainian history and cultural identity is more important than ever; - the research has fostered greater understanding among the general public through media engagements (CNN documentary, broadcasts on BBC Radio, newspaper interviews, etc.) in the UK and Ukraine featuring new findings about the history and heritage of the Ukrainian East; - the research has led to new collaborations ("5am. 24.02.2022. Testimonies from the War" project; and "An Ostroh Academy-University of St Andrews Partnership") that will significantly enhance Ukraine's capacity in the public humanities and build the country's cultural resilience at this uniquely difficult time.
First Year Of Impact 2023
Sector Creative Economy,Education,Government, Democracy and Justice,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal

 
Description Academic Network on Peace, Security, and the United Nations Research Workshop on Cultural Heritage, Violent Conflict, and Atrocity Crimes
Geographic Reach Multiple continents/international 
Policy Influence Type Participation in a guidance/advisory committee
Impact The workshop has resulted in a summary note for circulation among senior policy makers at the UN. The note details the debates, the evidence and the aftermath, and recommendations for policy.
 
Description Consultation for military strategy lobbying group following the Russian invasion of Ukraine in February 2022
Geographic Reach Multiple continents/international 
Policy Influence Type Membership of a guideline committee
Impact Following the invasion of Ukraine on 24 February 2022 I was invited to join a group of scholars at St Andrews who were developing policy advice for government. The group are working on a number of confidential circulars and rapid advice projects that have reached the highest levels of the defense administration in the UK, the US, and countries across the EU. My involvement in this group was founded on my AHRC-funded research into communities and political identities in Donbas in Eastern Ukraine. The advice provided by this group has the potential to significantly impact military strategy at the highest levels, increasing the chances of survival of those fighting in the Russia-Ukraine war.
 
Description UK-Ukraine R&I twinning grants scheme
Amount £198,162 (GBP)
Organisation Universities UK International 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2023 
End 08/2023
 
Description 24.02.22, 5 am: Testimonies from the War 
Organisation Centre for Urban History of East Central Europe
Country Ukraine 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution On 24 February 2022, the Russian Federation invaded Ukraine resulting in enormous human and material devastation. As a result of my collaborations with Ukrainian partners on my AHRC project, Victoria Donovan (AHRC PI) and Diána Vonnák (AHRC Research Fellow) have been invited to join a consortium that includes the Center for Urban History of East Central Europe in Lviv, the Centre for Contemporary and Digital History at the University of Luxemburg and the Polish Academy of Sciences to document the ongoing war. The AHRC research team is contributing to this partnership by providing expert consultation on questions of ethics, oral history research, and archiving.
Collaborator Contribution Center for Urban History of East Central Europe in Lviv is responsible for project management, collection of interview testimony and archiving. Centre for Contemporary and Digital History at the University of Luxemburg is responsible for managing the digital infrastructure of the project. Polish Academy of Sciences is responsible for coordinating interview work with Ukrainian refugees and humanitarian workers in Poland.
Impact - two online workshops with colleagues from University of St Andrews (AHRC team), Center for Urban History of East Central Europe, Centre for Contemporary and Digital History at the University of Luxemburg, and Polish Academy of Sciences; - online workshop with colleagues from the Centre of Urban History hosted by the workgroup Media and Cultural Memory at NECS - European Network of Cinema and Media Studies (9.03.22); - creation of a corpus of resources and summaries of resources relating to ethics of conducting work with human subjects in conditions of extreme violence, precarity, and trauma.
Start Year 2022
 
Description Collaboration with West Lothian Council on the coordination of the Bings Schools Photography workshop and Into the Bings creative writing workshop 
Organisation West Lothian Council
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution We worked together with Emma Peattie at the West Lothian Council archives to research the history and heritage of the Scottish oil shale industry. We coordinated a Schools Photography Workshop for school age children in West Lothian, making connections between history and heritage of the region and the Ukrainian East. We fostered new creativity and thinking among this young cohort and produced in collaboration with West Lothian Council an exhibition of the young people's work, which was exhibited at the Wee Museum of Memory at Livingston Shopping Centre for three months. We collaborated again with West Lothian Council and West Calder Community Garden (through the council) to coordinate Into the Bings, a creative writing workshop which engaged post-industrial landscapes, archives, and oral history and fostered new creative responses to the region's post-industrial realities.
Collaborator Contribution West Lothian Council faciliated archival consultation, liaised with schools to find participants for the Schools Photography Workshop, organised consultational work at the Schools Photograph Workshops, and hosted the exhibition and assocaited activities at the Wee Museum of Memory. For the Into the Bings creative writing workshop, West Lothian Council helped identify a location for the workshop (the West Calder Community Garden), liaised with local residents to find volunteer oral historians, and presented archival holdings to local audiences.
Impact - Exhibition "What is a Bing?" at the Wee Museum of Memory in Livingstone Center, November 2021-January 2022; - Exhibition "What Does Post-industrial Look Like?" at the Center for Energy Ethics with contributions from Schools Photography Workshop participants; - Exhibition "Places We Love: Art and the Ukrainian East" hosted by West Calder Community Garden for three months, June-September 2022; - internship for participant at the Schools Photography Workshop at the Scottish Oil Shale Museum in Linlithgow;
Start Year 2021
 
Description "Donbas Postcards and the Industrial Sublime," invited lecture at the Energy Café, Centre for Energy Ethics, University of St Andrews 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Research in progress talk "Donbas Postcards and the Industrial Sublime," at the Energy Café, Centre for Energy Ethics, University of St Andrews. The Energy Café is an informal, open and inclusive space where people across University of St Andrews, from undergraduates to Professors Emeriti, can come together for an hour to share ideas about the energy research they are working on. It is intended to encourage collaborations, expand research horizons, and inspire new ideas and questions about issues of energy.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://energyethics.st-andrews.ac.uk/events/energy-cafe-10/
 
Description Conference paper: " "No Photography!": Guardians and Gatekeepers of Industrial Heritage Collections in the UK and Ukraine" 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The workshop brought together oil museum curators and leading scholars researching oil industry heritage in different parts of the world. It aimed to initiate a conversation about the role that the oil industry heritage and its memorialisation can play in the future of oil-producing localities in the context of transition to renewable energy sources. This workshop aimed to begin this conversation and to explore the differences and similarities of memorialisation practices in oil-producing localities.

The five-day workshop covered regions with diverse historical experiences of oil production, including onshore and offshore, industry pioneers and current producers, places where the oil industry has become a part of local culture and others where populations have remained disengaged from it. The programme included presentations from museums in Scotland, Norway, Romania, Poland, Russia, and Canada; virtual tours of Wiess Energy Hall in Houston, Texas and Norwegian Petroleum Museum, academic talks on the challenges of representing industrial heritage in Iran, Azerbaijan, Venezuela, and Qatar; and a talk on the experience of memorialisation in an older 'sister' fossil fuel energy, coal, in Ukraine and the UK.

The workshop generated great interest from museum curators, scholars as well as industry professionals, and people interested in oil and heritage. We plan to continue this conversation with further events, publications, and workshops.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://energyethics.st-andrews.ac.uk/a-place-for-oil/schedule/
 
Description Creation of online teaching materials for GCSE and A-Level high school pupils in Wales: "Hughesovka - Welsh Migration and Industrialization in the Russian Empire": 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact This resource invites learners to approach the history of Welsh industrialisation from a different perspective. The city of Hughesovka in the former Russian Empire was founded by Welsh and British workers. Using Hughesovska as a case study, the resource aims to enable learners to develop a more nuanced and critical perspective on the history of industrialisation in their country and to critically engage with archival material.
The source material (photographs and other images) within this resource comes from the Hughesovska Research Archive, held at the Glamorgan Archives, and these are reproduced here with their kind permission.
The sources are available in an Open Access archive where high school teachers can download them and use them for preparing their classes. To date they have been viewed 297 times.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.peoplescollection.wales/learn/hughesovska-welsh-migration-industrialisation-russia
 
Description Diana Vonnak featured on BBC Radio 3 Arts and Ideas "Odessa Stories" 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Diana Vonnak featured on BBC Radio 3 Arts and Ideas "Odessa Stories" discussing Babel, the war against Ukraine, and decolonization.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p0c59smq
 
Description Exhibition "Ekologiia u kadry" at the "Poruch" Centre for veterans and their families in Kramatorsk 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact An exhibition of work on the theme of post-industrial environments and ecologies co-curated by Victoria Donovan, Iryna Sklokina, Dmytro Bilko, and Anna Bahachenko. The exhibition featured new digitized photography from industrial heritage collections acrsoss Ukraine and research texts co-authored by UK and Ukrainian researchers. The exhibition stimulated new thinking about the evironmental consequences and ecological realities of industrial and post-industrial transformation in the Ukrainian East. It was displayed at the "Poruch" Centre for Veterans and their Families in Kramatorsk from January 2021-present (the outbreak of war in Ukraine in February 2022 has obviously impacted on attendance). We also intended to translate and publish an online English-language version of the exhibition, but these plans have been disrupted by the outbreak of war.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.kramatorskpost.com/v-kramatorsku-vidkrilas-vistavka-arxivnix-fotografii-ekologiya-u-kadr...
 
Description Exhibition "What Is A Bing?" at the Wee Museum of Memory at Livingston Centre 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact +500 members of the general public attended an exhibition at the Wee Museum of Memory at Livingston Centre featuring creative work and research texts emerging from the Schools Photography Workshops on the West Lothian oil shale bings. The exhibition was shown between September 2021 and January 2022. The Wee Museum of Memory is part of the Living Memory Association. It encourages people to become actively involved in their community, share their memories, learn from one another, feel valued and respected, and give their knowledge of the past to younger generations. The exhibition stimulated memories of life in West Lothian during the era of oil shale industry, prompted reflections on the value of industrial heritage today, and new thinking about the kinds of creativity that can be produced in response to this history and heritage.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Exhibition of work emerging from Un/archiving Post/industry Summer School at the Pokrovsk Local History Museum 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact +100 members of the general public attended an exhibition of work emerging from the "Un/archiving Post/industry" Summer School coordinated together with the Center of Urban History of East Central Europe in Lviv at Zaleznyak-fest at the Pokrovsk Local History Museum. The exhibition resulted in increased public awareness of industrial heritage collections and the work heritage professionals are doing to preserve a record on industry in the Ukrainian East. The artist responses to the heritage collections prompted new thinking about new creative ways that this history and heritage can be enaged in the region and work that can be done with schools and marginalised communities (such as schoolchildren with various additional learning needs).
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.lvivcenter.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/pokrovsk-final-ukr.pdf
 
Description Feature on BBC Radio 3 Free Thinking 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Featured on BBC Radio 3's Free Thinking "Sesame Street and Soviet Culture" talking about Ukrainian film and visual art of the East.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p0f6bpmw
 
Description Industrial Dreams. Voices from industry erased - resistance and archive in Ebbw Vale and Mariupol 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact "Industrial Dreams" was a workshop and mini film-festival that took place in Ebbw Vale, exploring erased industrial pasts and the struggle for remembrance, in Wales and in Donbas. The workshop brought together photographs, maps, and postcards from the collections of the Gwent Archives, Ebbw Vale Works Museum, Ebbw Vale Institute archives, the Mariupol Local History Museum and the Center for the Urban History of East-Central Europe's Urban Media Archive. FreeFilmers' Life Beyond the CV was screened, and people were invited to think about the closure and the destruction of industry, war in Ukraine, and erasure in Wales, led by Stefhan Caddick, Victoria Donovan and Diána Vonnák. The event culminated with the UK premiere of the documentary Eurodonbas, followed by a discussion with director Kornii Hrytsiuk and producer-scriptwriter Anna Palenchuk. Around 50-60 people attended including a reporter from ITV Wales, several local politicians, former steelworkers, and Ukrainian refugess. The workshop sparked conversations about the shared heritage of industrialization, deindustrialization and socio-economic transformation.
Participants wrote postcards to Ukraine, expressing solidarity and telling them about their own histories of labour migration, family histories of war and survival, and the similar challenges they have lived through amidst the broader social process of de-industrialisation.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://donbasinfocus.wordpress.com/industrial-dreams/
 
Description Interview about the AHRC project for Vil'ne Radio, Bakhmut 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Interview about my AHRC research and fieldwork in Donbas with Natasha Zhukova for Vil'ne Radio, Bakhmut, Ukraine.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://freeradio.com.ua/rodom-z-uelsu-vykladaie-u-shotlandii-vyvchaie-donbas-interv-iu-z-brytankoiu...
 
Description Interview for the Time Radio "The Welsh Affair" 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Interview about Hughesovka for Times Radio podcast "Red Box"
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.thetimes.co.uk/podcasts/red-box?ilc=timesradio:podcasts
 
Description Into the Bings. Explore - Write - Repeat 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact In this day-long workshop we explored the industrial history and heritage of the West Lothian region and brought this into conversation with stories of industrial regions from Ukraine, with bings of their own. Working with the West Lothian Council archives, and artists and writers from Scotland and Mariupol, we asked what new stories can be told about the (post-)industrial places that we love.

The day included a creative writing workshop. Award-winning poet and author Garry MacKenzie helped us discover how to write about the world around us - from animals and plants to the traces of West Lothian's industrial past which are visible in the landscape. We delved into the history of the region's mining communities, and worked together on composing a community poem celebrating the area's heritage and looking forwards to its future. Fun writing activities helped us explore some of the techniques which writers use to bring their imaginations, and their physical environments, to life.
The workshop was a great success, bringing together different generations from octogenarians to young kids. After Victoria Donovan's introduction we started the day by screening films from our partners from Mariupol, FreeFilmers, introduced by St Andrews ESRC postdoctoral researcher and Mariupol scholar, Anna Balázs. People then explored our outdoor pop-up exhibition featuring artwork by Oleksandr Kuchynskyi and Viktor 'Corwic' Zasypkin. Their paintings and digital collages were hung on trees along the paths of the community garden, some of which follow old industrial tracks. The garden itself is a space marked by post-industrial questions, friendly, sustainable and resilient response to the challenges of figuring out life and community after industry in West Lothian. Kuchynskyi's and Zasypkin's works with their re-imagined archival images and urban photography brought similar dilemmas into sharp relief.

After delicious Ukrainian food we re-convened for the writing workshop led by Garry, where people thought together about the language we use to describe our surroundings, mixing lyrical, technical, official languages into community poetry. Emma Peattie from West Lothian Council brought us maps, photographs and objects from the holdings of the archive, to help us get a sense of the history and the geology of West Lothian. FreeFilmers artists Sashko Protyah, Masha Pronina and Alisa Oleva created audio stories for the workshop, reflecting on walking through East Ukrainian landscapes, exploring slag heaps, industrial beaches and urban edgelands.

We finished the day reflecting on ecology after industry, the similarities in how grassroots initiatives reclaim spaces and reimagine abandoned, disused buildings in West Lothian and Donbas. We convened this workshop because we were inspired by these resonances, but were still surprised to see how many synergies emerged in our discussions with local audiences.



Program

Gates open at 13.00

13.00-14.00 Buffet lunch, arriving, intro

14.00-14.45 Film screening (FreeFilmers)

14.45-15.45 Walking and free writing workshop

16.45-16.00 Coffee Break

16.00-16.30 Film screening 2 (Free Filmers)

16.30-17.30 Writing workshop + exploring archival materials from West Lothian

17.30-18.00 Wrap-up
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://donbasinfocus.wordpress.com/into-the-bings/
 
Description Presenter of CNN documentary "The Donbas region is at the heart of Russia's war. Here's why it's so important," 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Development and presentation of documentary exploring why Russia's war on Ukraine has turned toward the country's eastern industrial region of Donbas.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://edition.cnn.com/videos/world/2022/04/19/why-putin-wants-donbas-ukraine-lon-orig-cb.cnn
 
Description Public lecture "Archive Fever in Pandemic Times," keynot lecture at Un/archiving Post/industry Summer School in Pokrovsk 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Public lecture "Archive Fever in Pandemic Times," keynote lecture at Un/archiving Post/industry Summer School in Pokrovsk delivered to artists and heritage practitioners. The talk sparked discussion and informed the archival focus of the artworks produced at the summer school.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.lvivcenter.org/updates/unarchaving-postindustry-summer-school/?fbclid=IwAR1PzDtUn4ZWhaIX...
 
Description Research workshop: Embodied Forms of Research 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact I delivered a workshop on methodologies of embodied research together with my PhD student Darya Tsymbalyuk. The workshop formed part of the annual postgraduate symposium organised by the Institute for Cultural Identity and Memory Studies at the University of St Andrews.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://cims.wp.st-andrews.ac.uk/other-research-events/
 
Description Schools Photography Workshop in West Lothian 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact 11 pupils attended four photography workshops on the oil shale bings of West Lothian. They were joined by museum practitioners from the Museum of Scottish Oil Shale Industry, archivists from the West Lothian Archives, former workers in the Shale Industry, and geologists from the St Andrews GeoBus team. The workshops resulted in new creativity in the form of an exhibition of cyanotypes produced using bings flora and fauna, new thinking around post-industrial heritage and its usage, increased awareness of disciplinary tracks at HEIs and options for practical experience in museums and heritage sectors, improved self-confidence, and professional growth for artists and practitioner involved.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://padlet.com/daryatsymbalyuk/86frug1zrg2wkmwc
 
Description Talk about the exhibition "What Does Post-Industrial Look Like?" at the Being Human Festival 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact A talk about the exhibition "What Does Post-Industrial Look Like?" at the Art of Energy gallery at the University of St Andrews delivered at the Being Human Fesitval, the UK's only national festival of the humanities.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://beinghumanfestival.org/events/art-energy-creative-encounters
 
Description Talk at the event "Whose Data Is it Anyway" organised as part of the GCRF Cultural Heritage hub 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Talk about work with Ukrainian archives and digitization initiatives for the event "Whose Data Is It Anyway?" with Iryna Sklokina, Oleksandr Makhanets Anna Bahachenko, and Miroslava Liakhovych" at the GCRF Cultural Heritage Hub Project Seminar Series. Ukrainian colleagues participating at the event reported that is was very useful to speak about these topics with partners across the globe, particularly with St Andrews project partners in the Global South. As a result of the talk one of the Ukrainian participants published an article reflecting on the topics discussed in a Ukrainian language publication.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://events.st-andrews.ac.uk/events/global-converation-whose-data-is-it-anyway-webinar/
 
Description Un/archiving Post/industry Summer School in Pokrovsk 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Together with the Center for Urban History of East Central Europe, I coordinated a Summer School for 20 artists, heritage practitioners, museums professionals, researchers and other creative practitioners at the Pokrovsk Local History Museum in Ukraine. Participants worked with industrial heritage collections, contributed to seminar discussions, and innovated new creative projects and work in response to the archival materials. The Summer School sparked great interest among artist contributors and heritage professionals, resulting in proposals for art projects that were realised with further funding from the Center for Urban History of East Central Europe.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.lvivcenter.org/en/summer-schools/un-archiving-post-industry/
 
Description Virtual Exhibition: What Does Post-Industrial Look Like? 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact A virtual exhibition of photography produced by Ukrainian project collaborator Mykhailo Kulishov and participant at AHRC Schools Photography Workshop, Martyna Krupa, "What Does Post-Industrial Look Like?" The exhibition formed part of the Centre for Energy Ethics "Art of Energy" exhibition featuring work by St Andrews scholars engaging energy and industry themes. The exhibition
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://energyethics.st-andrews.ac.uk/galleries/