The War of the Locust: science, politics, culture and collaboration in the Anti-Locust Research Centre, 1940-45

Lead Research Organisation: University of Warwick
Department Name: History

Abstract

Outbreaks of the desert locust - Schistocerca gregaria - have plagued agricultural societies since the beginnings of recorded history. How states have perceived and dealt with this threat has not only affected the livelihoods of generations of farmers and pastoralists; it has played an important part in the making and unmaking of states' legitimacy. This project brings together an historian, a forensic entomologist, an artist and an ecologist to examine the record of one of the most prominent international efforts ever made to counter this threat - the British Empire's Anti-Locust Research Centre (ALRC). Over the course of the twentieth-century, the ALRC drew on the expertise of entomologists, explorers, meteorologists, cartographers, filmmakers, colonial administrators, diplomats and military personnel in an unprecedented attempt to monitor, control and eradicate the desert locust across great swathes of the earth. At the height of its activities, during the Second World War in the Middle East, the ALRC came to the attention of some of the foremost scientists and statesmen of the day. Its successes were built on the collaboration of widely varying forms of expertise; its campaigns laid the foundations for systems of international control that still endure. But its record was not without frustrations, with compromises and tensions born of discrepancies between the differing disciplinary views of its participants, and of varying interpretations of their objective and the wider world.

This project brings together history, ecology, entomology and art to examine the work of the Anti-Locust Research Centre, and the unique and hitherto unexplored archive it left behind. The ALRC was inherently an interdisciplinary undertaking; it requires an interdisciplinary approach to examine its record. Each Co-Investigator brings their own disciplinary expertise to bear upon key ALRC activities, from its navigation of imperial bureaucracies and wartime geopolitics to its specimen sampling and forecasting techniques, its use of visual media, and the multiple forms of environmental knowledge it promoted and inscribed. But throughout, the project also explores the process and nature of interdisciplinary work itself, examining how very different individuals and disciplines spoke to one another under the umbrella of the ALRC, and how we as Co-Investigators come to collaborate as we reconstruct its activities.

This project is of interest to a wide number of communities both inside and outside of academia, including historians of the British Empire and the modern Middle East; entomologists and students of climate change, food security and bioterrorism possibilities; scholars and practitioners concerned with the dialogues and frictions between science and policy; and wider audiences interested in how 'migrants', 'pests' and systems of control are represented. Our exhibition and artist's book, which will explore the poetics and metaphors within the archive, also bring the possibility of our findings engaging with unanticipated audiences: those who encounter the gallery/exhibition space by chance and whose curiosity becomes piqued.

Planned Impact

This project engages with a variety of users across academia, museums, non-governmental organisations and the wider public. Our key objective is to bring a multiplicity of perspectives to bear on the Anti-Locust Research Centre, the work of which has considerable contemporary relevance. The desert locust remains a potential threat to communities from Mauritania to Bangladesh; at the time of writing the Malagasy migratory locust is threatening the livelihoods of 13 million people in Madagascar, with UN FAO spending $36.4 million in 2013-16 to protect the island's crops and pasture. Our project has three complementary strategies for delivering impact.

Firstly, our four, specifically tailored seminar events have considerable potential for public engagement. Each involves a group presentation on our findings, methodologies, and experience of collaboration. At the NHM, the Public Engagement Group and Programme Manager Stephen Roberts have agreed to liaise with us to explore the most effective means of engaging Museum public audiences. At Glasgow School of Art our presentation during term time to students and staff will feature a strong multi-media and visual element; it is likely that a small exhibition will also accompany this seminar. These two events are designed to elicit a range of responses from wider audiences, whose reactions and responses will then feature in our 'Archive Box' activity (see below). At The British Ecological Society (BES) Annual Meeting our interactive workshop will examine methods, conflicts and synergies when the arts and sciences collaborate. The final event at the University of Warwick will disseminate our findings to important academic communities, but is also designed as a forum in which to begin discussions with invited practitioners and potential partners (such as UN FAO) regarding subsequent research project applications with a significant non-academic impact.

Secondly, our work will be of benefit to the Natural History Museum itself, as we highlight new findings that will assist Library staff with future collection development. The ALRC collection is still only catalogued to a basic (box) level: our investigation of its documents, photographs, maps and specimens will offer a much deeper undertaking of its workings and of the content of the collection. Collectively, our multi-disciplinary approach to the ALRC collection will support innovative outputs and ways of working which NHM may ultimately bring to bear on other collections in their possession.

Finally, all Investigators will contribute to a private online research journal throughout the project's duration, documenting our questions, findings, sketches, approaches and experiences as a collaborative space. Selected content will then be edited for a separate, public-facing blog, with a focus on using specific archive artefacts as a window onto particular narratives, events, data and findings (selected posts may also be suitable for the AHRC Science in Culture blog). At the project's end we will make the newest submission to the ALRC archive by depositing an Archive Box full of our research documents, artistic outcomes, and USB disk copies of our online research journal and blog posts. It will also contain responses to our work arising from the public events at GSA and NHM. This research time capsule will serve as an 'archive within the archive', detailing our methods and findings as well documenting the experiential, personal and mundane aspects of this interdisciplinary project, and wider reactions to it. By depositing this Archive Box, we will construct a direct connection and prop for our other engagement activities.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Fletcher, R. (2017) The Locust, the Empire and the Museum in evolve

 
Description The work arising from this grant is still ongoing, and being continued through subsequently funded research. But the main findings have been focused around the uncatalogued collection at NHM; the re-discovery of a forgotten specimen collection; and an increasingly sophisticated understanding of how the different constituent parts of the archive engage with one another. This has enabled a new understanding of the history of Britain's efforts at international locust control; the methods and reliability of both specimen collection and data management by those organisations; and the wider human, economic and political contexts in which scientific labour has occurred across the twentieth-century.
Exploitation Route The knowledge of the collection our work has generated will be of considerable practical use to its owner and curator, the NHM; we are keen to stay in dialogue with them about future development opportunities around this collection. Our findings on the history and science of locust control will also be taken forward by the National Museum of Wales in a public exhibition on the subject later in 2019, and by the UNFAO (the organisation responsible for locust control today) with whom we met in 2018.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Environment,Government, Democracy and Justice,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/arts/history/ghcc/research/deserts/
 
Description The major impact contribution of this project has been to explore the uncatalogued archive of the antilocust research centre at the Natural History Museum; to share our findings and knowledge of this archive with archive staff in order to better facilitate its conservation and promotion; and to raise awareness of its significance as a cultural and historic resource. In addition to many discussions with archive staff, we published a feature article in the Museum's public-facing magazine "evolve" to promote the collection. This had led to contact with a number of members of the public which we continue to pursue. Our growing understanding of the collection led to a second funded project, with which we have developed a public exhibition with the National Museum of Wales on locust control; workshops with the UNFAO on the history of locust control; and other public engagement opportunities.
First Year Of Impact 2016
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink,Environment,Government, Democracy and Justice,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Policy & public services

 
Description AHRC Science in Culture Follow-on Funding
Amount £80,203 (GBP)
Funding ID AH/R004633/1 
Organisation Arts & Humanities Research Council (AHRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2017 
End 09/2018
 
Description Natural History Musem 
Organisation Natural History Museum
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Myself & research team working w/ Andrea Hart (Head of Special Collections), Jane Smith (Head of Library) and Library staff to identify important material in the uncatalogued antilocust collection, to raise awareness of its significance and value to wider audiences, and to explore pathways for the digitisation and display of this material.
Collaborator Contribution Logistic support in access to the material. We will need further support from NHM staff in order to digitise this material and to put it on display in the future.
Impact Major outcome has been the identification of - photographs - films - maps - locust specimens - documents --- all of which of great potential in communicating the important work of the antilocust research centre and its part in the histories of economic entomology; man's complex relationship with flora and fauna in Africa and SW Asia; histories of colonialism and global exchange. The identification and selection of material from the archive for loan to NMW for the Cardiff exhibition has also resulted in select items being restored and sent to preservation; a number of 35mm films were specifically digitised for the exhibition - the first time these films had been rendered into a viewable state since their accession. This material has supported our ongoing academic outputs, a brief summary of the scope of which is provided in our "evolve" piece. The identification of suggestive visual material has also laid the groundwork for an exhibition application, which became the subject of a subsequent UKRI grant application.
Start Year 2016
 
Description Research Fellow at Natural History Museum 
Organisation Natural History Museum
Department Life Sciences Department
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution - working with Library and Archives staff to develop collections. Working with uncatalogued material; sharing information about the context and scope of the collection with library and archives staff; producing new catalogues of material - discussing material, particularly on the anti-locust collection, with entomologists in the museum, including Andy Polaschek - working with the Centre for Arts and Humanities Research in group seminars to share news about these collections and promote an Arts and Humanities approach to Museum collections - as part of this, developing a further research grant application on a focused part of the Museum's collections (this grant was successful, through the Science in Culture theme)
Collaborator Contribution - provision of library support and study space in CAHR office
Impact - forthcoming article in EVOLVE magazine, the NHM's member magazine, on my research - conversations about future research grant collaboration - multidisciplinary - entomology, ecology, art, history
Start Year 2015
 
Description UNFAO 
Organisation Food and Agricultural Organisation (FAO)
Country Italy 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Collaboration with United Nations Food and Agricultural Organisation focused on a workshop at UNFAO Headquarters in Rome, with ongoing dialogue around the possibilities of future collaboration. We have developed these activities in close consultation with Locust Group's Director, Keith Cressman, who has articulated a clear need for an historical and comparative exploration of the origins of his organisation, especially in light of the recent passing of some of the ALRC's last surviving members. The main seminar, attended by 3 of the 4 members of the research team and an equal number of Locust staff at UNFAO, focused on sharing insights from the past and present of locust control to explore gaps in the scientific, administrative and political capabilities of both past and present organisations. The seminar involved an all-morning tour of Locust headquarters at UNFAO during which the team learned a great deal about the operational capacity and systems of UNFAO locust watch. In the afternoon we held a structured workshop with the Locust team at UNFAO in which we prepared materials from the archive and used these as the basis for an active discussion of what this older information might add to understandings of the methodologies, shortcomings, work and cultures of locust monitoring and forecasting in the present and the future, with the potential to influence current policy and practice. The workshop ended with an outline for potential future collaboration around intensive research of specific 'case studies' from the archive which could be of particular interest to UNFAO today in understanding how to respond to the increasingly unpredictable nature of locust control - a particular feature of some of the earlier plagues in our archival record, but which UNFAO has not had to face in more recent memory.
Collaborator Contribution UNFAO's tour and hosting of the workshop helped our research to come to the attention of critical practitioner communities, while enriching our mutual understanding of the wider contexts of international anti-locust campaigns and the challenges of interdisciplinary collaboration. The seminar also worked to support the pursuit of new user contacts in the world of international development, helping to build capacity for subsequent funding applications on a larger scale.
Impact The seminar included activities that actively used and compared the data, methods and forecasts uncovered by the research team in the ALRC archive with the contemporary systems and practices of UNFAO Headquarters. The dialogue around the implications of this material and the possibilities of future collaborative research around it is still active.
Start Year 2017
 
Description Locust paper at workshop on mobility in the interwar Middle East, in Neuchatel, Switzerland 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact This event will run in October. Paper on the great locust plague of 1940-48, and place on final roundtable, at this postgraduate/ECR event.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Participation in Radio programme on locust control 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact I was invited to be one of three discussants on Swiss Public Radio (SRF) in a 30 minute program on locust control, past and present. The programme was twice broadcast on the airwaves, and streamed online; an edited full length version (1 hour) was subsequent;y released as well. The estimated audience from SRF was 100,000 people.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL http://www.srf.ch/sendungen/wissenschaftsmagazin
 
Description Talk at UEA on history of international locust control 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Talk at UEA on international locust control in November 2017.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description War of the Locust 1940-45 workshop at Warwick December 2017 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact All-team workshop on the project, with particular attention paid to exploring the nature and challenges of interdisciplinary work, for the benefit of postgraduate research students in particular. Students reported orally and in written feedback (see link) how the event was inspiring and informational about the possibilities and constraints of interdisciplinary work.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/arts/history/ghcc/blog/workshop_report_the/