Coping with climate: the legacy of H. heidelbergensis

Lead Research Organisation: University of Reading
Department Name: Archaeology

Abstract

We've all seen, whether in books, museums or on television and other media, representations of our early human ancestors, typically naked or with only the most limited forms of animal skin 'clothing'. We've also all woken up on cold winters' mornings, and crawled back under the duvet (or spent ten minutes de-icing the car). These themes of behaviour, material culture and climate, and the connections between them, are central to the story of Europe's earliest humans, who date back at least one million years.

The proposed research network therefore aims to address two fundamental evolutionary questions: firstly, what were the 'globalising' adaptations of Homo heidelbergensis (a key early human species in Europe, which existed prior to the Neanderthals and our own species, Homo sapiens)? In practical terms such adaptations would be required for early humans to deal successfully with the varying day-to-day challenges brought on by the changing latitudes and longitudes encountered during dispersals through Eurasia: e.g. long winters, short days, and marked seasonality. These factors would have impacted significantly on issues as varied as food availability, climatic tolerances, human technological and social behaviours, inter-species interactions (as suggested by recent palaeogenetic studies), and even human morphology and speciation events (the evolution of new human species). Secondly, how have those 'globalising' adaptations contributed to the evolution of our own species' abilities to manage climatic and environmental challenges (both past and present)?

These questions are currently unanswered, despite the fact that during the last twenty years researchers have come to recognise that the emergence of our own species, H. sapiens, was a more gradual and complex process than the 'human revolution' perspectives of the late 1980s (that older viewpoint argued that there was a rapid and dramatic 'step-change' in human behaviour, which appeared with H. sapiens). However even the newer perspectives continue to ignore over 1 million years of human evolution: this is the period sandwiched between the first dispersals of older human species from Africa (occurring around 1.8 million years ago) and the first appearance of H. sapiens (around 200,000 years ago in Africa). Yet the intervening period is critical to our understanding of human behavioural evolution, because H. heidelbergensis (whose European fossils are mostly dated to between 600,000 and 400,000 years ago) is widely recognised as our last common ancestor (albeit one that we also shared with the Neanderthals), and was also the first human species to engage successfully and enduringly with the new climatic and environmental challenges faced during those initial dispersals from Africa. This species, and other early Europeans such as Homo antecessor, are thus an invaluable test case for developing our understanding of how early humans met the challenges of Eurasian environments, and the associated implications for evolutionary developments in hominin technology, social life, and cognition.

The overall goal of the network is therefore to engage academics (e.g. from archaeology, palaeoenvironmental studies, palaeoclimatology, palaeogenetics, and anthropology), stakeholder groups (bushcraft organisations, museums and teachers), and the general public with the dynamic realities of Pleistocene (Ice Age) life and behaviour: e.g. taking paleoclimatologists from the climate model to the realities of a cold winter morning, while taking archaeologists from the stone tool to the dynamics of animal migrations and plant food security. This will advance our knowledge and understanding across multiple research fields, an exercise which is the only means of coming to understand the complex dynamics and the realities of the great dispersals of our human past. The trans-disciplinary approach proposed by this network application is the first step in achieving this goal.

Planned Impact

Who will benefit from this research?

The principal non-academic beneficiaries of the research will be:

- School teachers and pupils;
- Local, regional and national museum organisations;
- The general public (museum visitors).

The principal intended impacts on the above groups will emphasise:

- The day-to-day survival strategies of Britain's earliest ice age humans;
- The ice age lives which lie behind museums' stone tool collections;
- The importance of present-day, hunter-gatherer cultures in developing understanding of our European past.

The project will thus emphasise:

- A re-alignment in the presentation and dissemination of 'origins' archaeology, placing greater emphasis upon the (Palaeolithic) realities of living within (Pleistocene) worlds: helping visitors to see stone tools not as type x or y, but rather in the context of the risks (e.g. climate, predators, injury) of travelling a few kilometres from a 'safe' sleeping site to a source of stone for tool-making.

- Bushcraft organisations and experimental archaeological outreach demonstrators: developing the general public's perception of bushcraft skills and hunter-gatherer lifestyles, with reference to their varied roles in helping all of us to understand both our contemporary environments and our human pasts.

These impacts will be achieved through a variety of means, primarily:

- The "Day in the Ice Age" event (hosted at Reading Museum) which will demonstrate, and engage school groups and the general public with, the theme of practical Ice Age survival strategies (e.g. wild foods, pyrotechnology, shelters and clothing). Schools from Reading and Brighton and the surrounding regions will receive targeted invitations to the respective events. The events will also promote the project's resources (see below; to be circulated through the project's hub website).

- Teaching resources for schools. These resources will be explicitly targeted at Key Stage 2, and current needs for resources to support the teaching of prehistory in the curriculum. These needs have been established, and resource types identified, through discussions with Reading University's Institute of Education and teaching consultancies (Schools Prehistory). Resources will include: lesson plans; image banks (e.g. of artefacts; reconstructions of Ice Age environments, hominin habitats and behaviours); Palaeolithic (= Old Stone Age) Timeline; 'Fundamentals' Fact-Sheets (Palaeolithic chronology and behaviour, and Ice Age environments); video-clips & photographs (practical Ice Age survival techniques; e.g. tool-making; processing of animal skins; exploitation of wild plant foods); digital 3D PDF models of artefacts (for display) and files for 3D printer replication; practical exercises (e.g. 'human' timelines); and links to existing web-based resources (see the Pathways to Impact document for further details).

- Evaluation of the "Day in the Ice Age" event and the school resources (e.g. level of event participation and resource take-up, and evidence of modified practices [e.g. in teaching]), through pre- and post-event on-line surveys and interviews/discussions via Skype, email and in person.

- Evaluation of the "Day in the Ice Age" event and school resources will lead to a set of recommendations, to be shared with the British Museum and the Museums Association (http://www.museumsassociation.org/), for consideration as a model for the promotion of Palaeolithic archaeology to the general public.

- The integration of stakeholder groups (teachers, bushcraft organisations and local, regional and national museums) and academic participants throughout the project, ensuring that schools, museums and bushcraft groups are active participants in the creation of the research, rather than static (and perhaps unwilling) 'recipients' of the project's outcomes and/or 'visual illustrators' of hunter-gatherer behaviours (e.g. tool-making and animal skins preparation).

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The network meeting highlighted a number of key themes for the understanding of early humans (i.e. from roughly 1.5 million years ago to 300,000 years = the Lower Palaeolithic period) in Europe with respect to Pleistocene ('Ice Age') climate and how they coped with it. These themes cut-across various sub-specialisms (i.e. Palaeolithic archaeology [focusing on technology and diet], Palaeoanthropology [fossil humans], and Quaternary climates and environment [including plant and animal communities]). Key themes included population characteristics (e.g. the periodic fragmentation, geographical isolation and then re-combination of early human groups, and the implications of this for human evolution and artefact patterning in the archaeological record), developing appropriate reconstructions of Pleistocene environments (e.g. being cautious when using modern animals as models for their Pleistocene equivalents; the meeting discussed various methodologies [such as microscopic dental analysis] which are providing increasingly detailed understanding of past animal behaviours), and being more explicit about the nature of, and bias in, our evidence (e.g. the different scales and resolution of our evidence - from sub-annual to tens of thousands of years; those landscapes settings that we know less and more about - such as uplands compared to river valleys). The meeting as a whole expressed interest in developing new research to explore and resolve some of these issues. Post-workshop we have identified a group of 15 multi-national colleagues and institutions who are developing a new research project application for the ERC. We have also developed new initiaties in Palaeolithic fieldwork and palaeofire.
Exploitation Route We have shared our new school resources (aimed at KS2: http://blogs.brighton.ac.uk/copingwithclimate/resources-for-schools/) through the Schools Prehistory website (http://www.schoolsprehistory.co.uk/2018/02/25/resources-collected-from-around-the-web-for-teaching-human-evolution/), the Prehistoric Society website (pending) and thinkinghistory.co.uk (pending). Feedback from potential school users is pending. We are currently preparing a blog publication with Reading Museum staff, reflecting on the project's impact activities ('A Day in the Ice Age' event for the general public/schools, and the project's temporary museum exhibition) from a 'lessons learned' perspective - this will be posted on the Reading Museum blog (https://www.readingmuseum.org.uk/blog) and shared with the wider museums and education sectors.
Sectors Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL http://blogs.brighton.ac.uk/copingwithclimate/project-workshop-and-events/
 
Description Our key impact activities (general public/school group events [1-day event and temporary exhibition] and new school teaching resources for Key Stage 2) have been completed, with school group and general public attendance (at the events) and circulation of the new teaching resources (through the project website and other key organisational websites; feedback from potential school users is pending). The lessons learned from the general public/school group events will be shared with the wider museums and education sectors (the document is currently in preparation).
First Year Of Impact 2017
Sector Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural

 
Description A Day in the Ice Age (Reading Museum) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact We ran a 1-day event, "A Day in the Ice Age", in collaboration with Reading Museum (July 2017) . The event was co-designed with Reading Museum, Wilderness Survival Skills (Joe O'Leary & Dr Theresa Kamper), and Ancient Craft (James Dilley), and Royal Holloway, University of London (Prof. Danielle Schreve). The event promoted 'ice age' survival skills (e.g. shelter building, fire making, animal skin processing and clothing, and stone-tool making) and the evidence (human remains, animal remains, stone tools) for the earliest human occupation of Europe. Activities from the event (e.g. shelter construction and hide working) were recorded and made available through the project website (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8LZg_5psM34&feature=youtu.be). The event was targeted at Reading and Berkshire schools (n=85) with a general public session (public numbers attending the event cannot be precisely calculated due to the format of the event, but the number of people who visited Reading Museum during the day was c. 650). We are currently writing a 'best practice' reflective post on the planning and organisation of the event, for the Reading Museum blog (https://www.readingmuseum.org.uk/blog), in collaboration with Reading Museum staff. The follow is selected email feedback from participants: "The event was thoroughly enjoyed by all. The staff were impressed with the way it was run and the children really loved the hands on activities."; "Thanks for organising such a wonderful event. The children and teachers that attended said it was fantastic."; "I would just like to say how much I enjoyed the displays last Wednesday. I was particularly impressed with a young man who was showing the skulls of bears. (I think his name was Dan). He was very enthusiastic."
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8LZg_5psM34&feature=youtu.be
 
Description Conference paper (Pal-Meso 2016) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Conference presentation at the Palaeolithic-Mesolithic 2016 meeting (hosted by and at the British Museum). The paper ("Winter is coming: How to think a northern survival strategy?"), by Hosfield & Cole, focused on a key network project theme - the earliest occupation of Europe and the climatic challenges faced.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
 
Description Conference paper (RAI 2016) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Conference presentation at the RAI (Royal Anthropological Institute) 2016 conference "Anthropology, Weather and Climate Change" (hosted at the British Museum), in the "Climate change and the evolution of technology and palaeobiology in Homo from ~1.5 million years ago" panel. The paper ("Winter is coming: How to think a northern survival strategy?"), by Hosfield & Cole, focused on a key network project theme - the earliest occupation of Europe and the climatic challenges faced.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
URL http://www.nomadit.co.uk/rai/events/rai2016/panels.php5?PanelID=3819
 
Description Project workshop (Brighton) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact 40 colleagues from the UK and across Europe (Spain, France, Germany, Poland) and beyond (Israel) attended a three day project workshop (Coping with climate: the legacy of H. heidelbergensis; hosted at the University of Brighton, UK; February 2nd-4th 2017). The workshop included a mixture of structured discussions (days 1 and 2) and podium presentations (day 3), with the key focus being assessments of current understanding, identifying areas for further research, and developing new collaborations. The discussions at the workshop also significantly informed a single-authored monograph published in 2020 by Hosfield (The Earliest Europeans: A Year in the Life - Seasonal survival strategies in the Lower Palaeolithic; https://books.casematepublishers.com/The_Earliest_Europeans.pdf), although this was not a direct outcome of the workshop.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL http://blogs.brighton.ac.uk/copingwithclimate/project-workshop-and-events/
 
Description Reading Museum Temporary Exhibition (Earliest Europeans: How did our ancestor survive?) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact A temporary exhibition at Reading Museum ("Earliest Europeans: How did our ancestor survive?"; September-February 2018), co-designed with Reading Museum staff; and a hands-on knapping event (October 2018; n=22), also run in collaboration with Reading Museum. The temporary exhibition and the knapping event were linked to the 'A Day in the Ice Age' event'. Visitor numbers to Reading Museum over the duration of the temporary exhibition were 36,838 (although of course not all of those visitors necessarily saw the temporary exhibit). We are currently writing a 'best practice' reflective post on the planning and organisation of the exhibition, for the Reading Museum blog (https://www.readingmuseum.org.uk/blog), in collaboration with Reading Museum staff.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017,2018
URL https://www.readingmuseum.org.uk/whats-on/tea-and-talks-two-life-%E2%80%98ice-age%E2%80%99
 
Description Workshop paper (Brighton workshop, 2017) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact Presentation opening the project workshop (Brighton, 2017). The paper ("Winter is coming: How to think a northern survival strategy?"), by Hosfield & Cole, focused on a key network project theme - the earliest occupation of Europe and the climatic challenges faced, and the presentation was designed to outline our current thinking to the network members, establish discussion themes for the meeting, and encourage critical feedback.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017