Debating, Performing & Curating Symbolic Reparations and Transformative Gender Justice in post conflict Societies. (HN)

Lead Research Organisation: King's College London
Department Name: International Development Institute

Abstract

There is a global momentum to address sexual violence in conflict, as well as an emphasis on women in peacebuilding. UN resolutions and guidelines such as SCR 1325 urge governments and peacemakers to include women in peace and reconstruction processes and address gendered harms, and transitional justice and reparation programmes are now expected to include a gender perspective. Within these processes, there is increasing attention for commemoration and the arts as tools for reconciliation and symbolic reparation. However, both in global governance as in transitional justice processes, there is a tendency to reduce gendered harms to sexual violence, and gender to women. This prevents a more transformative gendered perspective on repair, justice, and social change. Hence, we believe that there is an urgent need for a more complex and feminist understanding of the gendered nature of conflict and post-conflict symbolic reparation as well as transformative gender justice.

This project rests on the following assumptions, drawn from research carried out by the applicants:
The specific manifestations of wartime violence and atrocity tend to take place along lines of existing inequalities and injustices, and gender based violence, especially rape, is a tool to forge and reproduce such inequalities. This is not only a wartime strategy, but precedes it and continues afterwards.
The current high-profile attention for sexual violence in policy and law have not done much to mitigate or end sexual violence in conflict or in peace.
Symbolic reparation, or arts as critical intervention, can potentially question and unsettled known hierarchies. This might be a tool for transformative gender justice.
Art may unsettle and question ongoing legacies of colonialism and persistent inequalities that have not been acknowledged or addressed;
Constructions and performances of masculinities that have not been interrogated, particularly in previously colonised societies, can and should be questioned in innovative cultural ways.

Aims and objectives
Debate, compare and analyse existing projects of commemorating periods of violence in a range of post-conflict countries, particularly South Africa and Peru;
Raise questions regarding the relation between national commemoration, symbolic reparation, and transformative gender justice;
Examine and discuss existing performances of symbolic reparations in relation to conflict related gendered harms in South Africa, Peru and beyond.
Identify, debate and compare counter-narratives for gender justice;
Examine the tension between preserving "heritage" and addressing abusive pasts in curating memory;
Consolidate a global and interdisciplinary network of scholars, artists and curators interested in feminist perspectives on commemorative arts and symbolic reparation.

The project aims to achieve above-mentioned objectives by organising three events plus an interactive web-presence, or Virtual Community, that will record the activities, and invite further reflection and intervention. Event 1 will be a two-day academic workshop held in London to debate feminist perspectives on commemoration, symbolic reparation, and the arts. The workshop will invite international scholars to reflect on different country case studies. Event 2, held in Cape Town, will be an interactive two-day workshop/three day visit involving artists, activists, and civil society organisations to reflect and demonstrate how art and performance can contribute to symbolic reparation and transformative gender justice in post-conflict settings. Event 3 involves a South-South exchange between Peru, Colombia and South Africa, where curators involved in national commemoration projects are invited to Lima to discuss sensitivities and opportunities when curating national histories of violence. The impact is expected to be high and cross disciplinary.

Planned Impact

This project has a potential for high impact academically, as well as in the global practice of working for symbolic reparation and transformative gender justice throughout the world, but particularly in Peru and South Africa.

The project aims to influence the debate around transitional versus transformative justice and how to include a gender perspective in these efforts. Focussing on symbolic reparations -arts, memory works, museums etc.- specifically addressing gendered harms, and debating this across disciplinary boundaries, we improve our understanding of the specifically gendered sensitivities and opportunities that symbolic reparations may pose towards transformative gender justice. This is not only relevant to the academic bodies of literature to which this contributes, but likewise to institutions of and practitioners in global bodies with the power to shape symbolic reparations, such as the UN, the World Bank, the International Centre for Transitional Justice, the International Criminal Court, and the FCO/Prevention of Sexual Violence in Conflict Initiative.

All three planned events, (1) Debating, (2) Performing and (3) Curating actively involve scholars and practitioners. We specifically aim for an interdisciplinary environment where scholars, artists, curators and advocates can learn from each other and reflect on their own practice from different perspectives. The website consolidates this and will widen the network far beyond those who are invited into the room. While there is an emphasis on Peru and South Africa, we aim to learn and discuss beyond these two countries, and include both in the events as well as in our social media strategy a range of experiences from different disciplines and geographical areas. As such, we aim to have impact on advocates for women's rights and transformative gender justice, specifically in South Africa and Peru, but also globally. For the Performing event in South Africa, we aim to invite activists, artists and curators from across sub-Saharan Africa. Considering the emphasis on memorialising and symbolic repair in transitional justice processes in Kenya, Rwanda, and DRC, as well as the use of art as protest in, for example, Somalia, we feel that including a range of relevant performers from the region would enrich the debate significantly, and engender a cross-regional critical community not often seen. We also explicitly invite practitioners working for reparation and/or gender equality in policy spaces to the activities in South Africa, expanding the debate to include application of art-as-transformation.

We aim to directly influence the reflective practice of curators in Peru, Colombia and South Africa through a joint visit to the controversial Lugar de la Memoria and associated exhibitions and memorials in Lima. This event directly asks curators to engage with different practices of memorialising, and how their practices do or do not facilitate symbolic reparation and transformative gender justice. Peruvian artists and curators will be invited to present and discuss their work and worries with the international guests. The three countries, all in different transitional (or post-transitional) phases of justice and repair, make for an excellent opportunity to explore the possibilities and constraints to curating conflict-related gendered harms for symbolic reparation.

Lastly, the website will be designed in such a manner that it can provide a platform for engagement for interested scholars, artists, curators and advocates around the world, with an interactive interface. The website can serve as a platform for information, debate, showcasing, and indeed, networking. We hope that this network project will lead to further research projects and collaborations in the future, whereby the website can serve as a central point of contact, dissemination, and engagement.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Drawing on the expertise of 60 participants from around the world in three conferences held in London, Lima and Cape Town, discussing twenty different country contexts from Kurdistan to Namibia and Peru, and a wide range of commemorative practices and activisms, we have learned the following:
- symbolic reparations (apologies, recognition through commemoration, museums) as part of transitional justice processes, tend to include women and gendered harms using stereotypes of what gendered roles are, reproducing patterns of harm and inequality in peacetime;
-But there is widespread use of memorial arts and activism in the broadest sense, to counter such official narratives of conflict or authoritarian rule;
-There is a need to highlight, support, and further foment feminist counter-narratives of conflict as part of transitions to democracy and peace, in order to ensure gender justice.
Exploitation Route The network established through this grant includes a wide range of scholars, activists, performers, artists and curators from around the world, and will likely have unexpected impacts upon the practice of these individual experts. We are compiling two different academic books, one in Spanish and one in English, that will include contributions from non-academics.
Through these outputs we aim to influence understandings of symbolic reparations and gender justice among transitional justice policy makers and practitioners globally.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Government, Democracy and Justice,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL http://www.genderjusticememory.com/blog-gender-justice-and-symbolic-reparation-rethinking-transformative-gender-justice-2/
 
Description The project brings together academics, practitioners, artists and activists to discuss how memorial arts affect gender justice. This is organised around three conferences in London (June 2017), Cape Town (Feb 2018) and Lima (July 2018). Including non-academic practitioners has fruitfully cross-fertilised our thinking and practice. To give a concrete example, the Cape Town conference included a Human Rights Lawyer from Kenya who focused on strategic litigation. There were also Peruvian artists and academics who discussed how in the Peruvian case strategic litigation is accompanied by cultural interventions to create societal support and awareness for the cases they work on. The Kenyan participant is now discussing this strategy with her colleagues in Nairobi to see what they can do in terms of cultural interventions to increase support from civil society. These respective participants came together for a second time in Lima in July 2019, where there were Peruvian human rights lawyers, and hence, this discussion furthered the exchange of good practice between Kenya and Peru. Likewise, feminist activists from South Africa and Peru discussed strategy of mobilisation, likely to influence practice on both sides. In Lima 2018, curators from Peru, Colombia and South Africa continued this cross-fertilisation to discuss how women are/are not represented in post conflict memorial projects. Considering these are three relatively similar case studies in terms of the transitional justice process, but with different outcomes in terms of commemorative practices, this has been a very fruitful exercise. We are preparing two academic books, one in English and one in Spanish (published by the Catholic University of Peru) with contributions from scholars as well as activists, artists, and curators. The project has genuinely created a constructive cross-continental network of scholars and practitioners.
First Year Of Impact 2017
Sector Government, Democracy and Justice,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Other
Impact Types Cultural,Societal

 
Description Newton Mobility Grant
Amount £9,012 (GBP)
Funding ID 2018-19 RD1 
Organisation The British Academy 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2018 
End 09/2019
 
Description Gender Justice Memory Conference 1, London, June 2017 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact The first conference of three under this award was held in June 2017 at king's College, London. 25 International participants presented their work, and 10 scholars from around the UK joined the audience. The conference discussed 'Feminist Perspectives on Commemoration, Symbolic Reparation, and the Arts'. The conference included two performances: one poetry reading by Kurdisch poet-scholar Choman Hardi and one theatre performance by Kenyan performer Mshai Mwangola. Photos, podcasts and videos can be found on the website genderjusticememory.com
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL http://genderjusticememory.com/debating
 
Description Gender Justice Memory Conference 3, Lima 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact This was our last Gender Justice Memory International Conference, inviting human rights lawyers, national memory museum curators, artists, activists and scholars from South Africa, Peru, Colombia, Guatemala, and Kenya to engage in debate about the use and abuse of memorial arts to promote gender justice. The event was attended by 25 participants, and viewed and followed by the broader network established through the first two conferences plus further local (Peruvian and South African) audiences via life streaming and social media reporting. The three conferences have provided a rare opportunity for scholars and practitioners from Southern Africa to discuss their experiences with colleagues in Latin America -a necessary and useful cross-continental debate, considering how transitional justice processes build upon lessons learned globally, but without the consultation of local experts.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL http://www.genderjusticememory.com/lima/
 
Description Gender, Justice, Memory Conference 2, Cape Town 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact This second international conference, held in Feb 2018 in Cape Town, South Africa, was called 'Gender, Symbolic Reparations and the Arts: Exploring and
Disrupting Narratives of Gender Based Violence within Transitional Justice'. The event brought together 25 scholars from Southern Africa and South America to discuss gender and symbolic reparation over three days. The event included a guided tour through some of Cape Town's memorials, from a gender and ethnic lens.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL http://genderjusticememory.com/performing
 
Description Website 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact In early 2017 we set up a website Genderjusticememory.com where we report our activities and findings. the website reports on the international conferences we organise, provides information about the participants in those events, provides a bibliography of works published by network members, and has a blog section in which members post reflections on cultural interventions relevant to the theme of symbolic reparations. The website is also linked to other social media -facebook, twitter and instagram to increase its general audience.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017,2018
URL http://genderjusticememory.com