The effect of dietary bioactive compounds on skin health in humans in vivo

Lead Research Organisation: University of Leeds
Department Name: School of Food Science and Nutrition

Abstract

The skin is the largest organ in the body and is readily visible. The consumer is often very aware of his/her skin and it is a sign to the outside world of health status. Ultraviolet (UV) radiation in sunlight is an important environmental agent that is responsible for short and longer-term negative aspects of skin health, including sunburn and most of the features associated with skin ageing. Behavioural changes have resulted in exposure to higher levels of UV, such that related health issues are increasing, and anticipated to increase further due to predicted climate change. Many previous studies have examined negative effects of food on skin, for example allergy or other diseases, or vitamin or mineral deficiency. There is also a substantial body of evidence showing beneficial effects of drugs and some nutrients on animals and when applied topically to the skin. However, there is surprisingly little information on the effect of orally taken bioactive compounds on skin in humans clinically, despite much supporting evidence for an effect from cell culture, animal, topical and mechanistic studies. The range of expertise provided by our 3-centre collaboration makes us ideally placed to address this area. To underpin the concept of nutrition for a healthy skin, we propose to examine the effect of bioactive compounds for which information in other systems is already available, on humans in vivo using state of the art techniques for measuring biomarkers of skin health directly in the skin, and further to measure nutrient uptake into the skin. Specifically, the data from laboratory studies on human skin cells shows that the compounds in green tea protect very efficiently against UV radiation stress. In addition, a large number of pre-clinical studies on rats and mice have shown a protective effect of green tea against cancers of many types. There are also many papers that report a protective effect of green tea against inflammation when applied directly (topically) to the skin. Taken together, this evidence suggests that a human study where the green tea is given orally is urgently needed and very timely. The importance of vitamin C to skin and connective tissues has been known for a long time. During UV and other stresses, the requirement of vitamin C increases. The study will be conducted over 3 months since the skin takes several months to replenish itself (turnover). The study has been designed to demonstrate a protective effect, and, if results are as expected, the study will be useful to both consumers and industry since it will validate the use of green tea in oral skin care formulations, and also provide the consumer with a choice to drink green tea for improving skin quality and even slowing ageing. It is anticipated that the results will also receive substantial press coverage with good publicity for the researchers and for the BBSRC DRINC programme.

Technical Summary

There is little information on effect of oral catechin, a nutritionally relevant bioactive compound, on skin health in humans in vivo, despite considerable evidence for protective effects, including against UV stresses, in experimental studies. Vitamin C is essential for skin health, and also stabilises catechins in the gut lumen. Ultraviolet in sunlight is a key environmental stressor impacting on skin health, effects including acute inflammation and longer-term photodamage. Our collaborative group has established: (i) Quantitative systems for assessing UV-induced inflammation in human skin in vivo and protective effects of oral nutrients (ii) Effects of polyphenols in humans and evidence of abrogation of UV-stress in vitro (iii) Expertise in measurement of bioavailability of nutrients, especially polyphenols (iv) Short-term model for longer-term photodamage Our primary objective, to examine protection by a combination of dietary catechin and vitamin C on UV-induced inflammation, will be achieved through a double-blind study where 75 healthy humans are randomised to high or low dose bioactive or placebo. Before and after 3 months' supplement, protection against UV-induced inflammation will be examined through clinical, histological and biochemical end-points. Specifically, we will examine for skin erythema, leucocytic infiltration, and for molecular mediators of these processes in samples of skin and skin fluid. We will determine bioavailability of catechin in unexposed and inflamed skin and determine relationships between its skin levels and levels of UV protection. Further, skin samples taken will also be used to assess for immunohistochemical evidence of protection against UV-induced changes in MMP-1, fibrillin-1 and pro-collagen-1, in a short/term model of photoageing. Overall, this project will establish efficacy of bioactives against UV-inflammation, the oral and skin nutrient levels required, and indicate potential against longer-term skin damage.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description We have developed a new method for quantifying and identifying green tea polyphenol metabolites and conjugates in skin, blisters and plasma have been developed. We have also made significant progress in the quantitative analysis of polyphenol conjugates (methylated, sulphated, glucuronidated), especially related to flavanols such as epicatechin and galloylated forms. Previously enzyme deconjugation was used for these types of analyses, losing all the information on the actual species present, and often hydrolysis was incomplete. We have adopted a minimal sample handling technique, coupled with the use of a triple quad mass spectrometer and high resolution HPLC. This has allowed quantification of very low levels of compounds and has guided chemo-enzymatic synthesis. We have demonstrated that some catechins and metabolites are bioavailable in the skin after consumption of green tea. We have made significant advances in the analysis of polyphenolic compounds within skin and interstitial tissue, becoming the first group to detect and report these in skin (biopsies, and blister fluid, representing the liquid between cells) after consumption of green tea. We have also showed that green tea and vitamin C supplementation, at a fairly high level for 3 months, did not improve the protection of skin against sunburn, despite encouraging and positive data from a pilot study, and previously published animal and in vitro studies. These have been published and it is important that results showing "no effect" are published to improve the conclusions from future meta-analyses and systematic reviews on supplements.
Exploitation Route The data should in the future help regulatory authorities such as European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) to formulate policy in the area of supplements and health claims, and to prevent false claims on supplements.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Healthcare

 
Description The findings on the human study have just been published in several papers. A new method for analysis of green tea catechins has also been published. The data should in the future help regulatory authorities such as European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) to formulate policy in the area of supplements and health claims, and to prevent false claims on supplements.
First Year Of Impact 2014
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink,Healthcare
Impact Types Policy & public services

 
Description BBSRC DRINC
Amount £574,702 (GBP)
Funding ID BB/M027406/1 
Organisation Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2015 
End 08/2018
 
Description European Research Council Advanced Grant
Amount € 2,499,000 (EUR)
Funding ID polytrue? 322467 
Organisation European Research Council (ERC) 
Sector Public
Country Belgium
Start 04/2013 
End 03/2018
 
Title LC-MS of green tea metabolites 
Description An improved method to quantify and assess green tea metabolites from biological fluids and biopsy samples was developed. This was published in J Chrom B, Clarke et al, 2014. It is a listed output 
Type Of Material Biological samples 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The method allows other to determine green tea flavonoid metabolites in biological samples. It is only published in the last few weeks and so impact is not yet possible to judge. 
 
Description Nestle Research Center 
Organisation Nestlé (Global)
Department Société des Produits Nestlé SA
Country Switzerland 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Advice on green tea and its health benefits
Collaborator Contribution They prepared the green tea samples and arranged to have them packaged into capsule form and labelled in a way that they were blinded for the human intervention study
Impact Nestle funded projects with Prof Williamson's lab prior to and during this project.
 
Description Prof Nicolaou 
Organisation University of Manchester
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The lab of Prof Rhodes at University of Manchester conducted the human intervention studies in the BBSRC DRINC project. Samples were then passed to our lab for analysis, especially for bioavailability measurements which we conducted using LCMS. Prof Nicolaou's lab analysed the various skin samples for lipids and inflammatory mediators. The whole study was written and conceived as a joint effort.
Collaborator Contribution The lab of Prof Rhodes at University of Manchester conducted the human intervention studies in the BBSRC DRINC project. Prof Nicolaou's lab analysed the various skin samples for lipids and inflammatory mediators.
Impact This work has been published in 2 papers which are already in the publication outputs, and 2 more are currently in the pipeline; the latter 2 will be submitted to American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, the top journal in the nutrition area.
Start Year 2007
 
Description Prof Rhodes 
Organisation University of Manchester
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The lab of Prof Rhodes at University of Manchester conducted the human intervention studies in the BBSRC DRINC project. Samples were then passed to our lab for analysis, especially for bioavailability measurements which we conducted using LCMS. This work has been published in 2 papers, and 2 more are currently in the pipeline. The whole study was written and conceived as a joint effort.
Collaborator Contribution The lab of Prof Rhodes at University of Manchester conducted the human intervention studies in the BBSRC DRINC project. Samples were then passed to our lab for analysis. Prof Rhodes's lab carried out all of the intervention study including feeding the green tea, collecting plasma, interstitial fluid and biopsies. They also were responsible for obtaining ethical permission.
Impact This work has been published in 2 papers which are already in the publication outputs, and 2 more are currently in the pipeline; the latter 2 will be submitted to American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, the top journal in the nutrition area.
Start Year 2007
 
Description CoCoTea conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Participants in your research and patient groups
Results and Impact First International Congress on Coffee, Cocoa and Tea (CoCoTea), Sept 2011: opening keynote lecture, Novara, Italy entitled Bioavailability and bioefficacy of the polyphenols from tea, cocoa and coffee. This led to repeat invitations in subsequent years and many industrial and academic contacts

Collaborations with other labs and exploring future industry funding
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2011