A pipeline of resistance genes to Phytophthora infestans from wild Solanum species and their accelerated isolation using Illumina sequencing methods

Lead Research Organisation: University of East Anglia
Department Name: Sainsbury Laboratory

Abstract

Late blight of potato caused by Phytophthora infestans (Pi) is one of the world's most important crop diseases. UK farmers spray 10-15 times per year for blight control, and in developing countries, late blight also dramatically reduces potato yields. In the wet summer of 2007, blight pressure in Europe was so severe that demand for blight control chemicals exceeded supply. Potato breeding is extremely slow and inefficient- the most popular UK variety (Maris Piper) is over 30 years old- so the best way to control potato blight is to isolate multiple Resistance to P. infestans (Rpi) genes from wild potato relatives and introduce these Rpi genes into popular varieties. It is not clear if the most durable strategy will involve stacking multiple Rpi genes in the same variety, or planting mixtures of the same variety with different Rpi genes, or using different Rpi genes each year. Either strategy requires the isolation of multiple Rpi genes. Isolation of Rpi genes involves making crosses between blight resistant and blight sensitive plants, and scoring the segregation of resistance and sensitivity in the next generation. Using new sequencing methods, we will be able to identify candidate resistance genes that are always associated with resistance by their sequence similarity to known resistance genes. These candidate genes will be transformed (using Agrobacterium) into blight sensitive potato variety Desiree, and transformed plants tested for blight resistance. We have isolated two Rpi genes, Rpi-mcq1 and Rpi-oka1.1 in previous work funded by EU and by BBSRC. To fully explore this approach, we will isolate multiple additional Rpi genes. We are mapping more Rpi genes from additional Solanum species, creating a pipeline for future Rpi gene isolation and deployment, with the goal of providing durable blight resistance to the potato crop. Our work will shed light on how Rpi genes evolve, and also enable us to identify the pathogen molecules that these Rpi genes recognize and confer responsiveness to. We plan to carry out small scale field trials of GM blight resistant potatoes during the course of this project.

Technical Summary

We previously identified what we believed to be three segregating Resistance genes to P. infestans (Rpi-oka1, Rpi-oka2 and Rpi-neo1=Rpi-nrs1) in wild Solanum species, as well as Rpi-mcq1 and Rpi-bst1 (now isolated under EU funding). Rpi-oka1.1 was isolated under BBSRC grant BB/C007522/1; however, there is clearly at least one additional linked Rpi gene (Rpi-oka1.2) at the locus, which we have recombined away from Rpi-oka1.1 and crossed to a susceptible line. We will isolate Rpi-oka1.2 in this project. We will also isolate Rpi-ber1 and Rpi-ber2 from Solanum berthaultii, and a 1:1 segregating Rpi gene from variety Sarpo Mira which carries elevated blight resistance compared to most varieties. In collaboration with a Polish group, we will also investigate and seek to isolate Rpi-ngr genes from S. nigrum. We will use the Illumina GA2 next-generation sequencing (NGS) instrument, and Velvet software, to sequence and assemble cDNA sequences from disease-resistant and -sensitive bulked RNA preps. By analysis of assembled cDNA sequences, we will identify alleles of NB-LRR-encoding Rpi gene candidates that cosegregate with a genetically targeted locus, and after high-resolution mapping, will introduce cDNAs for these candidate genes into a binary vector to make transgenic potato lines and test them for blight resistance. Both Sophien Kamoun at the SL, and Paul Birch in SCRI, are developing libraries of P. infestans effectors in plant viral expression vectors, and we plan to use transient co-delivery of Rpi and effector candidate gene in Nicotiana benthamiana to identify the effectors recognized by the Rpi genes. The ultimate aim of the project is to deploy these multiple Rpi genes in the field and to investigate the best strategy for conferring durable resistance against this very destructive, highly variable and rapidly evolving pathogen.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Potato late blight- cause of the Irish potato famine- is one the world's most devastating crop diseases. Our goal is to identify, understand and exploit natural genetic variation for resistance to potato late blight in wild relatives of potato. There are highly valued varieties of potato that are very blight sensitive. It is extremely difficult to breed blight resistance into valued varieties without changing the other trait combinations that make them so favored by the market. An alternative approach, which we favor, is to clone additional blight resistance genes from wild relatives of potato, and use GM methods to add these genes to favored varieties.

In this proposal, we were funded to "chase down" some additional blight resistance genes, and to develop methods for accelerating blight resistance gene cloning. Paradoxically, we have been more successful at the latter than the former. One gene we chased was too weak. Another was cloned first by a competing group in Holland. Resistance in variety Sarpo Mira is too complex, involving multiple genes, for easy cloning.

However, we have identified a new source of resistances in Solanum americanum, a much more tractable plant for genetics than most potato relatives, and we have identified extremely closely linked genetic markers to two resistance genes. We have deep genome sequence data for both resistant and susceptible S americanum accessions. We also have established a biochemical enrichment for sequencing the complete R gene set of any Solanum and for identifying R gene alleles that are linked to resistance. In a current BBSRC grant that began Oct 2012 we expect to clone these two genes and define the molecules they recognize in the late blight pathogen.
Exploitation Route many are now using the Renseq method to accelerate R gene cloning in other systems
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink

URL http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23937694
 
Description We have used our findings now to clone one and nearly clone another Rpi gene from wild Solanum sp
First Year Of Impact 2011
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink
Impact Types Cultural

 
Description TSL/Simplot/James Hutton/U Dundee partnership for understanding and deploying late blight resistance genes 
Organisation James Hutton Institute
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution we collaborated with Ingo Hein to develop and deploy Renseq for resistance gene analysis
Collaborator Contribution we collaborated with Ingo Hein to develop and deploy Renseq for resistance gene analysis
Impact Simplot is commercializing a resistance gene we cloned, Rpi-vnt1, for blight control in the US It has now received FDA, USDA and EPA approval
Start Year 2012
 
Title LATE BLIGHT RESISTANCE GENE FROM SOLANUM AMERICANUM AND METHODS OF USE 
Description Compositions and methods and for enhancing the resistance of plants to a plant disease caused by a Phytophthora species are provided. The compositions comprise nucleic acid molecules encoding resistance (R) gene products and variants thereof and plants, seeds, and plant cells comprising such nucleic acid molecules. The methods for enhancing the resistance of a plant to a plant disease caused by a Phytophthora species comprise introducing a nucleic acid molecule encoding an R gene product into a plant cell. Additionally provided are methods for using the plants in agriculture to limit plant disease. 
IP Reference WO2016182881 
Protection Patent application published
Year Protection Granted 2016
Licensed Yes
Impact None yet, beyond licensing to Simplot We are using Rpi-amr3 in our HAPI grant
 
Description Interview on Radio 4 Today program re GM crop regulation post Brexit 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact Interview on Today program re GM crop regulation post Brexit
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019