Mechanistic and evolutionary analysis of the natural variation in Arabidopsis vernalization response

Lead Research Organisation: John Innes Centre
Department Name: Cell and Develop Biology

Abstract

A full understanding of how climate change will influence plants requires an understanding of how mechanisms used to monitor environmental cues have changed as plants have adapted to different habitats. Regulation of flowering in many plants in temperate and arctic environments includes a requirement for a period of exposure to cold, known as vernalization. In this proposal we want to fully characterize the molecular basis of natural variation in vernalization. A major regulator of this process is FLC, a floral repressor. The gene encoding FLC needs to be silenced for flowering to proceed and the speed this happens differs in Arabidopsis collected from different habitats. We will analyse FLC regulation and how it has evolved in response to adaptation to different climates. 'Mix-and-match' versions of FLC genes from the different natural variants will be analysed in transgenic plants to uncover which of the different nucleotide changes contributes to the altered vernalization response. In collaboration with Dr Magnus Nordborg, a population geneticist, we will then analyse FLC in a worldwide set of Arabidopsis accessions and relate sequence variation to vernalization response. We will also undertake experiments analysing the fitness benefits of this variation and compare these data to field-derived phenotypic data generated in two parallel studies. This will reveal whether variation in vernalization is important for adaptation.

Technical Summary

Our aim will be to understand how molecular variation in the gene encoding the floral repressor, FLC, perturbs the chromatin silencing mechanism underlying vernalization in Arabidopsis natural variants collected from diverse habitats. Mix and match versions of the floral repressor gene FLC will be analysed to identify the causative polymorphism and molecular basis of the altered silencing. At first we will focus on the FLC allele from a N. Swedish accession Lov-1, which is particularly insensitive to 4 weeks cold. We will then analyse FLC alleles from two S. Swedish accessions Ull-2-5 and Var-2-6 in order to explore whether they evolved independently. To extend this analysis even further we will use an association analysis. FLC genomic sequence will be compared with FLC expression dynamics in cold and post-cold conditions in a well-characterized and genotyped, world-wide set of Arabidopsis accessions. Polymorphism likely to be contributing major effects to the variation will be tested through a site-directed mutagenesis strategy aiming to recreate the phenotypic behaviour of the different alleles in transgenic plants. Knowledge of the different causative polymorphism and the overall genetic architecture of FLC will shed light on the evolutionary history of FLC. Lastly, we will undertake controlled environment room reciprocal transplant experiments to ask if the variation in vernalization and FLC contributes to adaptation of these accessions. This analysis will complement two field studies funded from elsewhere.

Planned Impact

The research in this proposal will have impact in three quite different areas. Firstly, it should add to our overall understanding of the evolutionary processes underpinning natural diversity. For a given trait what are the constraints of the type of variation that has been successful in nature? How many times has similar phenotypic variation evolved? To date there are still few examples where the molecular basis of diversity has been fully defined. As many more genomic sequences become available it will be increasingly important to have studies linking genotypic and phenotypic variation. This will not only be true for plant genomes but also for human biology field where we are entering the period of 'personal genomes'. Understanding evolutionary processes, and the connection of genotype and phenotype, have never been more important. Secondly, this work has an emphasis on variation in response to changes in temperature. It is clear that our world is warming so information from this research will be highly relevant for improving knowledge on the likely changes in plant phenology - plant timing mechanisms - as our climate changes. Modelling the effects of global warming has so far not included effects on plant populations - will plant populations adapt quickly enough to remain in their present locations? Will timing of flowering change - if so will it become out of sync with the pollinators - this could have global effects on plant biodiversity and a major impact on crop yield. Lastly, it addresses time to flowering, a key trait in breeding of many crops. Our focus is the molecular basis of natural variation in vernalization - a key process in the breeding and production of many winter-grown vegetable crops, broccoli, cauliflower, parsnips and carrots. Varieties of these vegetables are bred to ensure year round supply but the vagaries of winter temperatures tends to lead to gluts or shortages in production. Development of varieties less influenced by temperature but still producing in different seasons of the year would considerably reduce waste, potentially open up new production areas and increase efficiency of delivery. We have ongoing collaborations with breeding companies aiming to translate this understanding into practical benefits.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The evolution of the vernalization response has proven to be an excellent system to explore the molecular basis of adaptive changes providing fundamental understanding in evolutionary and ecological genetics. We exploited understanding of the epigenetic in silencing mechanisms of Arabidopsis and the extensive variation in vernalization response, to fully interrogate the evolution of this adaptive trait. We achieved all four objectives:

1) Elucidating the phase of the epigenetic silencing mechanism of FLC perturbed in natural variants.
We analysed where in the molecular mechanism natural variation was occurring both in controlled environment cabinets and in natural field conditions in Sweden and Norwich. It was very clear that most of the variation occurs in the initial levels of FLC transcription that link to cold-induced transcriptional down-regulation. This is all prior to the onset of epigenetic silencing. In one accession we also found significant variation in the rate of epigenetic silencing during winter.

2) Investigating whether variation in vernalization response has evolved independently during adaptation of Arabidopsis to different habitats.
Extensive QTL analysis showed that a considerable proportion of the natural variation in vernalization mapped to the FLC locus itself. Sequence analysis initially 80 and then 1200 Arabidopsis accessions grouped FLC into a small number of distinct haplotype groups differentiated by non-coding SNPs. These groups mapped onto the different phenotypic variants and near-isogenic line production, plus transgenic analysis, of the five major FLC haplotype groups showed that the non-coding SNPs were causative for the phenotypic variation. Analysis of the SNPs showed that the changes in vernalization response had evolved independently in the different haplogroups.

3) Relating genetic architecture and vernalization phenotype in a worldwide set of accessions.
Collaboration with the groups of Magnus Nordborg (GMI, Vienna) and Joy Bergelson, U. of Chicago) revealed the worldwide distribution of the different FLC haplogroups, reduced recombination around those haplotypes and no clear geographical or climatic association.

4) Exploring the contribution of variation in vernalization response to adaptation in different habitats.
We undertook extensive field experiments to ask if variation in vernalization was adaptive. We were fortunate that autumn conditions were very different in the two years we used. In the first we have a warm autumn in Norwich and together with controlled environment studies in fluctuating temperatures this revealed that it is absence of warm temperatures at any time of the day that is the signal for winter progression. In the second year we had very warm conditions in N. Sweden and found many accessions flowered before the first snow. This does not happen normally, and together with analysis of near-isogenic lines we could show that the initial levels of FLC transcription play an important adaptive role to prevent flowering in those rare occasions where autumn is warmer than normal.
Exploitation Route This work will be very important for predicting what will happen to flowering in a range of plants as our climate changes
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Environment

URL http://www.jic.ac.uk/staff/caroline-dean/
 
Description The research in this proposal had impact in three quite different areas: • It has added to our overall understanding of the evolutionary processes underpinning natural diversity. • The emphasis on variation in response to changes in temperature is important given our world is warming. Information from this research will be highly relevant for improving knowledge on likely changes in plant phenological behaviour - plant timing mechanisms - as our climate changes. • Time to flowering is a key trait in breeding of many crops. The focus on molecular basis of natural variation in vernalization is relevant to breeding and production of many winter-grown vegetable crops, specifically broccoli and cauliflower. This work led to a BBSRC LINK grant (starting 2009) with Elsoms Seeds and Bejo Zaden BV, Weatherquest and Jim Monaghan at Harper Adams to analyse similar variation in horticultural brassicas. Development of varieties less influenced by temperature but still allowing production at different times of the year would considerably reduce waste, potentially open up new production areas and increase efficiency of delivery. We have continued to discuss the climate change work with colleagues in the Environmental Sciences Dept at the University of East Anglia - now a formal partnership called the Earth and Life Systems Alliance. One PhD studentship has been funded under this agreement to model how molecular variation in temperature-regulated gene expression would influence the effect of future climate warming on vernalization of A. thaliana accessions.
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink,Environment
Impact Types Societal,Economic

 
Description GCRF databases and Resources phase 2
Amount £98,000 (GBP)
Organisation Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 11/2017 
End 07/2018
 
Description Mechanistic basis of nucleation and spreading underlying a Polycomb-mediated epigenetic switch (EPISWITCH)
Amount € 2,100,000 (EUR)
Funding ID 833254 
Organisation European Research Council (ERC) 
Sector Public
Country Belgium
Start 09/2019 
End 09/2024
 
Description Invited speaker at Wellcome Trust Plant 'Genomes in a Changing Environment' meeting 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Caroline Dean gave the keynote lecture on the 24th October 2018 at the Wellcome Trust Hixton Hall Plant Genomes in a Changing Environment meeting. Her talk was entitled: 'Adapting to different winters'.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description Invited speaker at the Garnet Natural Variation meeting 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Invited speaker at the Garnet Natural Variation meeting in Cambridge (12th -13th December 2016). Talk entitled: "Natural Variation in Vernalization".
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
 
Description Invited speaker to the Genetic Society meeting in London 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Prof Caroline Dean was invited to speak at the Genetic Society meeting in London (10th-11th November 2016). Talk title: "Non-coding sequence variation influencing natural variation in vernalization in Arabidopsis"
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
 
Description Seminar to Brassica breeders at Bangladesh Agricultural Research Institute 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Prof Caroline Dean gave a seminar to Brassica breeders at Bangladesh Agricultural Research Institute.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
 
Description Talk at Norwich Science Festival 2016 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Professor Caroline Dean gave a talk entitled: "Sensing and Remembering Winter" to the general public at the Norwich Science Festival on the 24th October 2016.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
 
Description Talk to lay audience at the Norwich Science Festival 2016 Science Café evening 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Prof Caroline Dean gave a talk entitled "What is epigenetics?" at the Norwich Science Festival 2016 Science Café evening to a lay audience.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016