Effect of chromatin modification on meiosis: wheat, a model for polyploid crops

Lead Research Organisation: John Innes Centre
Department Name: Crop Genetics

Abstract

This project will address an important problem which has hampered the efficient exploitation of the genetic diversity held within wild relatives of wheat. Being able to work with wild relatives so that beneficial characteristics can be introduced into wheat will be a major scientific achievement and dramatically improve the way breeders can generate new varieties of wheat with increased performance.

Some wild relatives are adapted to thrive under different climatic conditions to that of domestic wheat, or they carry natural resistance to important diseases and/or carry other important characteristics which could influence yield. What we want to do is to produce the tools which will allow the exploitation of this diversity and genetically introduce these favourable characteristics into wheat. In doing so we will be enable wheat breeders to, amongst other things, improve wheat performance in a sustainable way, increase yield, introduce disease resistance and drought tolerance.

In a small number of cases this has already been achieved. What stops wild relatives being used efficiently? The wild relative and the wheat chromosomes must align and efficiently exchange (recombine) during meiosis. Without recombination, there isn't the opportunity to introduce the genetic diversity of wild relatives into wheat. The Ph1 locus substantially reduces recombination between wild relative and wheat chromosomes. Ph1 even reduces recombination between chromosomes derived from wheat landraces where they are significantly diverged. This makes gene transfer by recombination during meiosis difficult in the case of wild relatives, or inefficient in the case of landraces.

So how can we overcome this problem? In wheat, the Ph1 locus regulates recombination. Understanding this Ph1 regulation will provide us with an insight into this process. It will provide us with an understanding of how recombination sites are selected in wheat, and leading from this , how the process can be altered and tailored for specific needs, thus enabling us manipulate it for plant breeding.

Technical Summary

Most related chromosomes of wild relatives of wheat exhibit extensive gene synteny along their chromosome length. Moreover the genes on related chromosomes exhibit more than 95% homology at the sequence level. Despite this level of similarity, there is little recombination between wild relative and wheat chromosomes at meiosis due the presence of the Ph1 locus. The wild relative chromosomes and wheat chromosomes differ in their repetitive content and the level of transcription from their genes. Deletion of the Ph1 locus allows the chromosomes to behave like homologous chromosomes and recombine. Recombination involves the initiation of double strand breaks within genic regions and then repair of breaks. Recent data indicates that Ph1 is affecting chromatin structure and this affects the distribution and processing of double strand breaks. Thus Ph1 is affecting the genic regions in some way enabling them to be recognised, or not, in terms of the recombinational machinery.

By exploiting next generation sequencing and cell biological approaches, we will identify what is being altered in the genic regions by the presence or absence of Ph1 at the onset of meiosis. We will access whether there is altered distribution of double strand breaks or their processing, chromatin structure or methylation of and transcription from the genic regions. From this information, we will treat developing wheat anthers prior to meiosis with drugs which themselves induce similar changes and then score the resulting effects on chromosome pairing during metaphase I, to confirm the association of the particular change with a pairing effect.

Planned Impact

In the past there are examples where the wild relatives of wheat have been successfully exploited as a novel source of genetic variation for traits in wheat breeding programmes. However, the introgression of genes from wild relatives into wheat is very time consuming and inefficient and therefore fell out of favour. Recently, international breeding centres have again started to exploit wheat's wild progenitors, to generate synthetic hexaploid Triticum aestivum, in order to create a "synthetic wheat" breeding programme. Some 25% of elite lines of wheat generated by CIMMYT are derived from crosses to these synthetic wheat genotypes. Having exploited this approach successfully, many now argue that to increase yield production in wheat it is imperative to revisit the exploitation of genetic variation available in the wild relatives in breeding programmes. As a result of this, a number of private sector breeders are encouraging the reestablishment of wheat alien introgression in the UK public sector.

To facilitate the transfer of genetic variation via wheat/alien introgression, research is required to increase the speed and enhance the efficiency of the process. In brief, wheat/alien introgression involves the hybridisation of wheat with a wild relative followed by repeated backcrossing to generate lines of wheat carrying an alien chromosome on which a target gene is located. A series of further crosses to specific genotypes/mutant lines are then required before the chromosome of the alien species can recombine within those of wheat, allowing the transfer of the target gene to wheat without linked deleterious effects.

There are some key barriers to the exploitation of wild species in breeding programmes. One of these barriers is the ability to induce exchange between the wild relative chromosomes of wheat and the wild species. The presence of the Ph1 locus suppresses this exchange. Deletion mutants of the Ph1 locus exist. However once the Ph1 locus is removed, then the chromosomes undergo extensive rearrangement. Thus within an alien introgression programme, one is trying to induce exchange between the wild relative chromosome with a rearranged wheat chromosome. It is important to develop an approach from our understanding of the Ph1 locus, where its effect can be switched off with one generation to allow the wheat and wild relative chromosomes to exchange. Thus the present aims to understand how Ph1 is affecting the genic regions where recombination occurs. Based on this understanding, the present proposal aims to exploit drugs to overcome the Ph1 effect.

The expected outcome of this project will the creation of tools which enhance the ability of breeders to have access to the genetic potential of wild wheat species by enhancing exchange between wild relative and wheat chromosomes. It will provide an indication of how the level and distribution of recombination may be altered in wheat. It will also allow the development of a skills base, particularly in cytogenetics, a dying art in the UK which can be utilised by the next generation of scientists involved in wheat breeding and the larger wheat breeding community.
 
Description Polyploid species possess more than one genome. Most flowering plants are polyploids or have a polyploid origin. Previous studies have suggested from studying gene expression that polyploidisation results in significant changes in gene expression in somatic tissues. However none of the studies had been undertaken on meiosis where there is a major issue for polyploids in that the related chromosomes must be accurately sorted, paired and segregated for the polyploid species to be stable. We had observed chromatin changes at the start of meiosis associated with this process. The grant assessed whether these chromatin changes , the pairing process and Ph1 locus (which is involved in altering the meiotic process on polyploidisation) affected gene expression. We therefore generated six RNA seq meiotic libraries from wheat, wheat-rye hybrid and doubled wheat-rye hybrids, with and without Ph1. The availability of a gold standard wheat genome sequence finally allowed us to fully analyse these substantial RNA seq meiotic datasets. Surprisingly the analysis reveals that neither ploidy, synapsis/pairing or the Ph1 locus affects genome wide transcription. This study represents a substantial amount of work. These results contrast with the previous studies on somatic tissues. Given that we are not observing a difference, it shows how accurately the meiotic cells were staged. The data was published and the datasets deposited in the wheat expression.com site for the research community to access and use.
The expression data obtained for the major meiotic gene (ZIP4) which is part of the Ph1 locus as part of RNA seq dataset. This data was published as part of a separate publication on the analysis of the Ph1 locus.
The RNA seq data was recently exploited to generate the first meiotic coexpression network. This analysis revealed that contrary to what had been proposed, there had not been a reduction of the meiotic gene content of the wheat genome on polyploidisation. Essentially the three homoeologous copies of the meiotic genes had been largely retained. Also contrary to expectations, the three homologous copies of each meiotic gene had also largely retained balanced expression
We also published a paper in Nature Communications (DOI: 10.1038/ncomms5580) which showed that double strand breaks marked by MLH1 don't always become crossovers. This was unexpected in the meiosis community, where the general perception was that MLH1 sites always result in crossovers, and that MLH1 always mark sites of crossover. Our data indicates that this is not always so.
Exploitation Route Our meiotic RNA seq dataset deposited and publicly available in wheatexpresion.com now allows any researcher to assess the expression of any meiotic gene for themselves in wheat, which they could not have done before.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink

URL https://www.wheatexpression.com
 
Description The research results were highlighted for the breeding industry in http://globalplantcouncil.org/news-events/latest-news/uncovered-the-mystery-of-exchanging-genes-with-wild-relatives. The research results have also be also discussed on twitter, and extensively retwitted. The expression data on the meiotic gene ZIP4 which is part of the Ph1 locus helped confirm that this is responsible for the crossover and pairing phenotype, i.e that ZIP4 is the Ph1 gene. The meiotic RNA seq expression data deposited and publicly available in wheatexpression.com is being used by researchers within the wheat community to assess the expression of individual meiotic genes for themselves
First Year Of Impact 2018
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink
 
Description Either myself or members of my group have given 6 talks on ZIP4 5B as the major Ph1 gene controlling homologous/homoeologous crossover and pairing in wheat and its hybrids 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Of 6 talks on ZIP4 5B (Ph1) gene given, one was UK graduate students; and 5 at international meetings
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019,2020
 
Description Meeting and presentation to discuss interactions between those international groups involved in meiosis research on wheat and barley in Paris 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The meeting has led to the proposal to hold a much larger meeting on cereal meiosis researchers in 2019 at RRes
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description Plenary talk at Genomics in breeding meeting, IPK Gatersleben, Germany 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Gave plenary talk at the main crop institute in Germany.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017