RESUBMISSION: Neural processing underlying auditory pattern recognition in an insect brain

Lead Research Organisation: University of Cambridge
Department Name: Zoology

Abstract

Neuroscience aims at understanding how sensory pathways are organised, how stimuli are processed and how features are extracted to elicit an appropriate motor response. Especially in intraspecific communication the recognition of specific stimulus features plays an important role as species-specific olfactory, visual and/or acoustic signals are employed for mate attraction and rivalry behaviour. As sounds are always transient, signalling by repetitive patterns of pulses is central to acoustic communication in many vertebrates and invertebrates. Especially frogs and insects like bush-crickets and crickets use simple sound pulses generated with species-specific temporal patterns for communication. In the auditory pathway of the receiver, these signals require neural filter mechanisms that respond to the temporal structure of sound patterns. Considerable progress has been made in frogs in describing brain neurons with selective tuning to pulse patterns. However, there is still a very limited understanding of neurons underlying temporal processing of sound patterns in crickets although since decades they are a model system for insect hearing. Female crickets are attracted to the species-specific pattern of male calling song. In behavioural experiments we demonstrated the tuning of their phonotactic behaviour to changes in pulse interval, pulse duration and chirp interval. For example their phonotactic behaviour is tuned to the pulse pattern of the male song as pulses with shorter or longer periods are not attractive. We now aim to understand at the level of identified neurons the filter mechanisms in the brain that allow the recognition of the species-specific song pattern.
The ascending auditory interneuron that forwards the pulse pattern of the calling song from the first thoracic ganglion to the brain exhibits no filter properties. Hypothesis for temporal filtering in the brain have been put forward, however, the actual neural mechanisms have not been revealed. In preliminary experiments we identified local brain neurons which form a ring-like auditory neuropil in the protocerebrum matching the axonal arborisations of the ascending interneuron. Some of these neurons showed a selective response to the pulse interval of the calling song and received inhibitory and excitatory synaptic inputs. In other systems the interaction between inhibition and excitation is crucial for selectivity to pulse patterns. Using the same acoustic paradigms as in the behavioural studies we will analyse the activity of auditory brain neurons. We will focus on four questions:
1). Which brain neurons are involved in temporal filtering of acoustic pulse patterns?
2). What are the neural mechanisms underlying temporal filtering?
3). What is the structural and functional organisation of the auditory neuropil?
4). Which projection neurons connect the auditory neuropil to other brain regions?
The project will be based on our experience of recording intracellularly the activity of auditory brain neurons with sharp microelectrodes. The neural responses will be compared with our behavioural data and quantitative analysis will reveal to what degree the activity of single neurons mirrors the behavioural tuning. The pattern of inhibitory and excitatory synaptic activity will provide crucial information on how temporal filtering is achieved within the auditory network. We will manipulate the membrane potential of neurons by intracellular current injection to analyse the nature of the neural filter mechanisms in detail. Finally we will use confocal microscopy to reveal the structural details of these neurons in the brain and we will identify neurons which link the auditory neuropil to other areas of the brain. The analysis of the pattern recognition network in crickets will provide insight to principle mechanisms of temporal filtering at the level of identified neurons and can be a model for temporal selectivity in other systems.

Technical Summary

Experiments are based on our experience to record the activity of auditory brain neurons. The head of tethered crickets will be positioned in an Eppendorf tube and the head capsule will be opened to expose the brain, which will be stabilized between a silver platform and a ring. Computer generated acoustic test paradigms with systematic variations in pulse interval, pulse duration and pulse period will be presented. The behavioural tuning of females to these paradigms has already been established in behavioural experiments. Sound patterns will be presented by two audio speakers positioned at 45 deg left and right in front of the crickets. During acoustic stimulation we will record the synaptic and spike activity of brain neurons using sharp glass-microelectrodes. Signals will be amplified with high-impedance DC amplifiers and stored on-line to the hard-disk of a PC. For off-line analysis of the neural activity we will use Spike 2 and our custom-designed software Neurolab. Analysis will focus on spike activity and the timing of excitatory and inhibitory postsynaptic potentials relative to the acoustic stimulus patterns. This will reveal to what degree the tuning of neurons matches the tuning of behaviour. The structure of brain neurons will be revealed by intracellular iontophoretic labelling with fluorescent dyes like Alexa or Lucifer yellow followed by histological processing. Brains will be counterstained with antibodies against e.g. synapsin or bruchpilot to reveal the organisation of the auditory neuropil and the projection areas of neurons in whole mounts using a confocal laser scanning microscope. Neural arborisation patterns will be reconstructed from confocal stacks. The named RA has excellent experience with the dissection, intracellular recording and labelling techniques of brain neurons. Most equipment required for the experiments is available and already set up. The Department runs a colony of Gryllus bimaculatus that will be used for the experiments.

Planned Impact

1. Neuroscience community: In 2011 the PI gave the prestigious Florey Lecture of the German Neuroscience Society. For 2012 the PI is invited to conferences on the Central Complex of the Insect Brain and on the Evolution of Acoustic Communication Systems at Janelia Farm. The PI will also speak at the Conference on Crickets organised by Prof. S. Noji (Japan), which has been be rescheduled for March 2012. The PI will use these and future meetings to share research methods, to discuss his research with other scientists and to build up collaborations. Neuroscientists exploring the insect brain will benefit from our specific recording techniques; research on auditory pathways in more complex brains may use the outcome of the project to tests hypothesis on processing of temporal patterns. Textbooks describing auditory processing in insects may need revision.

2. Research collaboration: The PI collaborates with the group of Prof. S. Noji (Tokushima/Japan) and with Dr. H. Horch (Bowdoin/US), which aim to generate transgenic crickets expressing calcium reporters like GCaMP3 in their central nervous system. Once this genetic approach is successful, our analysis of identified auditory neurons will be of major advantage. Calcium reporters will allow studying signal processing with both imaging and neurophysiological techniques at the level of identified neurons and neural networks. By combining the research methods of the different labs to study cricket auditory processing we expect new avenues and strong synergetic effects for the analysis of the system (see statements of Prof. Noji and Prof. Horch).

The PI also has an ongoing collaboration with Prof. B. Webb (Edinburgh), who develops bio-inspired robots designed to perform acoustic orientation. As soon as a proper picture of the pattern recognition circuit in the brain of crickets has emerged, our should allow her to implement more realistic neural networks and to fine tune the control circuits of the robots (see statement of Prof. Webb). Travel costs to Edinburgh will occur.

The PI will explore possible collaboration with Prof. K Shaw who is an expert in the field of the genetic basis of cricket speciation.

3. Engage with the public: Two events in Cambridge are suited to give the public insight to our research: the Science Week and the Conversatione of the Natural History Society. The PI will present either a talk to a wider audience or a cricket trackball system used for behavioural studies together with high speed video recordings from walking crickets. Some minor costs for poster printing and a suitable large video monitor will occur. We also will also use opportunities to present our research in radio or TV programs.

4. Industrial exploitation: The PI contacted the research group of Siemens Audiology in Erlangen/Germany, a leading manufacturer of hearing aids. It is my intention to introduce the findings on cricket auditory processing to the engineers from Siemens. Consequently principles of auditory processing may be incorporated into the electronic circuits of hearing aids. Travel costs for a trip to the Siemens group have been included. (see statement from Siemens Audiology).

5. Capacity and involvement: The RA will be trained in neurophysiological research techniques, and will be strongly involved the management of project objectives, time and resources, and in the publication process. The RA will present data at scientific conferences and contribute to any public science events. An essential part of the training will deal with job and grant applications to secure the next position for the RA. The PI will provide substantial support of these RA activities in form of discussions of research results, proof reading of manuscripts and applications, and with advice on career development. Cambridge University runs an excellent program career development and transferable skills. The RA will be strongly encouraged to attend such seminars.
 
Description We have successfully analysed the functional principle of the auditory pattern recognition network in the cricket brain. We have identified the structure and response properties of local auditory interneurons, which function as a delay-line and coincidence detector network. We think that the described circuit with a non-spiking interneuron as delay-line, is fundamental to temporal processing in different species and published the data in Science Advances. Furthermore we have developed a new imaging approach to the cricket brain, which allows iontophoretic loading of the auditory neuropil with anatomical and functional tracers. When spread in the brain neuropil, calcium sensitive dyes allow to identify auditory neurons, which specifically respond to acoustic stimulation with the species-specific song pattern. This imaging method has a great potential for any insect system, where genetically encoded calcium indicators are not available. Furthermore two computational approaches have been initiated to test the functional principles of the delay-line and coincidence detection circuit in neural models and neuromorphic electronic circuits. A manuscript for the computational approach is under revision.
Exploitation Route We had a very positive response from the research community and we think that the principle of auditory pattern found in the cricket also occurs in other auditory pathways. Recording spike patterns in vertebrate auditory pathways may not provide the full picture. One of my colleagues put it: "We may be missing a complete class of neurons when analysing auditory processing with extracellular recordings."
Sectors Education,Electronics,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology,Other

 
Description Findings have inspired researchers in the field of neuro-electronics, which used our model to build electronic circuits with similar function. See: Sandin F and Nilsson M (2020) Synaptic delays for insect-inspired temporal feature detection in dynamic neuromorphic processors. Frontiers in Neuroscience doi: 10.3389/fnins.2020.00.00150. We currently collaborate with Dr Nanami Takuya, from the Institute of Industrial Science at University of Tokyo to develop an in-silico neuronal network for temporal pattern recognition, based on our data.
First Year Of Impact 2020
Sector Education,Electronics,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology
Impact Types Cultural

 
Title New dye-loading technique 
Description A new method has been developed for electrophoretic loading of neurons with dyes for anatomical and functional imaging via surface electrodes. 
Type Of Material Technology assay or reagent 
Year Produced 2017 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact The method has been published in Scientific Reports and in J Neurophysiology. It may have a major impact on invertebrate neuroscience and it is the basis for the application of our grant on calcium imaging. 
 
Title Peltier device for cooling and deactivating cricket auditory organs 
Description I developed a cooling method for cricket auditory organs. The frontlegs iof the animals are placed on a small Peltier element and can rapidly be cooled to 5-10 deg. At this temperature the afferent s stop responding, the afferents recover when the temperature raises again. The method is used to analyse reciprocal inhibition in the auditory system 
Type Of Material Technology assay or reagent 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact It should be possible to use this method in hearing research in other insects as well. 
 
Description Auditory-vibratory communication in Eneopterine crickets 
Organisation Dartmouth College
Country United States 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We provided the facilities for housing the animals, running the experiments and provided the neurophysiological expertise to record auditory neurons in these crickets
Collaborator Contribution Analysing the behaviour and providing the behavioural and taxonomical background for these crickets
Impact ter Hofstede HM, Schöneich S, Robillard T, Hedwig B (2015) Evolution of a Communication System by Sensory Exploitation of Startle Behavior. Current Biology, 25:1-8, doi:10.1016/j.cub.2015.10.064
Start Year 2013
 
Description Processing in the bushcricket auditory organ 
Organisation European University Viadrina Frankfurt (Oder)
Country Germany 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We provided the training and expertise on how to record the auditory sensory cells in the hearing organ of bushcrickets
Collaborator Contribution Our partners performed the full set of experiments.
Impact Hummel J, Schöneich S, Kössl M, Scherberich J, Hedwig B, Prinz S , Nowotny M (2016) Gating of Acoustic Transducer Channels Is Shaped by Biomechanical Filter Processes. J Neurosci 36(8):2377-2382, doi:10.1523/JNEUROSCI.3948-15.2016
Start Year 2016
 
Description Wing movements in flat-winged crickets 
Organisation University of St Andrews
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We provided the recording technique and facilities to record the wing movements in flat-winged crickets
Collaborator Contribution The partners performed the actual recordings
Impact Schneider WT, Rutz C, Hedwig B, and Bailey NW (2018) Vestigial singing behaviour persists after the evolutionary loss of song in crickets. Biol. Lett. 14: 20170654. http://dx.doi.org/10.1098/rsbl.2017.0654.
Start Year 2016
 
Description Cambridge Brain Fest 2017 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an open day or visit at my research institution
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact over two long days (Saturday and Sunday), me and the members of my lab demonstrated auditory organs and also a live recording from an auditory nerve in a locust to the wider public visiting the Cambridge Brain Fest. This involved moving our equipment to the venue, and setting up recordings and microscopes. We had a lot of interesting discussions with the audience and we think we provided them with an insight into neuroscience with insects.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description Ethology, neuroscience and genetics in crickets: How can they meet? 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact I organised a workshop at the International Congress of Neuroethology in Sapporo/Japan. This was attended by about 70 researchers in the filed.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
URL http://www.neuroethology.org/ebusisne/MEETINGS/ISNCONGRESS2014.aspx
 
Description Pattern Recognition in Crickets 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Talk at the Orthopterist Meeting of the Royal Entomological Society
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
 
Description Processing of acoustic pulse patterns: Common themes in different brains? 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact This symposium at the German Neuroscience Meeting brought together about 200 researchers from different background, who are all interested in analyzing the neural basis of auditory signal processing. The similarity of some fundamental processing mechanisms became apparent.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
 
Description SfN Meeting 2015 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact The Society for Neuroscience meeting is a major international meeting, presenting a talk and chairing a symposium is an achievement and a recognition of our work
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015