Cell-type-specific environmental signal integration networks controlling a binary developmental switch during the life cycle of plants

Lead Research Organisation: University of Birmingham
Department Name: Sch of Biosciences

Abstract

A growing human population is placing increasing demands on agriculture, with current production needing to double by the year 2050. Compounding this challenge are the effects of climate change which are limiting the yields we have previously come to expect. The need to develop crop varieties resistant to the yield-limiting effects of environmental change is urgent. The information generated by this project will be vital to the successful development of new crop varieties with sustainably high yields across a range of environmental conditions.
In order to ensure their survival and reproductive success, plants have evolved the ability to alter the timing of decisions during their life cycle in response to a wide variety of signals from their environment. Key choices during plant development include the decision to reproduce, or start flowering, and the decision to commence growth, which begins with the germination of their seeds. Both of these transitions are influenced by more than one cue from the environment, including light, temperature and nutrients. The process of signal integration describes the incorporation of multiple pieces of information into a single verdict. This amalgamation of information occurs in plants through a complex series of interactions between various molecules. This project will use seed germination as a model system to understand how diverse environmental signals are integrated into a single binary decision, to terminate dormancy and start germination.
Many individual factors mediating seed responses to the environment have been uncovered previously. What is not known is how these individual components interact with one another to form a signal integration network. This proposal will fill this gap in our understanding by defining the molecular network which plants use to merge diverse environmental cues into a single decision to commence their growth. The project will as well define previously uncharacterized components of the signal integration process, and explain how information from the environment is passed onto the final molecular targets that drive the final decision.
It is well known that plants use multiple pieces of information to guide their developmental transitions, yet it much less clear in which cells this decision-making process occurs. The proposal will investigate the role of a specialized sub-group of cells within the plant embryo that we have recently uncovered as a site where diverse signals are integrated into a single decision. The way the environment controls the signal integration network within each of these cells will be determined, characterizing a cellular decision-making centre in plants.
The information derived from this project will represent a step change in our ability to develop crop plants with robust yields across a wide range of environmental conditions. Previous attempts to modify plant response to the environment using individual components have been met with limited success, largely due to the lack of understanding of how these isolated factors exert their influence through a complex series of interactions within molecular signal integration networks. In order to accurately and robustly modify plant response to the environment, we must first understand what these networks are, and how they function to control plant responses. This knowledge can be used to tactically perturb key interactions, rather than individual components, to achieve a desired output.
Another factor limiting the success of modifying plant response to the environment is a lack of understanding of the spatial control of these processes. Distinct decisions are made within distinct sites. The ability to target modifications to interactions present within specific cells that are making key decisions will greatly enhance our ability to modify plant behaviour in response to the environment.

Technical Summary

Plants as sessile organisms have evolved the ability to modulate their developmental programs based on a wide range of environmental cues to ensure their survival and successful reproduction. The process of signal integration describes the information processing system by which multiple perceived environmental cues are integrated by a complex network of molecular interactions into a single binary developmental output. Key gaps in our understanding of this process in plants are a lack of knowledge of the signal integration network topology at a molecular level, and the cellular sites where this information merger occurs.
This proposal will address these gaps in our knowledge by defining the molecular network underlying the integration of diverse signals in seeds. The passage of each light, temperature and nutrient signal through this network and their convergence upon the promoters of two GA3-oxidase gene promoters, representing the downstream targets of an integrated signal, will be uncovered. The quantitative dynamics of this network will be determined within individual cell types of the newly described signal integration centre in plant embryos using a novel computational 3D quantitative image analysis pipeline. This work will collectively provide a multi-scale link between environmental cues, and the quantitative dynamics of the molecular networks mediating the merger of diverse information within specialized cell types.

Planned Impact

There is currently an urgent need to develop crops resistant to climate change. The information generated in this project will be of great value to both crop breeders and industry who are seeking to modulate plant response to the environment and enhance crop productivity despite environmental fluctuations. The project will uncover both new components involved in mediating plant response to the environment in addition to understanding how these pieces fit together to generate responses. Both these new components and their newly identified functional interactions provide novel targets to develop new technologies for climate change-resistant crop development, Understanding the role of individual cell types in the control of plant environmental responses represents an additional level of information and understanding that can be used to control individual environmental responses through the development of new technologies using cell type specific promoters.
This project will result in the training of a PDRA who will develop a range of molecular biology skills in addition to imaging and novel quantitative computational analyses of these images. This will result in a highly qualified research scientist who will contribute to the competitive UK research. The technician will obtain additional skills and research experience over the duration of this project and contribute to UK research over a longer term.
A wider public interest in this work will also be generated as it related to mitigating the negative impacts of climate change on our food supply. Both the rising cost of food and the impact that a changing climate is having on the agricultural industry is of increasing interest to the media and general public. The notion of the capacity of plants to make decisions and the role of the specialized subgroup of cells within the embryo can also stimulate a philosophical general interest in biological processes outside of the animal kingdom.

Impact activities and publications will be undertaken and written by Dr. George Bassel. Computational aspects of this project will include an informal collaboration to further develop the open-source software package MorphoGraphX with Professor Richard Smith (Max Planck Insitute, Cologne) (see letter of support for this application), and webpage development will be undertaken by all members of the proposal. Pathways to Impact will be monitored and evaluated every six months. Web site impact will be monitored by collecting website statistics.

Publications

10 25 50

publication icon
Bassel G (2015) Accuracy in Quantitative 3D Image Analysis in The Plant Cell

publication icon
Bassel GW (2018) Information Processing and Distributed Computation in Plant Organs. in Trends in plant science

publication icon
Bassel GW (2014) Mechanical constraints imposed by 3D cellular geometry and arrangement modulate growth patterns in the Arabidopsis embryo. in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America

publication icon
Bassel GW (2016) Quantifying morphogenesis in plants in 4D. in Current opinion in plant biology

publication icon
Bassel GW (2016) To Grow or not to Grow? in Trends in plant science

publication icon
Duran-Nebreda S (2019) Plant behaviour in response to the environment: information processing in the solid state. in Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological sciences

 
Description Key findings here are that we identified a decision-making centre in the dormant plant embryo. Within this small collection of cells we found that positively and negatively acting cells were spatially separated from one another. This topological configuration of cells is similar to the decision-making module in the human brain that controls motor movement (basal galglia-cerebellum-cortex loop). The spatial separation of positive (cerebellum) and negatively acting (basal ganglia) components in the human brain are thought to filter noisy imputs, and improve the speed vs accuracy tradeoff in decision-making (Fitts Law).

We tested whether the conserved topological configuration in dormant seeds also serves this noise filtering function by performing experiments with constant and noisy temperature inputs. In contrast to the human brain, seeds in fact preferred variable inputs, rather than filtering them. The spatial separation of signaling centres was needed in order to perform this computation.

The harnessing of varaible temperatures is complex computation for a plant, and acts to predict the onset of changing seasions, as is it in spring and autumn that the greatest daily fluctuations in daily temperatures are observed.
Exploitation Route It provides a rational framework to re-engineer plant responses to the environment. By understanding how the signaling components are localized across the plant embryo, it is possible to target regulatory proteins to specific locations to obtain a desired outcome. This is important for the seed industry which seeks to achieve uniformity in germination and crop establishment.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Energy

 
Description My findings have not been used but have attracted interest from several members of the seed industry. Findings have begun to uncover the cellular basis of decision-making in seeds which has potential impact the the synchornization of germination, a key objective of the seed industry.This work has also received widespread media attention in its reporting of a cellular basis of decision-making in plant organs.
First Year Of Impact 2015
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink
Impact Types Societal,Economic

 
Title Quantitative analysis of 3D cell shape changes in plants 
Description A computational method to image and quantitatitve analyse changes in the 3D shape of plant cells. The statistical analysis of these changes has also been developed. This represents the first tool to comprehensively analysis the growth of plant cells in 3D over time. 
Type Of Material Biological samples 
Year Produced 2014 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact This approach formed the basis of the PNAS paper in 2014, and continues to be a part of the work we are doing in the project, looking at the genetic control of cell shape changes across whole organs. 
 
Title Cellular resolution connectivity networks describing cell organization in whole organs 
Description This is an image analysis pipeline used to extract cell-to-cell connections from 3D images and abstract these into networks. These describe the organization of cells in ogans. We have further developed a series of computational algorithms that are capable of quantitatively analysing these networks using graph theory. Further computational scripts have been written to visualize these datasets in 3D to be able to graphically interact with these data. 
Type Of Material Computer model/algorithm 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact This is the first pipeline capable of exploring how cells come together in whole organs. This will help address the structure-function relationship between cell organization and organ function in complex organisms. The networks provided represent roadmaps of possible information flow through organs and will serve as enduring templates to reveal how genetic networks are embedded within cellular networks. 
 
Description Collaboration with Dr. Richard Smith, MPI Cologne 
Organisation Max Planck Society
Department Max Planck Institute for Plant Breeding Research
Country Germany 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution This collaboration between the Smith and Bassel labs has focused around the development of novel computational tools for the quantitative 3D analysis of plant growth and development. Software is being co-developed in both places and being implemented within the central framework developed by the Smith lab (www.MorphoGraphX.org). The Bassel lab has written software capable of semi-automatically identifying cell identity in 3D images. The Bassel lab has also collected quantitative data relating to 3D cell shape changes driving plant development
Collaborator Contribution The Smith lab has taken the code to semi-automatically identify cell identity in 3D images and implemented it directly within the software framework. This has added value to this software both in terms of the ease of use, speed and dissemination of the tool. The Smith lab has received quantitative growth analysis data from the Bassel lab and developed 3D mechanical models to recapitualte the observed growth behaviour. These models were part of the recent PNAS paper our labs published.
Impact Key output so far is a paper published in PNAS (Bassel et al, 2014). This is a multi-disciplinary paper which involved the localization of proteins in 3D images, quantitatitive 3D growth analysis and 3D mechanical models to describe and predict the observed data. The disciplines included: - seed biology - quantitative 3D image analysis - FEM-based 3D mechanical modelling
Start Year 2011
 
Title Quantitative analysis of protein abundance within individual cells in 3D 
Description This software is capable of quantifying protein abundance within individual cells in 3D, providing comprehensive and accurate data. This facilitates digital single cell analysis in plants and high resolution understanding of plant development. 
Type Of Technology Software 
Year Produced 2014 
Open Source License? Yes  
Impact This is enabling accurate protein abundance to be achieved within the context of fully segmented organs in 3D. In this regard the spatiotemporal abundance of proteins in individual cells can be accurately quantified. 
URL http://www.plantcell.org/content/27/4/1018.full
 
Description Meet the scientist event at The Birmingham ThinkTank Science Museum 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact This event provides an opportunity for scientists to engage with the public in an informal setting across a full day. A presentation of the work and overall objectives of this project, and the issues surrounding seed quality in agriculture, was provided. Members of the public then in turn asked questions relating to the science and its societal and economic impacts.

This event took place during half term and was attended by hundreds of visitors to the museum on that day. These included students, their parents and members of the general public.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description Scientific outreach and Universtiy of Birmingham Open Day 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an open day or visit at my research institution
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact As part of the University of Birmingham Open Day I made a presentation to the general public on the research being undertaken in my lab and funded by the BBSRC. This was principally focused on seed research and the challenges faced by agricultural production in the face of rapid climate change. An emphasis on linking this to the personal experiences of the audience in their local allotment gardens was made to help illustrate what may appear to be abstract concepts.

These events have been very well attended and there were productive discussions following the presentations.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014,2016