13TSB_N4L2FS: Functional food and feed ingredients from green leaf tissue
Lead Research Organisation:
University of Nottingham
Department Name: Sch of Biosciences
Abstract
Functional food and feed ingredients from green leaf tissue
Project Summary
Background
Green leaves contain chloroplasts, these organelles are enriched in galactolipids, (the most abundant lipid on the planet),
which carry omega-3 fatty acids, tocochromanols (vitamin E), a range of carotenoids with known health benefits, vitamin C,
and proteins. In vitro and in vivo studies indicate that only between 1/6 and 1/4 of the beta-carotene in green leaf tissue is
bioaccessible. If this is the case, then only a fraction of the nutritional potential is being released when we consume leaf
material; this may be explained by the retention of cell wall material acting as a barrier to digestive enzymes.
One obvious way to increase the nutritional impact of green leaf tissue therefore is to recover chloroplasts from plant cells
and to convert these isolated organelles into functional food/feed/supplement ingredients. Despite the great potential of
chloroplasts to contribute to the human diet, we do not know what happens to them on consumption. Food manufacturers
and processors would not only be able to exploit these natural structures, they would be ideally placed to generate
innovative microstructures for the controlled delivery and release of lipophilic bioactives.
Recent work within Food Sciences at the University of Nottingham has highlighted the potential nutritional value of isolated
chloroplasts; only 4 g of chloroplasts contains the recommended adult daily nutrient intake for vitamins A, C E and omega-3
fatty acids.
Project Outline
The nutritional quality of chloroplasts recovered from cultivated vegetation (e.g. spinach leaved) and waste material (e.g.
grass clippings) will be compared. This will be achieved through compositional and ultrastructural analyses. The impact of
blanching leaf material on the quality of chloroplasts will also be established. Candidate wet preparations of chloroplasts
will then be converted into prototype ingredients, which will be tested for storage stability and for their compatibility within a
range of food/feed formulations.
Outputs
1. New data on the composition of chloroplasts from a range of materials
2. Process flow information for converting green leaf tissue into a novel chloroplast-based functional food ingredient
3. Performance indicators for the compatibility of this new, natural, ingredient, in a range of food/feed /supplement
formulations
4. Blueprint for scaling up production
5. Viable material for a large scale feeding trial
Project Summary
Background
Green leaves contain chloroplasts, these organelles are enriched in galactolipids, (the most abundant lipid on the planet),
which carry omega-3 fatty acids, tocochromanols (vitamin E), a range of carotenoids with known health benefits, vitamin C,
and proteins. In vitro and in vivo studies indicate that only between 1/6 and 1/4 of the beta-carotene in green leaf tissue is
bioaccessible. If this is the case, then only a fraction of the nutritional potential is being released when we consume leaf
material; this may be explained by the retention of cell wall material acting as a barrier to digestive enzymes.
One obvious way to increase the nutritional impact of green leaf tissue therefore is to recover chloroplasts from plant cells
and to convert these isolated organelles into functional food/feed/supplement ingredients. Despite the great potential of
chloroplasts to contribute to the human diet, we do not know what happens to them on consumption. Food manufacturers
and processors would not only be able to exploit these natural structures, they would be ideally placed to generate
innovative microstructures for the controlled delivery and release of lipophilic bioactives.
Recent work within Food Sciences at the University of Nottingham has highlighted the potential nutritional value of isolated
chloroplasts; only 4 g of chloroplasts contains the recommended adult daily nutrient intake for vitamins A, C E and omega-3
fatty acids.
Project Outline
The nutritional quality of chloroplasts recovered from cultivated vegetation (e.g. spinach leaved) and waste material (e.g.
grass clippings) will be compared. This will be achieved through compositional and ultrastructural analyses. The impact of
blanching leaf material on the quality of chloroplasts will also be established. Candidate wet preparations of chloroplasts
will then be converted into prototype ingredients, which will be tested for storage stability and for their compatibility within a
range of food/feed formulations.
Outputs
1. New data on the composition of chloroplasts from a range of materials
2. Process flow information for converting green leaf tissue into a novel chloroplast-based functional food ingredient
3. Performance indicators for the compatibility of this new, natural, ingredient, in a range of food/feed /supplement
formulations
4. Blueprint for scaling up production
5. Viable material for a large scale feeding trial
Technical Summary
Chloroplasts are the abundant organelles, ubiquitous in green leaf tissue, that are responsible for converting light energy into chemical energy through the process of photosynthesis. What is not generally recognised is that they contain vitamins A, C and E, protein and omega-3 fatty acids. There is a growing demand for sustainably sourced, nutritious ingredients. Chloroplasts are potentially an untapped source of functional food/feed ingredients that could be recovered from cultivated or waste plant material. The aim of this feasibility study is to characterise chloroplasts extracted from green plant material (cultivated & waste) and to develop a viable market ingredient which will be assessed for it's application as a sustainably sourced functional ingredient with high protein content for use in the animal feed (global food security / sustainability) and human nutrition sectors. If successful the proposed product shall be further developed by Eminate and launched within two years from the end of this feasibility project. This project will reduce the risks associated with developing an innovative ingredient with a large potential impact in the food and animal feed markets.
Planned Impact
Who will benefit and how?
1. Postdoctoral researcher - will develop analytical skills and gain knowledge in the area of biomaterial processing
2. Eminate (lead company) - will generate IP covering an innovative food/feed ingredient, and will create a blueprint for the
commercial manufacture of this prototype ingredient.
3. Food, Feed and supplements companies - access to a novel functional ingredient that contains a number of vitamins in
their natural state (preferred by the body)
4. Producers of leafy material that ends up as waste e.g. farmers, food manufacturers and the parks departments of county
councils - valorisation of waste
5. Consumers - improved health on consumption of this ingredient
6. Environment - the process of delivery vitamin A and E into the food supply chain will be benign compared with the
recovery of these oil soluble vitamins from the refining of edible oils (organic solvents and high temperatures).
7. Environment - reduced pressure on fish stocks thought the delivery of omega-3 fatty acids in this novel and renewable
functional food ingredient
1. Postdoctoral researcher - will develop analytical skills and gain knowledge in the area of biomaterial processing
2. Eminate (lead company) - will generate IP covering an innovative food/feed ingredient, and will create a blueprint for the
commercial manufacture of this prototype ingredient.
3. Food, Feed and supplements companies - access to a novel functional ingredient that contains a number of vitamins in
their natural state (preferred by the body)
4. Producers of leafy material that ends up as waste e.g. farmers, food manufacturers and the parks departments of county
councils - valorisation of waste
5. Consumers - improved health on consumption of this ingredient
6. Environment - the process of delivery vitamin A and E into the food supply chain will be benign compared with the
recovery of these oil soluble vitamins from the refining of edible oils (organic solvents and high temperatures).
7. Environment - reduced pressure on fish stocks thought the delivery of omega-3 fatty acids in this novel and renewable
functional food ingredient
Publications
Assaye H
(2017)
Seasonal variation in the nutrient profile of Arthrospira fusiformis biomass harvested from an Ethiopian soda lake, Lake Chitu
in Journal of Applied Phycology
Gedi MA
(2017)
Component analysis of nutritionally rich chloroplasts: recovery from conventional and unconventional green plant species.
in Journal of food science and technology
Mohamad N
(2020)
Spinach leaf and chloroplast lipid: A natural rheology modifier for chocolate?
in Food Research International
Sahaka M
(2020)
The digestion of galactolipids and its ubiquitous function in Nature for the uptake of the essential a-linolenic acid
in Food & Function
Torcello-Gómez A
(2019)
Chloroplast-rich material from the physical fractionation of pea vine (Pisum sativum) postharvest field residue (Haulm).
in Food chemistry
Wattanakul J
(2019)
In vitro digestion of galactolipids from chloroplast-rich fraction (CRF) of postharvest, pea vine field residue (haulm) and spinach leaves
in Food & Function
Description | A physical method to recover nutrient-rich, intact chloroplasts from green tissue. Initial work suggests that this material could replace fish-meal to a certain level in aquaculture feed. |
Exploitation Route | 1. The results from this project formed the platform for a successful bid for IBB PoC funds in collaboration with the Green Pea Company (a cooperative of pea farmers in Yorkshire). 'Could a viable, nutritionally attractive, chloroplast-rich fraction (CRF) be recovered from pea-vine waste?' 2. CRF could be used as a commercial food or feed supplement 3. CRF from green waste material could offset a nutritional shortfall in millions of people in developing countries. |
Sectors | Agriculture, Food and Drink |
Description | Recovering nutrient-rich, intact chloroplasts, using a physical process has generated interest in academia and in industry. The results from this work triggered a collaboration with the Green Pea Company (and a successful bid for some PoC funding), who are interested in adding value to pea-vine 'waste'. The IBB Foodwastenet PoC funded project ran from May 2015 - January 2016. The results form this supported a successful bid for Pathfinder funding (BB/P012884/1); results from this are now being used to support a BBSRC Follow on Fund. This application was unsuccessful, but the PoC data was used to support a successful submission to the EPSRC Circular Economy Grant - 'Re-SAUCE' Sustainable, Alternative Uses for food waste in the Circular Economy (Jan 2017-Dec 2018). |
First Year Of Impact | 2018 |
Sector | Agriculture, Food and Drink |
Impact Types | Economic |
Description | Foodwastenet IBB Network Proof of Concept Fund |
Amount | £49,623 (GBP) |
Funding ID | PoC14_15 |
Organisation | Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) |
Sector | Public |
Country | United Kingdom |
Start | 05/2015 |
End | 01/2016 |
Description | Pathfinder Award |
Amount | £10,771 (GBP) |
Funding ID | BB/P012884/1 |
Organisation | Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) |
Sector | Public |
Country | United Kingdom |
Start | 10/2016 |
End | 02/2017 |
Description | 'Physical Fractionation of Green Waste - Innovative recovery of nutrient-rich food/food supplement ingredients as an initial stage in a broader biorefinery process' |
Organisation | The Green Pea Company |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Private |
PI Contribution | Recovered a chloroplast-rich fraction from postharvest peavine field residue biomass, dried it and measured the nutritional value (lipid soluble nutrients). |
Collaborator Contribution | The provided the postharvest peavine field residue biomass for our studies and attended meetings |
Impact | Proof of concept that a nutrient rich particulate fraction can be obtained from peavine haulm (postharvest filed residue) by a simple physical process One publication |
Start Year | 2015 |
Description | Preliminary Fish Feeding Trials |
Organisation | University of Liverpool |
Department | Institute of Integrative Biology |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | Provided novel chloroplast-rich material for a fish-feeding trial |
Collaborator Contribution | Evaluated the potential of a novel chloroplast-rich material to replace a percentage of fishmeal in the diet of zebra fish. |
Impact | The encouraging results from this preliminary study were used in a successful bid for Proof of Concept Funding from the Foodwastenet IBB network. |
Start Year | 2014 |
Description | Sustainable, Alternative Uses for food waste in the Circular Economy |
Organisation | University of York |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | Tested the impact of heat treatment on the post-harvest peavine biomass, or its recovered juice, on the nutritional quality of a derived chloroplast-rich fraction. |
Collaborator Contribution | Microwave heat treatment of biomass |
Impact | Blueprint for larger scale processing of postharvest peavine field residue to produce a nutrient-rich dried chloroplast-rich fraction One pager presenting case for the valorisation of postharvest peavine field residue (puiblished by Anthesis) |
Start Year | 2017 |
Description | TSB/BBSRC '13TSB_N4L2FS: Functional food and feed ingredients from green leaf tissue' (Feb 2014 - July 2014) which demonstrated that a nutrient-rich subcellular fraction (rich in chloroplasts) can be extracted from spinach leaves. In collaboration with Eminate Ltd. |
Organisation | Eminate Ltd |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Private |
PI Contribution | We introduced Eminate to a novel concept in producing a natural form of a food supplement rich in a wide range of nutrients (chloroplasts), and carried out experimental work to prove the idea worked. |
Collaborator Contribution | Provided commercial perspective during meetings. |
Impact | This project led on to further funding: 1. BBSRC Network in IBB: PoC funds from the IBB Foodwastenet, 'PoC_05: Physical Fractionation of Green Waste - Innovative recovery of nutrient-rich food/food supplement ingredients as an initial stage in a broader biorefinery process' (May 2015-January 2016) revealed that pea-vine waste can be used to recover a chloroplast-rich fraction. In collaboration with the Green Pea Company. [8] 2. BBSRC Pathfinder Award 'Chloroplast-rich material from green waste' BB/P012884/1 (October 2016-January 2017). In collaboration with SPG Innovation Ltd. |
Start Year | 2014 |
Description | Foodwastenet IBB Network Workshop |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | National |
Primary Audience | Industry/Business |
Results and Impact | Invited to give a talk and contribute to a workshop designed to identify plentiful 'waste' feedstocks in the UK, and innovative ways to add value to them. Dr. Gray's ideas were voted as the most promising in terms of future funding. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2015 |
Description | Invited to present 'Nutritional Ingredients from Postharvest Peavine Field Residue ('Haulm' or 'Pea Straw')' Medilink UK November 6th 2019 |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | Regional |
Primary Audience | Industry/Business |
Results and Impact | I was invited to give a talk during a session run by Medilink on sustainable solutions in the food supplements sector. This led to a conversation with Brunel Healthcare IVC International about a research project. I wrote a proposal which was accepted in principle by the technical officer of the company. Covd-19 arrived and the company decided not to fund this work. I am now in conversation with another company about possible funding to move this work into commercial applications. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2019 |
Description | Pathways to Commercialisation, Manchester Conference Centre, 1-2 March 2016 |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | National |
Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
Results and Impact | Invited to report on the results of a recently finished PoC IBB network-funded project. This project built on the outputs of the TSB-funded project which this submission forms part of the output for. The response from both academic and industry was very encouraging. The idea that the physical fractionation of all the pea vine waste in the UK could generate a chloroplast-rich fraction that could satisfy the vitamin A requirement of 30 million people over a period of one year did capture the imagination. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2016 |