13 ERA-CAP: Functional characterisation and validation of nonhost components in Triticeae species for durable resistance against fungal diseases

Lead Research Organisation: National Institute of Agricultural Botany
Department Name: Centre for Research

Abstract

Nonhost resistance (NHR) is the most durable and broadly acting form of resistance plants posses to ward off the majority of pathogen attacks regularly occurring within the environment they are living in. In order to exploit NHR in future crop protection concepts we need to understand why the minority of adapted host pathogens can circumvent or suppress NHR and what defense- or accommodation-related proteins, signalling pathways or structural components of their host plants are targeted in order to establish disease. A major obstacle to the rapid exploitation of NHR in crop breeding is related to the fact that NHR is operating at the species level, and only in exceptional cases corresponding sources of resistance can be crossed with related crop plants. Therefore, gene technological approaches to transfer nonhost-resistance components across species barriers are an attractive alternative to traditional or molecular breeding.

In the ERA-NET consortium TritNONHOST, plus a number of related projects e.g. funded within the German GABI program (BMBF), we identified a number of genes and genetic loci in barley and wheat that are associated or correlated with NHR to three major fungal pathogens including powdery mildews. A limited set of those belonging to the group of receptor-like kinases were successfully validated in functional transient assays in barley and wheat and will provide an important source for the proposed work in the DURESTrit consortium, in addition to resistance loci derived from the wild barley species Hordeum bulbosum or from experimental barley populations segregating for NHR strength. In DURESTrit, we propose to functionally validate receptor-like kinase genes plus a limited number of genes with outstanding regulation behaviour in host- versus nonhost interactions both in barley and wheat by generating and characterizing stable transgenic and backcross lines from wild barley introgressions, respectively. These materials will either carry transgenes or genome fragments from NHR donors, or have potentially important resistance components silenced by RNAi or genetically modified using TALEN technology.

The project will result in the validation of previously identified strong NHR candidates , with a special emphasis on receptor-like kinases, and in the identification of new NHR components introduced into barley or wheat by wide crosses or genetic engineering. This will deepen our understanding of NHR in cereals and provide materials and know-how for the exploitation of NHR by translational research.

Technical Summary

DURESTrit will address the objectives within six scientific work packages (WP) that are organized along a gradual shift from the validation and potential use of previously identified NHR genes and loci to the discovery of additional NHR components and study of molecular interactions between pathogen-derived effector-, host target and corresponding nonhost (non)target molecules.

In WP 1 and 2 the focus will be on the identification and validation of genes in barley that underlie NHR to Bgh, along with three barley receptor-like kinase genes already shown to confer nonhost-like resistance in wheat upon transient expression.

In WP 3, the receptor-like kinase genes will be knocked down by RNAi and knocked out by TALEN-mediated, targeted mutagenesis in order to undertake comparative analyses of their role in host basal resistance to Bgh and NHR to Bgt.

In WP4 novel candidate genes for NHR, derived from a large-scale transcript profiling and gene-mapping approachs in wheat and barley, will be functionally tested by virus-induced gene silencing (VIGS) leading to the validation of additional NHR genes.

In WP5 and WP6 the link between gene function in barley for NHR or fungal accommodation and effector-gene function in Bgh will be made by a systematic protein-protein interaction screen and by functional assays such as host-induced gene silencing of interacting candidates in Bgh and CSEP delivery /expression (transient and stable transgenics).

Planned Impact

DURESTrit addresses the strategic, international priorities of Global Food Security through sustainable agricultural practises with low environmental impact. The research underpins the effective and sustainable exploitation of disease resistance in our cereal crops, namely wheat and barley, providing knowledge, genetic resources and tools to deliver durable broad-spectrum resistance. While numerous studies have dissected the genetic pathways conferring disease resistance in non-crop model plants, we know very little about how these findings relate to disease resistance in our major crops. This project addresses this serious gap in our knowledge, looking at the roles of candidate NHR genes, including three RLK in plant-pathogen interactions in wheat and barley, and the fungal effectors responsible for disease in the barley powdery mildew pathogen. The barley RLKs in the focus of the DURESTrit consortium have been identified in previous projects at IPK as being implicated in NHR in barley and wheat, and now need to be functionally characterised more precisely and tested for their potential value in conferring NHR-like disease control. Thus, the research outputs from DURESTrit will strongly capitalize on previous achievements of partners and may impact on agricultural production by providing novel resistant cereal varieties, lowering chemical inputs and providing positive outcomes for the European economy, environment and society.

The completion of the genomic sequence of barley and wheat will revolutionise research on Europe's major cereal crops. It is therefore imperative that the European science base ensures that the necessary scientific expertise, tools and resources are in place to take maximum advantage of these invaluable resources. This project will provide advanced training for 4 PhD students and 4 early-stage researchers (post-docs), providing them with the knowledge and skill base to undertake functional genomics and advanced genetic studies in cereals, besides offering scientific exchanges between European and US partners, e.g. by secondments.
 
Description Nonhost resistance is the most durable and broadly acting form of resistance plants posses to ward off the majority of pathogens regularly occurring within the environment within which they live. In order to exploit NHR in future crop protection concepts we need to understand why only a minority of adapted host pathogens can circumvent or suppress NHR and what defense- or accommodation-related proteins, signalling pathways or structural components of their host plants are targeted in order to establish disease. Because NHR is operating at the species level, corresponding sources of resistance can only in exceptional cases be crossed with related crop plants. Therefore, gene technological approaches to transfer NHR components across species barriers are an attractive alternative to traditional or marker-assisted breeding. The key finding from this study is that transferring NHR from one plant species to another will not be a simple exercise.

NARRATIVE FROM FINAL REPORT SUBMITTED TO DGF IN JUNE 2018:
Nonhost resistance (NHR) is the most durable and broadly acting form of resistance plants possess to ward off the majority of pathogens regularly occurring within their environment. In order to exploit NHR in future crop protection concepts, we need to understand how the minority of adapted host pathogens can circumvent or suppress NHR and what defense- or accommodation-related proteins, signalling pathways or structural components of their host plants are targeted in order to establish disease. Because NHR is operating at the species level, corresponding sources of resistance can only in exceptional cases be crossed with related crop plants. Therefore, gene technological approaches to transfer NHR components across species barriers are an attractive alternative to traditional or marker-assisted breeding. In the ERA-NET consortium TritNONHOST, plus a number of related projects e.g. funded within the German GABI program (BMBF), we previously identified a number of genes and genetic loci in barley and wheat that are associated or correlated with NHR to three major fungal pathogens including powdery mildews. A sub-set of those belonging to the group of receptor-like kinases (RLKs) were successfully validated in transient over-expression or gene silencing assays in barley and wheat, thereby providing an important source for the DURESTrit consortium. We have functionally tested three RLK genes (HvLEMK1, HvRLK7 and HvRLK10) by generating and characterizing stable transgenic RNAi lines in barley and stable over-expression lines in wheat. Results of pathogen assays with this set of transgenic lines indicated that it might be difficult to transfer NHR from barley into wheat using these RLKs. While transient over-expression of the barley RLKs in the wheat cv. Kanzler gave a positive resistance phenotype towards the wheat powdery mildew pathogen, the same phenotype could not be replicated in wheat cv. Fielder, suggesting that the wheat genetic background influences limits efficacy of transfer of NHR from barley to wheat. . Putative mutants of RLKs from RNA-guided Cas9 technology were obtained in barley, providing additional resources whereby the role of these genes in NHR can be determined. The genetic fine mapping and physical mapping of (1) a major QTL located on 2HL from cultivated barley, (2) a NHR gene from a 2HS H. bulbosum introgression and (3) a large-effect QTL for NHR to the wheat powdery mildew in barley (Rbgtq1) resulted in the generation of valuable genetic material and the genetic and in part physical delimitation of novel sources of NHR. A library of synthetic secreted effector protein genes from the barley powdery mildew fungus was generated and used for targeted interaction assays with plant RLK candidate proteins. This part of the project was linked to the NSF-funded project "Host targets of fungal effectors as keys to durable disease resistance". Besides RLKs, a selected subset of candidate genes with differential regulation in host- versus nonhost interactions or belonging to potentially relevant protein families were also tested by transient expression/silencing assays in barley. The results obtained within DURESTrit deepen our understanding of NHR in cereals and provide novel materials and know-how for the exploitation of NHR by translational research.
Exploitation Route Considerable research is still required before NHR can be effective deployed as a viable approach to crop protection.

Unfortunately the sudden death of Dr Patrick Schweizer, the co-ordinator of this project, on the 9th March 2018, will have implications for how this collaborative research is taken forward.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink

URL http://www.niab.com/pages/id/377/Dr_Lesley_Boyd
 
Description Max-imising the potential of CROP researchers
Amount € 1,467,958 (EUR)
Funding ID 607178 Max-CROP 
Organisation Marie Sklodowska-Curie Actions 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country Global
Start 01/2014 
End 12/2017
 
Description TritNONHOST Workshop Presentation 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? Yes
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other academic audiences (collaborators, peers etc.)
Results and Impact Talk stimulated further discussions

Started a new collaboration with researcher in US
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2012