MECHANISTIC INSIGHTS INTO THE DEVELOPMENTAL-STAGE SPECIFIC ACTIVITY OF A UBIQUITOUSLY EXPRESSED TRANSCRIPTION FACTOR

Lead Research Organisation: University of Birmingham
Department Name: Cancer Sciences

Abstract

All our cells originate from one single fertilised egg cell which divides many times and gives rise to all the complex cell types in our body. The most fascinating aspect of such developmental processes is the fact that the timing of how different cells form is always the same, thus ensuring that our organs develop in the right order and at the right time. The reason for this synchrony is that all information for our body plan is encoded in our DNA which contains instructions on when our genes should be expressed and when they should be silent. The result is that humans are built with one plan and primates are built by another. However, humans and primates are 99% identical in their DNA, the question therefore arises what is different between the two species. The answer most likely can be found in subtle changes of the order of expression of genes that regulate the expression of other genes, the so-called transcription factors. These proteins can "read" the genetic code and they work together with many other regulator proteins to make sure that a gene is expressed in the right cell and at the right time. In the last years it was found that there are different types of transcription factors: those which are only found in one cell type, and those who are present in many cell types. All types of factors work together to regulate specific genes. When cell-specific factors are missing, usually this cell type does not form. When a factor is missing that is present in every cell, the effects can be dramatic, and often the organism is unable to develop. In this proposal we wish to study a member of the latter class of transcription factors, Sp1. We have shown that without it, blood cell development gets more and more compromised and mature blood cells cannot form. Now we want to know, how Sp1 works, when exactly it is needed and with which other factors it cooperates.

However, not only the timing of expression of transcription factors can be different. Also the levels of how much of these regulators is present in a given cell is critical since small changes in the concentration of a factor that regulates other regulators will have a huge effect in further development. An important example of what differences in factor levels can make is seen in people with Down's syndrome who have an extra chromosome in each cell. They have too much of the products of these genes from this chromosome and their development is strongly perturbed. In this grant, we will change the levels of Sp1 and measure, how such changes impact of the expression of its target genes and how this, in turn, then impacts of how many cells of a given type are formed.
To this end, we will use a system based on mouse embryonic stem cells that mimics normal development in vitro and where we can generate enough cells to examine many different features. Our work will answer a number of fundamental questions on how transcription factors interact with each other and how the balance and timing of important regulator genes is controlled.

Technical Summary

Development is regulated by the interplay of tissue-specific and ubiquitously expressed transcription factors, such as Sp1. Sp1 knock-out mice die in utero with multiple phenotypic aberrations. We have used the differentiation of mouse ES cells as a model to compare differentiation potential, global gene expression patterns and Sp1 target regions in Sp1 wild-type and deficient cells representing different stages of haematopoiesis. Sp1-/- cells progress through most embryonic stages of blood cell development but cannot complete terminal differentiation. For most Sp1 target and non-target genes, gene expression is unaffected by Sp1 inactivation. However, Cdx and multiple Hox genes are stage-specific targets of Sp1 and are down-regulated. As a consequence, genes involved in haematopoietic specification are progressively deregulated. The molecular mechanism of this deficiency is unclear.

Our work demonstrates that the early absence of active Sp1 sets a cascade in motion that culminates in a failure of terminal haematopoietic differentiation and emphasizes the role of ubiquitously expressed transcription factors for tissue-specific gene regulation. The current proposal will build on this work. We wish to dissect parts of the Sp1-responsive transcriptional network in a system-wide fashion, by studying (i) at which precise developmental time-point Sp1 is essentially required, (ii) which target genes directly respond to Sp1 presence or absence and how, (iii) how changing levels of Sp1 impact on down-stream target gene expression and last, but not least (iv) to which extent downstream effectors of Sp1 such as the Hox/Cdx genes can fully or partially rescue the Sp1 knock-out phenotypes. Our studies will deliver profound mechanistic insights into how a ubiquitously expressed transcription factor and tissue specific factors interact to drive developmental-stage-specific gene expression and how regulating the levels of Hox/Cdx genes drives differentiation forward.

Planned Impact

Who will benefit from this research:
Our work will have an impact not only on our immediate research field but also far beyond. Currently the scientific community has embarked on a quest to not just study single genes within single cells, but to examine biological phenomena in a systems-wide fashion using high-throughput methodologies. The haematopoietic system is an excellent model to perform such studies because is already the subject of multiple systems-wide studies and multiple data-sets are already available that are waiting to be integrated into complex models.

If successful, our work will benefit a number of diverse research fields. This includes
(i) developmental biology, because so far the relevance of ubiquitously expressed transcription factors for the regulation of developmental-stage-specific gene expression is not well understood
(ii) stem cell research, because the molecular details of early haematopoietic specification are unclear
(iii) mathematical modelling and bioinformatics research, because our time-course data and those from a perturbed system will provide ample opportunity for mathematical modelling and developing novel methods for data integration.
(vi) leukaemia research, because Hox genes are important regulators of leukaemogenesis and understanding their regulation will be of utmost importance for the understanding of tumour cell behaviour.

How will they benefit from this research?
(i) We will make our system-wide data sets and network models publicly available.
(ii) We will generate data that will be highly relevant to scientists studying other developmental/differentiation pathways both in academia and industry.
(iii) One significant potential outcome of our work is the identification of how early regulators of haematopietic are regulated. Such knowledge may be used to drive the production of HSCs from ES cells which may be of significant commercial benefit. We will make our expertise available to members from industry and academia who wish to explore this possibility.
(iv) Through our international collaboration there will be a significant knowledge transfer into the UK
(v) Our work will enhance the skills base in the UK. Future advances in biology and medicine will depend on building a skills base consisting of researchers which will be capable of thinking both in molecular terms as well as in system-wide terms, and researchers working on this grant will be exposed to the forefront of research in this field. They will also have the opportunity to be trained at the Institute of Computational Biology.
(vi) Along the same lines, we are attracting students into this area. Birmingham has a number of studentship schemes, and one Wellcome Trust student has already been encouraged to participate in our research. Our data will also form the basis of Master's and PhD projects in the Cazier department.
 
Description The grant has now finished and we have made a number of important observations.
• Using genome editing, we show that the original Sp1 knock-out lacking the DNA binding domain is a hypomorph. The complete Sp1 knock-out is blocked very early in development and cannot differentiate into blood cell precursors.
• We show that the complete knock-out of Sp3 also has a defect in hematopoietic specification.
• Cells with a knock-out of both genes are not viable.
• We show that the presence or absence of either Sp1 or Sp3 has little influence on the overall chromatin accessibility pattern of pluripotent and differentiating cells.
• Moreover, we show that the general direction of cell fate decisions is not affected: cells use the correct route to develop from one cell to another with chromatin accessibility patterns changing the correct way.
• We show that Sp1 and Sp3 binding sites largely overlap and that Sp3 can compensate for the lack of Sp1 binding at a number of sites but cannot direct hematopoietic specification on its own.
• We show that the hypomorphic Sp1 protein can cooperate with Sp3 to direct differentiation up to a certain point, but cells are unable to terminally differentiate.
• The most important result comes from our single cell analyses which studied normal and perturbed differentiation in WT and Sp1 mutant cells. Developmental pathways are normally highly robust, with cells executing cell fate decisions in a highly coordinated fashion within the developing organism. In the majority of studies published so far, the perturbation of tissue-specific factors led to a loss of a specific differentiation trajectory. We show by single-cell RNA-seq that this is not the case here. The most import and conceptually novel result from our work is that in the presence of mutant Sp1 the timing of differentiation is defective i.e. the coordination of a specific cell fate decision within cohorts of cells is disturbed.
• Since Sp1 sites are enriched in promoters, and since the overall pattern of chromatin accessibility at distal elements that is dictated by tissue-specific factors is not affected by the absence of Sp1/3, our data are consistent with the idea that these factors are involved in setting up stable promoter structures that are capable of interacting with distal elements in a coordinated fashion. In Sp1 hypomorphic cells this interaction is unstable which introduces a stochastic element into differentiation. However, changes in gene expression are progressive. As cells approach the terminally differentiated state, too many deregulation events have accumulated and development crashes, and cells are unable to execute differentiation past a certain point.
• Our results explain why the phenotype of the original Sp1 mutant mouse was highly heterogeneous with development blocked at various early stages and why the introduction of the same allele in late precursor cells such as myeloblast/monocytes had no effect on differentiation. Our data are therefore consistent with the novel concept that Sp1 and Sp3 do not regulate the direction, but the robustness of developmental processes. We suggest that the mutation of the majority of general and ubiquitously expressed transcriptional regulators will generate similar phenotypes, with development becoming uncoordinated and unstable, thus paving the way for further aberrations such as developmental defects and cancer. While our conclusions appear blindingly obvious, nobody has actually devised experiments that prove this idea at the systems level and by following a specific developmental pathway.

A publication has been submitted to Nature Communications
Exploitation Route Others have now shown that Sp1 is a very important factor in hematopoietic development. Moreover, it was also shown that a mutation of this factor cuases a familial type of bone marrow failure, vindicating the importance of our work. Others are now studying why this is the case
Sectors Other

 
Description Wellcome Trust studentship
Amount £86,000 (GBP)
Organisation Wellcome Trust 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2014 
End 10/2017
 
Title Single cell data 
Description Using single cell RNA Seq we showed that Sp1 and Sp1 are required for robust hematopoietic specification 
Type Of Material Model of mechanisms or symptoms - in vitro 
Year Produced 2018 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Not yet available 
 
Title Sp1-complete knock-out cell liine 
Description We used CRSPR/CAS9 to generate an ES cell line where all of the Sp1 gene has been deleted 
Type Of Material Cell line 
Year Produced 2016 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Once published, the cell line will be useful for the scientific community 
 
Title Sp3 Chip-Seq data 
Description Note that none of the classifiers fits here - Global data on Sp3 binding in ES cells 
Type Of Material Biological samples 
Year Produced 2016 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Data will be in the public domain once published 
 
Title Multiple ChIP-Seq, DNaseI-Seq and gene expression data-sets 
Description data from our LoLa consortium 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2016 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact data re-use and incorporation into publicly available data resource 
URL http://codex.stemcells.cam.ac.uk/
 
Description Collaboration with Sjaak Philipsen University of Rotterdam 
Organisation Erasmus MC
Country Netherlands 
Sector Hospitals 
PI Contribution Performing experiments and sharing expertise
Collaborator Contribution Performing experiments and sharing expertise
Impact Joint publication: A crucial role for the ubiquitously expressed transcription factor Sp1 at early stages of hematopoietic specification. Gilmour J, Assi SA, Jaegle U, Kulu D, van de Werken H, Clarke D, Westhead DR, Philipsen S, Bonifer C. Development. 2014 Jun;141(12):2391-401. doi: 10.1242/dev.106054 Presentation of the data by Sjaak Philipsen on the Sp1 meeting in 2015. Presentation of the data by Jane Gilmour on the ISCCR meeting in 2014.
Start Year 2010
 
Description Conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact We had the kick-off meeting from our Genome Biology Centre which brought together researchers from all over the UK, but also representatives from industry.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
URL http://www.birmingham.ac.uk/facilities/mds-cpd/conferences/bcgb-launch/index.aspx
 
Description Talk at the BCGB symposium in Birmingham 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact This was the second national sy,posium of the Birmingham Centre for Genome Biology
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://www.birmingham.ac.uk/research/cancer-genomics/news/2019/07/second-birmingham-symposium-on-ge...