Dynamics of Electron and Proton Transfer Chemistry in Copper and Hybrid Copper-Haem Enzymes

Lead Research Organisation: University of Essex
Department Name: Biological Sciences

Abstract

Abstracts are not currently available in GtR for all funded research. This is normally because the abstract was not required at the time of proposal submission, but may be because it included sensitive information such as personal details.

Technical Summary

We will study, at the atomistic level using large scale QM/MM and molecular dynamics calculations and rapid room temperature crystallography, the structure, dynamics and mechanisms of copper and haem containing nitrite reductases involved in biological catalysis critical for the global environment. These enzymes carry out difficult chemistry involving controlled electron and proton transfer mechanisms that are ubiquitous in nature and applicable to numerous synthetic chemical and biochemical systems. We have assembled a multidisciplinary team of researchers allowing us to apply a powerful combined computational-experimental approach.

Specifically, we will address the factors that determine the redox properties and electron/proton transfer, substrate (nitrite) and proton delivery pathways of a two-domain copper nitrite reductase (AcNiR) and a novel three-domain, haem-Cu-nitrite reductase tethered 'self-electron transfer' complex (RpNiR). We will use fast-repeat room temperature X-ray crystallography to determine frame-by-frame movies of the dynamics of catalysis and perform high-level hybrid QM/MM modelling and all-atom MD of the Fe-haem, type-1 Cu and type-2 Cu centres and determine the 'minimum enzyme' environment involved in ligand binding, electron and proton transfer and catalysis (nitrite to nitric oxide). The computational and experimental aspects of the project will work synergystically to provide unprecedented dynamic and structural detail for the entire catalytic process. The outcomes will be highly relevant for both academic and industrial applications in mechanistic enzymology and will result in experimental and computational tools for use by the wider UK research communites engaged in developing synthetic enzymes, biomimetics or nanoparticles for catalysis.

Planned Impact

Our research is well-aligned to BBSRC strategic priorities, including long-term multidisciplinary research, technology development for biosciences and new tools for chemical biology and high resolution structural analysis, through close engagement with large scale facilities (Hartree & Diamond) and immediate international impact via collaboration with the Swiss Light Source. We are conducting transformative research that provides a paradigm shift, through rapid room temperature crystallography allied to advanced computational chemistry. Each group of beneficiaries is given below along with the means by which they will benefit from the research impact.

Information gained will be relevant to general mechanisms for electron and proton transfer and catalysis in natural and synthetic enzymes, having broad impact for synthetic biology, chemical catalysis, and biotechnology. Thus our work will, in the medium term, be relevant to the UK biotechnology and chemical industries.

- In synthetic biology, we will provide information on 'minimum enzyme' structures required for catalysis
- In chemical catalysis, our contribution will be helpful in the rational design of biomimetic catalysts
- In technology, our work has impact in bioremediation technologies, e.g. the nitrogen cycle, as well as for industrial and academic users of synchrotron facilities.

We will contribute new capabilities to STFC's ChemShell QM/MM package for chemical modelling of native and synthetic enzymes, with benefit to other UK BBSRC researchers, academics and industrial scientists. New software will be placed in the CCPForge repository and included in subsequent releases of the code, freely available to UK academics. Commercial sectors will benefit through inclusion in the Accelrys software 'QMERA'. Experimental developments (e.g. rapid room temperature crystallography) will be made immediately available to the benefit of hundreds of academic and industrial researchers, including major pharma companies and SMEs engaged on chemical catalysis or structure-based drug-discovery programmes. We will seek to further relationships with industry, working closely with Liverpool's Business Gateway and the Research and Enterprise Office at Essex to achieve this aim.

We are committed to wide dissemination of our new methods and best practice, in partnership with the synchrotron laboratories and the Hartree Centre. We believe our project will serve as an exemplar of the great benefits of linking high resolution, room-temperature kinetic crystallography with advanced computational simulation. We aim to inform and inspire other researchers and large scale facility users, industrial and academic, to adopt this approach. Methodologies and outcomes will be publicised by permanent poster displays and at facility User meetings attended by UK academics and industrialists. This will lead to impact in several stakeholder groups, including the chemical industry, enzyme/biocatalysis communities; and academic and industrial groups interested in synthetic biology.

Our proposal offers excellent training for PDRA staff in multidisciplinary science. The PDRAs will develop skill sets of value to both commercial and academic sectors, enhanced by full involvement in international collaboration. The Liverpool PDRA will receive substantial training in highly parallelised high performance computing, addressing the future of the UK's economic development by contributing to a cadre of well trained professional HPC specialists. PDRA secondments to partner sites, including Diamond and Hartree, and extensive use of national and international facilities will maximise the training benefit. This will yield rounded and highly skilled researchers who will be well placed to contribute further to the UK science base and competitiveness of UK industry.

Detailed timelines with milestones for delivery of impact is given in the Workplan and Pathways to Impact

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description This was a joint proposal with awards BB/M020924/1 and BB/M022390/1 to investigate Cu proteins involved in a vital catalytic process in agriculture - the global nitrogen cycle, a process that also has environmental relevance, including formation of greenhouse gases like nitrous oxide. The key findings to date may be summarised as follows:

Revealing multiple structural states relevant to catalysis
We produced a large number of series of high-resolution X-ray structures of functionally relevant states of the enzymes, with reactions being driven by the X-ray beam. These structures provide the most relevant starting points for computational simulations (see report BB/M020924/1]. We used two domain nitrite reductase [2D-NiR] to produce series at room temperature [Horrell et al, 2018 IUCrJ 5, 283] providing the best representation of the structures in vivo. This complemented work to produce similar series at 190-240K [Horrell et al, 2018 IUCrJ 5, 283; Sen et al. 2017, IUCrJ 4, 495]. We conducted this work using the fastest X-ray detectors at typical beamlines. This was repeated for several functionally-relevant mutants of 2D-NiR. We were unable to complete comparable experiments on the catalytic cycle of a hybrid haem-Cu protein [3D-NiR] because suitable nitrite binding under our experimental conditions was not established - although we produced series using the resting state and developed a novel approach for monitoring the redox state of the different metal centres (see below). We also expanded our work to analysis of an octaheme nitrite reductase enzyme via collaboration with the group of Professor Vladimir Popov, Research Centre of Biotechnology (RAS), Moscow.

Multi-modal spectroscopy of redox states in 3D-NiR
To identify where a particular structure lies along a reaction pathway it is desirable to use a spectroscopic probe on crystals in parallel with X-ray experiments. For 3D-NiR, the visible spectrum from a copper centre is obscured by the stronger signal from the haem domain. We developed a novel method using resonance Raman spectroscopy tuned to show only the copper signal, allowing both copper and haem chromophores to be independently monitored. This provides an opportunity to monitor multiple RpNiR redox states during MSOX experiments and is also applicable to a wide range of other enzymes that contain multiple chromophores.

New Collaboration: Diamond Light Source
We produced room temperature series (see above) but discovered that it was challenging to obtain high (sub-1 second) time resolution using large crystals. We addressed this with Dr Robin Owen (Diamond) to use 'chips' holding many thousands of microcrystals of approx. 10 micron size. This was conducted by PIs Hough & Strange following the end of the 18 month PDRA position associated with the award. We measured data extremely rapidly, requiring only 10-20ms X-ray exposure per structure with a full series of dose-dependent structures being measured in approximately 100-200ms per crystal [Ebrahim et al., Acta Cryst D75, 151]. We also developed this further as a development in MSOX by applying it to a peroxidase system to carry out zero dose extrapolation using MSOX series [Ebrahim et al. IUCrJ 2019).

New Collaboration: SACLA (Japan).
One inherent limitation of using synchrotron X-rays is that even the first structure of a series is affected by the X-rays, so does not represent a true 'zero' starting point. To overcome this, we used the chip system described above, at the SACLA X-ray free-electron laser [BBSRC Partnering Award BB/R021015/1]. The X-ray pulse of 10 fs is too rapid for X-ray induced changes to occur. The 'damage-free' resting state and nitrite-bound structures were determined (1.9Å) and will feed into future computational work as well as providing an initial 'anchor' structure for the dose-series measurements described above. The Cu-nitrite complex data obtained has been used as a method development to examine the feasibility of high throughput protein-ligand structure determination using XFEL sources (published in Moreno-Chicano et al, IUCrJ, 2020).
Exploitation Route Methodology advances applicable to many other enzyme systems
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink

 
Description Training, Skills and Public Engagement The PDRA on this award, Dr Sam Horrell gained significant training and expertise in advanced structural methodologies and in the use of X-ray beamlines in the UK, France and Switzerland as well as working closely with computational researchers. These skills led to him securing a position at the Center for Free Electron Science, DESY/University of Hamburg from 2016-2019. Dr Horrell subsequently secured a further position at Diamond Light Source from 2019 where he is working on microfocus and serial crystallography, returning knowledge to the UK. Dr Horrell delivered several conference presentations describing the work in the project as well as multiple internal presentations at Essex. A number of public engagement activities were undertaken in the scope of the overall joint proposal, some examples of which are: -An article aimed at the general public published in 'Research Features' Magazine. - Public engagement at the large scale STFC Daresbury Laboratory Open Week event. - Visiting school children engaged with a protein crystallisation activity at Essex. Other impacts include several workshop presentations at Diamond Light Source describing our research and engaging with the community. Academic/Industrial Impacts: New collaboration on serial crystallography with Diamond: In Key Findings we describe the use of a chip-based serial crystallography approach at Diamond to measure dose-series data at room temperature. This approach is available to other Diamond users and has already been applied by a group from the University of Southampton. Our 2019 paper in IUCrJ from ourselves describes an approach to use zero-dose extrapolation from a series of dose-dependent structures to reproduce the intact resting state structure of a peroxidase - work that subsequently arose based on our development of this approach for nitrite reductase. Similarly, our work on applying SFX to protein-ligand complexes (with Cu nitrite reductase/nitrite as key example) has been published in 2019 in IUCrJ. These approaches may become widely applied in structural biology including by industrial researchers studying enzymes for biotechnology and as drug targets (e.g. high throughput and fragment based drug discovery). New collaborations: Together with Diamond, Southampton and RIKEN we have successfully been granted four consecutive beamtime awards at the SACLA X-ray free-electron laser in Japan. This has been supported by a BBSRC Japan Partnering Award (BB/R021015/1) and support from the UK XFEL Hub. This work involves further work on 2 domain Cu nitrite reductase including moving towards time-resolved crystallography experiments using photocages and X-ray pump-probe methodology. Our work is highly applicable to other users of X-ray free electron lasers around the world, particularly recent work determining the structures of protein-ligand complexes by serial femtosecond crystallography (published in 2019 in IUCrJ) - highly relevant to fragment based high throughput screening in the pharmaceutical industry. The SFX programme has expanded into work at the LCLS, Stanford Our work contributed to the science case for the new KMX Flagship Beamline proposal for Diamond-II for which Hough is the working group chair
First Year Of Impact 2016
Sector Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology,Other
 
Description BBSRC Internation Partnering Award (Japan)
Amount £32,360 (GBP)
Funding ID BB/R021015/1 
Organisation Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 05/2018 
End 04/2021
 
Description BEORHN: Biological Enzymatic Oxidation of Reactive Hydroxylamine in Nitrification via Combined Structural Biology and Molecular Simulation
Amount £441,577 (GBP)
Funding ID BB/V01577X/1 
Organisation Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 07/2021 
End 06/2024
 
Description Breaking the Cage: Transformative Time-resolved Crystallography using Fixed Targets at Synchrotrons and XFELs
Amount £446,146 (GBP)
Funding ID BB/W001950/1 
Organisation Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 01/2022 
End 01/2025
 
Description Diamond PhD Studentships 2019
Amount £50,679 (GBP)
Organisation Diamond Light Source 
Sector Private
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2019 
End 09/2023
 
Description Part funding for a Jointly-Supervised PhD Studentship
Amount £32,360 (GBP)
Organisation Diamond Light Source 
Sector Private
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2016 
End 09/2019
 
Description Rapid mixing Laue Experiments for Time-resolved Structural Biology of Copper Nitrite Reductase
Amount £3,000 (GBP)
Funding ID BB/R006008/1 
Organisation Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2017 
End 09/2018
 
Title High throughput fixed target serial femtosecond data collection at the SACLA XFEL 
Description We used Cu nitrite reductase microcrystals to determine damage-free serial femtosecond crystallography structures at SACLA of the resting state and nitrite bound forms. As part of this, these datasets were part of a broader project to develop high throughput data collection at XFEL sources using silicon nitride fixed targets. This work is currently in preparation for publication. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2019 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact None as yet 
 
Title High throughput ligand binding at XFEL sources 
Description We used Cu nitrite reductase microcrystal (nitrite-complex) SFX data from SACLA for a method development activity to establish the limits of high throughput enzyme-ligand complexes using XFEL radiation and fixed targets. This work is shortly to be published 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2019 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Awaiting publication/dissemination of results 
 
Title Methodology for dose-series crystallography at Diamond 
Description We developed a method to carry out dose series experiments from microcrystals at Diamond beamline I24 and in parallel to separate polymorphs in microcrystallisations into separate structures. This work was described in Ebrahim et al (2019) Acta Cryst. D75, p151- This system is available to other users of the beamline and had been used by our collaborators from University of Southampton 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2018 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact None as yet 
 
Title PDB entries 
Description Deposition of crystallographic coordinates and data for nitrite-bound Cu nitrite reductase obtained through serial femtosecond crystallography. PDB entry 6QWG 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2019 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Dissemination of experimental result, associated with publication: Chicano, TM, Ebrahim, A, Axford, D, Appleby, MV, Beale, JH, et al. & Hough, MA. (2019) High-throughput structures of protein-ligand complexes at room temperature using serial femtosecond crystallography. IUCr Journal, 6, 1074-1085. 
URL https://www.ebi.ac.uk/pdbe/entry/pdb/6qwg
 
Title PDB entries 
Description Protein databank entries 6GB8 DOI: 10.2210/pdb6GB8/pdb 6GBB DOI: 10.2210/pdb6GBB/pdb 6GBY DOI: 10.2210/pdb6GBY/pdb 6GCG DOI: 10.2210/pdb6GCG/pdb These are associated with the following publication: Resolving polymorphs and radiation-driven effects in microcrystals using fixed-target serial synchrotron crystallography Ali Ebrahim, Martin V. Appleby, Danny Axford, John Beale, Tadeo Moreno-Chicano, Darren A. Sherrell, Richard W. Strange, Michael A. Hough and Robin L. Owen Acta Cryst section D 75, pp151-159 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2018 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact None as yet 
 
Title PDB files 
Description PDB entries 5of5; 5of6; 5of7; 5of8; 5ofc; 5ofd; 5ofe; 5off; 5ofg; 5ofh; 5og2; 5og3; 5og4; 5og5; 5og6; 5ogf; 5ogg 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2018 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Just published, so no impact yet 
URL http://www.pdbe.org
 
Title PDB files 
Description PDB files from high temperature and cryogenic structures Accession codes 5N8F, 5N8G, 5N8H, 5N8I NB Publically available database 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2017 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact None noted 
URL http://www.pdbe.ac.uk
 
Title PDB files 
Description Protein data bank submissions with accession codes 5I6K 5I6L 5I6M 5I6N 5I6O 5I6P 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact None yet 
 
Description Collaboration for elevated cryogenic temperature crystallography of Cu nitrite reductase 
Organisation Cornell University
Country United States 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Provision of enzyme expertise, protein samples and crystals
Collaborator Contribution Experimental beamtime at the CHESS synchrotron, Cornell. Data collection at temperature 200K-270K and provision of data to us. Collaborator: Professor Robert Thorne
Impact Paper submitted to IUCrJ
Start Year 2016
 
Description Collaboration on rapid mixing and time-resolved structural biology of Cu nitrite reductase 
Organisation University of Hamburg
Department Centre for Ultrafast Imaging
Country Germany 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Discussions based on BBSRC award outcomes led to submission of a successful joint proposal to the Advanced Photon Source, USA for time-resolved Laue crystallography of AcNiR. We provide enzyme expertise, protein samples, microcrystals for experimental work together with analysis of resulting structures.
Collaborator Contribution Novel microfluidic rapid mixing chips to mix CuNiR with substrates and reductants for time-resolved structure determination at ultra-low doses Collaboration with Dr Diana Monteiro and Professor Martin Trebbin
Impact Successful beamtime award for 2 years to Advanced Photon Source, Chicago, USA
Start Year 2016
 
Description Collaboration with Diamond Light Source 
Organisation Diamond Light Source
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Expert user input to beamline operation and design Collaborative research project on fast X-ray data collection
Collaborator Contribution In house beamline access for this BBSRC-funded project Non-standard experimental set ups via collaboration
Impact Jointly-funded PhD studentship between Diamond Light Source and University of Essex focusing on rapid X-ray data collection methods.
Start Year 2015
 
Description Collaboration with RIKEN and SACLA-SPring-8, Japan and Diamond Light Source 
Organisation Diamond Light Source
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Collaborative beamtime proposals to SACLA X-ray free electron laser. Sample preparation and experimental design, data analysis. Submission of successful BBSRC Japan Partnering Award proposal based on results of initial collaborative experiments. NB our recently funded Japan Partnering Award from BBSRC arising from this collaboration included a £200,000 (2.9Million Japanese Yen) in kind contribution.
Collaborator Contribution SACLA/SPring8 - provision of facilities (lab equipment), reagents and expertise. Diamond Light Source: Sample stages, mounts and translation equipment, microscopes etc. We have accessed the above in experimental visits to SACLA in 2017, 2018 and 2019.
Impact This is a new collaboration. We successfully applied for a BBSRC Japan Partnering Award (start date May 2018) to develop the collaboration further. Successful beamtime proposals to SACLA 2017B8014, 2018A8005 2019A8004 were made, resulting in 108 hours of joint collaborative beamtime. Drs Sugimoto and Tosha visited the UK team in December 2019 for discussions, planning an collaborative experiments at Diamond Light Source.
Start Year 2017
 
Description Collaboration with RIKEN and SACLA-SPring-8, Japan and Diamond Light Source 
Organisation RIKEN
Department RIKEN SPring-8 Center
Country Japan 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Collaborative beamtime proposals to SACLA X-ray free electron laser. Sample preparation and experimental design, data analysis. Submission of successful BBSRC Japan Partnering Award proposal based on results of initial collaborative experiments. NB our recently funded Japan Partnering Award from BBSRC arising from this collaboration included a £200,000 (2.9Million Japanese Yen) in kind contribution.
Collaborator Contribution SACLA/SPring8 - provision of facilities (lab equipment), reagents and expertise. Diamond Light Source: Sample stages, mounts and translation equipment, microscopes etc. We have accessed the above in experimental visits to SACLA in 2017, 2018 and 2019.
Impact This is a new collaboration. We successfully applied for a BBSRC Japan Partnering Award (start date May 2018) to develop the collaboration further. Successful beamtime proposals to SACLA 2017B8014, 2018A8005 2019A8004 were made, resulting in 108 hours of joint collaborative beamtime. Drs Sugimoto and Tosha visited the UK team in December 2019 for discussions, planning an collaborative experiments at Diamond Light Source.
Start Year 2017
 
Description Collaboration with University of Southampton (Dr Ivo Tews) 
Organisation University of Southampton
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Our work on Cu nitrite reductase serial crystallography at Diamond and SACLA led to the establishment of a new collaboration with Dr Ivo Tews, University of Southampton to exploit our new methodology.
Collaborator Contribution New samples & proteins to apply our methodology to (FutA iron transport system) Participation in SACLA and Diamond beamtime We have been granted SACLA beamtime jointly with Dr Tews for 2019 and 2020.
Impact Multiple future publications from joint serial crystallography experiments are anticipated.
Start Year 2018
 
Description Collaborative experiments in lauee 
Organisation Argonne National Laboratory
Country United States 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Participation in beamtime - Laue experiments at BioCARS facility, APS (two visits)
Collaborator Contribution Training, experimental participation and data processing
Impact Manuscript in preparation
Start Year 2017
 
Description SLS collaboration 
Organisation Swiss Light Source (SLS)
Country Switzerland 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Samples and expert user input to experimental beamline setup Collaborative research programme under this BBSRC grant
Collaborator Contribution In house beamtime made available via collaboration
Impact Several publications prior to commencement of this grant award
Start Year 2012
 
Description Article for he general public in 'Research Features' 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact A magazine article describing the work undertaken in this BBSRC grant aimed at the general public in Research Features
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL https://researchfeatures.com/2017/08/08/demystifying-denitrifying-bacterial-enzymes/
 
Description STFC Daresbury Laboratory Open Week 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an open day or visit at my research institution
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Poster display and talk at an open week event at STFC Daresbury Laboratory. This event attracted a large audience including schools and the general public.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
URL http://www.stfc.ac.uk/public-engagement/activities-for-the-public/visit-daresbury-laboratory/daresbu...
 
Description Schools work experience in protein crystallisation 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an open day or visit at my research institution
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact 8 school pupils (ages 15-17) attended for a 1 week work experience in the School of Biological Sciences. Mike Hough ran a crystallisation workshop and discussed grant-funded research. Students had the opportunity to grow protein crystals and examine them under the microscope.

Very positive feedback received, with pupils expressing interest in biological sciences degrees
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016