ERA-IB 5. ECOYEAST SJH: Mastering the economics of adaptation through constraint-based modeling in yeast (Hubbard)

Lead Research Organisation: University of Manchester
Department Name: School of Biological Sciences

Abstract

Living cells evolved a remarkable ability to adapt to environmental conditions, or to withstand mutations. In biotechnology, this compromises success in metabolic engineering and causes instability of engineered strains. "Functional genomics" has allowed the cost-effective measurement of many of the components of the cell. However, we still mostly fail to understand how their interactions lead to cellular function and adaptation. It becomes clear, however, that physics and (bio)chemistry impose strong constraints on adaptation and evolution. Such constraints limit the total amount of protein that a cell can synthesize, and impact on how it should partition that limited resource over its processes to optimize fitness ("cellular economics"). Such knowledge is important to come with better metabolic engineering strategies that take into account the impact of novel genes and pathways on cellular economics, to develop processes with high yields that enable cost-effective bio-based chemicals and biofuels. In this proposal we will develop a modeling framework that will allow the integration of large data sets into comprehensive mechanistic models. These models are of genome-scale and will be able to compute the costs and benefits of implementing metabolic engineering strategies. The economic models will be used to provide proof-of-concept in two ways: (i) as tools for data integration and interpretation of adaptive responses; (ii) as predictive tool, through optimisation to predict more realistic theoretical yields and through exploration of metabolic engineering scenarios. This will be tested by a user case provided by our industrial partners, DSM and Roquette, involving succinate production, a versatile C4 diacid with a lot of potential applications, e.g. in polymers and resins.

Technical Summary

Living cells evolved a remarkable ability to adapt to environmental conditions, or to withstand mutations. In biotechnology, this compromises success in metabolic engineering and causes instability of engineered strains. "Functional genomics" has allowed the cost-effective measurement of many of the components of the cell. However, we still mostly fail to understand how their interactions lead to cellular function and adaptation. It becomes clear, however, that physics and (bio)chemistry impose strong constraints on adaptation and evolution. Such constraints limit the total amount of protein that a cell can synthesize, and impact on how it should partition that limited resource over its processes to optimize fitness ("cellular economics"). Such knowledge is important to come with better metabolic engineering strategies that take into account the impact of novel genes and pathways on cellular economics, to develop processes with high yields that enable cost-effective bio-based chemicals and biofuels. In this proposal we will develop a modeling framework that will allow the integration of large data sets into comprehensive mechanistic models. These models are of genome-scale and will be able to compute the costs and benefits of implementing metabolic engineering strategies. The economic models will be used to provide proof-of-concept in two ways: (i) as tools for data integration and interpretation of adaptive responses; (ii) as predictive tool, through optimisation to predict more realistic theoretical yields and through exploration of metabolic engineering scenarios. This will be tested by a user case provided by our industrial partners, DSM and Roquette, involving succinate production, a versatile C4 diacid with a lot of potential applications, e.g. in polymers and resins.

Planned Impact

Expected results and patents - we will deliver a methodology for large-scale genomics data
integration and modeling, that can be used and will be tested by our industrial partners. The
approach is generic and therefore of general use in industrial biotechnology. No patents are
expected from the modeling methodology per se, but as it is a powerful enabling technology for
biological discovery and innovation, there might be IP on optimization strategies. More directly,
findings for specific or general strain and/or process development of the succinic acid process, or
more general yeast fermentation might be achieved.

Preliminary exploitation plan - knowledge and expertise developed in this project, as well as
software and models, will be valuable assets for follow up in public-private partnerships. Software
will be developed under open-source agreement for academic use. None of the academic partners
have the ambition at this moment to set up a company to provide modeling services. All groups
involved have a large network with industrial partners to team up with to implement and apply the
developed technologies.
 
Description The recent acquisition of high quality quantatitive proteomics data on yeast samples grown on different carbon sources has been highly productive. We are using this data to feedback proteome levels for the modelling partners in Netherlands and Sweden, and also for own uses. It has helped us develop novel analysis pipelines to examine changes in metabolic pathways and novel visualisation approaches. A paper on this was submitted in 2018, was rejected from one journa, and is now accepted in Mol Omics. We also have high quality transcriptome and proteome data for yeast grown at different growth rates, which has been analysed and the lead collaborators in Netherlands are writing a manuscript.We are also exploring this data for fundamental aspects of transcription vs translation in control of gene expression and have reanalysed some new data, along with existing data concerning gene expression in yeast growing under different growth rates in chemostat.
Exploitation Route Using the protein quantitation data to extend genome scale metabolic models - this has now happened and a paper has been published
Sectors Chemicals,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology

 
Description We held some joint project meetings with European and industrial partners which were productive, with sharing of expertise about genome scale metabolic modelling and the use of the proteomics data in this project appears to be bearing fruit. Industrial partners may integrate this into their own work, and we are working in their industrial yeast strains (with appropriate MTAs etc) though I am not aware this has reached a mature stage. A more mature genome-scale model has also now been developed from the project which is available, and is now published in Nature Communications.
First Year Of Impact 2021
Sector Chemicals,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology
Impact Types Economic

 
Title Whole-cell modeling in yeast predicts compartment-specific proteome constraints that drive metabolic strategies 
Description Mass spec data associated with the publication in Nature Communications 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact none yet - other than the paper 
URL http://proteomecentral.proteomexchange.org/cgi/GetDataset?ID=PXD030003
 
Description ERA-IB yeast proteomics and turnover studies 
Organisation DSM
Country Netherlands 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution The collaboration was borne out of email discussions with a PI at VU who had seen our proteomics and transcriptomics work and wondered if we wanted to collaborate on a yeast systems biology project. We bring the bioinformatics, transcriptomics and proteomics expertise, and allows us to integrate our quantitative proteomics platform (developed on the LoLa grant to Hubbard/Beynon) to generate data for systems modelling efforts in NL and Denmark.
Collaborator Contribution Provision of expertise in modelling, with industrial partners providing industrially important yeast strains which are able to produce high yields of succinate. We aim to investigate this at the systems level through post-genomic science and genome scale modelling
Impact This project is in its early days but we now have acquired quantitiative proteomics data via the Liverpool partners and have improved our data analysis pipelines for estimation of protein turnover rates
Start Year 2015
 
Description ERA-IB yeast proteomics and turnover studies 
Organisation Delft University of Technology (TU Delft)
Country Netherlands 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The collaboration was borne out of email discussions with a PI at VU who had seen our proteomics and transcriptomics work and wondered if we wanted to collaborate on a yeast systems biology project. We bring the bioinformatics, transcriptomics and proteomics expertise, and allows us to integrate our quantitative proteomics platform (developed on the LoLa grant to Hubbard/Beynon) to generate data for systems modelling efforts in NL and Denmark.
Collaborator Contribution Provision of expertise in modelling, with industrial partners providing industrially important yeast strains which are able to produce high yields of succinate. We aim to investigate this at the systems level through post-genomic science and genome scale modelling
Impact This project is in its early days but we now have acquired quantitiative proteomics data via the Liverpool partners and have improved our data analysis pipelines for estimation of protein turnover rates
Start Year 2015
 
Description ERA-IB yeast proteomics and turnover studies 
Organisation Free University of Amsterdam
Country Netherlands 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The collaboration was borne out of email discussions with a PI at VU who had seen our proteomics and transcriptomics work and wondered if we wanted to collaborate on a yeast systems biology project. We bring the bioinformatics, transcriptomics and proteomics expertise, and allows us to integrate our quantitative proteomics platform (developed on the LoLa grant to Hubbard/Beynon) to generate data for systems modelling efforts in NL and Denmark.
Collaborator Contribution Provision of expertise in modelling, with industrial partners providing industrially important yeast strains which are able to produce high yields of succinate. We aim to investigate this at the systems level through post-genomic science and genome scale modelling
Impact This project is in its early days but we now have acquired quantitiative proteomics data via the Liverpool partners and have improved our data analysis pipelines for estimation of protein turnover rates
Start Year 2015
 
Description ERA-IB yeast proteomics and turnover studies 
Organisation Novo Nordisk Foundation
Country Denmark 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution The collaboration was borne out of email discussions with a PI at VU who had seen our proteomics and transcriptomics work and wondered if we wanted to collaborate on a yeast systems biology project. We bring the bioinformatics, transcriptomics and proteomics expertise, and allows us to integrate our quantitative proteomics platform (developed on the LoLa grant to Hubbard/Beynon) to generate data for systems modelling efforts in NL and Denmark.
Collaborator Contribution Provision of expertise in modelling, with industrial partners providing industrially important yeast strains which are able to produce high yields of succinate. We aim to investigate this at the systems level through post-genomic science and genome scale modelling
Impact This project is in its early days but we now have acquired quantitiative proteomics data via the Liverpool partners and have improved our data analysis pipelines for estimation of protein turnover rates
Start Year 2015
 
Description ERA-IB yeast proteomics and turnover studies 
Organisation Roquette Pharma
Country France 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution The collaboration was borne out of email discussions with a PI at VU who had seen our proteomics and transcriptomics work and wondered if we wanted to collaborate on a yeast systems biology project. We bring the bioinformatics, transcriptomics and proteomics expertise, and allows us to integrate our quantitative proteomics platform (developed on the LoLa grant to Hubbard/Beynon) to generate data for systems modelling efforts in NL and Denmark.
Collaborator Contribution Provision of expertise in modelling, with industrial partners providing industrially important yeast strains which are able to produce high yields of succinate. We aim to investigate this at the systems level through post-genomic science and genome scale modelling
Impact This project is in its early days but we now have acquired quantitiative proteomics data via the Liverpool partners and have improved our data analysis pipelines for estimation of protein turnover rates
Start Year 2015
 
Description ERA-IB yeast proteomics and turnover studies 
Organisation University of Liverpool
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The collaboration was borne out of email discussions with a PI at VU who had seen our proteomics and transcriptomics work and wondered if we wanted to collaborate on a yeast systems biology project. We bring the bioinformatics, transcriptomics and proteomics expertise, and allows us to integrate our quantitative proteomics platform (developed on the LoLa grant to Hubbard/Beynon) to generate data for systems modelling efforts in NL and Denmark.
Collaborator Contribution Provision of expertise in modelling, with industrial partners providing industrially important yeast strains which are able to produce high yields of succinate. We aim to investigate this at the systems level through post-genomic science and genome scale modelling
Impact This project is in its early days but we now have acquired quantitiative proteomics data via the Liverpool partners and have improved our data analysis pipelines for estimation of protein turnover rates
Start Year 2015
 
Description integrated bioinformatics to study the yeast chaperone 
Organisation University of Liverpool
Department Centre for Proteome Research
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Bioinformatics tools for this project have been exploited with various labs, including those at Manchester and at Liverpool, to improve a related manuscript on the effects of heat shock in Saccahromyces cerevisiae
Collaborator Contribution They provided proteomics facilities and data, which we integrated with bioinformatics networks to generate novel figures for a paper
Impact Andrew F. Jarnuczak, Manuel Garcia Albornoz, Claire E. Eyers, Christopher M. Grant, Simon J. Hubbard. A quantitative and temporal map of proteostasis during heat shock in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, 2018, Mol. Omics, 2018, 14, 37-52
Start Year 2017
 
Description yeast metabolic control bioinformatics with M Adamczyk 
Organisation Warsaw University of Technology
Country Poland 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We helped process proteomics data and generate figures for a manuscript describing proteomics data collected at the University of Liverpool. We integrated the data into metabolic pathways and cross referenced it with transcription factor target data to generate figures for the manuscript, which we helped interpret and write.
Collaborator Contribution The collborators in Poland provided yeast samples from mutant strains to the University of Liverpool, and subsequently raw mass spectrometry data was sent to us. We processed the data, integrated this with known pathway information, and this was interpreted by the partners who led the manuscript - just accepted at Biochemical Journal,
Impact Roza Szatkowska1, Manuel Garcia-Albornoz2, Katarzyna Roszkowska1, Stephen W. Holman3a, Emil Furmanek1, Simon Hubbard2, Robert J. Beynon3, Malgorzata Adamczyk *1 (2019) Glycolytic flux in Saccharomyces cerevisiae is dependent on RNA polymerase III and its negative regulator Maf1, Biochem J. In press (we don't have a DOI yet)
Start Year 2017