BB/N003861/1

Lead Research Organisation: NERC CEH (Up to 30.11.2019)
Department Name: Water Resources (Wallingford)

Abstract

The aim is to reduce the reliance on external inputs to the farm, by providing fertilizer for the grass on which the cows feed, to use the waste from the cows to grow duckweeds, a very fast growing floating aquatic plant with a high protein content. To use the duckweeds as a substitute supplementary feed source for the cows and to use any organic waste left over to produce biogas.

The project aim is to create a circular farm by using manure from cattle to create struvite (magnesium ammonium phosphate is a mineral compound with the formula: NH4MgPO4.6H2O) and ammonium sulphate fertilizer; duckweed biomass to provide a substitute feed source for the cattle in place of imported Soya; and to use waste material from these processes in an anaerobic digester to create biogas that will provide both heat and power to the farm and the production process.

The manure is collected and digested in an anaerobic digester unit to produce biogas and a residue. The residue is speared into solid and liquid fractions. The solid fraction can be used a s a soil conditioner directly on the farm. The liquid fraction is used to make struvite by adding magnesium chloride, and also processed to remove nitrogen to form solid ammonium sulphate. The residue form this process, which is still rich in both phosphorous and nitrogen, is heated and passed into an indoor slow flowing lagoon system designed to optimize the growth of Lemna species, or duckweeds. The effluent is processed by the duckweed and leaves the lagoon within the limits for discharge to the environment or is recycled through the lagoon system until the discharge limits have been reached. The process is designed to be continuous, but this depends on a constant supply of cow manure and duckweed. Part of the research project is to determine what conditions favor the most rapid growth of duckweeds in this system.

Technical Summary

The project aim is to create a circular farm. The electricity and heat will be generated by the biogas engine, fertilizer will be produced in the form of struvite and ammonium sulphate and the (protein rich) cattle feed by the duck weed. In this project the focus will be on the production of protein rich feed in the form of duckweeds. The goal of this project, is to do optimize the production of duck weed. The role of CEH will be to collect Lemna species form a variety of on farm locations in the UK and the Netherlands and to use effluent form the farm scale operation to select a suitable species mix that optimize removal of dissolved nutrient in low temperature situations, and produces a high protein basis for cattle feed and also provides some input to the biogas generator system as residue from the process. The end point of the CEH research will be a method for pre-selecting duckweed species mixtures for any farm scale operation by using small scale rapid selection procedures on a manageable scale, that can be implemented without technical equipment and can be undertaken by anyone interested in duckweed nutrient removal tank systems.The quality of the farm will be assessed by comparing milk production (quality and yield), the quality of the fertilizer produced, the amount of of heat energy and electricity produced.

Planned Impact

In the Netherlands, there is quite a surplus of manure, which will increase with the lifting of the milk quota system in 2015. By this system, the production of milk in the Netherlands, but also in the UK and to less extent in Poland, can be increased on the same amount of land. In the Netherlands, an increase of 15% in the milk production is expected in the coming years. The stables for the cows are already enlarged, the processing capacity for milk is being installed at this moment for a value of about 1 billion euro in the North of the Netherlands. So, there are only two limiting factors left, the surplus of manure and the feed for the animals. The impact of this proposal will be to solve these limiting factors.

The dissemination will take place by demonstrating the system on a research level. The only way to convince farmers is by demonstrating the system and to prove that it solves their problem of the limiting factors to enlarge their capacity.

The environmental impact is high. It will solve the phosphate problem in two ways. The first problem is the surplus in the Netherlands. This will be solved in a proper way. The second one is the minimization of the use of the phosphate by recycling it for the fertilizer industry.

The systems will generate more renewable energy as the farm needs. So, the system will contribute to the goals of renewable energy production. The systems will generate renewable fertilizer, so in the way a complete bio-refinery system will be demonstrated producing energy, fertilizer and feed for the cows.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The use of simple mono specific vegetative filters for processing of nutrient waste from animal farms does not work. A complex mixture of vegetation types, filtration media and flow management is required to optimise nutrient removal processes by aquatic vegetation in sites with a restricted footprint.
Exploitation Route Design criteria for on-farm wetland processing systems
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Environment

 
Description There is a problem with manure management in European dairy farms. We are developing an on farm solution that will produce a nitrogen and phosphate fertilizer suitable for use or sale on the farm. We are supplementing the diet for the animals by producing protein rich diets for addition to the normal diet.
First Year Of Impact 2015
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink,Environment
Impact Types Societal,Economic

 
Title struvite production on farm systems 
Description on farm system for struvite production. fertilizer made from digestate of AD bioreactor. 
Type Of Material Technology assay or reagent 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact circular economy, recycling of dairy manure and production of slow release fertilizer for grass. 
 
Description Cradle To Cattle Farming 
Organisation Cornelius Consulting Limited
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution This is a collaborative project to install wetland processing systems for nutrient management and fertilizer production to cattle farms across Europe. The research will be started in the Netherlands and rolled out to participating countries, starting in Poland and the UK. CEH has designe the wetland processing system for modular installation on farms. Essential is the good choice of duckweeds. CEH is specialized in this area and will help to find the good duckweeds for this system of refining the manure to cow feed by duckweed. CCS is specialized in designing these systems for farmers. They have already designed the complete concept of digester, gas engine, nitrogen stripper and struvite reactor (the latter two with ProfiNutrients) and will make a complete integral design with is feasible from a technical and economical view point. Furthermore, CEH will advise in the optimal grow conditions for duckweed. The aim will be to find duckweeds which still grow optimal under a lower temperature. In the way, the lake can be less heated. Research will be performed if a (plastic) roof is needed. The exhaust gasses of the gas engine can be used to increase the growth. However, these gases can also damage the weeds. This is being investigated. We will test three species of duckweeds separately and in combination. L. minuta has the fastest growth rate and will certainly be a major component of the duckweed system. It is also perennial at northern European temperatures and will form the main component of the system during winter months. Other species of Lemna, L. gibba and L. minor will have different nutrient uptake patterns and will be useful in the overall system to complete the uptake of nutrients. Other species of duckweed, including Spirodela polyrhiza and Wolffia arrhiza may also be used at different times of the year. The advantage of using different sized duckweeds is to vary the uptake rates of nutrients and to provide a complex system that can adapt to varying nutrient inputs. This work has not yet started because of a delay in the construction in the duckweed ponds. We are continually assessing the best way to manage nutrients which may be produced at toxic levels, and have redesigned the ponds to include a wetland filter to reduce potassium toxicity. This will be implemented in the summer of 2016.
Collaborator Contribution The partners have provided expertise on fertilizer production and design of machinery and equipment for manure processing.
Impact Consortium Agreement
Start Year 2015
 
Description Cradle To Cattle Farming 
Organisation Maatschap Nijkamp-Marsman
Country Netherlands 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution This is a collaborative project to install wetland processing systems for nutrient management and fertilizer production to cattle farms across Europe. The research will be started in the Netherlands and rolled out to participating countries, starting in Poland and the UK. CEH has designe the wetland processing system for modular installation on farms. Essential is the good choice of duckweeds. CEH is specialized in this area and will help to find the good duckweeds for this system of refining the manure to cow feed by duckweed. CCS is specialized in designing these systems for farmers. They have already designed the complete concept of digester, gas engine, nitrogen stripper and struvite reactor (the latter two with ProfiNutrients) and will make a complete integral design with is feasible from a technical and economical view point. Furthermore, CEH will advise in the optimal grow conditions for duckweed. The aim will be to find duckweeds which still grow optimal under a lower temperature. In the way, the lake can be less heated. Research will be performed if a (plastic) roof is needed. The exhaust gasses of the gas engine can be used to increase the growth. However, these gases can also damage the weeds. This is being investigated. We will test three species of duckweeds separately and in combination. L. minuta has the fastest growth rate and will certainly be a major component of the duckweed system. It is also perennial at northern European temperatures and will form the main component of the system during winter months. Other species of Lemna, L. gibba and L. minor will have different nutrient uptake patterns and will be useful in the overall system to complete the uptake of nutrients. Other species of duckweed, including Spirodela polyrhiza and Wolffia arrhiza may also be used at different times of the year. The advantage of using different sized duckweeds is to vary the uptake rates of nutrients and to provide a complex system that can adapt to varying nutrient inputs. This work has not yet started because of a delay in the construction in the duckweed ponds. We are continually assessing the best way to manage nutrients which may be produced at toxic levels, and have redesigned the ponds to include a wetland filter to reduce potassium toxicity. This will be implemented in the summer of 2016.
Collaborator Contribution The partners have provided expertise on fertilizer production and design of machinery and equipment for manure processing.
Impact Consortium Agreement
Start Year 2015
 
Description Cradle To Cattle Farming 
Organisation New Chemical Synthesis Institute
Country Poland 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution This is a collaborative project to install wetland processing systems for nutrient management and fertilizer production to cattle farms across Europe. The research will be started in the Netherlands and rolled out to participating countries, starting in Poland and the UK. CEH has designe the wetland processing system for modular installation on farms. Essential is the good choice of duckweeds. CEH is specialized in this area and will help to find the good duckweeds for this system of refining the manure to cow feed by duckweed. CCS is specialized in designing these systems for farmers. They have already designed the complete concept of digester, gas engine, nitrogen stripper and struvite reactor (the latter two with ProfiNutrients) and will make a complete integral design with is feasible from a technical and economical view point. Furthermore, CEH will advise in the optimal grow conditions for duckweed. The aim will be to find duckweeds which still grow optimal under a lower temperature. In the way, the lake can be less heated. Research will be performed if a (plastic) roof is needed. The exhaust gasses of the gas engine can be used to increase the growth. However, these gases can also damage the weeds. This is being investigated. We will test three species of duckweeds separately and in combination. L. minuta has the fastest growth rate and will certainly be a major component of the duckweed system. It is also perennial at northern European temperatures and will form the main component of the system during winter months. Other species of Lemna, L. gibba and L. minor will have different nutrient uptake patterns and will be useful in the overall system to complete the uptake of nutrients. Other species of duckweed, including Spirodela polyrhiza and Wolffia arrhiza may also be used at different times of the year. The advantage of using different sized duckweeds is to vary the uptake rates of nutrients and to provide a complex system that can adapt to varying nutrient inputs. This work has not yet started because of a delay in the construction in the duckweed ponds. We are continually assessing the best way to manage nutrients which may be produced at toxic levels, and have redesigned the ponds to include a wetland filter to reduce potassium toxicity. This will be implemented in the summer of 2016.
Collaborator Contribution The partners have provided expertise on fertilizer production and design of machinery and equipment for manure processing.
Impact Consortium Agreement
Start Year 2015
 
Description Cradle To Cattle Farming 
Organisation ProfiNutrients B.V.
Country Netherlands 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution This is a collaborative project to install wetland processing systems for nutrient management and fertilizer production to cattle farms across Europe. The research will be started in the Netherlands and rolled out to participating countries, starting in Poland and the UK. CEH has designe the wetland processing system for modular installation on farms. Essential is the good choice of duckweeds. CEH is specialized in this area and will help to find the good duckweeds for this system of refining the manure to cow feed by duckweed. CCS is specialized in designing these systems for farmers. They have already designed the complete concept of digester, gas engine, nitrogen stripper and struvite reactor (the latter two with ProfiNutrients) and will make a complete integral design with is feasible from a technical and economical view point. Furthermore, CEH will advise in the optimal grow conditions for duckweed. The aim will be to find duckweeds which still grow optimal under a lower temperature. In the way, the lake can be less heated. Research will be performed if a (plastic) roof is needed. The exhaust gasses of the gas engine can be used to increase the growth. However, these gases can also damage the weeds. This is being investigated. We will test three species of duckweeds separately and in combination. L. minuta has the fastest growth rate and will certainly be a major component of the duckweed system. It is also perennial at northern European temperatures and will form the main component of the system during winter months. Other species of Lemna, L. gibba and L. minor will have different nutrient uptake patterns and will be useful in the overall system to complete the uptake of nutrients. Other species of duckweed, including Spirodela polyrhiza and Wolffia arrhiza may also be used at different times of the year. The advantage of using different sized duckweeds is to vary the uptake rates of nutrients and to provide a complex system that can adapt to varying nutrient inputs. This work has not yet started because of a delay in the construction in the duckweed ponds. We are continually assessing the best way to manage nutrients which may be produced at toxic levels, and have redesigned the ponds to include a wetland filter to reduce potassium toxicity. This will be implemented in the summer of 2016.
Collaborator Contribution The partners have provided expertise on fertilizer production and design of machinery and equipment for manure processing.
Impact Consortium Agreement
Start Year 2015
 
Description Cradle To Cattle Farming 
Organisation University of Warsaw
Country Poland 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution This is a collaborative project to install wetland processing systems for nutrient management and fertilizer production to cattle farms across Europe. The research will be started in the Netherlands and rolled out to participating countries, starting in Poland and the UK. CEH has designe the wetland processing system for modular installation on farms. Essential is the good choice of duckweeds. CEH is specialized in this area and will help to find the good duckweeds for this system of refining the manure to cow feed by duckweed. CCS is specialized in designing these systems for farmers. They have already designed the complete concept of digester, gas engine, nitrogen stripper and struvite reactor (the latter two with ProfiNutrients) and will make a complete integral design with is feasible from a technical and economical view point. Furthermore, CEH will advise in the optimal grow conditions for duckweed. The aim will be to find duckweeds which still grow optimal under a lower temperature. In the way, the lake can be less heated. Research will be performed if a (plastic) roof is needed. The exhaust gasses of the gas engine can be used to increase the growth. However, these gases can also damage the weeds. This is being investigated. We will test three species of duckweeds separately and in combination. L. minuta has the fastest growth rate and will certainly be a major component of the duckweed system. It is also perennial at northern European temperatures and will form the main component of the system during winter months. Other species of Lemna, L. gibba and L. minor will have different nutrient uptake patterns and will be useful in the overall system to complete the uptake of nutrients. Other species of duckweed, including Spirodela polyrhiza and Wolffia arrhiza may also be used at different times of the year. The advantage of using different sized duckweeds is to vary the uptake rates of nutrients and to provide a complex system that can adapt to varying nutrient inputs. This work has not yet started because of a delay in the construction in the duckweed ponds. We are continually assessing the best way to manage nutrients which may be produced at toxic levels, and have redesigned the ponds to include a wetland filter to reduce potassium toxicity. This will be implemented in the summer of 2016.
Collaborator Contribution The partners have provided expertise on fertilizer production and design of machinery and equipment for manure processing.
Impact Consortium Agreement
Start Year 2015
 
Description Workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact workshop for farmers in Poland to exploit outcome of project
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
 
Description Workshop meeting 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact We attended a workshop organised by the project coordinator to present our thinking on the project to the target audience of dairy farmers near Wageningen in the Netherlands. the purpose of the meeting was to inform the farmer about what we were intending to do in the project and listen to feedback from the farmers. We were also shown a prototype duckweed farm that had been constructed on top of a cow parlor using waste material form a biomass boiler system designed to process the waste manure. Nutirent systems were in place to manage flow through of liquid waste material to grow duckweed. Our aim in this project is to improve the removal of nutrients from the waste stream and to produce an alternative source of protein supplement for feeding cattle.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015