Management and use of beneficial bacterial biofilms to control aquatic pathogens, for reliable chemical-free sanitisation of swimming pools

Lead Research Organisation: University of the West of England
Department Name: Faculty of Health and Applied Sciences

Abstract

We seek to develop innovative biofilm technology, in order to manage waterborne pathogens in swimming pools. Our biofilm based biofilter is a new and novel solution to pool water filtration. By using beneficial biofilms it negates chemical disinfection, enables complete control of algae and algal films, and recent preliminary data has shown the potential for management of key aquatic pathogens.

The swimming pool filtration market (worth 3.2bn) currently lacks chemical-free alternatives despite customers' demands of healthier, easier and cheaper solutions to pool water treatment. Therefore a unique market oportunity exists. The benefits of biofiltration over the incumbent (chemical) filters are: 1. Higher reliability potential (less reliance on chemical testing /dosing ), 2. Lower maintenance (no monitoring of water chemistry), 3. Cost savings: Zero chemical usage, lower circulation energy (120w vs 1200w circulation pumps) 4. Enhanced user experiences (fresh vs chemical laden water). This project would help to fully realise the mass market potential for this biofilm based technology, through innovative and robust scientific research and development.

This project will assess and develop the potential for beneficial biofilms to control pathogens through understanding and optimising biofilm performance. To this end, we will utilise novel scientific techniques, e.g. bioluminescent bacterial reporters (enabling temporal and spatial monitoring of known pathogens), to gain new scientific insights and knowledge in this area where research is currently lacking. Whilst the vast majority of aquatic biofilm research tends to focus on the widesperad elimination of biofilms (which are seen as a health threat), we have already proved that biofilm based biofilters in swimming pools can successfully control algae-sustaining nutrients (P and N).

This study seeks to answer the following research questions:

1) To what extent do beneficial biofilms grown on biofilters (CWR biofiltration system) reduce the levels of known waterborne pathogens in freshwater?
2) Does the CWR biofiltration system prevent the re-introduction of pathogens in water?
3) How can the beneficial biofilm within the CWR biofiltration system be optimised to maximise pathogen removal?

This 12 month feasibility project brings together scientists from the University of the West of England and Bristol based business entrepreneurs, Clear Water Revival Ltd. (CWR) who specialise in the development and production of chemical free swimming pools. A laboratory phase will be used to inform real-world testing on full scale biofilters fitted to full size swimming pools thereby providing direct, tangible and immediate technology benefit/s from applied scientific research and discovery.

The successful completion of this project would help to fully realise the mass market potential for this biofilm based technology, through innovative and robust scientific research and development. It will help place the UK at the forefront of chemical free water treatment, ultimately improving quality of life, reducing environmental impact whilst generating wealth creation opportunities for the UK leading to the creation and securing of jobs.

The proposed scientific research has many cross sector applications, since the fundamental aim is to understand and encourage beneficial biofilms which can sanitise water; as a healthy alternative to using harmful chemicals. While the practical application will focus on bio-filters for pools, the scientific knowledge gained would also be highly applicable to all aquatic pathogens, and in particular, waste water treatment, contaminated water remediation and intensive fish farming.

Technical Summary

This is a joint project between Clear Water Revival Ltd and the University of the West of England, Bristol. Clear Water Revival Ltd has been creating Natural Swimming Pools in the UK for 8 years. UWE and Clear Water Revival will develop a novel bio filter system that uses natural biological action (biofilms) to manage water quality. Specifically we will develop and optimise a new biofilm bio filtration technology platform for management of key waterborne pathogens within natural swimming pool environments. Six interconnected work packages (WP) correlate with the main study objectives. (1) To determine and quantify the efficiency of pathogen removal using biofilms developed on an existing CWR bio media substrate [WP2]. (2) To develop the performance of the biofilm (developed in WP2) by optimising the biofilm formation within the bio media, enabling efficient pathogen removal [WP3]. (3) To assess and observe the extent to which pathogens are capable of residing, propagating and dispersing from biofilms contained within the optimised CWR bio filtration system [WP4]. (4) To implement full scale, real world testing of the optimised bio media and physicochemical parameters for optimal biofilm performance within full scale bio filters for swimming pools, and to validate and quantify pathogen removal using these systems [WP5]. [WP6] will focus on the Dissemination and Exploitation Strategy (months 1-12); We will drive the developed bio filtration technology platform through to commercialisation via exploitation and implementation. A key challenge will be to improve our understanding of how pathogenic bacteria physically interact with the biofilm/bio media, in particular whether the biofilm acts as a sink or a reservoir for potentially harmful bacteria.

Planned Impact

The global swimming pool market is estimated to be worth over £3 billion. The project seeks to address the specific challenge of using beneficial biofilms to reliably control aquatic pathogens, and by doing so potentially provides a new, innovative (low energy and chemical free) technology solution to the treatment of swimming pool water. The project 's objectives assess and develop the potential for biofilms to control pathogens through understanding and optimising biofilm performance. To this end, we will utilise novel scientific techniques such as bioluminescence (which visually detects and monitors specific bacterial and bacterial biofilm metabolic behaviour) to gain new scientific insights and knowledge in this area where research is currently lacking. Whilst the vast majority of aquatic biofilm research tends to focus on the widespread elimination of biofilms (which are seen as a health threat), we have already proved that biofilms do successfully control algae-causing nutrients (P and N) . This project aims to investigate and demonstrate biofilm management strategies for the potential to control pathogens with high degrees of reliability and repeatability. We will show proof-of-concept of our main ideas; to build a biofilm based filter for the management and control of waterborne pathogens in swimming pools. We will develop a bio-filter representing a new and novel solution to pool water quality control. By using beneficial biofilms the ultimate aim of this project is to remove the need for chemical disinfection all together. If this was realised then significant reductions in energy use (required for water circulation) could also be achieved along with enhanced user experience (zero chemicals) and lower maintenance levels (no chemical dosing/monitoring).

The project will bring together biological sciences and technologists driving forward the use of basic science to develop biological based and inspired tools that can improve the quality of life and economic prosperity in the U.K. These are key drivers for both the BBSRC and Innovate UK.

The work will have immediate impact on (1) scientists and technologists interested in the use and management of biofilms, (2) environmental scientists and engineers and those interested water treatment technologies and processes. This application and it's objectives are well aligned with the competition scope as demonstrated below:

The potential for biofilms to remove and control pathogens involves numerous management factors including optimised water flow rate over the biofilm, the make up of biofilm growth substrate (including porosity and pore size), pH, temperature and nutrient levels present. The project seeks to specifically understand and exploit these key techniques and processes, and to optimise beneficial biofilm performance, in order to specifically maximise efficiency and reliability with regard to pathogen control.

The translation of knowledge of model biofilm systems into technology, tools and techniques with broad, generic or cross sector potential. Lab studies will be used to inform real life testing on full-scale bio-filters during the course of the project thereby providing direct, tangible and immediate technology benefit/s from applied scientific research and discovery.
The proposed scientific research has many cross sector applications, since the fundamental aim is to understand and encourage beneficial bio-films which can sanitise water; as a healthy alternative to using harmful chemicals. While the practical application will focus on bio-filters for pools, the scientific knowledge gained would also be highly applicable to all aquatic pathogens, and in particular, waste water treatment, contaminated water remediation and intensive fish farming.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Our research have helped developed a biofiltration system (using biofilms) that have a high level of reliability, low running costs, ease of maintenance to ensure the best possible performance at all times. For the first time, it is now possible to achieve all the benefits of a formal, heated traditional (chlorinated) pool, with the added benefit of a freshwater swimming environment, whilst saving thousands per year in running costs (no chemical disinfection required). Our research has shown that efficient control of nutrients, through the deployment of biofilm technology which relies on microbial action rather than chemicals or plants, is possible. This enables "natural" pools to be built indoors or outside, with or without plants and allows for the water to be heated up to 30 degrees.

Key Discoveries and Findings
• We have developed a laboratory scale bio-filter model system for the testing and evaluation of biofilm biofiltration systems. These systems have the advantage that they can be arranged and configured in a range of geometries with a view for informing the manufacture and production of optimized systems for use in the real-world.
• We have discovered that biofilms can be used to manage and control nutrients to a level that inhibits pathogen survival within the bulk water.
• We have developed a novel multi-pass through-flow model system that enables the quantification of pathogen removal via bio-filtration.
disinfection or sterilization.

We found that;
- Mature biofilms removed pathogens from swimming water reservoirs quickest. Thereby reducing magnitude and swimmer exposure quickest.

- The presence of a substrate (organic/nutrients) did allow for prolonged pathogen survival compared to no substrate (5+ days vs 2 days)
- The no substrate systems saw fastest complete removal.
- Bacterial shearing from the biofilm filter was seen for 4-7 days in the mature, 5-10 days in the sterile.

- We found that after introducing sterile substrates, pathogen removal was low, we hypothesise that this is die to the lack biotic competition.

- We conducted bioluminescent work which confirmed quick removal (from water) of pathogens after passing through biofilters.

The technology and understanding is sufficiently developed to allow product development and modularisation of the biofilter technology via an Innovate KTP. The eventual hope is that product will disrupt the swimming pool sector internationally in the first instance, allowing further exploitation of the technology for developing IKEA flat pack styled drinking water biofilter treatment systems
Exploitation Route CWR provide the only natural swimming pool company in Europe who have taken a ground up, scientific approach to developing a natural filtration system for private and commercial swimming pools and are the only UK company with an in-house developed natural filtration system.

At the laboratory facilities at the University of the West of England (UWE), CWR employ a team of full time scientists and engineers who are continually perfecting our market leading bio-filter technology, and we have won numerous innovation awards from Innovate UK.

We presented these results at the International Swimming Pond Congress (IOB)" and was held in Leeuwarden, Holland on Wednesday, November 15 (2017) and ended on Thursday, November 16, 2017. The title of the presentation that was given to industrial leaders was entitled; "The effect of established biofilms on the survival of pathogenic bacteria under natural swimming pool conditions"
Sectors Chemicals,Environment,Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL http://www.clear-water-revival.com/biofiltration-technology/
 
Description The project is proving for the first time that biofilms can control pathogens in freshwater bodies. Current research in this area is sparse and the results of this project have significant potential to change current thinking regarding the use of chemicals to sanitize or cleanse water. This will open up new markets and applications for biological filtration, and disperse assumptions that chemicals are the only method of controlling pathogens in fresh water. Our partnership is driving business growth and product development. Economic Impact: The results from the project underpin biological filtration technology from a safety perspective. Proving that natural filter systems are safe (and control pathogens) is an essential to greater uptake of this technology and market penetration. We expect the results of the project to have the following impacts: - Creation of 10 new jobs/placements between 2017 - 2019 - Establishment of longer term research in this area with additional private sector investment of £100,000 - Increasing of sales revenue from £1m to £5m over 3 years due to increased consumer confidence - Increase of bio-filtration market share from current chemical based technologies - Funding from Innovate UK (KTP) to drive and accelerate product development - The funding of a PhD studentship which will develop "IKEA style" flat packed drinking water treatment systems for export to developing countries. Societal Impacts: - Reduction in the use of chemicals which are harmful to human health - Demonstration of how natural processes can control pathogens - Potential applications in the sanitization of drinking water in third world counties
First Year Of Impact 2017
Sector Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Chemicals,Environment,Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal,Economic

 
Description Development of postgraduate teaching material
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
Impact This project is in partnership with a commercial entity. This work has informed basic R&D that has allowed product development and the securing of future orders. The research aims at replacing chemicals that are currently used for the disinfection of swimming pools, improving environmental sustainability, energy consumption, reduction in the use of chemicals, and ultimately, improved human health. Our research will help the company provide the first world's First naturally treated (no chlorine), heated community-run open air swimming pool in Clevedon (near Bath UK). The pools will be the first ever to use special microbiological filters to keep water clean without the use of traditional chemicals. The pools were originally fed from the river so using a natural filter system seems fitting to return the pool to its natural freshwater origins. We are able to use this knowledge to inform our postgraduate teaching provision (particularly in relation to Sustainable Development Goals and to targetd PG course MSci Environmental Science, MRes in Environmental Science (2017/18 intake)
URL https://www.permaculture.co.uk/news/14593397277115/world-first-heated-chemical-free-public-natural-s...
 
Description Clear Water Revival Ltd & University of the West of England, Bristol
Amount £119,952 (GBP)
Funding ID KTP 11541 
Organisation Innovate UK 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 06/2019 
End 05/2021
 
Description Partnership PhD: Development of small scale, low-cost, energy efficient biofilter systems for water treatment
Amount £155,000 (GBP)
Organisation Clear Water Revival Ltd 
Sector Private
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2018 
End 09/2021
 
Title Biofilm model 
Description We have developed new biofilm models for assessing the "removal or prevention" of important pathogens in water specifically; • A novel multi pass through-flow model system has been developed enabling quantification of pathogen removal via bio-filtration • A small (laboratory) scale bio-filter model has been developed and built, representative of real-world CWR bio-filtration systems and can be configured in a range of geometries. 
Type Of Material Biological samples 
Year Produced 2016 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact This tool is currently being utilised by a commercial company who wish to exploit this approach for biofilm product development (CWR Ltd). www.clear-water-revival.com 
URL http://www.clear-water-revival.com/biofiltration-technology/
 
Description Clear Water Revival Partnership 
Organisation Clear Water Revival Ltd
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution This award has enabled us to foster a partnership with Clear Water Revival (CWR) which was established in Bristol in 2006. During this time CWR had research facilities based at Cranfield University and this award has enabled UWE and CWR to mutually benefit from a growing and rich partnership. CWR are now located on UWE Campus near to UWE's Future Space an initiative that forms part of UWE's University Enterprise Zone. The R&D has grown during this time, creating knowledge and creating jobs.
Collaborator Contribution Given their close proximity CWR are able to participate in our undergraduate programs providing opportunities for undergraduate internships as well as presenting the real-world aspects of science and technology to the our student community. We believe that this is a new blue print for University/Industry interactions proving new value across the knowledge chain.
Impact The employment of two UWE graduates by CWR. Teaching on undergraduate modules (Scientific Frontiers and Enterprise at level 3) Internship opportunities for the student community This collaboration is multidisciplinary - microbiology, aquatic sciences, environmental sciences, water engineering, biotechnology, business, commerce and innovation and enterprise.
Start Year 2016
 
Title Next generation natural pool water filtration technology 
Description Five stage water filtration process: Bio filtration - beneficial microbes remove nutrients and pathogens Fine filtration - removes suspended particles down to 3 microns Absorbent filtration - removes remaining phosphorous UV filtration - kills off any remaining pathogens Mineraliser - re-mineralisees water with trace elements such as selenium and magnesium to replicate thermal spa water Furthermore, the system benefits from: Automation of flow, dosing, top-up and filter cleaning process (back washing) A smart metering application to ensure remote monitoring and proactive maintenance A standard sized unit that can upgrade or retrofit into most existing pool control rooms An five to ten year payback on chemicals, electricity and call outs vs disinfection systems 
Type Of Technology Systems, Materials & Instrumental Engineering 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact initial sale, business growth, chemical free maintenance of swimming pool water 
URL https://www.origin-aqua.com/technology
 
Company Name Hydrolyze Ltd 
Description construction of water projects 
Year Established 2019 
Impact Developing new products for treating water systems (drinking and amenity)
Website https://www.hydrolize.co.uk/
 
Description Interntional Workshop (Brazil) - Invited Keynote talk 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The overall aim of the project is to develop a sustainable and affordable technology model to provide
recovery of nutrients, water and energy from waste streams for the development of organic farming
and rural communities.
The specific objectives of the project are:
- Identify the traditional practices of organic agriculture, including the reuse of water, energy use, and
the management of the natural resources, such as solar irradiation and manure as soil conditioners
and fertilizers;
- Evaluate the efficiency and sustainability of the water-waste-energy-food (WWEF) system model to recovery of nutrients, energy and water from farming waste streams;
- Increase the capacity of small farmers and cooperatives, in particular women and youth, to develop
sustainable technologies for organic farming;
- Support policy and appropriate regulatory instruments to enhance rural development.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://wwef-nexus.org/
 
Description School visit (Bristol) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact I gave a talk to school children aged between 14-18 yrs old as part of a Science Festival (December 5th to 9th, 2016). The talk was about "how to feed a planet" and describing how this research project feeds into water security.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
URL http://www.trfwia.org.uk/news/festival-of-science-book-a-place-today/