Phytodetoxification of the explosive 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene

Lead Research Organisation: University of York
Department Name: Biology

Abstract

The explosive 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene (TNT) has become an extensive global pollutant over the last 100 years and there are mounting concerns over the toxicity of TNT to biological systems. During World War I and II the toxic effects of TNT were discovered during large scale production, with 475 fatalities and over 17,000 TNT poisoning cases reported at manufacturing facilities. TNT has been shown to severely impact the diversity of soil microbial communities and the establishment of vegetation. In the U.S. alone it is estimated that some 10 million hectares of military land is contaminated with munitions constituents. Unlike similar situations where the environment has become contaminated with toxic agrochemicals and their use subsequently banned, the huge demand for military explosives means that TNT will continue to be manufactured and used globally on a massive scale for the foreseeable future.

Because of the scale of explosives pollution, particularly on military training ranges, there is considerable interest in developing plant based remediation strategies. Plants offer a low cost sustainable solution to containing and remediating explosives pollution. However, a fundamental understanding of the phytotoxicity of explosives, and the enzyme systems plants use to detoxify these compounds, and the rate-limiting steps, are required to enable the development of robust plant systems to contain and remediate explosives pollution effectively in situ. In plants, the majority of TNT remains in the roots, where it inhibits growth and development reducing whole plant biomass.

We have recently discovered that the mitochondria- and plastid-targeted enzyme monodehydroascorbate reductase 6 (MDHAR6) reduces TNT by one electron, forming a nitro radical which reacts with atmospheric oxygen, generating highly reactive superoxide. This futile catalytic cycle only requires catalytic quantities of TNT to continuously generate damaging reactive oxygen species in the mitochondria. We have demonstrated that mutants in MDHAR6 have dramatically enhanced TNT tolerance, and we propose that this reaction accounts almost entirely for TNT toxicity in plants.

The major goal of this research programme is to rigorously and quantitatively establish the fate and effects of TNT on plants. In order to achieve this objective we propose to study mechanisms of TNT toxicity and fully elucidate TNT induced detoxification pathways that include glucosylation, glutathionylation and oxidative activity by cytochromes P450. The fate of the TNT metabolites produced by these enzymes will then be established. We have previously demonstrated that the TNT active glutathione transferase GST-U25 results in the removal of a nitro group which could render the aromatic ring more amenable to biodegradation. We now have detailed structural information on GST-U25 that will allow us to engineer and improve the specificity and activity towards TNT. We hope to use the knowledge gained from this study to develop improved plant systems that will clean up polluted sites and prevent explosives pollution from contaminating water sources.

Technical Summary

Our goal is to elucidate the mechanisms of 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene (TNT) detoxification and, to ultimately, use this information to generate improved plant systems for remediating TNT contaminated sites. Specifically:

1) We will use plant liquid culture based techniques to identify TNT metabolites. 13C-Labelled TNT will be used to increase sensitivity for LC/MS analysis.
2) In previous studies we have identified enzyme systems involved in TNT detoxification including nitroreductases (NR), glucosyltransferases (UGT) and glutathione transferases (GST). The further processing and fate of the TNT metabolites is not known nor has the metabolic flux of TNT through these routes been established. We will investigate the sequestration and localisation of these metabolites using engineered plant lines, including lines depleted in TNT active UGTs and GSTs using CRISPR-Cas9 gene editing techniques and NR and GST overexpressing lines. Metabolite profiling of the plant vacuoles will be performed using 13C-TNT and LC/MS.
3) Structural and mechanistic characterisation will be performed on GST-U25 to gain insight into the specificity of U25 for TNT. Rational mutagenesis will be performed to improve TNT-GST performance and increased production of a desirable TNT-gutathionyl product.
4) We will investigate the role of cytochromes P450 in TNT detoxification. In underpinning studies we have demonstrated that three P450s are likely to play a key role in TNT detoxification. The P450s will be deleted using CRISPR-Cas9 and mutant lines tested for increased sensitivity towards TNT. The P450s will be recombinantly expressed and activity towards TNT determined.
5) We have previously shown that the enzyme monodehydroascorbate reductase 6 (MDHAR6) mediates TNT toxicity in plants. We plan to establish an understanding of the physiological roles of all MDHARs in different subcellular locations and how each contributes to TNT toxicity.
(up to 200 characters)

Planned Impact

The project will have a very positive environmental impact since it promotes the use of plant systems to remove toxic pollutants from the environment. With population growth placing pressure on existing agricultural soils it is becoming ever-more necessary to remediate contaminated land. Plants offer a low cost sustainable alternative to expensive ex situ remediation processes and much greater public acceptance, especially compared to destructive processes such as removing polluted soil and incinerating it or sending it to landfill. Our work could, therefore, have long-term benefits for the environment and society at large.

Key beneficiaries in the short term will be the military who are interested in the development of plant based systems to prevent off site migration of explosives pollutants and subsequent contamination of water sources. The project will most likely lead to new research grants with the U.K. MoD and the U.S. DoD.

In addition, we are committed to seeing that the impacts of the work are maximised. The PI and researcher Co-I have a good record in terms of public outreach and communication. Beneficiaries include schools and the public through outreach activities, highlighting the use of plants for environmental remediation.

We will use proven processes to protect IP and publish results in scientific journals and at conferences. We will also use existing UK networks (eg the Bioscience KTN, the NNFCC, BBSRC NIBBs) to communicate progress through their events and web-based or printed media. When appropriate, discoveries will be disseminated by the University to the general media through press releases. To ensure professional management of intellectual property, CNAP operates regular IP reviews of all projects. CNAP has an outstanding track record in commercialisation of strategic research through on-going collaborations with companies throughout the Industrial Biotechnology sector. Potential impacts include new patent filings and license agreements that will have a commercial value.

The programme will provide researchers with wide-ranging skills relevant to the establishment of a vibrant industrial biotechnology and innovation-led industrial sector in the U.K. We will encourage the researchers to attend networking meetings organised by the BBSRC's NIBBs and other relevant networks that may be established through the new BBSRC new initiatives in industrial biotechnology.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Explosive compounds used in munitions are highly toxic and the potential for progressive accumulation of such compounds in soil, plants and groundwater is a significant concern at military sites. There is an urgent need to develop sustainable in situ technologies to contain and treat these pollutants. Plants have a remarkable ability to extract compounds from their environment and have evolved complex signalling and enzyme systems to deal with a diverse range of toxic chemicals. A fundamental understanding of the phytotoxicity of explosives and the enzyme systems plants use to detoxify these compounds will allow the development of robust plant systems to contain and remediate explosives pollution effectively in situ. Considering the worldwide scale of contamination, plants are the only low cost, sustainable solution to cleaning up these polluted sites. A fundamental difference between plant and microbial metabolism of TNT is that plants conjugate some transformed TNT intermediates to a range of molecules including sugars and glutathione. Evidence also suggests that TNT is bound up in plant macromolecular structures such as lignin and incorporated into plant woody tissues, although the mechanisms of sequestration and whether the conjugated derivatives are stored in vacuoles or incorporated in lignin are currently unknown.

Structural and mechanistic characterisation of GST-U25

We identified two Arabidopsis Tau class glutathione transferases, GSTU24 and GSTU25 that catalyze the formation of three TNT-glutathionylated conjugates. These two GSTs share 79% identity yet only GSTU25 catalyses the substitution of a nitro group for sulfur to form 2-glutathionyl-4,6-dinitrotoluene. The production of this compound is of interest because substitution of a nitro group could lead to destabilisation of the aromatic ring, enabling subsequent biodegradation. To identify target amino acids within GSTU25 that might be involved in the formation of 2-glutathionyl-4,6-dinitrotoluene, the structure for GSTU25 was determined, in complex with oxidised glutathione, and used to inform site-directed mutagenesis studies. Replacement of five amino acids in GSTU24 established a conjugate profile and activity similar to that found in GSTU25. These findings contribute to the development of plant-based remediation strategies for the detoxification of TNT in the environment.

Understand the roles of monodehydroascorbate reductases (MDHARs); the enzymes responsible for TNT phytotoxicity.

Monodehydroascorbate reductases (MDHARs) are enzymes that protect the plant from oxidative stress by recycling one of the major plant antioxidants, ascorbic acid. There are five MDHARs in the Arabidopsis genome; MDHAR1, 2, 3, 4 and 6. MDHAR1 and 4 are both located in the peroxisome, an organelle in the plant cell, whilst MDHAR2 and 3 are cytosolic and AtMDHAR6 is present in the mitochondria or plastid. Unexpectedly, and in contrast to the described plant protective role of MDHHARs, MDHAR6 has been shown to catalyse the reduction of TNT resulting in the production of a nitro radical that autoxidizes to generate a destructive superoxide within the plant's mitochondria attenuating the toxicity of TNT to the plant. However, prior to the start of this project the activity of the remaining four MDHARs towards TNT was not known.

All five MDHARs were successfully cloned, recombinantly expressed and purified for characterisation studies. All of the recombinant MDHARs showed activity against monodehydroascorbate except MDHAR3. Enzyme kinetic studies were undertaken for the four active recombinant proteins, MDHAR1, 2, 4 and 6 with TNT as the substrate. All four proteins utilised TNT as a substrate with MDHAR2 having the greatest affinity (lowest Km) and MDHAR4 the lowest affinity for TNT (highest Km). We also demonstrated MDHAR6 had activity towards the new military explosive dinitroanisole (DNAN). DNAN is increasingly being used as a chemically more stable alternative to TNT in munitions. To test the contribution of MDHAR6 to DNAN toxicity in planta, Arabidopsis lines were grown in soil contaminated with DNAN. Mutant plant lines lacking MDHAR6 grew significantly better than wild type on DNAN-contaminated soil, producing aerial biomasses that were not significantly different to those when grown on uncontaminated soil. This result confirmed that MDHAR6 has a physiological role in determining the phytotoxicity of DNAN in Arabidopsis. Key insights into the roles of MDHARs are informing strategies for ameliorating TNT phytotoxicity and development of plants for environmental clean-up of explosives pollution.

Following germination, Arabidopsis, along with all oilseed crops, relies on storage oil breakdown to supply carbon skeletons and energy for early seedling growth. As part of this process huge amounts of hydrogen peroxide are generated within the peroxisome as a by-product of fatty acid ß-oxidation. MDHAR4 is involved in the detoxification of hydrogen peroxide, but the involvement of MDHAR1, present in the peroxisomal matrix, was previously questioned. Characterising an mdhar1 mutant, we were able to show that in the mutant, lipids are broken down normally, and confirm that MDHAR1 does not contribute to the amelioration of hydrogen peroxide during ß-oxidation.

An international workshop was held in York on 17th October 2019 to disseminate the results of the project. Speakers and stakeholders attended from the US and Europe, including representatives from the UK Ministry of Defence and the US Army Corps of Engineers. The workshop covered practical, and potentially cost-effective, solutions to remediate these pollutants. Focus was on the phyotoremediation of explosives, harnessing natural metal hyperaccumulator species, the use of technologies such as GM, and the increasing contribution of plant-associated microorganisms.
Exploitation Route The findings from this project will aid the development of plant-based remediation strategies for the detoxification of TNT in the environment.
Sectors Environment

 
Description Environmental impact of DNAN and NTO on plants
Amount $1,339,796 (USD)
Organisation Department of Defense 
Sector Public
Country United States
Start 03/2018 
End 04/2021
 
Description Phytoremediation of explosives pollutants 
Organisation US Army
Country United States 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Jointly wrote the project proposal.
Collaborator Contribution Jointly wrote the project proposal.
Impact The project was funded and started in 2017 a paper is currently in preparation but been delayed by COVID.
Start Year 2018
 
Description Article in @STEMLearningUK Catalyst Ed 34, a schools resource for 14-19 year olds 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact The article 'Explosive-eating GM plants are having a blast!" discussed the research behind developing genetically modified plants to remediate environmental pollutants, with military explosives as the example. The article aimed to give insight into why the research was needed, and explain hurdles (scientific, regulatory, logistically) that were overcome in the development of a GM technology to field trial.

"Catalyst is a topical [print and online] magazine that offers features on a wide range of themes from the science curriculum bringing them to life with insights into cutting-edge research and practical applications of complex science in the world around us. Catalyst magazine is aimed mainly at science students aged 14-19", and teachers. Impact report available from https://www.stem.org.uk/impact-and-evaluation.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://www.stem.org.uk/impact-and-evaluation
 
Description Convincing young minds that science is cool? 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact A hands-on demonstration, with props and direct interaction (actively involved in pipetting liquids, applying aqueous solutions to media) was given to batches of 10-12 pupils from across 6 classes. The demonstration included two-way dialogue to spark critical thinking and questions. At the start, and end, of the demonstration, pupils were asked to rate, both vocally, and via a liquid-dispensing measurement, their enthusiasm for plant science. This activity reached 60-70 pupils directly, plus 4-5 school teachers and adult volunteers. Indirectly, the activity reached local parents and carers.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Podcast 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact Talking Biotech Podcast hosted by Dr Kevin Folta, - Dr Liz Rylott spoke about "Plants Engineered to Remediate Military Toxins"
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL http://www.talkingbiotechpodcast.com/175-plants-engineered-to-remediate-military-toxins/
 
Description Public lecture 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact The talk was to the Humanist Society in York and the topic of discussion was loosely based around the use of GMOs to remove pollutants from the environment. The discussions after the talk largely focused on issues around the use of GMOs.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://nyhg.humanist.org.uk/Archives.html
 
Description School Visit (Dringhouses Primary School) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact Dr Liz Rylott gave a presentation entitled "Working as a plant Scientist is Brilliant! " at Dringhouses School. The presentation was to the whole school and teachers and designed to inspire the next generation of biological scientists using our work on explosives remediation as an example of the benefits of biological science to society. The talk was followed up by discussion on social media.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description School Visit (Dringhouses Primary School) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact The Outreach event was delivered to the whole school, this comprised approximately 250 pupils aged 4+ to 11 years, plus staff.
The event aimed to show children that science can be fun, challenge dogmatic thinking and tell them about the science that is happening in their nearby university.
A 'show of hands' at the beginning of the event revealed approximately 25% of the children would like to be a scientist. Quizzes and audience participation during the presentation sparked lots of questions from the children.
At the end of the event, nearer 90% of the children thought they would like to be a scientist. The event was shared, and re-tweeted on the school's Twitter page.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL https://sites.google.com/a/york.ac.uk/liz-rylott/home/out-events
 
Description Talking Biotech Podcast hosted by Dr Kevin Folta, "Plants Engineered to Remediate Military Toxins" 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact The podcast was tweeted by Kevin Folta (20-March-20: 24K followers).
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL http://www.talkingbiotechpodcast.com/175-plants-engineered-to-remediate-military-toxins/