Engineering Water Capture in Terpene Synthases

Lead Research Organisation: University of Bristol
Department Name: Biochemistry

Abstract

Enzymes are remarkable biomolecules that are able to make complicated chemical reactions occur under the mild conditions found in living systems, with remarkable precision. Terpene synthases are enzymes that catalyze the conversion of only a small number of substrates to a myriad of different hydrocarbon products called terpenoids, structures that form the chemical basis of the largest group of natural products. Many terpenoids have beneficial applications, such as the anti-cancer drug taxol, the anti-malaria drug artemisinin and so-called semiochemicals that can act as insect repellents. These are based on sesquiterpenes, a subset of the terpenoid family that contain 15 carbon atoms and derive from the same molecule, farnesyl diphosphate (FDP). Natural sesquiterpene synthases can generate more than 300 different hydrocarbon scaffolds from FDP. Whether or not these scaffolds incorporate water (through hydroxylation, or 'water capture') affects their biological activity and use. Structural and mechanistic work performed over the last decades has revealed that these enzymes share a three-dimensional fold and use similar chemical strategies to achieve the transformation of FDP into products. While much progress has been made to decipher the biochemical details, our knowledge is not complete enough to have predictive power so that a rational approach could be used to convert the 'water capture' behaviour of terpene synthases in a targeted fashion.
The proposed research, which is based on a solid foundation of previous work and the complimentary experience of the applicants, will bring together enzymologists, computational biochemists and structural biologists to generate in-depth understanding of the mechanisms of 'water capture' in terpene synthases. This understanding will then be used to rationally change 'water capture' behaviour in example enzymes, which will lead to novel terpenoid products with potential beneficial properties. The combination of state-of-the-art computational and experimental work is crucial for achieving this. By using experimental data, such as structures obtained through X-ray crystallography, computational modelling offers unique detail not accessible through laboratory experiments, which in turn can be used to predict the effect of amino acid changes. These predictions subsequently need experimental validation. Through this combined approach we will discover in great detail how enzyme structure and mobility affect the reaction outcome. Once successful alteration of water capture behaviour has been achieved, we will develop general, streamlined protocols that can be applied to other terpene synthases. These protocols will therefore allow rational modification of efficient biocatalysts to obtain specific terpenoid products with desired properties, e.g. to develop new drugs or insect repellents.

Technical Summary

The main aim of the proposed work is to rationally change sesquiterpene synthases so that they specifically generate hydroxylated or non-hydroxylated products, different from their natural function. A combined computational/experimental approach will be used to gain in-depth understanding of the mechanisms of water binding, water flow and hydroxylation. This understanding will be used for a) targeted modification of enzyme active site and entrance loops to alter hydroxylation behaviour in example cases and b) developing step-by-step computational/experimental protocols to modify hydroxylation behaviour in terpene synthases. To gain understanding, we will use simulation and experiment to predict and verify water binding, the active enzyme-substrate complex and the detailed mechanism of key reaction steps (in particular hydroxylation by water molecules). The combined approach requires intensive collaboration between the two sites involved, as well as collaboration with overseas experts. Experimental methods will include protein modification using site-directed mutagenesis and incorporation of non-natural amino acids using a native chemical ligation approach, organic synthesis of mechanism-based inhibitors, kinetic characterization of enzymes, measurement of product distributions and product characterisation, and protein X-ray crystallography. Computational methods will include hybrid quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical simulations of reactions, molecular dynamics simulations of enzyme dynamics and water flow, and docking/Monte-Carlo protocols to predict water binding sites/affinities. By combining results from all methods, we will build up extensive and uniquely detailed knowledge on the mechanisms guiding water capture, leading to general streamlined protocols for rationally changing water capture in terpene synthases. This will then help to unlock the great potential of terpenoids as useful compounds with applications in health care, agriculture and bio-energy.

Planned Impact

The proposed work will lead to 1) detailed, fundamental insights into terpene synthases that can be used as biocatalysts, 2) engineered enzymes for the production of new terpenoid compounds and 3) the development of protocols to rationally engineer product outcomes in other terpene synthases. The new examples of engineered biocatalysts and the methods to obtain them will be of high interest to the biotech industry, due to their ability to enhance the cost-effectiveness and sustainability of synthesising terpenoid compounds. As part of the work proposed, computational and experimental protocols will be developed that are useful for enzyme and protein engineering as well as structure-based drug design, and will thus benefit academic and industrial researchers in these areas. The work exemplifies a rational, synthetic biology approach to obtain desired biocatalysts for industrial biotechnology, and as such offers the opportunity to engage with the general public. Via outreach activities, the general public will benefit by obtaining insight into the use of synthetic biology and how publicly funded research in academia affects biotechnology, topics of interest to many.
Apart from these short-term benefits to a wide range of researchers and the public, the proposed work has significant potential impact in the medium and long term.
In the medium term, the knowledge and protocols obtained in this research can be applied to redesign natural terpene synthases into efficient biocatalysts for the production of specific desired terpenoids. This can have a significant impact by making industrial production of terpenoids efficient, sustainable and relatively cheap. By disseminating the results from our research directly to relevant biotechnological companies in the UK, this will give UK biotech a competitive edge over other biotech companies world-wide. UK-based companies are active in the field of biocatalyst optimization and bio-based chemical production, and the national economy can therefore benefit significantly.
In the long term, the application of novel terpenoid biocatalysts will allow new, beneficial terpenoid compounds to be conceived and produced. This in turn can lead to new valuable (agro)chemicals and potential new drugs, leading to healthcare and food production benefits. In addition, efficient, sustainable production of terpenoids will strengthen the UK economy whilst limiting environmental impact, thus benefitting both the general public and the UK industry.

Finally, the proposal will help bring together and integrate further two research communities that are strong within the
UK: biomolecular simulation and chemical biology/enzymology. The UK should capitalise on the strengths of these communities to catch up and, in future, overtake efforts in other countries in the area of biocatalyst (re)design. The close collaboration between computational and experimental groups, and the training and knowledge exchange activities planned, will help train a new generation of researchers. These researchers will be well-equipped for many areas that require a cross-disciplinary outlook (both in academia and industry), such as synthetic biology and industrial biotechnology. The related professional skills acquired by the researchers involved (significant IT, communication, analytical thinking and time management skills) will make them valuable for many/all employment sectors. This impact on UK 'human capital' will further contribute to the mid- to long term benefits.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Context:
Terpenes are the most complex and structurally diverse class of natural products and many have economic value, e.g. as volatile scents, pheromones and actual or potential medicines or agrochemicals. Their synthesis through standard solution-phase organic chemistry is typically prohibitively expensive, which limits their application. Here, we are using a combined and mutually directed (computation leads experiment and experiment informs computation) approach to understand how terpene synthases mediate capture of water in the final chemical steps of catalysis. Terpene synthases generate a carbocation from an isoprenyl diphosphate substrate and then coordinate a cascade of cyclisation and carbocation rearrangements, prior to quenching the final cation by (most commonly) proton loss to generate a hydrocarbon, or by water capture to generate an alcohol. The latter event is difficult to understand, predict and engineer, since the intermediate cations must not be quenched by water. Molecular orbital alignment and geometries must thus be tightly coordinated both in time and in space.

Key findings:
Our combined approach to altering terpene synthase hydroxylation behaviour has led to key advances in our understanding of their water management strategies and we have demonstrated protocols for subtle rational enzyme engineering. Specifically, we have carried out detailed simulations related to four different terpene synthase enzymes: the non-hydroxylating aristolochene synthase (AS) and selinadiene synthase (SdS), and the hydroxylating germacradiene-11-ol synthase (Gd11olS) and patchoulol synthase (PS). For AS, our simulations explained previous results for active site mutations leading to linear hydroxylated terpenoid compounds (indicating the difficulty to generate complex cyclic hydroxylated compounds in this enzyme). For SdS, we used simulations to predict a range of variants that might change product distribution towards complex hydroxylated products. The subsequent experimental exploration of these predictions has resulted in creating a SdS variant (SdS G305E) which was able to use water to quench the final carbocation to produce 20% selina-4-ol, a complex hydroxylated terpenoid product. Further simulations representative of the enzyme-cation in the final hydroxylation step then gave detailed insight into how the mutation led to formation of the complex hydroxylated product. Other variants also shifted the product distribution, with the variant SdS A301Y/G305E resulting in exclusive formation of germacrene B. These findings demonstrate the ability, albeit with difficulty, of engineering terpene synthases to use water in active site to produce hydroxylated product (manuscript in preparation).

To find a general strategy for engineering hydroxylating terpene synthases for generating complex non-hydroxylated natural products, we have identified a region in H-alpha loop subdomain, structurally conserved throughout the enzyme family, which closes the active site during catalysis. Experimental modification of selected residues in the H-alpha loop region (Gd11olS 238-241) with the corresponding amino acids from SdS resulted in a switch in the product profile towards the non-hydroxylated complex isolepidozene product (85%) with significant reduction in hydroxylated product. Models were made of the H-alpha loop variant, and simulation of these models confirm the change in water distribution around the isolepidozene that explain the shift in product distribution. Importantly, changing the corresponding residues in the patchoulol synthase (PS) H-alpha loop region (PS 458-461) completely abolishes formation of hydroxylated product (patchoulol), with predominant formation of the complex non-hydroxylated alpha-bulnesene (86%). Alpha-bulnesene has been reported to have inhibitory effect on platelet-activating factor (PAF), however, no enzyme is known to produce this compound as a major product, suggesting that H-alpha loop variant of PS is first alpha-bulnesene synthase. These findings suggest that modifying the H-alpha loop could be a possible general strategy for engineering terpene synthases for generating complex non-hydroxylated sesquiterpenes which can be produced at significantly high purity using synthetic biology tools (manuscript in preparation). Through modelling and simulation, the likely initial enzyme-substrate complex structure of PS was predicted, which further led to prediction of a single-point mutant (PS Y525A) that also leads to predominant formation of alpha-bulnesene (82%).

Overall, our recent work generated new, highly specific, and environmentally friendly designed biocatalysts to produce small natural products such as: isolepidozene, selina-4ol and alpha-bulnesene that are not easily synthesised by traditional chemical methods. The generation of these new biocatalysts will allow efficient and sustainable production of these terpenoids with potential biotechnological and agrochemical applications.
Exploitation Route Protocols and computational approaches developed in this project are or will be published, and thereby add to the growing body of knowledge on catalysis by terpene synthases. Production of high-value terpenoids will be greatly facilitated by the availability of robust natural and artificially engineered biocatalysts capable of making these compounds and their analogues in unprecedented quantities. Biochemists, natural product chemists, medicinal chemists and other chemically oriented researchers may also use the understanding of enzyme catalysis at the molecular and atomic level to solve more diverse problems, widening the impact of this work.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology

 
Description Allemann/Miller Terpene synthase water capture 
Organisation Cardiff University
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution This project is part of a two-institution award, with the experimental work carried out with Prof Rudolf Allemann & Dr David Miller from the School of Chemistry at Cardiff University. We meet every three months to discuss progress and our postdocs are in regular contact, to allow a combined computational / experimental approach to understanding and engineering water capture in terpene synthase enzymes.
Collaborator Contribution This project is part of a two-institution award, with the experimental work carried out with Prof Rudolf Allemann & Dr David Miller from the School of Chemistry at Cardiff University. We meet every three months to discuss progress and our postdocs are in regular contact, to allow a combined computational / experimental approach to understanding and engineering water capture in terpene synthase enzymes.
Impact We are currently investigating an enzyme variant with simulation that was indicated by experiment to change water capture behaviour.
Start Year 2018
 
Description CCPBioSim Training Week 2019 - QM/MM enzyme reaction modelling 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact During the CCPBioSim training week in 2019, I led a training workshop to introduce non-specialists to the use of combined quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) methods for modelling enzyme-catalysed reaction mechanisms. The open-source course material for this is available online. ~25 people attended, and it was evaluated very positively. Excellent discussion afterwards with several attendees.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL http://www.ccpbiosim.ac.uk/events/workshop-course-material/eventdetail/120/-/ccpbiosim-training-week...
 
Description Training on enzyme simulation 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Training in molecular visualization, docking and QM/MM enzyme reaction simulation was given to a group of 20 colombian students.
It was positively evaluated with several students interested in continuing to apply the techniques learned.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Training workshop on Enzyme reaction simulations 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact About 120 postgraduate & undergraduate students and researchers from locations around the world actively engaged with this online training activity. All were running and analysing enzyme reaction simulations, guided by the trainers (PI Van der Kamp and two postdocs). The introduction and wrap-up talks were made available via the CCPBioSim YouTube channel: https://youtu.be/ROd0libkRy0.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://www.ccpbiosim.ac.uk/events/workshop-course-material/eventdetail/127/-/training-week-2020