Kinetochore life-histories: understanding the mechanical events that ensure error-free chromosome segregation

Lead Research Organisation: University of Warwick
Department Name: Warwick Medical School

Abstract

A fundamental challenge in modern cell biology is to understand how complex behaviours emerge from populations of molecular machines, machines that work close to the thermal energy level, thereby giving their behaviour a significant random component, whilst working independently within the context of a global communication network. Working with such systems poses significant challenges given their small size; however recent advances in light microscopy has enabled these systems to be observed and quantified with unprecedented spatial and time resolution.

The biological system we are interested in is how chromosomes are separated during cell division. Human beings are built from a single fertilised cell, the zygote. Each cell contains 46 chromosomes - the packages of genetic material (DNA), which provide the instructions for how a cell should work and how to build a human. Cells divide generating two near identical daughter cells. The chromosomes are copied prior to division and a key part of cell division is the accurate separation of these replicated chromosomes such that each daughter receives 1 and only 1 copy. Failure of a cell to receive a complete set of 46 chromosomes is a cause of multiple human diseases, including cancers and Down's syndrome. During the mechanical process of cell division, most of the time is taken up with relocating the paired chromosomes (original and copy) into a holding pattern at the equatorial plane, prior to pulling the pairs apart to either end of the cell. Clearly it is vital that we work out how chromosome separation works.

Chromosome separation is a mechanical spatial process. To move a chromosome the cell makes use of molecular cables called microtubules that can grow and shrink. Each chromosome has a "hook" called the kinetochore, which attach to these cables, both on their sides (lateral attachment) and to the ends of these cables. The kinetochore is an extremely versatile and 'intelligent' machine, comprising sensors and motors that allow it to determine how it is attached to microtubules and how its paired sister is attached, making a sequence of informed decisions so that the paired chromosomes are relocated to the equatorial plane. The kinetochore is thus the "control centre" that decides when and where a chromosome moves. But, how does the kinetochore do this? Why and how do kinetochores make decisions, and using what information as input? The experiments that we propose to carry out will help answer these exciting and intriguing question and therefore advance our understanding of how chromosomes are faithfully separated into daughter cells during cell division.

We will use state-of-the-art imaging technology (microscopes) to observe how chromosomes move in living human cells. We will then use mathematical modelling and sophisticated statistical techniques (called reverse engineering) to determine the parameters of that model from the data (one engineers what the system must be from the observations). This will allow us to infer what cues the kinetochore is using to regulate the attached microtubules. This will include forces acting on the kinetochores and internal stretch and rotation of the kinetochore, our previous study showing that the kinetochore has a structure similar to a hip joint which potentially prevents breakage of the attachment under impulse forces. Our model will only be as good as our data; thus we will use a variety of techniques to perturb the system (remove or knock-down certain components, thereby changing behaviour), and thus 'road-test' our model through a range of different situations. Through such techniques we will achieve greater biological understanding.

Technical Summary

Chromosome congression is a complex, highly orchestrated spatial mechanical process, the kinetochore being central to brokering and regulating forces that position chromosomes within the cell. Kinetochores are multi-protein complexes that navigate the microtubule spindle by regulating their attachment to microtubules, demonstrating an ability to self-organise to the metaphase plate (at the equatorial plane) through sensory and mechanical cues, although the exact signals are unknown. Multiple, layered, processes are involved, including chromosome capture, lateral movement along microtubules, lateral to end-on conversion, maturation of microtubule attachments and error correction, whilst mal-attachment states generate signals that regulate the SAC and delay anaphase. Elucidating the mechanisms and signals that control this range of processes is the primary aim of this proposal. We propose a state-of-the-art combined experimental and computational study, utilising the latest high resolution live-cell imaging (light sheet) and experimental techniques (CRISPR, correlative serial block-face scanning electron microscopy) with sophisticated computational algorithms to automatically annotate trajectories for their attachment state based on their dynamic signature. We will use endogenously tagged reporters for the first time, with 2 and 3 channel live cell microscopy to quantify both kinetochore conformation and protein recruitment, thereby ascertaining how kinetochore maturation, inter-kinetochore forces and intra-kinetochore stress determine kinetochore function that ultimately leads to high fidelity segregation. By detecting state switching at high resolution throughout congression, we will determine the causal factors for late congressing chromosomes, and crucially the risk factors for segregation errors at anaphase. We will validate our results by utilising a range of perturbations, and develop a data driven mathematical model of chromosome congression and segregation.

Planned Impact

Economic and societal impact.
The general public: It is well understood that multiple human diseases are a consequence of errors in chromosome segregation. For example, mis-segregation of chromosomes during the cell divisions that generate gametes (meiosis) are responsible for a wide range of syndromes such as Down's and Turner's and are also associated with >70% of miscarriages and stillbirths. These risks worsen as women age; our work has the potential to improve our understanding of how the success of chromosome segregation diminishes with time. Mis-segregation events during mitotic cell divisions are associated with the development of cancer. Moreover, changes in chromosome number are involved with cells becoming resistant to existing chemotherapeutic drugs. We need to know how the process of chromosome segregation works before we can unlock new therapeutic routes to deal with these major diseases and healthcare issues. Such advances will be of direct benefit to the general population both in terms of health, well-being, and indirectly on the socio-economic state of the United Kingdom.
Translational medicine: Translational medicine has established itself as discipline in which research inputs from basic and social sciences are converted into patient benefits. Given the importance of chromosome segregation in multiple human diseases, including cancer and developmental disorders our basic-scientific work will generate new knowledge that could be utilized by translational medicine. Drugs that affect kinetochore motion are in clinical trials as candidate cancer treatments.
Pharmaceutical and Biotechnology industries: Pharmaceutical and Biotechnology industries are a vital part of the UK economy employing around 250,000 people and generating billions of pounds of income each year. However, this process of drug discovery relies heavily on a strong basic-science base to provide insights into potential drug targets as well as the development of new cell-based assays and technologies. Our work into the processes of chromosome segregation will contribute to the knowledge-base. In addition, we are developing state-of-the art live-cell imaging assays and computational methods, which we predict will become an important part of the drug-development and testing process.
Science outreach: Science outreach is vital so that the general population is aware of scientific advances and understands how they fit into the pipeline that takes discoveries in basic science and converts them in to new therapies and health improvements.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description It is critical when a huamn cell divides that it maintains the correct number of chromosomes (23 pairs). To acheive this the cell must make a copy of each chromosome (called sister chromatids) and then make sure the copies are segregated to daughter cells. This process involves a molecular machine called the mitotic spindle which using dynamic cables (called microtubules) that attached to each sister chromatid at a protein structure called the kinetochore. However, kinetochores can become incorrectly attached to microtubules and it is known that before anaphase (when chromatids are segreated) an active process "corrects" these problems.

1. We have discovered that man more incorrect attachments survive to anaphase - this means that chromosome segrgeation has a much higher potential for errors than previosuly thought.
2. We reveled a new error correction process that operates during anaphase. This allows cells to correct mistakes even when chromosome segregation is underway.
3. These findings were possible becuase we used the latest lattice light sheet microscopy and custom wrtten software to track the posiitons of kinetochores during cell division.
4. By following the "life history" of each kinetochores we identified key signatures before anaphase onset that can predict the future outcome for a chromosome.
Exploitation Route Our findings have had significant impact in the chromosome segregation field being highlighted in several recent review articles.
Our imaging and analysis pipeline can be of use in multiple cell biological fields where defined objects need to be tracked and analysed. This will be of great use in teh chromosome segregation field and we will be using these advances in other funded studies where we seek to analysis chromosome behavior in human eggs and embryos (Wellcome Collaborative Award).
Sectors Healthcare

 
Title Kinetochore Tracks: Kinetochore life histories reveal an Aurora B dependent error correction mechanism in anaphase 
Description Dataset of kinetochore tracks in human RPE1 cells showing chromosome dynamics and segregation from prometaphase through to anaphase as described in detail in Sen, Harrison, Burroughs and McAinsh, 2021, https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.03.30.436326 Tracks correspond to 3D time-lapse movies of Ndc80-eGFP and were acquired in the 488nm channel using 1\% laser power, 50 ms exposure time/z-plane, 93 z-planes, 307 nm z-step, which results in 4.7 s/z-stack time frame. Cells are subject to nocodazole arrest-and-release or equivalent treatment with DMSO as indicated in the folder names, and some cells are subject to additional treatment with ZM to inhibit Aurora B (also indicated in folder names). Tracks were produced using kinetochore tracking software, KiT v2.3 (see Armond et al., 2016, Bioinformatics), available from https://github.com/cmcb-warwick/KiT/ 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2020 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact 49 views and 3 dowloads 
URL https://zenodo.org/record/5551168#.YjMDd7inwvA
 
Title Kinetochore Tracks: Ndc80-eGFP imaged via lattice light sheet microscopy (LLSM) at high temporal resolution 
Description Dataset of Human RPE1 cells expressing Ndc80-eGFP imaged via lattice light sheet microscopy (LLSM) at high temporal resolution (2.05s per z stack) over long timescales (up to 15 mins). To accompany Harrison et al, 2022, "Computational modelling and near-complete kinetochore tracking reveal how chromosome dynamics during cell division are co-ordinated in space and time" 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Manuscipt in preparation 
URL https://zenodo.org/record/6811344#.ZA3nGbTP2Es
 
Description iCASE MRC studentship with 3i (Intelligent Imaging Innovations) 
Organisation Intelligent Imaging Innovations Ltd
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution The Bretschneider group provides expertise in image analysis and machine learning and together with 3i will develop a novel analysis pipeline for making predictions about cellular states from 3D lattice light sheet microscopy. This pipeline will be integrated into the microscope setup to allow automated classification and tracking of cells. The main application is the identification of stages of the cell division cycle which is investigated by Co-I Prof. Andrew McAinsh.
Collaborator Contribution Intelligent Imaging Innovations (3i) will host a PhD student at their reference laboratory in London. The student will be trained in the software controlling their lattice light sheet microscope. Furthermore, 3i will engage with other MRC-DTP students of the cohort to start in September 2020, who will be given access to try out 3i's microscopy setups in their reference laboratories at Imperial in London that might be of interest to specific research projects and generate sample data for comparison with the current imaging setups at Warwick. 3i welcomes MRC-DTP students to their advanced training events and will offer a couple of bespoke training events at Warwick, where 3i will present to the entire cohort and share firsthand insight about careers in imaging in the life sciences. 3i will co-organise one summer school and would be happy to contribute approx. 20 hours of a staff member's time.
Impact No outputs yet.
Start Year 2020
 
Title Kinetochore tracking in 3D from lattice light-sheet imaging data with KiT 
Description KiT is free, open-source software implemented in MATLAB and can be downloaded as a package from https://github.com/cmcb-warwick/KiT. The source repository is available at https://bitbucket.org/jarmond/kit (tag v2.4.0) and under continuing development. 
Type Of Technology Software 
Year Produced 2022 
Open Source License? Yes  
Impact manuscripts in preparation 
 
Description British Science Festival 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact One cell to rule them all
Friday, September 13, 2019 • 17:00 - 18:00

There are 10 trillion cells in your body, but they all came from just one.

Until now, research has largely neglected to visualise what your chromosomes, which contain all of your DNA and dictate how you develop, are doing at the time of fertilisation. Yet, how a cell divides and makes exact copies of itself is what Andrew McAinsh from the University of Warwick believes could be the crux to understanding a multitude of diseases and genetic disorders.

lots of great questions from enaged audience!

see: https://britishsciencefestival.org/event/one-cell-to-rule-them-all/
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019