ISCF WAVE 1 AGRI TECH Development of a diagnostic tool to assess risk levels of pea foot rot pathogens in soils

Lead Research Organisation: University of Warwick
Department Name: School of Life Sciences

Abstract

Foot rot diseases in pea crops cause root and stem rots which result in substantial yield losses and reduction in the quality of the peas, decreasing their value by £12.5M per annum. The diseases are caused by several soilborne pathogens which cannot be controlled with fungicides, and severity of losses is determined by pathogen levels in soils, soil structure and weather conditions. Currently crop rotations whereby peas are not grown for several years are the only means of mitigating the problem. However, measuring pathogen levels in soil before planting peas holds the potential to identify fields where disease risk is low. This project will develop molecular tools to quantify foot rot pathogens in soils and link levels to potential yield loss. This will provide a risk assessment tool for pea growers helping them to choose fields with healthy soils for growing high quality peas. Efficiency of pea production in the UK will be increased and the use of land, water, energy and fertilisers will be reduced.

Technical Summary

Peas are valuable crops for the environment, crop rotation, diet and human health. Production in the UK is worth £69M but is severely threatened with yield decline due to footrot pathogens which include Fusarium oxysporum f.sp pisi, Fusarium solani f.sp pisi, Didymella pinodella and Aphanomyces euteiches. This costs the industry £12.5M per annum and the situation is exacerbated by the fact that frozen peas are grown in restricted areas due to climate and the need to be close to processing facilities. Mitigation of footrot is limited to rotational planning but yield losses could be further avoided by quantification of pathogen levels before planting. Although PGRO already offer soil tests for F. solani, D. pinodella and A. euteiches, these are based on morphological identification of fungal colonies on agar or on disease symptoms on pea roots and hence are time consuming, expensive and prone to error. The main aim of this project is to develop molecular diagnostic tools to assess risk of foot rot disease development in pea crops. This will involve developing quantitative PCR tests for the main foot rot pathogens, optimising DNA extraction protocols from soil and relating qPCR test results to disease levels and pea yields. This will allow PGRO to offer new commercial tests providing a rapid, reliable and accurate test for multiple footrot pathogens and an increased estimated income of £5,000-10,000 per annum. Growers will benefit from a cheaper, more efficient and accurate service that will enable more precise assessment of disease potential in field. This will result in more efficient rotations and greater sustainability and economic returns for the UK pea industry. The approaches taken and the protocols developed will benefit work on detection/quantification of soilborne plant pathogens in other cropping systems. The project brings together a multidisciplinary team comprising PGRO and academics with expertise in fungal biology and molecular diagnostics.

Planned Impact

This project aims to help alleviate the severe decline in UK pea yields caused by the increased prevalence of the footrot complex of soilborne plant pathogens through the provision of rapid, accurate and quantitative molecular soil tests. The UK produced 148,700 tons of frozen peas in 2015 (Source: British Growers Association) worth £44.6M and 176,000 tons (Source: Eurostat) of combinable peas worth £24.64M per annum (at current prices) and, depending on disease pressure, soil conditions and weather, yield decline losses are estimated at a minimum of £12.5M per annum. Mitigation is limited to crop rotation strategies and hence knowledge of pathogen soil inoculum potential and associated predicted yield losses would greatly improve this approach. The corresponding reduction in yield decline will have a major economic impact and safeguard against further decline of UK pea yields. One of the main beneficiaries of this research will be PGRO, as they will have access to new tools to better identify/quantify the presence of footrot pathogens on behalf of growers. These tests will be faster, more reliable and cheaper generating an increased estimated income of £5,000-10,000 per annum for PGRO. The other major beneficiary will be pea growers who will benefit from a cheaper, more accurate and wide-ranging foot rot test. This will save them approximately £72 per sample which equates to £21,600 per annum for the ten major grower groups. However, the major benefit will be in allowing the growers to make much better informed decisions about their rotations and which fields have the lowest risk of disease when they plant. This will lead to increased yield, less waste and decreased economic losses through the overall reduction in disease as well as more even maturity at harvest and more reliable factory throughput. Following the project, pea growers will therefore be able to maintain and potentially increase production for both home and export consumption with associated economic benefits.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Foot rot disease in peas causes great yield losses and reduces the quality of peas. Yield losses of greater than 0.85 t/ha are common even in moderately infected fields. The foot rot complex is caused by several soil-borne pathogens, mainly Fusarium solani f.sp pisi (FSP), Fusarium oxysporum (FO), Didymella pinodella (DP) and Aphanomyces euteiches (AE). All pathogens can occur together and produce resting spores that can survive in soils for several years. Chemical treatment against foot rot diseases is not available and mitigation is limited to crop rotation strategies. Severity of disease development is determined by pathogen levels in soils, soil structure and weather conditions. One strategy for pea growers to mitigate risks is to assess pathogen levels in fields before planting pea crops. This project aimed to develop DNA-based molecular tests to quantify foot rot pathogens in soils. The advantages of molecular tests are higher throughput, faster and more accurate results than tests based on pathogen morphology.

We successfully optimised methods for DNA extraction from soil and developed DNA based quantitative PCR (qPCR) tests for all four foot rot pathogens FSP, FO, DP and AE. Tests for FO and AE were based on previously published work but those for FSP and DP were new and diagnostic targets for these were identified by genome sequencing which provides an additional publicly available research for further work on these pathogens. Current work is now relating results from qPCR to pathogen levels in soil and subsequent disease development in order to provide a risk assessment tool for pea growers that will be exploited by PGRO to help them choose fields with healthy soils for growing high quality peas. Efficiency of pea production in the UK will be increased and the use of land, water, energy and fertilisers will be reduced.
Exploitation Route The provision of quantitative molecular tests for the pea foot rot pathogens FSP, FO, DP and AE will allow accurate assessment of soil inoculum potential and enable pea growers to select field with healthy soils for planting, hence mitigating yield losses. This reduction in yield decline will have a major economic impact and safeguard against further decline of UK pea yields. One of the main beneficiaries of this research will be PGRO, as they will have access to new tools to better identify/quantify the presence of footrot pathogens on behalf of growers. The other major beneficiary will be pea growers who will benefit from a cheaper, more accurate and wide-ranging foot rot test. However, the major benefit will be in allowing the growers to make much better informed decisions about their rotations and which fields have the lowest risk of disease when they plant. This will lead to increased yield, less waste and decreased economic losses through the overall reduction in disease as well as more even maturity at harvest and more reliable factory throughput. Following the project, pea growers will therefore be able to maintain and potentially increase production for both home and export consumption with associated economic benefits.

The project will benefit academics and researchers in the biological sciences, especially those involved in crop research and plant pathology. In particular new quantitative diagnostic techniques for the key pea footrot pathogens that we have developed will enable further research as it will allow the response and dynamics of these fungi to be studied more easily in relation to environment, cropping system or potential control treatments. This will lead to further refinement of relationships between inoculum levels, disease development and yield. This has not been possible before due to the absence of suitable specific, quantitative methods. Furthermore, the development of DNA extraction methods in this project using larger quantities of soil will be of interest to many researchers working on soilborne microorganisms. Most soil DNA extraction kits use small amounts of soil and this limitation has continued to hamper progress in understanding the components and dynamics of soil microbial communities especially as amplicon sequencing is being increasingly used as a technique to profile the organisms present. Finally, genome sequences of FSP and DP generated in the project will be made publically available for the first time, hence contributing to the increasing number of fungal genomes being published and allowing subsequent comparative genomics studies.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink

 
Description Foot rot disease in peas causes great yield losses and reduces the quality of peas. The foot rot complex is caused by several soil-borne pathogens, mainly Fusarium solani f.sp pisi (FSP), Fusarium oxysporum (FO), Didymella pinodella (DP) and Aphanomyces euteiches (AE). All pathogens can occur together and produce resting spores that can survive in soils for several years. Chemical treatment against foot rot diseases is not available and mitigation is limited to crop rotation strategies. Severity of disease development is determined by pathogen levels in soils, soil structure and weather conditions. One strategy for pea growers to mitigate risks is to assess pathogen levels in fields before planting pea crops. This project aimed to develop DNA-based molecular tests to quantify foot rot pathogens in soils. The advantages of molecular tests are higher throughput, faster and more accurate results than tests based on pathogen morphology. We successfully developed DNA based quantitative PCR (qPCR) tests for all four foot rot pathogens FSP, FO, DP and AE. Tests for FO and AE were based on previously published work but those for FSP and DP were new and diagnostic targets for these were identified by genome sequencing which provides an additional publicly available research for further work on these pathogens. Current work is now relating results from qPCR to pathogen levels in soil and subsequent disease development in order to provide a risk assessment tool for pea growers that will be exploited by PGRO to help them choose fields with healthy soils for growing high quality peas. Efficiency of pea production in the UK will be increased and the use of land, water, energy and fertilisers will be reduced. The development of these new diagnostic tests with increased sample throughput and shorter reporting times has the potential to create an additional revenue potential for PGRO. Conservative estimates of yield losses caused by the foot rot complex cost the UK economy around £12M per year (farm gate value). The new tool will help to reduce these losses by enabling better risk assessment and improved crop planting strategies.
First Year Of Impact 2018
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink
Impact Types Economic

 
Description Understanding and mitigating against the causes of yield decline in pea
Amount £122,000 (GBP)
Funding ID 1898612 
Organisation Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2017 
End 01/2022
 
Title Quantitative PCR tests for pea foot rot pathogens 
Description New quantitative PCR tests for Didymella pinodella and Fusarium solani f.sp. pisi 
Type Of Material Technology assay or reagent 
Year Produced 2018 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact These new qPCR assays will be used by PGRO as part of a pea foot rot diagnostic test. 
 
Description Collaboration with PGRO 
Organisation Processors and Growers Research Organisation (PGRO)
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Provision of pea foot rot diagnostics
Collaborator Contribution Provision of foot rot fungal isolates, soil samples
Impact Ongoing but likely to result in foot rot tests fro growers to mitigate yield decline in peas
Start Year 2018