Mechanically Interfacing with Biology via Piezoelectric Nanowires

Lead Research Organisation: University of Cambridge
Department Name: Materials Science & Metallurgy

Abstract

Collectively, cells can perform incredibly complex tasks. Their function allows us to interact with the world, fight disease and repair the materials that make us. The ability to control this behaviour could lead to significant advances in areas such as regenerative medicine, tissue engineering and bio-mimetic materials. However, interfacing directly with cells to dictate their behaviour is far from trivial. The chemical pathways and mechanisms that typically regulate cell function have been devised over millions of years of evolution, resulting in fiercely complex and finely balanced systems. Interfering with these schemes rarely succeeds. Interestingly, a new and emerging field of research known as mechanobiology may offer a solution to this problem. This describes the phenomenon whereby cellular systems are exceptionally sensitive to their mechanical environment, i.e., the function and behaviour of cells can be regulated by the physical properties of their surroundings and the forces that they experience. As an example, human stem cells grown on a soft substrate are likely to differentiate into fat cells, while growing those same stem cells on a rigid substrate will lead to the formation of bone cells. The challenge of controlling cell function is then shifted to the challenge of controlling the mechanical properties of cell surroundings. In this context, piezoelectric materials are ideal candidates for tools within mechanobiology, given their ability to both detect and apply small forces. By combining piezoelectric materials with a grid of electrodes, similar to that found on the touch screen of a phone, a 'touch screen for cells' can be created. Cells growing on this device will exert a force on the piezoelectric material, causing it to develop some electric charge. This charge can then be detected with some degree of spatial resolution using the grid of electrodes. Furthermore, via the same grid of electrodes, individual areas of the piezoelectric interface material can be excited to provide local mechanical stimulation to a specific part of the platform. In this way, an effective bio-electromechanical interface can be created to both electrically detect and apply physiologically relevant mechanical forces on cells to manipulate their functionality.

Meeting the materials selection criteria for the piezoelectric element is challenging, as what is required is a small, flexible and biocompatible piezoelectric structure to interact with cells. Nanostructured piezoelectric polymeric materials are ideally suited for this purpose as cells are themselves typically micron sized and exert forces in the pico- to nanonewton range. The proposal therefore aims to develop appropriate biocompatible piezoelectric polymer nanowires as the bio-electromechanical interface material, thus leading to the development of a powerful tool for synthetic biology. The proposal uniquely aims to undertake inter-disciplinary research involving the application of cutting-edge materials science and engineering to develop new and exciting tools for bioscience research.

Technical Summary

It has become increasingly evident that the mechanical environment of a cell is crucial in determining its behaviour, and the subsequent long range morphology of multicellular systems. In this regard, functional and responsive nanomaterials can provide a convenient route towards achieving a bio-electromechanical interfacing platform with advanced functionality. With the platform outlined in this proposal, the possibility arises for directly sensing and actuating extracellular forces within a cellular environment for the first time under external and addressable dynamic electric field control. Piezoelectric materials make this possible due to their ability to inter-convert mechanical and electrical energy, and piezoelectric nanomaterials in particular are ideal candidates for tools within mechanobiology, given their ability to both detect and apply small forces on a length scale that is compatible with cellular dimensions. While the proposal targets a fundamental understanding of electromechanical properties of bio-compatible piezoelectric polymernanowires and their interactions with cells, the findings will be directly relevant to developing a simple and inexpensive technology that would allow for a high throughput of synthetic biology experiments with minimal unwanted influence on the cell behaviour.

In order to achieve spatial resolution to the electrical signals being applied to or detected from the bio-electromechanical interface, an array of electrode 'pixels' is required to address sections of the piezoelectric nanowire array via a pre-patterned and electroded substrate. The resulting piezoelectric bio-electromechanical interfacing tool will be tested across a variety of cell lines. The proposal thus aims to rise beyond the limitations of the available methods to apply physiologically relevant stress profiles on cells, particularly with sub-cellular resolution, through external electric field manipulation, with simultaneous force sensing capabilities.

Planned Impact

This project is aiming at providing significant breakthroughs in terms of developing a novel bio-electromechanical interfacing technology with wide-ranging applications in healthcare, regenerative medicine, bio-mimectics and synthetic biology, to name a few. The long term societal and economic impact of this project can be significant in particular through these diverse applications. For example, the ongoing revolution in synthetic biology, underpins a growing multi-billion £ global market with a rich activity in the UK. Advances in cell-imaging and cell-interfacing can potentially revolutionise the healthcare market, including delivering personalised healthcare, rapid and non-invasive diagnostics, and offering an active platform to better understand physiology in health and disease. Perhaps the most exciting possibility of such an advance would be dynamic remodelling of tissues in a manner analogous to bone remodelling. External and addressable control over intercellular mechanical signals could have numerous medical or industrial applications for generating advanced composite materials in arbitrary shapes using low intensity energy sources, and would represent an entirely new route to fabrication of bulk materials. The proposed bio-electromechanical interface thus presents significant potential for both innovation and exploitation. This will drive innovative and sustainable bio-medical tools in the UK for 21st century products, delivering a step change in both throughput and breadth of application to facilitate new research discoveries.

Key technology outcomes from this project will be identified and translated to commercial exploitation quickly and efficiently, through collaboration, patenting/licensing and entrepreneurship. Cambridge Enterprise, which is the technology transfer division of the University of Cambridge, will oversee IP and commercialisation arrangements. It is envisaged that the piezoelectric nanowire bio-platform will create ideas which can attract funding from other sources to further support exploitable concepts and provide fertile ground for the generation of spin-off companies. Cambridge provides unique access to its vibrant science parks including the Cambridge Biomedical Campus, and thus fertile ground for exploitation of new concepts to achieve commercial success. The EPSRC and BBSRC also provide a funded route for UK researchers to access a wider academic-industrial network via the SynbiCITE, which is also accessible to the UK and global industry. Hence the developed knowledge and processes will be directly available to all stake holders via this network, and represents an immediate route to impact. As well as transferring knowledge and expertise into industry, the broader public and policymakers will be educated about this research and its potential impact. The PI has a strong track record in public engagement and outreach to young people and the general public and will continue to inspire the public at an influential level on technology related societal challenges and opportunities.
 
Description The key findings of this award is that it is indeed possible to create a nanostructured polymeric interface on which cells and tissue can be grown, and then sensed and stimulated via external electrical means. The response of biological materials can be tuned by varying the crystallinity of the polymeric interface which can be controlled via the processing route. This gives rise to a range of different cellular responses as effectively the local electromechanical environment can be controlled with a high degree of spatial resolution. The applicability of this novel polymeric interface has been tested across a variety of cell lines, and has opened up new avenues for research using this highly veratile and powerful technique.
Exploitation Route The outcomes of this funding are being taken forward through collaboration with cell biologists across the UK. Now that the interface has been successfully fabricated, it can be tuned to match the requirements of cell biologists. For example, our ongoing collaboration with a group from Haematology in the university is exploring how this platform can be used to improve the yield of endothelial cells from iPSCs. We are also in talks with other research groups to see how this technology can be extended to the study and control of neuronal cells, platelets and smooth heart muscle cells.
Sectors Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology

 
Description Following on from this project, the PI was awarded a BBSRC IAA award to IAA funding to help translate the project outcomes. The aim of the IAA project was to facilitate the commercialisation of technology developed in the PI's group on microfluidic force sensing for application in joint replacement surgery, and its application to a completely unmet clinical need, which is the measurement of forces in the setting of implants in arthroplasty surgery. This is crucial for improving the outcomes of a range of orthopaedic surgical procedures, particularly hip arthroplasty, and there is currently no technology available for the measurement of forces and strains in hip joints during or after the implantation procedure. Through the IAA project, a detailed business plan was commissioned and delivered, illustrations and animations of the force sensor and its applications in orthopaedic surgery were commissioned and delivered, and a fully calibrated working trial insert was developed as a prototype for demonstration purposes. Based on the results and outcomes from the IAA project, further funding is being sought from through MRC, DPFS, i4i and also through med-tech companies to commercialise the technology.
 
Description BBSRC IAA
Amount £35,728 (GBP)
Funding ID BB/S506710/1 
Organisation Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 06/2021 
End 03/2022
 
Title Research data supporting "Enhanced Molecular Alignment in Poly-l-lactic acid nanotubes induced via melt-press template wetting" 
Description The file WAXD_data_PLLA_NT contains raw Wide-Angle X-ray Diffraction (WAXD) data from scans of PLLA films and nanotubes. The heat treatment temperature is listed as a header for each column. All heat treatments were for 1 hour, followed by slow cooling to room temperature. The folder 'Isothermal DSC' contains raw DSC data exported from TA Universal Analysis software. The data fields 'Time', 'Temperature' and 'Heatflow' are marked by headers in each file. The temperature profile of the scan can be seen by plotting the 'time' column verses the 'temperature' column. Sample masses are included as a .txt file. The MATLAB code IsothermalAnalysis_v5.m can be used to perform Avrami analysis of the isothermal DSC data. The structure of the alpha crystal phase of PLLA used for XRD simulation is included as a alpha.cif file. The atomic co-ordinates of this model were determined from the work published by Wasanasuk et al. Macromolecules, 2011: http://dx.doi.org/10.1021/ma2006624 The folder POM images contains polarised light microscopy images taken of amorphous and crystalline PLLA nanotubes dispersed on a glass slide. A wave plate is used to determine the sign of any birefringence. Reference images of a drawn film are also included. In img2 the drawing direction is east-west, in img3 the drawing direction is southwest-northeast and in img4 is northwest-southeast. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2019 
Provided To Others? Yes  
 
Title Research data supporting "Poly-L-lactic acid nanotubes as soft piezoelectric interfaces for biology: controlling cell attachment via polymer crystallinity" 
Description  
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2020 
Provided To Others? Yes  
URL https://www.repository.cam.ac.uk/handle/1810/303986
 
Title Research data supporting "Unprecedented Dipole Alignment in a-phase Nylon-11 Nanowires for High Performance Energy Harvesting Applications" 
Description esearch_support_non-Ferroelectric Nylon nw TENG.zip file contains original SEM images and experimental data in the main text of the manuscript and supporting information. The original SEM images contain original scales and beam conditions at which SEM images were taken. raw-data.xlsx contains data files for the graphs, such as XRD, DSC, KPFM, energy harvesting measurements and electrical characterization, discussed in the main text of the manuscript and the supporting information. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2020 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Choi, Y., Kim, S., Williams, F., Vickers, M. E., Elliott, J., & Kar-Narayan, S. (2020). Research data supporting "Unprecedented Dipole Alignment in a-phase Nylon-11 Nanowires for High Performance Energy Harvesting Applications" 
URL https://www.repository.cam.ac.uk/handle/1810/304417
 
Description A tuneable method of nanostructuring polymer for tissue growth surfaces 
Organisation University of Cambridge
Department Department of Haematology
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Biological systems are responsive not only to chemical changes, but also changes in their mechanical environment. This 'mechanobiology' is believed to regulate some important cell functions, such as the how stem cells differentiate and the direction in which brain cells can grow. For the fields of regenerative medicine and tissue engineering, understanding and controlling mechanical cues is an important pathway for directing tissue behaviour. A major issue for this field remains that the stiffness of biological tissue is often many orders of magnitude lower than that of bulk material surfaces on which cell or tissue based experiments are performed, and creating biocompatible surfaces with appropriate and tubeable mechanical properties is challenging. In this collaboration, we show that biocompatible poly-l-lactic acid (PLLA) nanotubes grown by template wetting provide a suitably "soft" surface for cell cultures. Importantly, the effective stiffness of the nanostructured surface is dependent on the aspect ratio of the nanotubes, which can be controlled through appropriate heat treatment during the fabrication process. The suitability of this nanostructured PLLA surface for cellular interaction is demonstrated through culturing human induced pluripotent stem cells (hhiPSCs), which are shown to remain pluripotent after 14 days. Remarkably, when hhiPSCs were differentiated on PLLA, to endothelial cells (iECs) using a chemically-defined protocol, , there was a slight increase in the final yield, from 3,900 cells mm-2 for standard tissue culture plastic, to 6,500 cells mm-2 on the nanostructured surface. We therefore envisage that the manipulation of the mechanical properties of PLLA nanotubes will lead to highlevels of control of cellular response.
Collaborator Contribution Collaborators at the Department of Haematology, University of Cambridge, provided the hhiPSCs for this study, as well as access to their cell culture labs, equipment and analysis tools.
Impact A manuscript is currently under preparation
Start Year 2019
 
Description Cambridge Science Festival 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact We presented results from our BBSRC-funded research to a general audience at the Cambridge Science Festival through a public talk.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019