Time domain modelling of sound attenuation by porous materials

Lead Research Organisation: University of Salford
Department Name: Res Inst for the Built and Human Env

Abstract

Porous materials are renowned for their ability to attenuate sound. As sound wave penetrates the pores, the air oscillates and friction occurs due to its motion relative to the pore walls. Friction and heating always come together - ancient people even produced light by rubbing stones! A lot of sound energy is transferred into heat in pores which leads to its attenuation.In many materials size and shape of the pores vary unpredictably across the sample. For this reason it is difficult to know exactly what happens within them. Luckily, some macroscopic material parameters can give indirect information about its pores. For instance by weighing the sample one can find the porosity, which indicates the volume fraction occupied by pores. Once all such parameters are known, the mathematical formula can be constructed out of them, which predicts effectiveness of attenuation of a certain frequency sound by the porous material. The exact formula however is only known for very high and very low frequency sound, what combination of parameters has to be used for the rest of the frequencies is not known exactly. For these frequencies the model for sound attenuation is constructed empirically, i.e. the formula is devised which gives correct results for low and high frequencies and at the same time provides good fit with the majority of data for the intermediate frequencies.Quite often the sound signal to be attenuated is not continuous but pulsed. Sound from explosions for instance only lasts for several milliseconds. However even in this case the signal can be thought of as an infinite sum of continuous sounds with all possible frequencies. In principle, if the signal is not very loud, it is possible to consider the attenuation of every frequency component by porous material and then sum the results and see what happens with the whole pulse. In reality, this procedure requires a lot of computer time. Moreover, if the pulse amplitude is high, its frequency components interact with each other as it propagates and hence can't be considered separately. That is why the project focuses on the time - domain model of pulse attenuation: it does not use expansion into frequency components but looks at the pulse as a whole. Its aim is to develop an empirical time domain model, similar to those existing for continuous sounds of specific frequency, working for any duration pulse, loud or not. When designed, such a model will most definitely result in equations which are too difficult to be handled without the use of computers. In fact, it is anticipated that the considerable part of the project will be devoted to finding fast and effective ways to solve them numerically. We will start from a simpler version of the model assuming that sound only propagates in pores, but not through the solid matrix of the material. To validate the model, the laboratory transmission measurements on heavy materials with simple pore geometry will be carried out.The ultimate goal of the project, however, is to develop a model working well for naturally occurred porous materials (like soils, sands and gravel), which can be used to attenuate sound outdoors. When sound hits some of these materials not only air in pores oscillates, but the solid granules themselves can be involved in motion. This situation requires further refinement of the model and further measurements on natural porous materials.The project will have two major outcomes:1. The model and the numerical algorithm can be used by scientists dealing with any aspects of pulsed sound interaction with porous materials, most likely in atmospheric and room acoustics.2. We will provide practioners involved in noise control, with a guide about what kind of porous material should be used for attenuation of sound pulses in each particular practical situation. The choice will depend on how long and loud the pulse is, what shape it has and what are the requirements for its attenuation.
 
Description The main outcomes of the project are the following:

We have developed a semi-empirical relaxational model for low amplitude sound propagation in rigid porous materials. It is based on two simple pore geometries (cylindrical pores of two different sizes in 'parallel' and in 'series') and is able to approximate porous materials with the whole range of shape factors. The new model requires a usual set of macroscopical independently measurable material parameters and can be analytically formulated in time domain. The numerical procedure has been developed to effectively solve the time domain equations which account for both viscous and thermal interactions of sound with porous materials. It has been demonstrated that the model provides an excellent agreement with the data for both long and short pulses. It is proven to be especially useful for the materials with shape factors very different from unity, i.e. when there are pores with very different characteristic sizes. This fact makes the model suitable for the naturally occured granular porous materials like for instance gravel where shape factor value is higher than 10.
We have developed a semi-empirical time domain model to describe high amplitude sound propagation in porous materials. In this case the properties of the material change with the amplitude, i.e. it can become strongly nonlinear. The major advantage of the new model is that it incorporates both viscous and memory effects and so is suitable for both long and short pulses interacting with rigid porous material. To validate the model we have performed a series of measurements using pulses generated in a shock tube and with a sparker source. The pulse durations were ranging from several microseconds to tens of milliseconds to cover different regimes of sound interaction with porous materials. The amplitudes of the pulses were in the range from 100Pa to 40kPa. It has been demonstrated that the new model has a significant advantage over the others for short pulses of moderate amplitude when both Forchheimer's nonlinearity and the memory effects have to be accounted for simultaneously.
Exploitation Route The models developed during the project can be used by other researchers and engineers to predict the performance of porous materials subject to high levels of acoustic excitation. This can be relevant to practical applications of these materials in industrial sites, aviation and construction industry as well as military applications.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Construction,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Security and Diplomacy,Transport

 
Description Several final year projects for BEng and MSc acoustics degrees at Salford University have been based on the ideas emerged during the duration of the project. The ideas developed during this project have been used in work for the projects funded by DSTL, UK on blast acoustic black hole and membrane metamaterials for ear defenders. They have already been used in developing a program for COST DENORMS network grant funded by EU commission. The grant has been awarded in 2016. The academic impact is reflected in citations of our papers by other researchers.
Sector Aerospace, Defence and Marine
Impact Types Economic

 
Description Membrane metamaterials
Amount £30,000 (GBP)
Organisation Defence Science & Technology Laboratory (DSTL) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 01/2012 
End 07/2012
 
Description Omnidirectional blast absorber
Amount £30,000 (GBP)
Organisation Defence Science & Technology Laboratory (DSTL) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 11/2011 
End 07/2012
 
Description DSTL 
Organisation Defence Science & Technology Laboratory (DSTL)
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution The models and the devices/ structures developed during the project
Collaborator Contribution Testing facilities, advice on the use of the project outcomes for military applications
Impact The collaboration is still in its early stage so there are no any particular outcomes yet
Start Year 2014