Quantum fluctuations and criticality in model magnets

Lead Research Organisation: University College London
Department Name: London Centre for Nanotechnology

Abstract

Phase transitions are ubiquitous in nature. Indeed, the daily pattern of peoples lives is intimately concerned with the phase transitions of one particularly important substance even though they rarely give it a second thought. Whether it is waiting for the kettle to boil for the morning cup of tea, or for the ice to melt in ones drink at the end of a long day, people depend on the properties of H2O in its different phases of ice, water or steam. The stability of these phases arises from a balance between, on the one hand, attractive forces between the H2O molecules, and, on the other hand, the disordering effects of thermal fluctuations which become more intense with increasing temperature. When attractive forces win out of thermal fluctuations a gas of H2O molecules first condenses to form water before freezing into ice.Does this mean that all materials will be icely sterile when cooled down to low temperatures, or correspondingly that phase transitions should only be expected at elevated temperatures? Surprisingly, perhaps, the answer to this question is no for certain classes of materials, and that matter can in fact melt even at the absolute zero of temperature, T= 0 Kelvin (-273.15 degrees centigrade), the point at which all thermal motion ceases. Materials that can melt at T= 0 K are those that experience strong quantum fluctuations. That is fluctuations that arise because of the quantum rules that apply to matter at the atomic scale. Roughly speaking, quantum fluctuations are the uncertainty in the famous Uncertainty Principle proposed by Heisenberg.Although quantum fluctuations might at first be thought to destabilise a system as much the same way as thermal fluctuations destabilise order at a classical (thermal) phase transition, experiments over the last decade or so have revealed in fact that entirely new states of matter can arise in the vicinity of so-called quantum critical points. The development of the theory describing thermal phase transitions produced one of the pinnacles of 20th century science, the Renormalisation Group Theory, for which Kenneth Wilson was awarded the Noble prize. In comparison, the study of quantum phase transitions can be said to be in its infancy. Our work is focussed on making significant contributions to the rapidly developing field of quantum phase transitions by performing experiments on some of the simplest systems that display such phenomena: arrays of interacting atomic magnets ( spins ). Chemical ingenuity allows magnetic arrays of different architecture and dimensionality, such as quantum spin chains, ladders, plaquettes, planes, etc., to be grown within three dimensional crystals. Changes to the spin configuration can then be monitored in exquisite detail by firing beams of neutrons through the arrays and monitoring how the neutrons are deflected as the system is driven through a quantum phase transition (e.g. by applying a magnetic field, pressure, etc.). The full spatial and temporal correlations of the spin system are reconstructed in this way, allowing questions to be answered such as whether the spins crystallise to form an ordered array, or remain disordered to form a quantum spin liquid (and if so what type). This is exactly the type of information required by the large community of theoretical physicists who study quantum phase transitions to test and develop their theories.Our neutron scattering experiments on quantum fluctuations and criticality in model magnets will thus not only help to answer the important fundamental question of how matter can melt at the absolute zero of temperature, but will also provide new insights into the nature of the fascinating states of matter that occur in the vicinity of quantum critical points.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The grant enabled several key advances to be made in a field of great significance to several branches of fundamental materials
science and more widely: how new states of matter emerge as a system is tunably driven by quantum fluctuations through a critical point.

For example, the onset of long-range magnetic order has played and continues to act as a central paradigm in the general field of
cooperative phenomena and phase transitions. Indeed much of what we undertand about conventional phase transitions, which are driven by
enhanced thermal fluctuations as the temperature is increased, is based on decades of experimentation on magnetic systems.
More recently, a completely different class of phase transitions - those driven by enhanced quantum fluctuations - have come to the fore, as
it has been discovered that new types of matter can exist in proximity to the quantum phase transition. Examples range from the appearance
of exotic superconductivity as magnetic order is suppressed, to theories relating the coarse grain structure of the universe to quantum
fluctuations in the primordial universe following the big bang.

One example output of the grant related to the above is the paper:

Quantum magnets under pressure: Controlling elementary excitations in TlCuCl3
PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS
Volume: 100 Issue: 20
Article Number: 205701
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.100.205701

which has been currently cited 161 times. In this paper we establish how pressure can be used to tune the magnetic interactions in a
model magnet to suppress the quantum fluctuations, allowing us to understand how long range order emerges, and crucially how the excitation
spectrum emerges. A key finding is the appearance of a longitudinal mode at the quantum phase transition, fully analogous in the relevant quantum
field theory to the Higgs mode of particle physics.

A second example is the paper:

Thermodynamics of the Spin Luttinger Liquid in a Model Ladder Material
PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS
Volume: 101 Issue: 24
Article Number: 247202

which has been currently cited 111 times. In this case, a model two leg magnetic quantum ladder was studied, and its phase diagram established
experimentally for the first time in all relevant areas of the temperature-magnetic field plane, thereby revealing various exotic quantum phases including
the spin luttinger liquid.

In summary, the funding was used to make several important breakthroughs in our understanding of how quantum fluctuations give rise to novel states of matter.
Exploitation Route Our work has been highly cited by other researchers.
Sectors Other