Micromechanics of seismic wave propagation in granular materials

Lead Research Organisation: University of Bristol
Department Name: Civil Engineering

Abstract

This research uses sophisticated laboratory testing and advanced numerical modelling to consider the dual problem of wave propagation in granular soils and estimation of stiffness. Understanding how stress waves propagate through soils is essential for earthquake engineering analysis and correct interpretation of current in-situ and laboratory seismic investigation results while accurate description of the soil stiffness is central for predictions of ground movements during and after construction. Soils are described as continua at scales which are large in comparison with the particle size, but this continuum response is a consequence of the particulate nature of the material. Discrete element modelling (DEM) describes the macroscopic response of particulate systems from integration of the mechanical interactions between particles. Computing power now permits the 3D analysis of assemblies of spherical particles with the actual dimensions of advanced laboratory tests. Sophisticated laboratory testing will be performed in a flexible boundary Cubical Cell permitting independent control of three principal stresses with fixed principal axes. Materials to be tested will include an angular sand, a rounded sand, and glass ballotini of two sizes: a size which matches the test sands and the larger size used in the DEM simulations. The influence of the nature of the granular material will be examined by increasing the complexity of the material in phases: starting with smooth spherical ballotini, then roughened ballotini, then real, irregular soil particles.Parallel DEM and multiaxial testing will be used to develop understanding of (1) the propagation through cubical samples of different granular materials of 'seismic' waves generated by piezoceramic elements; (2) the evolution of stiffness anisotropy with general histories of principal stresses; and (3) the effect of particle size and shape on the stiffness properties of granular materials.There will be three important outcomes: (1) testing and simulating the same system will provide important information on the reliability of DEM models to simulate wave propagation and on the level of detail in the DEM model required for accurate simulation; (2) testing of a range of different granular materials will show how results of DEM simulations of ideal particles can inform prediction of real soil response of real soils (under stress conditions which cannot be attained in the laboratory for example); and (3) knowledge of the nature of wave propagation and the evolution of small strain stiffness of geomaterials will inform the interpretation of laboratory and field tests.
 
Description Complex responses to perturbations in granular materials generated by point vibrational sources in experiments were compared to those found by the controlled movement of the particles in numerical simulations. The generally satisfactory agreement between experimental observations and simulations can be seen as a validation and support the use of numerical to investigate the influence of grain interaction on wave propagation in soils. These results allowed understanding of how waves propagate and suggest way for interpretation which can be directly applied to the stiffness characterisation of soils. The stiffness is one of the most important parameters that governs the behaviour of structures in the serviceability limit. Underestimation of the stiffness parameters results in excessive settlements while their overestimation results in increased project costs. The use of linear elements inserted into material appears problematic as some perturbation of the material structure may have consequences on the interpretation. The local contact between these elements and the particles also affects the results. It is also important to emphasise that the small vibrations induce the system to respond according to its dynamic characteristics and that opens the idea of using solutions for the system's resonance for stiffness calculation avoiding the use of the results in the time domain.
Exploitation Route The technique of soils stiffness evaluation based on wave propagation is extensively used by industry. However, the interpretation of the arrival time is still a topic under discussion. This project helps clarifying this important issue and provide a base for interpretation and calculation of the stiffness parameters.
Sectors Construction

 
Description This research explored fundamental aspects related to granular soils behaviour. Understanding how the waves propagate through soils is relevant and impacts not only the safety and costs of geotechnical and stuctural projects but also other areas like geophysics and earthquake engineering.
Sector Construction
Impact Types Economic

 
Description Newton Research Collaboration Programme
Amount £8,000 (GBP)
Funding ID NRCP1415/2/2 
Organisation Royal Academy of Engineering 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2015 
End 03/2016
 
Description Experimental and numerical investigation of the wave propagation arrival time through granular soils 
Organisation University of Lisbon
Country Portugal 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution This collaboration is based on the results generated by the research proposal. The data brought the attention of our colleagues in Portugal and following some preliminary discussions and meetings, we have decided to embark into a more structured research collaboration which will include development of numerical tools and laboratory data interpretation.
Collaborator Contribution our partners in Lisbon and Minho have developed numerical models that treat the wave propagation through multi-phase media. These numerical models have not been extensively tested and validated and our experimental data in Bristol can provide the ideal benchmark for such work. The importance of understanding the way in which waves propagate through soils as well as their interpretation in view of detecting key soil characteristics are extremely important for civil engineering and geophysics projects.
Impact We are planning to produce at least 4 papers in the next year.
Start Year 2019
 
Description Experimental and numerical investigation of the wave propagation arrival time through granular soils 
Organisation University of Minho
Country Portugal 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution This collaboration is based on the results generated by the research proposal. The data brought the attention of our colleagues in Portugal and following some preliminary discussions and meetings, we have decided to embark into a more structured research collaboration which will include development of numerical tools and laboratory data interpretation.
Collaborator Contribution our partners in Lisbon and Minho have developed numerical models that treat the wave propagation through multi-phase media. These numerical models have not been extensively tested and validated and our experimental data in Bristol can provide the ideal benchmark for such work. The importance of understanding the way in which waves propagate through soils as well as their interpretation in view of detecting key soil characteristics are extremely important for civil engineering and geophysics projects.
Impact We are planning to produce at least 4 papers in the next year.
Start Year 2019
 
Description Micromechanics of seismic wave propagation in granular materials 
Organisation Imperial College London
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Experimental investigation of wave propagation through granular media and stiffness evaluation.
Collaborator Contribution Numerical investigation of wave propagation through granular media and stiffness evaluation.
Impact Three journal and two conference papers have jointly been published but several publications are in advanced stage of preparation.
Start Year 2009
 
Description UK-Brazil research collaboration: advanced laboratory testing and modelling of treated soils 
Organisation Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul
Country Brazil 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We worked together with our partner on characterisation of cemented materials.
Collaborator Contribution The partner sent to Bristol a PhD student for one year.
Impact One journal paper has been submitted already and several journal papers (four) are in progress of submission.
Start Year 2015
 
Description Annual National Workshop: Micro-macro geomaterials 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact This type of workshops are very engaging, stimulating and provide an excellent environment for discussions and ideas exchanges.

The feedback received following the presentations was used to adjust procedures, improve data analysis.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2010,2011,2012,2013,2015
 
Description Organising International Workshop "Wave Propagation and Soil Stiffness: Particle-Continuum Duality" 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Type Of Presentation workshop facilitator
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact To mark the completion of this research project, a workshop entitled "Wave Propagation and Soil Stiffness" was held in Bristol on March 20 and 21. The dates were chosen to coincide with the BGA Rankine lecture. A total of 71 participants attended the workshop, about 40 of whom are based in the UK, with the remaining participants coming from diverse locations including Argentina, Japan, Portugal, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands, USA, Mexico, and Australia. 20 minute presentations were delivered by 16 invited speakers (three of the speakers were young geotechnical engineers who have been involved in the project), with the discussion on March 20 focussing on experimental studies, while the session on March 21 considered theoretical and numerical studies. The workshop was jointly supported by TC101 and TC105 of the International Society of Soil Mechanics and Foundation Engineering, the British Geotechnical Association and the Institution of Civil Engineers.

The workshop contributed to knowledge transfer and interaction between academia and industry, facilitating the rapid application and exploitation of recent research findings. During the workshop emphasis was placed on best practice in setting up the tests, interpreting the results to obtain appropriate parameters and developing a firm theoretical understanding of the mechanics underlying the tests. Ample time was provided for discussions and exchanges of good practice.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
URL http://www.bristol.ac.uk/engineering/events/2013/98.html
 
Description Wave Engineering Bristol Workshop: Wave propagation through granular soils: active probing and passive monitoring 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact The workshop was attended by researchers from different communities: physics, mathematics, as well as from industry.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL https://waveengbristol.wordpress.com/workshops/web-2017/