Influence of molecular structure of various hydrocarbons on soot formation

Lead Research Organisation: University College London
Department Name: Mechanical Engineering

Abstract

Many types of combustion system emit particles into the atmosphere which are known to be a major hazard due to their toxicity to human health, particularly the respiratory and cardiovascular systems. The smaller particles (less than about 100nm in size) are believed to be the most hazardous, as they can penetrate deep into the human lung. The purpose of this proposal is to gather scientific information on how the structure of fuel molecules affects the production of soot and particulates. During the next 10 to 20 years one can anticipate increasing interest in synthetic fuels which use molecules specifically developed to burn more efficiently and cleanly. The development of such molecules will require knowledge of how different molecular structures affect the production of harmful particulates and other emissions. Such clean fuels may be derived from fossil sources such as coal or increasingly from biomass (starches, sugars, and cellulosic materials) using chemical or biological conversion methods. The proposed project aims to determine in detail which features of a molecule's structure are responsible for producing more soot than others. The project relies on a new methodology which has not been used by the combustion research community previously to any significant extent. The methodology involves the replacement within a hydrocarbon molecule of selected commonplace 12C atoms with 13C atoms carrying a stable isotope label (extra neutron) which survives combustion intact, without altering the chemical and transport properties of the molecule. This label , which can be detected in the soot particles, provides a unique ability to determine which atoms or group of atoms of a molecule become soot particles. Two extensive series of experiments will be conducted, the first on a laminar diffusion flame and the second on a diesel engine. Unlike a diesel engine, the laminar flame allows the principal influences on soot formation to be chemical ones, by eliminating spray formation and evaporation and the effects of turbulent mixing and intermittent combustion. A laminar flame also allows readily the sampling and analysis of the contents of its envelope and it permits the introduction of controlled amounts of oxygen and other diluents at its base so as to study how these diluents affect soot formation. The second series of experiments will be on a diesel engine which represents a commonplace practical combustion system. Although the fuel spray in a diesel engine is less accessible, a diesel engine it is a truly realistic environment in which the pollutant particulate is formed. A total of 15, 13C-labelled fuel molecules have been selected to study the effect of their structure on soot and particulate formation. These 15 molecules have a wide range of structural features that could potentially affect soot and particulate formation and the 13C labelling method will allow the influences of these features to be evaluated. By the completion of the project it is envisaged that the knowledge gained could guide the production of future synthetic fuels so that the molecules they contain result in less soot and toxic particulates when combusted.

Planned Impact

The knowledge gained from this research will be at a fundamental level and it will help researchers worldwide to understanding soot formation better. It could also assist in testing computational models of soot formation. The results will thus form a seminal contribution to scientific knowledge in the field of soot formation and will enhance the UK's standing within the international scientific community through journal publications and presentations at important international meetings. We envisage that the knowledge gained from the project will also be useful to energy companies who could use it to develop synthesised molecules, including ones produced from sustainable sources, which result in less soot when combusted. For example, the results of the project could guide development of bio-chemical processes so that they are not just efficient in terms of productivity and resources but they also produce molecules which may burn more cleanly when combusted. In a similar manner, chemical post-processes may be optimised so that the post-processed molecules, originating from biomass or fossil fuels, produce lower levels of particulates. Likewise, biologists could be guided by the results of the project so as to develop micro-organisms (e.g. through genetic engineering) which in turn produce molecules from biomass (starches, sugars and cellulosic materials) which are more suitable for combustion and which produce lower levels of particulates. Particulate matter emitted from diesel and gasoline engines is a major toxic pollutant controlled by legislation internationally. The development of fuels producing lower soot levels would have a very substantial beneficial impact on human health. The project will result in a PhD graduate highly trained in a wide range of multidisciplinary skills, including engineering design and manufacture, rig and engine experimentation, analysis and interpretation of complex experimental results, complex analytical techniques such as 13C isotope analysis, communication of scientific results to researchers at international meetings, and time management. UCL's relationship with the sponsoring company (BP) will be strengthened and a new collaborative relationship between the applicants and Professor Tim Atkinson, Director of the UCL Bloomsbury Environmental Isotope Facility will be established.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description A new methodology has been developed which uses carbon 13 isotopically labelled carbon atoms in fuel molecules. The fuel molecules are then combusted and the soot/particulate pollutant formed during combustion is analysed. The isotopically labelled carbon atoms that were originally in the fuel are now traced in the soot/particulate pollutant. By comparing how many labelled atoms were in the fuel with how many of them were found in the soot/particulate matter, it is possible to know the likelihood that a particular carbon atom in the fuel molecule being converted to soot/particulate. The methodology has been applied to several fuel molecules, alcohols, esters, acetates, alkanes, aromatics, etc, and the results reported in the open literature through published papers in international journals.
Exploitation Route The findings have been published in international journals such as Combustion and Flame and have been presented in key symposia.
Sectors Environment,Transport

 
Description The findings have been published and presented in scientific symposia, and also presented to BP Oil Company, which is a major international producer of fuels. The findings are of fundamental nature and the knowledge gained from them is expected to guide the development and synthesis of future clean fuels which will produce lower levels f soot and particulate pollutant emissions emitted from internal combustion engines and other combustion systems.
First Year Of Impact 2013
Sector Energy,Environment,Transport
Impact Types Economic

 
Title Further development of the isotope tracing method 
Description The method of isotope tracing has been extended at UCL by Dr Aaron Eveleigh (who completed his PhD at UCL on isotopic tracing in combustion, while being supported by the grant). The method has been extended to a wide variety of hydrocarbons, including oxygen bearing ones. Under development is also a new extension to the method, which uses NMR to locate the isotope label in the soot sample. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2015 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Results have been published in high impact factor journals. 
 
Title Stable isotope tracing for combustion research 
Description Carbon 13 isotope labelling has been developed, whereby a fuel molecule has selected carbon atoms labelled as isotopic carbon 13. These atoms can then be traced in the particulate/soot generated form combustion and, thereby, the conversion rate of a specific carbon atom to soot can be determined. For example, ethanol has only 30% of its carbon atom adjacent to the OH group converted to soot, while up to 70% of the methyl carbon atom of ethanol is converted to soot. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2014 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact It is now possible to identify fuel molecular structures that can generate a lot of soot and particulates, after combustion; the molecular structures can be modified to reduce soot and particulate production 
URL http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0010218014001382
 
Title Soot flow reactor 
Description A soot flow reactor has been constructed capable of pyrolising a wide range of hydrocarbons, including ones with 13C tags and which allows control of: reaction temperature (ambient to 1750 deg C), reactants flow rate, use of both liquid and gaseous reactants 
Type Of Technology Physical Model/Kit 
Year Produced 2012 
Impact The reactor has enabled the EPSRC project to generate highly original data on the conversion of individual atoms within various single component fuel molecules to soot; these data has been published in international journals in the open literature