STRUCTURAL OPTIMISATION OF TIMBER OFFSITE MODERN METHODS OF CONSTRUCTION

Lead Research Organisation: Edinburgh Napier University
Department Name: Engineering and the Built Environment

Abstract

Efficient and sustainable building systems are required in order to achieve the UK government's target of building three million new homes by 2016. Given, the current lack of activity in the housing construction market to achieve this target, increased levels of off-site modern methods of construction (MMC) need to be adopted which conform to future regulatory and code requirements, are environmentally sound and structurally robust. The dominant form of timber construciton for housing in the UK is open panel platform frame construction (approximately 25% UK market share). In order to meet future market and building regulatory requirements this form of construction needs to evolve and become an efficient closed panel system solution. The system solution needs to be capable of being manufactured off-site to the highest possible specification in terms of mass customisation, inclusion of services, application of cladding, and to achieve a high standard of building performance (thermal insulation, reduced cold bridiging, acoustic separation) whilst remaining cost effective.Off-site MMC research has primarily focussed on: understanding the market; the conceptualisation of modern building systems and products; the adaption of production theories to construction; implementation of modern business processes to construction by means of adapting information and communication technologies; and micro-renewable solutions (photovoltaics, ground source heat pumps etc) to provide additional energy.It has been recognised that sustainable building envelopes should start with improving the efficiency of the building fabric. The evolution of timber plaform frame from an open panel to a closed panel system solution requires increased levels of off-site MMC and improved building performance.. This impacts upon the structural performance and requires the deriviation of novel technical solutions and incorporation of innovative products. Running concurrently with this is the need to structurally design and certify all new building systems in accordance with the new European Code of Practice as a result of the British Standard Code of Structral Practice now being obsolete (as of the 1st of April 2010).This research work will progress through testing in isolation, and in combination, novel technical solutions and innovative products which will form the timber closed panel system solutions of the future. These derived solutions will be used in pilot projects to demonstrate their application and, through post completion testing, overall system efficiency. Further to this the work will provide a generic product family architecture in accordance with Eurocode design requirements providing industry confidence in the code and the ability to specify the derived solutions or adapt them for their specific market or client needs.The proposed research work will be part of a wider scale research movement and therefore provide necessary outcomes for the implementation of sustainable and efficient methods of construction required to address the existing UK housing shortage. The work will support the UK timber frame industry and its suppliers in terms of both raw materials and services (i.e. consulting engineering practices). The project will also ensure that timber frame remains competitive relative to other less sustainable forms of construction and imports.

Planned Impact

This project is timely given the forthcoming environmental and structural legislative requirements, the need to provide affordable houses and enhance the UK manufacturing base. The UK needs to implement a sustainable strategy for meeting the housing shortfall and with respect to this it needs to meet the social, environmental and economic needs of the present without comprising the ability of future generations to meet their needs. Primarily, however, sustainability requires design in the broadest sense to be at the centre of the development process; critical to the design process, particularly when considering off-site MMC, is structural design. The project will be closely aligned with the requirements of industry and government agencies. Edinburgh Napier University has strong links with a range of industry partners as well as the British Standards Institution (BSI), UK Timber Frame Association (UKTFA), the British Research Establishment (BRE), Scottish Building Standards Agency (SBSA) and the National House Building Council (NHBC). These strong links will be used to disseminate the information either via the project Research Advisory Board or other collaborative mechanisms that are already in place such as the Construction Industry Advancement Centre (CIAS). By exploiting these mechanisms the project will also influence future building regulatory and structural design requirements as well as create increased levels of cross industry collaboration ensuring that derived solutions are generic and beneficial to the industry as a whole. The purpose of the project is to enhance the UK industry and not provide individual companies with a competitive advantage within the sector itself. This said, it is expected that company specific spin off projects will be instigated by the project to the benefit of the industry partner. Pilot projects in collaboration with industrial partners will be developed to showcase the project innovations. Results will be disseminated to industry via technical notes and industrial engagement seminars. Information from the project will also be disseminated via routes such as a dedicated project web site and software applications. Further to this research, workshops and seminars will be arranged and the project will report its overall findings at dedicated conferences. Journal (IstructE & ICE) and external conference papers will be published and presented (WCTE 2012 & 2014). Dissemination will also occur through the Scottish Construction Forum and trade and industry organisation events. Information from the project will be embedded into teaching and industry CPD material. The project will build on published work by the lead investigator including the TRADA & IStructE (2007) Manual for the design of timber building structures to Eurocode 5 and Hairstans (2010) Offsite and Modern Methods of Timber Construction - a sustainable approach published by TRADA Technology. It is highly likely that this proposed project will lead to further industry collaboration such as KTPs and academic collaborations building on the knowledge created. The project will also create a legacy of licensed products and processes to the industry that will generate income. Therefore, Edinburgh Napier will become the place for structural timber off-site MMC expertise and knowledge in the UK and Europe. Dr Hairstans has already demonstrated his ability to identify, manage and deliver industry research requirements and has also developed the communication network required to ensure that this project has the necessary impact. Overall the project team will develop professionally towards membership of the Institution of Structural Engineers and Institution of Civil Engineers, develop key project management competencies and enhanced knowledge of sustainability policy, building performance legislation, construction and manufacturing techniques ensuring they have key skills adaptable to other employment.
 
Description - Information that influenced the British Standard National Annex for the revised European Code of Practice in order to design timber frame walls
- New structurally robust details for closed panel wall solutions which have been used in commercial practice including utilisation in the Glasgow Commonwealth Games Athletes Village
- The development of structural design software released by Trimble Tekla via their Tedds platform to 16,000 engineers
Exploitation Route The findings of the research have been embedded in the Trimble Tekla Tedds software for standard design to the new European Code of Practice. These standardised calculation are now being used for parametric analysis to facilitate automated code compliance checking for future integration with Building Information Modelling.
Sectors Construction,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Education,Energy,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology

 
Description - Timber engineering closed panel system solutions including software development to European Codes of Practice for release to 16,000 engineers via Trimble, Tekla. - Standard details used in commercial practice including incorporation in the Commonwealth Games Athletes Village (Glasgow)
Sector Construction,Education,Environment,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology
Impact Types Economic

 
Description Follow-On Innovation Voucher Scheme "MAKAR Dowel-Lam"
Amount £29,000 (GBP)
Organisation Government of Scotland 
Department Scottish Funding Council
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 11/2014 
End 06/2015
 
Description UK Futures Programme - Addressing skills deficiencies in the Off-Site Construction sector
Amount £138,224 (GBP)
Organisation Government of the UK 
Department UK Commission for Employment and Skills
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2014 
End 03/2015
 
Description Low Carbon Building Technology Gateway 
Organisation European Commission
Department European Regional Development Fund (ERDF)
Country Belgium 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution The Centre for Offsite Construction + Innovative Structures delivered a series of projects on the the LCBTG projects including working extensively with industry partners.
Collaborator Contribution All project required in-kind contributions from industry partners in the form of time and/or materials to match the funding contribution from ERDF.
Impact - LCBTG01 - Cube retreat SIP details: strucutral review of structural insulated panel details for future building regs. - LCBTG02 - Stovemason: evaluation of masonry heater technologies for a Scottish context. - LCBTG04 - Capvond Sole Plate Detail: structrual reved of closed panel details using new material technologies. - LCBTG05 - MAKAR Timber Truss: structural optimisation of a truss system using new grading technologies. - LCBTG06 - Russwood Cladding: structural detailing of timber cladding systems. - LCBTG07 - Solid Timber Fire and Accoustic: fire and accoustic appraisal of solid timber systems. - LCBTG08 - Oregon Hybrid Racking Panel: strucutral optimisation and design automation of closed panel systems details. - LCBTG09 - JNES Space: appraisal of a solid timber modular system. - LCBTG10 - CLDB: structural appraisal of CLDB modular home system. - LCBTG11 - iQ Sole Plate Detail: closed panel detailing for CCG closed panels system. - LCBTG12 - Bungalow Retrofit: supply chain integration and use and application of novel technologies for a moder retrofit.
Start Year 2011
 
Description Wood Products Innovation Gateway 
Organisation European Commission
Department European Regional Development Fund (ERDF)
Country Belgium 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution The Centre for Offsite Construction + Innovative Structures work extensively with industry partnes and government agencies over the course of WPIG.
Collaborator Contribution Industry partners provide in-kind support in the form of materials and time to match the ERDF funding support.
Impact COCIS worked on 51 WPIG projects delivering outputs to industry, engaged on 17 networks to stimulate innovation and contributed to a number of CPD events.
Start Year 2011
 
Title Tekla Tedds Timber Racking Calculatioin to Eurocode 5 
Description Tekla (previously CSC(UK)) has been working successfully with the Edinburgh Napier Centre for Offsite Construction + Innovative Structures (COCIS) to deliver a new Tedds timber racking calculation to Eurocode 5. Funded by a research grant from the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) and part of a PhD research, the University's aim was to promote the structural use of timber, develop innovative solutions to assist with the specification of closed panel systems and to integrate these into engineering software used by commercial structural engineers. The first Tedds calculation resulting from this partnership enables racking walls to be designed in line with the "unified" approach detailed in the Provisional Draft 6693 document. Following a rigorous testing process, this EC timber racking calculation is now included within CSC's structural calculation software, Tedds, and is also available within the free trial version. Demonstrated at the Timber Expo in Birmingham and at EcoBuild 2014 in London, COCIS continues to develop further Tedds calculations for EC5 structural design and is currently developing a number of calculations to streamline the design of a range of commonly specified connections. 
Type Of Technology Software 
Year Produced 2014 
Impact 16,000 engineeris use the Tekla Tedds software and now have access to a unified approach to designinging timber frame racking panels inclusive of closed panel detailing. 
URL https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UaaF6MqBeEk
 
Description Timber Expo 2013 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The Centre for Offsite Construction + Innovative Strucutres exhibited and presented information at Timber Expo 2013

Following on from the event the centre received several enquiries relating to research and commercial activities. In addition contact made there has resuled in a joint publication utilising finding from the EPSRC funded programme of work.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013