TREViS: Tailoring Nano-Reinforced Elastomers to Vibrating Structures

Lead Research Organisation: Loughborough University
Department Name: Civil and Building Engineering

Abstract

Rubbers and other elastomers are very effective in mitigating vibrations experienced by Civil Engineering structures subjected to natural actions such as earthquakes, wind gusts or ocean waves. Following early applications in aircrafts and machineries, engineered rubbers have been successfully used in a number of energy dissipation devices and isolation bearings for buildings, bridges and other types of construction. A concerted effort has been made over the last few decades to further improve the performances of such elastomers with a variety of nano-reinforcements, e.g. carbon black, silica nano-particles and carbon-nanotubes, in so obtaining enhanced rubbers with significant nonlinearities. Despite this material complexity, manufacturers of elastomeric devices very often encourage the application of crude assumptions in the dynamic analysis of viscoelastically damped structures. Their interest is indeed to simplify as much as possible design procedures for structures equipped with their products, aimed at engaging more professional engineers. Unfortunately, such simplifications can be highly inaccurate, as demonstrated by previous investigations of the applicant in a range of design situations, e.g. buildings resisting seismic and wind forces. The TREViS project aims to demonstrate the feasibility of a radically new way of designing vibration-proof structures. According to the applicant's vision for the future, structural engineers must have the possibility to select the most appropriate mechanical properties of viscoelastic dampers and isolators, which optimise the global behaviour of new and existing structures under dynamic loadings; while the manufacturers' role should be simply to use suitable nano-reinforcements to tune structural rubbers according to the designers' specifications. As a necessary first step in this direction, an efficient computational framework will be theoretically established and experimentally validated throughout the proposed investigations; the aim is to allow accurate material information on nano-reinforced elastomeric devices to be incorporated and efficiently used to run dynamic analyses of structures equipped with such components within the limits of a reasonable computational effort. This novel strategy is intended to bridge the existing gap between academic appreciation of this challenging dynamic problem and current state of practice. A blend of experimental and computational studies will be conducted at Loughborough University along the three phases of TREViS. Orthonormal properties of Laguerre's polynomials will be used to approximate the relaxation function of elastomeric compounds containing carbon black and silica nano-particles, and special attention will be paid to strain-dependent effects and other nonlinear phenomena; an enlarged state-space model will be devised for viscoelastic beams with a sandwiched nano-reinforced core (Phase 1). Re-analysis techniques will be exploited to tackle material and geometrical nonlinearities, and a series of impulse hammer and shake table tests will be carried out for validation purposes (Phase 2). The proposed approach will be extended to frames made of viscoelastic beams with different dissipative properties, in so addressing the case of non-proportionally non-viscously damped structures (Phase 3). Each of these phases has a significant transformative aspect, namely: 1) nonlinear state-space formulation for viscoelastic materials and components, alternative to traditional characterisations in the frequency domain; 2) general computational strategy based on re-analysis techniques for enlarged state-space models, adaptable to other structural problems (e.g. flutter instability of bridge deck sections); 3) exploitation of normal modes for nonlinear structures with non-proportional non-viscous damping, providing structural engineers with physical insight and computational advantages in practical applications.

Planned Impact

Non-academic impacts anticipated from the TREViS project can be classified in four main categories: 1) PEOPLE. In addition to Principal Investigator (Dr A Palmeri), other people will directly benefit from proposed studies. The rubber advisor (Dr A Ansarifar) will have the possibility to work on Civil Engineering applications of nano-enhanced rubbers, while his previous experience has been concentrated on Mechanical & Manufacturing Engineering problems. Additional knowledge and skills acquired by the post-doctoral Research Associate (RA) will make him/her more competitive in the job market. Demand of structural engineers with solid expertise in vibration analysis and testing is expected to rise in the next years, as dynamic investigations for health assessment and monitoring of existing structures are becoming increasingly popular in the construction industry. The ambitious publication plan will also boost the RA's CV, along with his/her chances to find a more secure job (e.g. a lectureship) in academia. Moreover, two MEng Civil Engineering students will have the opportunity to develop their final-year dissertations on complementary aspects of this research, while a PhD student will use some viscoelastic members moulded for TREViS as a case study on damage detection via dynamic tests. 2) KNOWLEDGE. Relevant technical data gained from the proposed experimental campaign will be available online for downloading. As a result, new knowledge will also be disseminated outside the academic circle, e.g. including researchers of small to medium companies with limited access to scientific journals. Web 2.0 tools such as YouTube and SlideShare will be used to engage the non-specialist audience. 3) ECONOMY. Manufacturers of elastomeric devices will benefit from the outcomes of TREViS. Specific indications will be provided to improve the performances of structural systems embedding nano-reinforced rubber. Inaccuracies of traditional strategies of analysis and design will be identified and quantified. Medium to long-term impacts of the proposed investigations include less expensive and/or more efficient elastomeric dampers and isolators being installed in vibration-proof structures. 4) SOCIETY. The ultimate impact intended for the TREViS project is common to all developments of structural protection devices against dynamic loadings, i.e. improve reliability of buildings and bridges subjected to winds and earthquakes, and increase the number of constructions benefiting from these devices. This will result in contributing towards a more resilient built environment.
 
Description This project has investigated the dynamic performance of sandwich beams with nano-reinforced rubber core. This structural element, widely used in many engineering applications, has been selected because it makes possible to easily observe the effects of the nano-reinforcement on the viscoelastic damping. Material tests have shown that type and amount of nano-particles can significantly modify the viscoelastic behaviour of the rubber, and in particular the relaxation time; this in turn affects the dynamic response of the viscoelastic beams, as demonstrated by vibration tests. A novel computational model has been then formulated for the sandwich beams, which explicitly takes into account the relaxation function of the viscoelastic core with a reduced computational effort. The identification of the viscoelastic parameters has been improved with a more accurate mathematical representation of the relaxation test. The experimentation has also demonstrated a significant degree of nonlinearity in the dynamic behaviour of frame structures made of viscoelastic sandwich beams.
Exploitation Route Building upon the results of this project, further research will be needed to establish robust performance-based design strategies for viscoelastically damped structures subjected to environmental loads, e.g. response spectra for earthquake-resistant structures, which should include flexibility and relaxation time of the elastomeric components (instead of an equivalent viscous damping ratio, currently suggested by structural codes). Such improved design can result in more reliable and/or more economic structures.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Construction

URL https://sites.google.com/site/trevisproject
 
Description Project Presentation a ARUP Offices in London 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The aim and objectives of the project, as well as the initial results, have been presented, receiving some useful feedback from structural engineers working for one of the major consulting firms around the world.

An initial discussion has been held with the company to co-fund a PhD studentship on this field.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2012
 
Description Structural Dynamics Demonstration 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact A small-scale model has been used to demonstrate the effects of viscoelastic damping for the purposes of disaster risk reduction. A demonstration has been carried out as part of the undergraduate module on "Disaster Risk Reduction", showing the effect of viscoelastic damping in mitigate the effect of seismic forces.

Students become aware of the importance of non-conventional earthquake design using seismic isolators and dampers.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2012,2013,2014