Charge Carrier Dynamics and Molecular Wiring in Hybrid Optoelectronic Devices

Lead Research Organisation: Imperial College London
Department Name: Physics

Abstract

Charge Carrier Dynamics and Molecular Wiring in Hybrid Optoelectronic Devices

In the past decade there has been an explosion of interest in electronic devices using alternative materials to silicon, the traditional 'workhorse' of the semiconductor and photovoltaic industry. These alternative materials such as conducting molecules, polymers, metal oxides and metal sulphides are attractive because they can be deposited in a wide range of shapes and sizes from solution or printed onto flexible substrates. This allows low temperature, cheaper and more versatile manufacturing. They can be used to make devices such as next generation sensitised solar cells (SSCs), hybrid organic/inorganic solar cells and light emitting diodes (LEDs). These promise higher performance/cost ratios than conventional semiconductor devices. However the cost and processing advantages typically come at the expense of poor electrical charge transport due to the nature and processing of the materials used. This can lead to relatively low power conversion efficiencies in solar cells and LEDs based on these materials. Additionally variations in the energy of electrons (workfunction) at the interface between phases such as polycrystalline metal oxides and conducting polymers can cause non-ideal device behaviour leading to poor transfer of charge between the components and a corresponding loss in performance.

My proposal will address these problems by exploiting an interesting phenomenon where electrical charge is transferred between neighbouring molecules in a single continuous layer attached to a surface. This concept, known as two dimensional molecular wiring, has recently been applied in new battery technology which contains components with very poor conductivity. It allows more efficient collection of charge from the interface between the two phases in the electrochemical cell, allowing more rapid charging/discharging and more space for the active ingredients. I will work with the leaders in this field (EPFL in Switzerland) to apply molecular wiring to SSCs and hybrid optoelectronic devices. I have a strong research background related to dye sensitised solar cells (DSSCs, a particular class of SSC), and have recently been involved in a study that demonstrated molecular wiring between dye molecules covering the surface of titanium dioxide nanoparticles in liquid electrolyte DSSCs.

By applying molecular wiring in solid state SSCs and hybrid cells I hope to increase the separation and collection of charge from regions within the devices which are electrically isolated. This would lead to improved photocurrents and power conversion efficiencies. Additionally molecular wiring at oxide electrode interfaces should help to reduce variation in electron energy at interfaces by allowing neighbouring regions to reach equilibrium. This would be very attractive for the plastic electronics industry.

At Imperial College I have developed a unique series of measurements that will allow me to test the effectiveness of different configurations of molecular wiring in the solar cells. I will also work with Prof. Nelson who has expertise in molecular, charge and energy transport modelling to develop a method to screen suitable molecular wiring candidates to incorporate into the devices. I will compare these theoretical calculations with direct measurements of the conductivity through of layers of the molecules using a conducting atomic force microscope coupled with steady state and transient light sources. The results will help to direct researchers at EPFL and elsewhere towards synthesising new functional molecules for these applications. This strategy will be combined with increases in the charge separation efficiency in SSCs leading to easy to manufacture, higher performance devices.

Planned Impact

Knowledge
The knowledge generated by this project will contribute to the international research effort to develop low cost solar cells. The broad scope of the research will also help facilitate the transfer of ideas between researchers and add to the UK's research profile. Demonstrating new applications for the fascinating phenomena of hole hopping should generate considerable interest within both the academic and public spheres.

Society
This project will contribute to the development of photovoltaics as a sustainable energy source. There is thus a potential for huge impact in terms of mitigating CO2 emission, energy security, and in particular the development of off-grid communities. In off-grid regions, scalable photovoltaic panels requiring only a modest capital investment can bring major benefits by powering computers and telecommunications. Within the UK there is also a growing demand for photovoltaics to capitalise on recently introduced feed-in tariffs. The Grantham Institute for Climate Change at Imperial College will be able assess advances from the project in terms of their impact as a mitigation technology.

Molecular wiring used in plastic and hybrid electronics has the potential to improve biomedical, sensing and display technologies, all of which could contribute to the quality of life in society.

Economy
The plastic electronics industry in the UK is predicted to grow from £1.25bn today to £330bn by 2027. This industry stands to benefit from improvements in the performance of devices targeted by this proposal. For example homogenised work functions would potentially allow reduced operating voltages and improved efficiencies in OLEDs and OFETs. Imperial College has close links with companies developing materials for the industry such as Merck through its Centre for Plastic Electronics (one of 5 PE centres for excellence in the UK) thus the project is well placed to exploit potential new developments and contribute to wealth generation.

The UK is also a global centre for the commercialisation of DSSCs with G24i Solar having already shipped its first commercial order of cells and Tata Steel Colors investing heavily in the technology (£10m PV accelerator project to coat strip steel with DSSCs). Furthermore companies such as Solar Press (my sponsor Prof. Nelson is a Royal Society Research Fellow working with them) and Eight19 have been founded to commercialise advances in organic photovoltaics. Through the project's collaborations, the UK photovoltaics industry stands to benefit from advances in performance, stability and ease of manufacture resulting from this proposal, as well as through potential spin off companies to develop new advances.

I also anticipate that the research into 2D molecular wiring will have many additional applications in manufactured plastic and hybrid electronic devices, for example with the development of self-assembled monolayer transistors, and optimising the interfaces in organic LEDs.

People
The project will involve training two PhD students who will develop wide-ranging experimental and theoretical skills in what is a rapidly growing and high profile area. Following their studies they will be well positioned not only within the multi-disciplinary research world, but also to satisfy the increasing demand for highly trained individuals by companies in the field.

The multi-disciplinary nature of the project will also expand the academic horizons of the researchers involved in the project for example through strengthened links between the Chemistry and Physics Departments.

As part of the project we will also undertake a modest outreach programme to raise interest in science as a career path. This will include the development of demonstration devices to illustrate the technologies involved for presentations at schools, and offering student summer projects.

Publications

10 25 50

 
Description Key developments

Application of 2D molecular wiring:

By choosing dye molecules which allow charge conduction through monolayers we have shown that photocurrent can be doubled (charge collection improved from 30% to 60%) in solid state dye sensitised solar cells in which the mesoporous TiO2 film is only partially filled with hole transporting material. Incomplete pore filling is a major issue for solid state dye sensitised solar cells.

We have also demonstrated the first solid state dye cells that do not require a separate hole transporting phase. In our configuration, the monolayer of dye molecules perform several functions: harvesting light, separating the excited charge into free carriers, and transporting positive charges to a metal electrode. This innovation considerably simplifies the fabrication steps needed to make a solid state dye cell, however at present the performance of these devices is relatively modest.

Hybrid optoelectronic solar cells

We have demonstrated that a key degradation route of hybrid perovskite solar cells is via the formation of new hydrated crystal structures in the presence of water vapour. The hydration process is partially reversible so that the loss of photovoltaic performance caused by exposure to water vapour can be recovered if they are dried out. These observations are critical for developing strategies to improve the processing methods and stability of this class of material.

We have unravelled the causes of hysteresis in hybrid perovskite solar cells. These devices show photovoltaic behaviour that is dependent on their operational history and the phenomenon represents a major issue for the technology. We have shown that the hysteresis is almost certainly caused by the migration of charged ions through the material in combination with recombination of charge carriers at the interfaces. We have also shown that the effect is unlikely to result from ferroelectric effects which were also hypothesised as a possible cause. The simulation code for this project has been made available open source on GitHub.

New methods

We have found a new method to calculate the reorganisation energy for intermolecular charge transfer from first principles that properly accounts for the effects of the solvent medium (and substrate) surrounding the molecules. Our approach is useful for calculating the rates of charge transfer in dye sensitised solar cells, and is also more generally for assessing charge transfer of molecules in polar media, as well as validating first principle calculations.

We have developed two techniques to accurately measure the diffusion coefficient of holes in monolayers at both macroscopic and nanometre length scales. These methods correlated well and are essential for assessing the performance of molecules for 2D wiring applications.
We have developed a comprehensive set of optoelectronic tools to determine charge concentration, charge transport, charge recombination in dye and semiconductor solar cells, and hybrid perovskite solar cells. These tools allow the factors limiting the performance of photovoltaic devices to be determined enabling their design to be optimised. We have also now developed methods to accurately calculate the propagation of light through diffuse media.

Development of stability testing for dye, organic and hybrid perovskite solar cells. Using cheap light emitting diodes we have developed an approach to rapidly test the stability of these solar cells to high light intensities. The system then uses the optoelectronic toolbox we have developed to diagnose the underlying degradation methods.
Exploitation Route Our findings on the stability and hysteresis seen in hybrid perovskite solar cells will be of central importance to dealing with the problems of commercialising the technology. We plan to calculate stability phase diagrams to precisely quantify the limitations of the current materials. We are collaborating with the SPECIFIC project in Swansea to assess the industrial and scale up prospects for this class of perovskites.

Our results also suggest that hybrid perovskites might have significant potential for neuromorphic computing applications.

Further development of stable high hole mobility dyes could lead to simplified solid state solar. This work remains at a research phase primarily due to the relatively poor stabilities of the dyes.
Sectors Electronics,Energy,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology

URL http://www.imperial.ac.uk/people/piers.barnes
 
Description We have ongoing interactions with the company G24 power who manufacture dye sensitised cells for use in portable electronic devices. In particular in relation to their characterisation of these devices We are now collaborating with the company Ossila, examining the reasons underlying the variation seen in different grades of their prototype materials developed for the fabrication of hybrid perovskite solar cells. Interactions begun with Arc Electronics for potential use of hybrid perovskite devices as memristors in neuromorphic computing applications. Dissemination beyond the scientific community. We have made our drift-diffusion computer code (Driftfusion) used to simulated mixed semiconductor and ionic conductors available open source. This is of use for simulating perovskite solar cells as well as being potentially useful for systems such as batteries. We have presented demonstrations and public lectures of the science underlying solution processable solar technologies at a range of science fairs including the Imperial Festival, the solar sparks programme, the Big Bang science fair, and an award presentation at the British Science Festival. I've also been involved in Rise programme meeting MPs including Zach Goldsmith to discuss alternative solar technologies.
Sector Electronics,Energy
Impact Types Societal,Economic

 
Description Hybrid perovskite degradation routes 
Organisation Ludwig-Maximilians-University Hospital
Country Germany 
Sector Hospitals 
PI Contribution LMU - in situ XRD of hybrid perovskite films undergoing degradation, AFM ICL - spectroscopic elipsometry of films undergoing degradation + optoelectronic measurements of devices exposed to same conditions
Collaborator Contribution Collaboration with Dr Pablo Docampo on the effects of water vapour on the processing and degradation of hybrid perovskite materials. We established key degradation routes
Impact Reversible hydration of CH3NH3PbI3 in films, single crystals, and solar cells Authors Aure´lien MA Leguy, Yinghong Hu, Mariano Campoy-Quiles, M Isabel Alonso, Oliver J Weber, Pooya Azarhoosh, Mark Van Schilfgaarde, Mark T Weller, Thomas Bein, Jenny Nelson, Pablo Docampo, Piers RF Barnes Publication date 2015/4/22 Journal Chemistry of Materials Volume 27 Issue 9 Pages 3397-3407 Publisher American Chemical Society The Influence of Water Vapor on the Stability and Processing of Hybrid Perovskite Solar Cells Made from Non-Stoichiometric Precursor Mixtures Authors Michiel L Petrus, Yinghong Hu, Davide Moia, Philip Calado, Aurélien Leguy, Piers RF Barnes, Pablo Docampo Publication date 2016/9/22 Journal ChemSusChem Volume 9 Issue 18 Pages 2699-2707
Start Year 2014
 
Title Driftfusion 
Description First official release of Driftfusion. The recent application of lead-halide perovskites as an active layer material in thin film semiconductor devices including solar cells, light emitting diodes (LEDs), and memristors has motivated the development of several new drift-diffusion models that can include the effects of both mobile electronic and ionic charge carriers. Here, we present Driftfusion, a versatile simulation tool built for simulating one-dimensional ordered semiconductor devices with mixed ionic-electronic conducting layers. Driftfusion enables users to simulate devices with virtually any number of layers and with up to four charge carrier species (electrons and holes by default plus up to two ionic species). The time-dependent carrier continuity equations are fully-coupled to Poisson's equation enabling transient optoelectronic device measurement protocols to be simulated. In addition to the material parameters, users have direct access to adapt carrier transport, recombination and generation models as well as the system boundary conditions. Furthermore, a graded-interface approach circumvents the requirement for boundary conditions at material interfaces and enables interface-specific properties, such as high rates of interfacial recombination, to be introduced. 
Type Of Technology Software 
Year Produced 2020 
Open Source License? Yes  
URL https://zenodo.org/record/3670155
 
Title Driftfusion 
Description First official release of Driftfusion. The recent application of lead-halide perovskites as an active layer material in thin film semiconductor devices including solar cells, light emitting diodes (LEDs), and memristors has motivated the development of several new drift-diffusion models that can include the effects of both mobile electronic and ionic charge carriers. Here, we present Driftfusion, a versatile simulation tool built for simulating one-dimensional ordered semiconductor devices with mixed ionic-electronic conducting layers. Driftfusion enables users to simulate devices with virtually any number of layers and with up to four charge carrier species (electrons and holes by default plus up to two ionic species). The time-dependent carrier continuity equations are fully-coupled to Poisson's equation enabling transient optoelectronic device measurement protocols to be simulated. In addition to the material parameters, users have direct access to adapt carrier transport, recombination and generation models as well as the system boundary conditions. Furthermore, a graded-interface approach circumvents the requirement for boundary conditions at material interfaces and enables interface-specific properties, such as high rates of interfacial recombination, to be introduced. 
Type Of Technology Software 
Year Produced 2020 
Open Source License? Yes  
URL https://zenodo.org/record/3670154