Defining and Measuring Communication Flexibility for Smart Logistics

Lead Research Organisation: CARDIFF UNIVERSITY
Department Name: Cardiff Business School

Abstract

The provision of logistics services relies heavily on effective intra- and particularly inter-organisational information exchange and communication to which ICT is seen as a key enabler. Effective communication among shippers (consignors), carriers and customers (consignees) helps to foster collaborative relationships, reduce uncertainties and performance-related errors, thereby enhancing operational efficiency and customer responsiveness. Innovative logistics practices that are based on the use of the state-of-art technologies are often referred to as 'smart logistics', i.e. flexible and able to cope with uncertainties.

The proposed research is about understanding how increased connectivity and visibility enabled by recent advances in ICT, particularly the Internet, could be harnessed for innovative logistics provisions ('smart logistics') through the lens of defining and measuring communication flexibility. Even though much attention has been focused on the logistics flexibility concept in recent years, one critical dimension is missing - namely, communication flexibility. While the profound effect of ICT in supporting flexible operations, be it at supply chain level or manufacturing level, is well recognised, academic researchers need a more rigorous approach in assessing inter-organisational communication within the logistics context. This is the major driver and novelty of this proposal. Inter-organisational communication flexibility here is defined as the extent to which the firms are able to configure and reconfigure their information linkages in responding to the changing environment.

The main objectives are to develop a conceptual model capturing the key indicators of communication flexibility and subsequently validate the model using a large scale survey. As a result, an appropriate method for assessing the level of communication flexibility and its impact to logistics performance will be established, thus laying the foundation for this important yet largely overlooked subject. The data required for this research will be acquired through three focus group discussions, six case studies and a survey of seven hundred plus companies targeting shippers, carriers and ICT providers in the UK.

The proposed research is also timely; as it investigates and consolidates the key emerging technologies in the logistics field for instance real time tracking technologies using Global Positioning System (GPS) and electronic logistics marketplaces based on cloud computing solutions. Used separately or in combination they will facilitate interorganisational communication at different levels. Such technologies only emerged recently and therefore by incorporating them, this study advances and updates our knowledge towards the use of ICT in the logistics field. Consequently this research is of great value to practitioners as it will guide them to make sense out of and leverage such emerging technologies for competitive advantages.

Planned Impact

In addition to academic beneficiaries identified in the previous section, there are a large audience of industrial beneficiaries; shippers and customers from various sectors (e.g. retailing, manufacturing and construction), carriers of various transport modes (e.g. 4th-party logistics service providers, haulage companies, port and rail operators) and technology providers (e.g. ICT consulting companies, software, hardware and network application providers).

The proposed research adopts a two-way engagement mechanism with them. During the research, the use of focus group discussions and field visits to case companies will yield direct inputs from industry and meanwhile provide a platform for cross-learning between industries and between industry and academia. The interim and final dissemination of research findings will help to raise the awareness of how the emerging ICTs could help businesses to achieve competitive advantages and stimulate the adoption of technological and business innovations. Four knowledge-sharing methods will be deployed in order to realise the potential impact and enable a wide reach to UK's logistics practitioners: one industrial dissemination workshop, one Knowledge Transfer Network (KTN) event, two trade articles for Logistics Focus (with readership of around 55,000) and two dedicated pages via the host institution's website and the online platform Knowledge Transfer Network (KTN) which is under the auspices of Technology Strategy Board. In order to encourage the industrial take-up of the research findings, the applicant will also utilise the industrial network she has established for the one-to-one exploitation of the research findings. This will then lead to the exploration of setting up longer term Knowledge Transfer Partnerships (KTPs) when industrial partners are determined in adopting a specific ICT development and need to access skills and expertise possessed by the applicant. Two KTP proposals are anticipated at the end of the project.

Other beneficiaries include the research associate (RA) for the proposed project and students at the applicant's home school. The RA will directly benefit from conducting the proposed research. She or he will acquire and develop a set of critical research skills; for instance statistical analysis skills, interviewing and presentation skills with the mentoring and coaching from the PI and the department as a whole. The Continuing Professional Development training will be also provided which is a dedicated programme designed for researchers at the applicant's home institute.

The research findings will be used to inform the research-led teaching with both undergraduates and postgraduates. For instance, the applicant is the module leader for a postgraduate module BST123 E-commerce and Information Technology where the annual intake of students is around 120. The size of impact for undergraduates is smaller at around 30. However the impact can be substantial in improving our students' future employability. For instance, one of the students from the cohort 2009-2010 was offered a job immediately after interview by the multinational United Biscuits, due to the knowledge she acquired from the investigator's lecture on ELMs. The impact on student knowledge and capacity building in general, however, tends to be longer term throughout the students' academic life and future professional career.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description 1. We illustrated how data integrity, an often ignored matter, siginificantly impacts organisational performance.
2. We have identified how ICT impacts on CO2 emission in road freight transport operation.
3. We have developed a conceputual framework on how ICT supports both intra and inter-organisation communication flexibility and further validated via emprical research.
4. We demystified 'information sharing' in the supply chain by developing the concept of scaffolding.
5. We studied the impact of ICT community system such as port community system both at a micro level on supply chain and at a more macro-level on regional competitiveness.
Exploitation Route For academics, they could build on the research and explore further the implications the emerging technologies on the landscape of e-logistics.
For practitioners, there are a few take-aways from our e-logistics books from the specfic RFID implementation, telematics and cloud computing to single window system at national level. Our communication flexibility model can be used as a guild to build information linkages between organisations for competitive advantages.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Construction,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Retail,Transport

 
Description We've published the world's first most comprehensive book on e-logistics in March 2016. This book is a joint effort from both academics and senior practitioners such as Amazon, Portbase and BT. The target audiance is on both academics and practitioners in the supply chain and logistics field. One of the research publications (Harris, Wang et al 2015) has been one of the most downloaded articles of International Journal of Production Economics (over 39,500 downloads as of this writing). Paper [Han et al 2017] is also becoming one of the most downloaded articles (over 6,200 downloads). The report entitled Understanding the Impact of Emerging Technologies on the Freight Sector (2018) was commissioned by the Government Office for Science to inform future policy decisions on mobility within the UK government. This report is been published and now available at the Government Office for Science's website https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/future-of-mobility-emerging-technologies-and-uk-freight-sector. In addition, Dr. Yingli Wang has recently been invited by World Economic Forum (WEF) as an expert to participate its blockchain for supply chain project and is now as one of the lead authors on a number of white papers.
Sector Construction,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Education,Government, Democracy and Justice,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Retail,Transport
Impact Types Societal,Economic,Policy & public services

 
Description Emerging technologies in the freight transport sector
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Contribution to a national consultation/review
 
Description Evidencing the Effectiveness of the West of England Academic Health Science Network
Amount £250,000 (GBP)
Organisation West of England Academic Health Science Network 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 12/2013 
End 11/2018
 
Description Highways England R&D funds
Amount £62,290 (GBP)
Organisation Department of Transport 
Department Highways Agency
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 11/2015 
End 11/2016
 
Description Re-designing turst: blockchain for supply chains
Amount £5,275 (GBP)
Organisation Economic and Social Research Council 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 06/2019 
End 05/2020
 
Description Return to Sender! Analyzing the sustainability of the reverse logistics of clothing (r)e-tailers.
Amount 2,500,000 kr (SEK)
Funding ID 43182-1 
Organisation Swedish Energy Agency 
Sector Public
Country Sweden
Start 12/2016 
End 12/2018
 
Title Survey data: definining and measuring communication flexibility for smart logistics 
Description This is a survey data set that holds all respondents' responses in our questionnaire survey. The primary aim of this survey was to statistically test a structural equation model of IT flexibility and its direct & indirect impact on firm performance. The questionnaire was divided into five sections (A-E). Section A is to provide the respondents' organisation and the types of ICT utilised. Section B provides a list of questions covering the three types of IT flexibility by which respondents have to provide responses via a 7-point Likert scale ranging from strongly agree to strongly disagree. Questions in Section C are indicators of a construct (Process Integration Capability) while Section D is about firm performance. Finally Section E asks the general background information of the respondents themselves. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2017 
Provided To Others? Yes