Biofilm disruption by cavitation generated by dental ultrasonic instrumentation

Lead Research Organisation: University of Birmingham
Department Name: Dentistry

Abstract

This proposed programme of research builds on an existing strong partnership between the Universities of Birmingham and Bath, which bridges the interdisciplinary boundary between oral sciences and chemistry. The bacterial biofilm is a persistent factor in causing and prolonging infection in the mouth. We will target its removal through a new generation of dental instruments that will use cavitation to disrupt the biofilm. This work has direct relevance to patient treatment and the commercial development of new instrumentation. New clinical devices will be designed using the specialised technology developed from our research, to successfully overcome the challenges of removing deposits from teeth whether outside (the tooth root surface or implant surfaces) or inside (the root canal). Furthermore there is good potential for further commercial translation of the research findings from this project, illustrated by our relationship with Dentsply USA who contracted Professor Walmsley to deliver fact finding research and publications on their range of instruments. Therefore our research output will be of interest to manufactures of such instruments. Hence, we believe that the predictors for success for this proposal are high. Disruption of bacterial biofilms on teeth will provide a tremendous clinical advantage in periodontal and endodontic treatment, leading to a new range of instruments, which can be extended to cleaning hard to reach places. The results have a potential translational application to non-dental applications where the removal of and prevention of regrowth of the biofilm is paramount to success.

Planned Impact

The primary beneficiaries of our work will ultimately be patients who will leave the dentist's chair with cleaner, better treated teeth. This means better oral hygiene and so, in the long term, less dental disease, fewer non-routine visits to the dentist, less loss of earnings and better quality of also gain life. It should make a significant contribution to improving patient treatment. Dental practitioners will benefit from this improved treatment through consequent better use of resources. Further impact of the work will be felt by researchers both in academic and clinical practice. The fundamental science will be applicable in a number of areas, some related such as endodontics and others apparently not directly related such as ultrasonic cleaning of machine parts. Our Advisory Committee and clinical collaborators will be particularly important in ensuring that the results of our work will enter clinical practice. Finally, a successful system would be worthy of commercial exploitation for wealth creation, possibly through the creation of a spin-out company or license from a manufacturer.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description We have mapped the cavitation around the ultrasonic scalers and have commenced the removal of artificial biofilm both on natural teeth and on titanium. The latter mimics the dental implants that are used to replace teeth. Our work has been disseminated widely in publications and presentations to both researchers and end users. We have been contracted by industry to undertake research in this area and the activity is ongoing.
Exploitation Route We have moved forward on the research by using high speed cameras from the EPSRC Instrument loan pool. We are now observing how the biofilm is removed from the surface of the teeth. The work of preparing an artificial biofilm is of interest to manufacturers and we were approached by Unilever to look at using these models in evaluating their toothpastes. We have undertaken work for Dentsply on their instruments which showed that their movement was different to what they had envisaged. We have presented our work to clinicians who are the end users of this research and this has led to new avenues of research on the instruments.
Sectors Healthcare,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology

 
Description This research looks at how biofilm may be disrupted by ultrasonic scalers. It has become of interest to manufacturers of ultrasonic scalers and we are in discussion as to how these instruments may be used to remove it from teeth and implants. I have participated in giving talks on behalf of an international manufacturer (Dentsply Sirona) to promote our findings. This has taken the form of international training days in Hamburg 2016 and London 2017. Our work is cited on several manufacturer's website as references and this is embedded in the clinical use of these instruments. The manufacturers of ultrasonic scalers reside outside the UK and therefore it is difficult to produce major changes in their approach to the use of the instruments. A way forward is to commercialise out ideas and we have applied for follow on funding to take our ideas forward but were unsuccessful in the peer review process. The grant EP/P015743/1 has been an extension of grant EP/P015743/1 and we have published many more papers that are now being picked up and cited in the dental literature. Where it is possible to view clinical material about ultrasonic scalers on the web for education of clinicians then our work is always cited. It is fully embedded in the literature and in education of clinicians. The difficulty has been translating it from an educational prospective to convincing the major manufacturers of changes in the design of the equipment. Following on from COVID19, such instruments will require a redesign as they produce aerosols. Our work does show that the cleaning can be done using cavitation in the cooling water. Ideas may be that this can take place with reduced aerosol production. EP/J014060/1 researched the biofilm disruption by cavitation generated by ultrasonic instrumentation and the following one EP/P015743/1 Maximising cavitation to clean dental implants is the subject of a video publication in the Journal of visualised experiments. This publication contains a narrative of how we imaged quantified fast moving micro bubbles that would be used in the removal of dental plaque. Prof Walmsley is contributing a dental chapter to the global engineering book on "High Power Applications of Ultrasound" and this will cite many of our articles published with support from the EPSRC and UKRI. Full acknowledgement of the funding will be given. This book will be the "bible" of high power applications in dentistry and may be the vehicle which will see future changes in ultrasonic scaler design by manufacturers.
First Year Of Impact 2014
Sector Healthcare
Impact Types Economic

 
Description Public Engagement 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Filmed for TV programme "Fake Britain" and showed the use of Scanning Laser Vibrometry to determine wether dental drills were cheap fake replacements for the real dental drill. This has huge public interest as dentists may be inadvertently buying equipment that may have dangerous consequences in patient's mouths.

This is leading to interaction with industry and highlighting
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014