THE INFLUENCE OF SAND-MUD INTERACTIONS ON MIXED SEDIMENT DYNAMICS

Lead Research Organisation: Heriot-Watt University
Department Name: Sch of the Built Environment

Abstract

Estuaries and near-shore coastal zones are amongst the most productive, dynamic and complex ecosystems in the world. Their high environmental, social and economic value is reflected in EU and UK government policy through legislation targeted at managing these assets in sustainable and integrated ways. This policy is tasked with balancing future economic growth from continued human activities (e.g. ports, navigation, marine renewables), socio-economic impacts from increasing coastal erosion and flood risk, and the protection and enhancement of sensitive habitats and ecosystems. Under these competing demands, there is an urgent need for coordinated sediment management plans for UK estuaries and coastal regions to ensure sustainable practices are implemented and improved resilience in future planning strategies is realised.

To achieve these challenging goals, it is vital that engineers and scientists have the fundamental understanding of physical processes controlling the dynamic behaviour of sediments in estuarine and coastal systems and their role in large-scale morphological evolution. One of the biggest challenges to this, however, is a current lack of knowledge on the behaviour of mixed bed sediments that contain both non-cohesive sands and cohesive muds. Critical shortcomings in current estuarine and coastal modelling systems typically relate to their inadequate representation of important small-scale dynamical processes associated with these sand-mud mixtures including erosion, entrainment, flocculation, settling and deposition. As a consequence, the sensitivity of many estuaries and near-shore coastal regions to future impacts from climate change and anthropogenic development is currently subject to a high degree of uncertainty.

The proposed project will address these shortcomings in a systematic way. The research programme includes fundamental experimental studies in sophisticated settling column and benthic annular flume facilities to investigate these mixed sediment processes in greater quantitative detail than previously undertaken. This experimental work will be complemented by novel analytical model developments to provide better understanding of mixed sediment flocculation and differential settling processes through more physics-based descriptions of the important sand-mud interactions involved. A key outcome from this research will be to establish, for the first time, important linkages between these sand-mud interactions within mixed sediment suspensions and the resulting structural and compositional characteristics of mixed sediment bed deposits. The combined experimental data and analytical model outputs from this project will underpin the development of advanced numerical models required for the development of more sustainable and resilient estuarine and coastal sediment management strategies in the future.

Planned Impact

The potential beneficiaries from the research outcomes of this project will include: academic researchers (e.g. universities and research institutes); regulatory bodies and statutory consultants (e.g. SEPA, EA, Marine Scotland); environmental consultants and modellers; port authorities; marine renewables developers; and the UK and Scottish Governments.

From an economic perspective, a wide range of industry sectors are dependent on functional estuaries (e.g. ports, marine renewables, aggregate/sand extraction, aquaculture and fisheries, land reclamation, water abstraction, etc.). However, the economic success of many of these sectors depends entirely on the adoption of appropriate sediment management schemes to ensure both navigational access and minimal requirement for on-going remedial measures (e.g. maintenance dredging) within these environments. Intuitively, such anthropogenic interventions will lead to regional alterations to sediment sources (budgets), transport pathways and sinks, as well as local scour and sediment redistribution around individual marine structures. In this regard, the proposed project will provide much-needed clarity in the fundamental understanding mixed (sand-mud) sediment transport processes, typically encountered in these estuarine and near-shore environments. This will benefit future economic growth within these sectors by driving improvements in the representation of these processes within fully-coupled, integrated coastal modelling systems, required to improve current spatial planning practices and ensure more efficient and sustainable development within these environments. This is particularly crucial for the UK marine renewable energy sector to maintain its competitive advantage in the global market.

Recent UK Flood and Coastal Erosion Risk Management (FCERM) research strategy also highlights research into sediment management as being an urgent priority for political and operational drivers relating to the socio-economic impacts of coastal erosion and flooding. In the UK, over at least 6 million properties are "at risk" of flooding from a wide range of sources including rivers, estuaries, coastal waters and groundwater; while in Scotland alone, over 30,000 are known to be at direct risk from coastal flooding. This is especially pertinent given that these current risk levels are likely to increase under growing climatic and socio-ecomonic pressures. Similarly, pressures are also prevalent from an environmental perspective as estuaries and coastal zones are often made up of highly-productive habitats and ecosystems that are protected under existing EU legislation (e.g. Water Framework Directive, Birds and Habitats Directives). As such, the integration of ecological and socio-economic values is increasingly advocated within near-shore spatial planning as being essential to ensure sustainable development within these enviroments. Thus, through improved linkages between mixed sediment transport and morphological processes, the project outcomes will inform the development of integrated and adaptive management strategies that are both resilient to this increasing flooding and erosion risk, whilst ensuring protection of these important and sensitive ecosystems.

To this end, the proposed project aims to deliver research outputs focused on fundamental processes such as sand-mud erosion, flocculation, settling and deposition that will facilitate improved prediction of mixed sediment sources, transport pathways and sinks within regional-scale transport and morphological models. The critical pathway towards realising the socio-economic and environmental impacts and benefits from the proposed research will be delivered through the immediate availability of project outputs that are strategically beneficial to UK engineering consultancies, marine scientists and governmental agencies tasked with legislation and policy implementation.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Parametric experimental studies investigating the dynamic behaviour of mixed sediments have been undertaken to gain new knowledge on (i) small scale fluid-sediment interactions controlling the flocculation and settling characteristics of sand-mud suspensions, and (ii) sedimentation processes leading to the development of mixed and segregated bed layers within sand-mud bed deposits. Better fundamental understanding of these processes is essential to improve their representation within estuarine and coastal sediment transport models tasked with accurately predicting transport fluxes and morphodynamic change within these mixed sedimentary environments.

Main findings and developments from study are as follows:

(i) Development and application of new measurement techniques and characterisation of sand-mud deposits (WP2):

An electrical resistivity profiling technique has been developed and applied successfully to characterise layer segregation within mixed sediment (sand-clay) deposits under natural sedimentation processes. Calibration of this resistiviry technique has also enabled the depthwise variation of more physically-relevant parameters such as bulk density, volumetric concentration and porosity to be established for these deposits. Application of this electrical resistivity technique to investigate the natural sedimentation from mixed (sand-clay) suspensions has revealed the formation of distinctive bed deposit structures, with the degree of segregation found to be dependent largely on the initial mixture composition within the suspension. The proposed physical mechanisms under which this bed segregation occurs has also been demonstrated qualitatively by the application of a polydisperse, hindered settling model for cohesive and non-cohesive sediment mixtures. The findings from work have been submitted as a journal paper and are currently under review in Ocean Dynamics.

The resistivity technique has also been adapted successfully to study the restructuring of mixed sediment beds when subjected to cyclic erosion/deposition events generated within benthic annular flume experiments (i.e. Voyager I and II benthic flumes provided by PARTRAC Ltd.). These experiments were designed and conducted to attempt to better simulate the response of mixed sediment beds to cyclic tidal currents, as commonly encountered in dynamic estuarine environments. Findings indicate that bed mixtures with relatively low mud contents (< 5% clay by weight) were mobilised under higher shear conditions, resulting in the development of bed forms (i.e. ripples and dunes) and sand-mud segregation within the upper mobilised layer. By contrast, for mixtures with higher mud contents (> 7% clay by mass), there was little indication of the development of bed forms or sand-mud segregation under the same cyclic flow conditions. This work was presented at INTERCOH 2015 and will be submitted as a journal paper in due course.

(ii) Findings from grid-stirred settling column experiments on flocculation of sand-mud mixtures (WP1 & WP3):

Parametric experiments have been conducted within a sophisticated grid-stirred settling column to investigate flocculation processes for sand-mud mixtures. Results from the tests indicate that flocculation properties such as aggregation rates (i.e. floc development) and the maximal floc sizes generated within the column are strongly affected by external parameters including: (i) suspension composition (sand-mud ratio), (ii) total suspended sediment (TSS) concentration within the column, (iii) turbulent shear levels generated by the oscillating grids, and (iv) water salinity. In this regard, the largest flocs were typically generated for clay-only suspensions within brackish water, under high TSS and low turbulent shear levels, with the addition of sand to the column shown to reduce the maximal size of flocs generated, whilst having negligible effect on root-mean-square floc sizes. Within individual runs, floc sizes were shown to increase non-linearly with increasing TSS concentrations within the column, potentially due to (i) temporal lag effects in floc development rates (i.e. under non-equilibrium conditions); and (ii) the additional influence of sand particles in inhibiting floc growth through differential settling effects and direct sand particle collisions with flocs. At the end of individual runs, once TSS concentrations had typically stabilised within the column, floc sizes generated in both mud-only and sand-mud suspensions were shown to scale well with a dimensional parameter incorporating both TSS and shear rate G, similar to (but varying from) previous flocculation studies conducted under so-called equilibrium conditions.

A numerical model has been developed employing a poly-disperse, population balance technique (PDM) within a simplified 1DV model framework to investigate flocculation and settling characteristics under the parametric conditions tested within the experimental runs. Simulations have shown the the temporal change in TSS concentrations within the settling column and corresponding changes to representative root-mean-square and maximal floc sizes can be simulated well by this approach for mud-only (i.e. mono-disperse) suspensions. For sand-mud suspensions, it is proposed that additional break-up mechanisms can account for the direct influence of sand particles in inhibiting the development of mud flocs within the column, as demonstrated within the experiments themselves. This numerical modelling work is has been completed and a journal paper on the joint experimental and numerical study entitled "Model Studies for Flocculation of Sand-Clay Mixtures" has now been published in Coastal Engineering (Elsevier) (IF 2.84) in December 2016.
Exploitation Route Development of the new methodology for characterising mixed sediment deposits has been taken forward through the award of an EPSRC IAA grant award to support development of advanced alb and field-based versions of the measurement technique, in collaboration with an industry partner (see Collaborations & Partnerships). In a wider context, results from the experimental studies will inform academics and industry stakeholders of new knowledge associated with the dynamic behaviour of mixed sediments, which is especially crucial to improving current modelling capabilities (sediment transport; bed morphology) within estuaries and near-shore coastal regions.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Energy,Environment

 
Description The project outcomes, and the development of an electrical resistivity technique for the characterisation of structure and composition of mixed (sand-mud) sediment deposits, in particular, have been presented at high-profile international conferences including: INTERCOH 2013; 2014 EGU General Assembly; 36th IAHR World Congress; and INTERCOH 2015. This has generated significant interest from both external UK research groups and industrial project stakeholders (e.g. PARTRAC Ltd; HR Wallingford) in relation to enhanced field measurements of coastal/marine sediment transport processes. The PI has also be invited to participate in two Special Interest Groups (SIGs) of the UK Fluids Network, namely "Experimental Flow Diagnostics" and "Granular Flows in the Environment and Industry", and gave an invited talk at the MASTS Numerical and Experimental Hydrodynamic Modelling Forum Workshop in April 2018. The outcomes from the work have also motivated applications and awards for additional funding through an EPSRC IAA award (£50k) and a Carnegie Trust Research Incentive Grant (£7.5k) to further develop laboratory and field measurement techniques for sand-mud characterisation. The IAA award, in particular, supported an inward industry secondment to Heriot Watt of a marine scientist from PARTRAC Ltd to work on laboratory/ field characterisation techniques for investigating the response of sand-mud bed layers to cyclic hydrodynamic forcing (i.e. mimicking the effect of cyclic tidal currents), with the aim of benchmarking laboratory studies of cyclic erosion, deposition and segregation within idealized sand-mud sediment beds with equivalent measurements at an estuarine field site (Eden estuary, St Andrews). The experimental findings and modelling studies conducted during the grant are also forming the basis for further applications for additional research funding in the form of a proposed Early-Career EPSRC Fellowship application in the priority theme of Particle Technology and a Royal Society application to the Paul Instrument Fund. Both these applications were submitted in Spring/Summer 2017 and were unfortunately unsuccessful. A further research funding application, building on the methodologies and findings generated in the funded EPSRC project, was made to NERC Highlight Topics 2018 call on Topic A: Emerging risks from microplastics in the marine environment. Again, unfortunately, this research proposal was not funded.
First Year Of Impact 2013
Sector Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Environment,Other
Impact Types Economic

 
Description EPSRC Impact Acceleration (EP/K503915/1)
Amount £50,000 (GBP)
Funding ID EP/K503915/1 
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2014 
End 08/2015
 
Description Research Incentive Grants
Amount £7,500 (GBP)
Organisation Carnegie Trust 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2015 
End 03/2016
 
Title In-situ electrical resistivity technique for characterisation of mixed sediment deposits 
Description An in-situ electrical measurement technique has been developed to characterise the structure and composition of saturated sand-clay bed deposits, based on high-resolution resistivity measurements. While this development work to date has focussed on idealised sand-clay deposits formed under differential settling conditions within a settling column, the work has particularly relevance to mixed sediment environments, such as estuaries and near-shore coastal regions, where the combined action of tidal flows and waves can result in structural heterogeneity and sand-mud segregation within resulting bed deposits. The technique has subsequently been developed to provide detailed, in-situ, field profile measurements of electrical resistivity in order to characterise the substrate structure and composition of estuarine bed deposits that include a wider range of natural mixed sediments (sands, silts, muds, organics). This work is has been conducted in collaboration with PARTRAC Ltd (see Collaborations) and was funded through an EPSRC IAA award and a Carnegie Trust Research Incentive grant. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Interest in the technique has recently been expressed by another research group in the UK (with interests in marine renewables), presenting potential collaboration opportunities. Furthermore, discussions are ongoing with HR Wallingford, regarding the possibility of future developments of this field characterisation technique as part of a wider application for an EPSRC Industry CASE award. 
 
Description Enhanced Characterisation of Mixed Sediment Dynamics: Application of Lab-Based Techniques in the Field 
Organisation Partrac
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Following on from EPSRC Grant EP/K015117/1, funding has been obtained from an EPSRC Impact Acceleration Account (IAA) award (£50k) for secondment of a Partrac Scientist to Heriot Watt to assist in the development and application of lab and field-based measurement technique for characteristing mixed sediment deposits within estuaries and near-shore coastal regions.
Collaborator Contribution Within this project, Partrac provided support in (i) the development and testing of the laboratory and field-based measurement systems, (ii) the supply of specialist equipment and instrumentation, and (ii) the development of field survey work protocols for assessing the field-based measurement technique at an appropriate estuarine test-site (Eden estuary, Fife, UK).
Impact The project has lead to the development and testing of (i) a laboratory characterisation technique, based on electrical resistivity measurements, to measure the response of mixed (sand-clay) sediment beds to cyclic hydrodynamic forcing generated within a benthic annular flume (i.e. representing the influence of cyclic tidal currents), and (ii) a prototype field-based electrical resistivity profiling technique to investigate in-situ characterisation of discontinuities in subsurface composition within intertidal estuarine beds (i.e. Eden estuary, Fife, UK). This work was presented at the 13th International Conference on Cohesive Sediment Transport Processes (INTERCOH2015) in September 2015 (ISBN: 978-94-920430-8-5; ISSN:1377-0950) and it is anticipated that a journal paper will be prepared later in 2016 on this work.
Start Year 2015
 
Description EGU General Assembly 2014 (Vienna) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Type Of Presentation poster presentation
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact Presentation of a poster at EGU on preliminary research findings from EPSRC Grant EP/K015117/1 resulted in detailed and in-depth discussions with academics in the field of cohesive and mixed sediment dynamics.

Invitations received to collaborate on future research topics of common interest.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
URL http://www.egu2014.eu/home.html
 
Description International Conference Presentation at INTERCOH2015 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact Around 120 delegates from academia, industry and government agencies attended my presentation at INTERCOH2015, which sparked questions and discussions afterwards. Follow-up discussions with industry practitioners provided potential new avenues for further research.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
 
Description International Conference on Cohesive Sediment Transport Processes Intercoh 2013 (Florida) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Type Of Presentation paper presentation
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact Around 60 delegates attended the presentation, which was followed by questions and discussions on the research.

The activity sparked a number of follow-up requests for information on the research methodology presented.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
URL http://plaza.ufl.edu/khareyogesh1/intercoh.html
 
Description Invited Participant at UK Fluids Network Meeting (Special Interests Group in Granular Flows) (Cambridge) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact This is the first meeting for the UK Fluids Network Special Interest Group (SIG) in "Granular flows in the environment and industry" on Thursday, March 30th and Friday, March 31st in Cambridge. The theme of the meeting is for researchers within the SIG to get to know each other, develop collaborative research teams, and to identify and outline the big questions in granular research, with the end outcome being the development of future research projects and industry engagement within this theme.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL https://www.ukfluids.net/
 
Description Invited presentation at Marine Alliance for Science and Technology in Scotland (MASTS) Numerical and Experimental Hydrodynamic Modelling Forum Meeting 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Presentation entitled "Experimental and Numerical Studies on Flocculation of Sand-Mud Suspensions" to be given at the Marine Alliance for Science and Technology in Scotland (MASTS) Numerical and Experimental Hydrodynamic Modelling Forum Meeting to be held in Edinburgh on 19th April 2018.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description Membership of UK Fluids Network - Special Interest Groups (SIGs) in "Experimental Flow Diagnostics" and "Granular Flows in the Environment and Industry" 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact Invited participation in two Special Interest Groups of the UK Fluids Network, namely "Experimental Flow Diagnostics" (Graham Hughes, Imperial College London; Stuart Dalziel, Cambridge University) and "Granular Flows in the Environment and Industry" (Nathalie Vriend, Cambridge University). These groups will feature regular workshop meetings within the aim of develop new research areas, enhance engagement/collaboration with industry, create doctoral training partnerships, improve undergraduate/postgraduate teaching, etc.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL https://www.ukfluids.net/
 
Description Organisation of Research Seminar in Fluid Mud 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an open day or visit at my research institution
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact This seminar entitled "Nautical Depth Solutions to Fluid Mud in Channels", given by Prof. William H McInally, Professor of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Mississippi State University, was attended by academics, research staff, PhD and MSc students. Prof. McInally's presentation initiated a stimulating debate concerning the best way to deal with fluid mud problems within estuaries.

This seminar raised general awareness within the group of practical problems that require impoved understanding of the dynamics of cohesive sediments within natural aquatic environments.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
 
Description Participant at the UK Fluids Group Meeting of Special Interests Group on Granular Flows at the University of Sheffield (Sept 2017) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact This was the second meeting of the UK Fluids Network Special Interest Group (SIG) in "Granular flows in the environment and industry". The theme of this meeting is for researchers was about engagement with industrial sectors with interests in particulate and granular flows.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description Participation at Fluid Mud Workshop (London) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Approximately 30-40 delegates from industry and academia participated in the workshop, which promoted exchange of knowledge and ideas between academic researchers and stakeholders on the topic of fluid mud, as well as the development of future research areas of direct relevance to industry.

New contacts made with both academic and industry representatives with interests in cohesive sediment dynamics.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
URL http://events.hrwallingford.co.uk/acatalog/fluid_mud_workshop_speakers.pdf
 
Description Presentation at the 36th IAHR Congress 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact Presentation at 36th IAHR Congress in the Hague to around 50 delegates from academia and industry, which sparked questions and discussions afterwards as well as requrests for follow-up information.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015