The Use of Vegetation to Engineer Rivers for Water Quality and Ecological Status

Lead Research Organisation: University of Sheffield
Department Name: Civil and Structural Engineering

Abstract

Water resources in the UK and around the world are under increasing strain from the effects of population growth and climate change. Maintaining acceptable water quality, ecological conditions and security of supply in UK rivers is an increasingly energy intensive and expensive exercise. A significant increase in water treatment costs and carbon emissions are expected in order to meet increasingly stringent water quality legislation. There is therefore an urgent requirement for low energy techniques to improve water quality in rivers. This proposal utilises the unique expertise of the applicant in the field of environmental hydraulics, turbulence and mixing to propose a new scientific methodology by which vegetation induced flow structures (termed mixing layers) are utilised to optimise mixing rates in open channels, thereby causing a rapid reduction in peak concentrations of potentially harmful pollutants. This will reduce the ecological impact of discharges by the rapid reduction of chronic peak pollutant concentrations and provide alternatives to costly asset investment and the energy and chemical costs of additional treatment. This proposal will utilise the experimental facilities within the Pennine Water Group at the University of Sheffield to determine the optimum vegetation characteristics (type and configuration) required to engineer maximum water quality benefits. By proposing and developing advanced environmental fluid mechanics science in order to tackle engineering and societal challenges the proposal represents a step change in the development of a physically based, integrated approach to water management. The work will be conducted in partnership with key environmental stakeholders, and once the underlying science has been established the project will work with these partners to identify routes to implementation of the methodology in field conditions.

Planned Impact

By developing techniques to use the physical properties of vegetation to rapidly reduce peak concentrations of pollutants in rivers and water bodies this proposal will mitigate rising energy and financial costs of water treatment and reduce environmental impact. Current methodologies of managing water quality by imposing increasingly strict controls on point discharge consents will become increasingly expensive in terms of energy, carbon and treatment costs as new stringent water quality legislation such as the Water Framework Directive is fully implemented. The proposal will allow more effective compliance with increasingly strenuous and sophisticated water quality legislation such as the Water Framework Directive. It is anticipated that this will also lead to a reduction in costs of treating abstracted drinking water in order to make it fit for human consumption. The primary beneficiaries of this aspect of the proposal are anticipated to be the UK water industry and its customers as well as other river stakeholders such as the Environment Agency, as well as to the environment itself. The continued supply of clean water is of critical importance for the UK economy. Pressures on water bodies are increasing due to the impacts of both climate change and increasing water demand; therefore work on sophisticated approach to water management has significant economic benefits for the UK.
There are also significant wider societal and economic benefits to improved water quality in natural water bodies and adoption of a more sustainable approach to water treatment and management. Better water quality leads to improved natural ecosystems and an increased recreational use of water bodies by the public. The value of fully functioning ecosystems has been highlighted by several recent reports such as the UK National Ecosystem Assessment (Defra, 2011). Only 26% of UK water bodies achieved good ecological status in 2009 (Water For Life, White Paper). This work therefore benefits environmental groups and members of society with interest in ecological health of water bodies (such as the Rivers Trust and Natural England), as well as the recreational users of waterways.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The main development as a result of this work to date is a novel low cost imaging based system for combined Planar Concentration Analysis and Particle Image Velocimetry. This low cost system offers measurements of 2D solute transport over larger scales than comparative Laser Induced Fluoresance approaches and higher resolution information than traditional point fluorescence measurements. We have used this new technique to quantify how the mixing of solute changes in the near wall region for the first time. This work has been published and the system is currently begin used by a PhD student to study mixing and hydrodynamics in vegetated flows.
Exploitation Route The instrumentation developed is of interest to academics conducting experimental hydraulic experiments quantifying solute transport processes. Future findings will be of use to environmental mangers seeking to mitigate the impacts of pollutants in surface water systems.
Sectors Environment

 
Description The primary development of this award to date has been the development and use of a low cost laboratory measurement system for the characterization of mixing and hydrodynamic processes in shallow open channel flows. The instrumentation and project setup has also been used to support a PhD student focused on mixing processes in vegetated systems (graduated in 2021), who is now employed at Anglian Water Services. This measurement system has been subsequently used in a number of completed and ongoing projects, for example it has been used to support grant EP/K040405/1 in the study of flow characteristics around drainage inlet structures during urban flood events. It is also currently being used in the EU infrastructure project CO-UD labs (https://co-udlabs.eu/) and will be used by research visitors on a variety of projects.
First Year Of Impact 2020
Sector Education,Environment
 
Title Large scale combined PIV and PCA system for shallow water flows 
Description The work developed a cost-effective methodology to simultaneously measure solute mixing processes and surface velocity fields in shallow flows over a spatial area using low cost cameras and lighting. Velocity fields and depth averaged concentration of a soluble fluorescent tracer can be obtained using the new techniques.The method will help to improve the understanding of 2D mixing processes in shallow open channel flows by enabling direct linkage with the velocity fields. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2018 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Method has allowed rapid characterization of solute mixing processes and velocity fields within a number of laboratory facilities at the University of Sheffield. This has helped advance a number of ongoing research projects. 
 
Description Invited Talk on Vegetated Hydrodynamics Research - Warwick 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Provided an invited talk on "Planar Concentration Analysis for Measuring Transverse Mixing in Shallow Flows" on 18th March 2015 as part of a vegetated flow research seminar hosted by the University of Warwick. The event was attended by postgraduate students, UK wide academics, water company, environment agency and environmental professional representatives.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
 
Description Invited talk at UKM University, Malaysia 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Gave a talk as part of a research seminar describing current my research involving "Mixing and pollutant transport in urban water systems" as part of a visit to UKM University Malaysia in September 2014. The audience was a mix of academics, students and professional practitioners.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
 
Description Invited talk on Vegetated Flow Research - Durham University 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Invitation to give an invited talk followed by a discussion at the school of Geography, University of Durham on "Vegetated enhanced transverse mixing in open channels flows" on 10th September 2015.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
 
Description Invited talk on Vegetated Hydrodynamics - City University London 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Invited talk at Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Research Seminar hosted at City University London on the 17th June 1014. The title of the talk was 'Research Challenges in Vegetated Flows'
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014