Dispersion of localised releases in a street network (DIPLOS)

Lead Research Organisation: University of Reading
Department Name: Meteorology

Abstract

The security threat level from international terrorism, introduced by the UK Security Service, has been classified as either "severe" or "critical" for much of its six-year history, and currently remains as "substantial" (source: MI5 web site). Part of the risk posed by terrorist threats involves potential releases of air-borne chemical, biological, radiological or nuclear (CBRN) material into highly populated urbanised areas. Smoke from industrial accidents within or in the vicinity of urban areas also pose risks to health and can cause widespread disruption to businesses, public services and residents. The Buncefield depot fire of 2005 resulted in the evacuation of hundreds of homes and closure of more than 200 schools and public buildings for two days; consequences would have been much more severe if prevailing meteorological conditions had promoted mixing or entrainment of the smoke plume into the urban canopy.

In both these scenarios it is crucial to be able to model, quickly and reliably, dispersion from localised sources through an urban street network in the short range, where the threat to human health is greatest. However, this is precisely where current operational models are least reliable because our understanding and ability to model short-range dispersion processes is limited. The contribution that DIPLOS will make is: (i) to fill in the gaps in fundamental knowledge and understanding of key dispersion processes, (ii) to enable those processes to be parametrized for use in operational models, and (iii) to implement them into an operational model, evaluate the improvement and apply the model to a case study in central London.

Most of the existing research on urban dispersion has focused on air quality aspects, with sources being extensive and distributed in space. Scientifically, the proposed research is novel in focusing on localized releases within urban areas, and on dispersion processes at short range. Through a combination of fundamental studies using wind tunnel experiments and high resolution supercomputer simulations, extensive data analysis and development of theoretical and numerical models, DIPLOS will contribute to addressing this difficult and important problem from both a scientific research and a practical, operational perspective.

Planned Impact

Beneficiaries from this research:

(1) Developers of operational dispersion models in the commercial (e.g. ECL, CERC), public (e.g. Met Office) and security (e.g. DSTL) sectors.

(2) Model users, including emergency services and regulatory bodies (e.g. Met Office, DSTL, Local Authorities).

(3) The general public.


How they will benefit:

(1) Model developers: The immediate beneficiaries of the project will be developers of operational dispersion software in the commercial, public and security sectors. This includes direct collaborators in the project, namely the developers of the SIRANE model (Ecole Centrale de Lyon, ECL), the NAME model (UK Met Office) and the UDM model (Defence Science & Technology Laboratory, DSTL) - see their respective letters of support - but also developers of other software such as ADMS (Cambridge Environmental Research Consultants, CERC). They will benefit from the increased scientific understanding that DIPLOS will generate, the specific parametrizations that we will develop and the comprehensive datasets that we will make available, allowing them to improve their respective models.

(2) Model users, including emergency services and regulatory bodies: This includes the Met Office, DSTL and also other bodies such as Health Protection Agency, Environment Agency and Local Authorities. The results of DIPLOS will help to define a hazard area, allow a more precise definition of danger in a particular event, contribute to the reliability and quantify the uncertainty of models. These are key benefits from an operational point of view.

(3) The public: The public will benefit through better emergency preparedness, aided by more reliable modelling enabled by the advances made by DIPLOS.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Comprehensive datasets have been generated by supercomputer computer simulations of turbulent flow and dispersion over arrays of idealised buildings. Analysis of this data and other experimental and numerical data has given new insights into how air-borne pollutants disperse within the urban environment. This new understanding has helped to develop and refine simple predictive models for urban dispersion, including a novel street network model. The model has been tested against a hierarchy of other models of different levels of complexity and compares extremely well. Additional work has gone into characterising concentration fluctuations and developing improved parametrisations for an operational street network model (SIRANE, developed by ECL, France).
Exploitation Route This work will be valuable for developers of dispersion models. For example, the operational SIRANE dispersion model is being modified as a direct result of work being done in collaboration with the model developers within the project. There is also potential to help in ongoing efforts to apply the UK Met Office NAME model to urban areas. The DSTL is also a project partner and has a keen interest in using some of the data and insight produced during the project. The research findings could also be relevant for modelling and managing air quality in cities, and would therefore indirectly impact health as well as informing regulatory needs in different industries and government agencies. The primary objectives of the project are closely aligned with the needs of emergency-response modelling following accidental or terrorist releases of air-borne toxic material and hence there is a strong security-related relevance. It is also hoped that the knowledge and tools developed will eventually find their way into textbooks and training materials.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Chemicals,Communities and Social Services/Policy,Construction,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Education,Energy,Environment,Healthcare,Security and Diplomacy,Transport

 
Description Collaboration - Dr E V Goulart (Brazil) 
Organisation Federal University of Espírito Santo
Country Brazil 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Provided expertise and data and contributed to technical discussions and writing a research paper.
Collaborator Contribution Provided expertise and technical help with use of code and data through a visit. Performed data analysis and lead author of a scientific paper which is now published (Goulart et al. 2016).
Impact Research paper, DOI: 10.1007/s10546-016-0126-0
Start Year 2014
 
Description Collaboration - Dr George Efthimiou (Greece) 
Organisation National Centre for Scientific Research (NCSR) Demokritos
Country Greece 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Provision of data and scientific expertise. Contribution to a research paper.
Collaborator Contribution Scientific expertise and time; data analysis; lead author of a paper submitted to a scientific journal.
Impact A paper has been submitted to Journal of Wind Engineering and Industrial Aerodynamics. Title: A statistical model for the prediction of wind speed probabilities in the near-surface atmospheric boundary layer.
Start Year 2014
 
Description Collaboration - ECL 
Organisation Ecole Centrale de Lyon
Country France 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Provision of expertise and project time in developing methods to improve models developed by collaborator.
Collaborator Contribution Provision of SIRANE model and license free of charge, technical expertise and time for scientific discussions and project meeting attendance.
Impact In progress.
Start Year 2014
 
Description Collaboration - LANL 
Organisation Los Alamos National Laboratory
Country United States 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Evaluation of model developed by LANL (QUIC), published as a journal paper. The work revealed bugs in the code that were subsequently fixed by the developers. Also contributed results from high resolution simulations to enable LANL to improve the parametrisations in their model.
Collaborator Contribution Provided the QUIC urban dispersion model. Provided extensive feedback and discussion on the results and their write-up.
Impact Paper published (Hertwig et al. 2018, Env Fluid Mech)
Start Year 2016