Diophantine approximation, chromatic number, and equivalence classes of separated nets

Lead Research Organisation: University of York
Department Name: Mathematics

Abstract

In the branch of mathematics called combinatorics, a graph is an abstract object which can be thought of as a collection of points (called vertices), some of which are connected by line segments (called edges). We say that two vertices in a graph are adjacent if there in an edge connecting them. A colouring of a graph is a rule that assigns a label (called a colour) to each vertex, and the chromatic number of the graph is the minimum number of colours necessary to colour the graph so that no two adjacent vertices are the same colour.

Graph colourings have a multitude of practical applications. As an example, suppose you would like to invite a number of people for interviews on the same day but that there are certain pairs of candidates whom you don't want to interview at the same time. What is the minimum number of time slots that you need? Think of the candidates as the vertices of a graph, with an edge connecting one to another if they are to be put in different time slots. If we let our different colours represent different time slots, then answering our question is equivalent to determining the chromatic number of the graph. This is merely an example to demonstrate the ease with which one can turn a common logistics problem into a problem about graph colourings. There are many problems like this in biology, physics, industry, computer science, and in the social sciences and media (for example social networking). Part of our proposal is to identify these problems and to use our mathematical techniques to solve them.

Our approach to studying chromatic number is via an unexpected route. We will be considering the chromatic number of important families of infinite graphs, by connecting them with problems in Diophantine approximation (the study of approximation of numbers by fractions) and dynamical systems. This is a promising new direction which will push the boundary of current knowledge in mathematics and open the door for the flow of new ideas between many subjects.

Planned Impact

The research in this proposal is mostly concentrated on problems in pure mathematics. Most of the impact that it will generate will be realized first in mathematics and the rest of the sciences. However there very well could be some non-academic impacts, and although we don't know ahead of time what applications we will find, we anticipate that some of the non-academic impacts could be:

1. A better understanding of deformation properties of certain metallic alloys and polymers: Some of the separated nets which come from the cut and project method (described in the Case for Support) give rise to aperiodic patterns in Euclidean space which actually occur naturally in special materials called quasicrystals. This remarkable and unanticipated discovery was made in the 1980s by Prof. Dan Shechtman, and he won the Nobel Prize for his discovery in 2011. Our results about separated nets imply that these quasicrystals can be deformed to a lattice structure, and this could have real world applications to materials science.

2. Increased efficiency in logistics, engineering, and computer processing: Many everyday problems can be written in terms of graph colorings in a way that chromatic number plays a prominent role. As a prototypical example, suppose you would like to invite a number of people for interviews on the same day but that there are certain pairs of candidates whom you don't want to interview at the same time. What is the minimum number of time slots that you need? We can think of the candidates as the vertices of a graph, with an edge connecting one to another if they are to be put in different time slots. Then if our different colors represent different time slots, our problem is equivalent to determining the chromatic number of the graph. This is merely an example to demonstrate the ease with which one can turn a common logistics problem into a problem about graph colorings. There are many problems like this in industry, computer science, and in the social sciences and media (for example social networking).

3. Helping to maintain the international standing and image of the UK as a leader in science in technology: The UK's strength in certain areas of mathematics (for example Diophantine approximation and dynamical systems) enhances our reputation and image in the eyes of the rest of the world, and it also helps us to attract and train the brightest students from around the world. This proposal will aid in strengthening existing world-class research in the UK, and it will lay the groundwork for new connections between mathematics and other disciplines.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Alan Haynes (2015) Diophantine Approximation and Coloring in The American Mathematical Monthly

publication icon
Baake Michael (2017) A measure theoretic result for approximation by Delone sets in arXiv e-prints

publication icon
Goodbourn O (2016) Reductive pairs arising from representations in Journal of Algebra

publication icon
HAYNES A (2014) Equivalence classes of codimension-one cut-and-project nets in Ergodic Theory and Dynamical Systems

publication icon
Haynes A (2018) Perfectly ordered quasicrystals and the Littlewood conjecture in Transactions of the American Mathematical Society

publication icon
HAYNES A (2016) Gaps problems and frequencies of patches in cut and project sets in Mathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society

publication icon
Haynes A (2015) Hankel Determinants of Zeta Values in Symmetry, Integrability and Geometry: Methods and Applications

 
Description 1) We now have a good understanding of how to construct many examples of aperiodic cut and project sets which are bounded distance to a lattice.

2) We have made new connections between Diophantine approximation, tiling theory, and algebraic topology, that have allowed us to gain a new understanding of statistics of patterns in cut and project sets.
Exploitation Route Our findings may have applications to material sciences, virology, and the study of energy level distributions in physical problems involving sums of harmonic oscillators.
Sectors Chemicals,Healthcare

 
Description The grant has been running for a little over a year. Our papers have been cited by a number of other authors, and we have already been invited to speak at about a dozen universities/conferences about our work on the topics of the grant.
 
Description Math event (STEM centre, York) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact After a public lecture by a popular maths book writer, I led an interactive presentation about probability theory at weekend math event for primary and secondary school students. One of my postdocs (Sara Munday) led an interactive presentation about fractal geometry.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
 
Description Problem solving course (Univ York) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact One of my postdocs (Henna Koivusalo) and I have been organizing and running a bi-weekly problem solving course at the University of York. The course is aimed at Y12 and Y13 students. The goals are: 1) To help them develop their mathematical reasoning and problem solving skills, 2) To give them the flavor of what it is to do mathematics, at the same time introducing them to more advanced and abstract material than they will learn in their A-levels, 3) To help the Y13 students prepare to take the STEP exam, to qualify for entry to and scholarships in the mathematics programs at top schools.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014,2015,2016
 
Description RI Masterclass (York) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact I ran an RI Masterclass in York on the topics of large numbers and infinity. The audience were mostly Y9 students, and the goal was to give them a flavor of more advanced mathematical thinking, and to inspire some of them to want to purse further mathematical education.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016