Three-Dimensional Artificial Spin-Ice

Lead Research Organisation: Cardiff University
Department Name: School of Physics and Astronomy

Abstract

Frustration is when the pairwise interactions within a system cannot be simultaneously satisfied and the phenomena is important in explaining a diverse range of phenomena, from the production of solar flares to bonding within water-ice. In order to study frustration, physicists look for ideal systems where the interaction between physical elements, such as spin, can be directly probed via experiment. One such condensed matter system that has recently been subject of intense study is the spin-ice materials. These are bulk crystals where spins are located on the corners of joint tetrahedra. There are four spins per tetrahedra, and each of these can point either into or out from the centre of the tetrahedron. The spins, which would like to sit head-to-tail with each of their neighbours, are frustrated and this leads to a minimum energy configuration known as the ice-rules where two spins point into the centre of the tetrahedra and two spins point out. Flipping a single spin on a tetrahedron leads to an ice-rule violating defect with finite magnetic charge in the centre. These defects interact via a magnetic equivalent to Coulombs law and are magnetic monopoles in the vector fields M and H. The realisation of monopoles in spin-ice is exciting and has lead to a new field where the movement of magnetic charges (Magnetricity) is studied. Two-dimensional nanostructures can be fabricated in geometries that can simulate bulk spin-ice materials and these systems (Artificial spin-ice) have also shown to be home to monopole defects and exotic phase transitions that are driven by the frustration intrinsic to the lattice. However, in order to capture a complete physical model of bulk spin-ice, a 3D geometry is required.

This study will fabricate 3D artificial spin-ice structures. Fabrication will be carried out with a novel direct laser writing lithography system that is capable of carving out 3D holes within a resist on the sub-micron scale. These holes can then be filled with a magnetic material such as Nickel. Structures will be made such that they mimic the exact 3D geometry of the magnetic moments on a bulk spin-ice lattice, allowing a direct analogy between the two materials. The magnetic reversal will be studied using a combination of magnetometry and microscopy in order to distinguish phenomena arising from the surface and from the bulk. The work will explore the possibility of creating monopole defects in 3D artificial spin-ice systems, and explore their dynamics in samples of varying defect density.

Planned Impact

The world is now ever-reliant on digital data storage as businesses and consumers store more information. It has been estimated that the total amount of digital information stored worldwide is approximately 300 exobytes and this is set to increase by a factor of 50 in the next ten years (Source: IDC Digital Universe study). Today the vast majority of the worlds information (>40%) is stored on magnetic hard disk drives, and it is fundamental research into magnetic materials that has allowed the massive increase in areal density (Factor of >1000). New technologies such as patterned media and heat-assisted magnetic recording (HAMR) promise to maintain a steady increase in areal density over the next ten years but ultimately the computer hard drive will hit a plateau in data storage due to the fact that data is stored only within two dimensions.

Future technologies based upon magnetic materials, such as magnetic racetrack memory, have been proposed and these rely on magnetic materials that are nanostructured in all three dimensions. In order to understand the potential of such 3D magnetic storage devices, the fundamental physics of how nanostructured magnetic materials behave and interact in 3D geometries is needed. This work seeks to develop 3D magnetic nanostructures that mimic bulk frustrated materials known as spin-ice. Initial samples, made of simple tetrahedra will provide an insight into how simple 3D magnetic nanostructures behave when placed in close 3D geometries. The work may take important steps in understanding the fundamentals of domain wall movement in complex networks, and may help aid in the realization of 3D magnetic data storage devices. The research therefore has a large potential impact in a society that has increasing storage demands.

The bulk spin-ice materials have recently been shown to be home to quasi-particles that are analogous to magnetic monopoles. At this point in time it is unclear whether these magnetic charges can be controlled in order to make functional devices. This research will study the dynamics of monopole defects, analogous to the monopoles in bulk spin-ice, and determine how their dynamics change when lattice spacing, magnetic moment, or defect density are varied.
Such studies may aid in the understanding of magnetic change transport, ultimately helping the bulk spin-ice community in device design.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Our novel 3D lithography technique (two-photon lithography) can successfully be used to fabricate 3D magnetic microstructures. These structures have a clear magnetic signal and are measurable via standard magnetometry techniques.

By working with IBM, we have shown that spin-polarised scanning electron microscopy is an ideal characterisation tool for these structures.
Exploitation Route Our standard fabrication recipe will allow other research groups to manufacture 3D magnetic microstructures with feature size 700nm. By building upon this basic recipe, other groups should be able to reach smaller feature sizes and achieve single domain nanoscale magnets.
Sectors Electronics,Energy,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology

 
Description Ordering within 3D Nanostructured Frustrated Magnets
Amount £378,606 (GBP)
Funding ID RPG-2021-139 
Organisation The Leverhulme Trust 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country United Kingdom
Start 02/2022 
End 08/2025
 
Title A Magnetic Map Leads Juvenile European Eels to the Gulf Stream 
Description The "Orientation" worksheet provides information on the magnetic displacement experiments performed with European glass eels. Experiments were performed using a coil system that could precisely control the magnetic field experienced by eels, recreating conditions that exist in specific regions along the oceanic migration route of the eels. 16 orientation arenas were placed on a platform at the center of the coil system. Upon removal of a plastic settling cylinder, eels could escape in 1 of 12 directions, spacing of 30°. Column A indicates the arena number (1-16), Column B indicates the region of the magnetic field (NW Atlantic, Mid Atlantic, Sargasso Sea, and Ambient (Test Site)), Column C indicates the escape direction of the eel (0°-330°, 0°=north, 90°=east, 180°=south, 270°=west), Column D and E indicate the date (ddmmyy) and time (h:m) that the trials begun. The "Simulation' worksheet provides information on the virtual particle tracking simulations performed within the Global Hybrid Coordinate Ocean Model. Particles were released within the region of the model that corresponded to the location of the test fields. Particles were released in different years and at different depths and were programmed to either drift passively with the modelled ocean currents or to swim in the median escape direction that the eels adopted in corresponding test field. If eel orientation could not be distinguished from random, swimming was not simulated. 15000 particles were released during the month of May for each year, region, depth and behaviour and were allowed to drift for 180 days. From each region, we assessed the percentage of particles entering the Gulf Stream within this time period. For the Sargasso Sea simulations, particles were counted as entering the Gulf Stream if they crossed north of 25°N and west of 77°W. For the NW Atlantic region, particles were counted as entering the Gulf Stream if they crossed north of 40°N and east of 53°W. For the Mid Atlantic simulations, particles were already released within the Gulf Stream. Thus, values presented indicate the percentage of particles that had net eastward movement after 180 days. Column A indicates the region of particle release (Sargasso Sea, NW Atlantic, Mid Atlantic), Column B indicates the year of release (2000, 2005, 2010), Column C indicates the depth of release (30, 150, 300 m), Column D indicates the percentage of passively drifting particles that entered the Gulf Stream within 180 days, and Column E indicates the percentage of swimming particles that entered the Gulf Stream within 180 days (if applicable). 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2017 
Provided To Others? Yes  
 
Title Two Photon Lithography for 3D Magnetic Nanostructure Fabrication 
Description Magneto-optical Kerr effect (MOKE) magnetometry data: A 150 mW, 650 nm laser was attenuated to a power of approximately 50 mW, expanded to a diameter of 1 cm, and passed through a Glan-Taylor polarizer to obtain an s-polarized beam. The beam was then focused onto the sample using an achromatic doublet (f = 30 cm), to obtain a spot size of approximately 50 µm2. The reflected beam was collected using an achromatic doublet (f = 10 cm) and passed through a second Glan-Taylor polarizer, from which the transmitted and reflected beams were directed onto two amplified Si photodetectors, yielding the Kerr and reference signals, respectively. A variable neutral density filter was used to ensure that the reference and Kerr signals were of similar values. Subtraction of the reference from the Kerr signal compensates for any change in the laser intensity drift and also eliminates any small transverse Kerr effect from the signal. Here, we provide MOKE data for both angled single wires and tetrapod samples: single_wires_parallel_long.txt : Single wires with field applied along projection of long axis onto substrate. single_wires_perp_long.txt : Single wires with field applied perpendicular to projection of long axis onto substrate. tetrapod_Parallel_lower_wires.txt : Tetrapod structures with field applied along projection of lower wires onto substrate. tetrapod_Parallel_upper_wires.txt : Tetrapod structures with field applied along projection of upper wires onto substrate. In the above file the data is tab delimited. The first column is the magnetic flux density in Tesla measured at the sample position. The second column is the normalised MOKE signal. Two-photon lithography feature size data: Vertical magnetic nanowires which were fabricated using two-photon lithography (TPL) and electrodeposition were measured using scanning electron microscopy. The laser power used in TPL was varied yielding channels of different diameter. This yielded data where feature size can be plotted against laser power. Feature Size Data.txt : First column is laser power (%) and second column is feature size (microns) 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2017 
Provided To Others? Yes