Multi-Scale Self-Assembly of Nanotube Structures

Lead Research Organisation: University of Cambridge
Department Name: Engineering

Abstract

Carbon nanomaterials such as carbon nanotubes (CNTs), and graphene are entering a fascinating era where their physical properties and synthesis methods are understood well enough to attract industry's interest. The latter is best quantified by the production capacity of CNTs, which is increasing exponentially, and has now reached several thousand tons per year. The success of these materials is fueled by applications including CNT-reinforced composites, and battery electrodes. While impressive, these products typically comprise random mixtures of CNTs whose overall properties are limited compared to what is observed in the constituent individual nanotubes. In part, this is because today's CNT products are processed with traditional manufacturing capabilities, such as injection molding and spray coating. Unfortunately these processes do not enable any structural control over the nanoparticle arrangement, resulting in limited material properties. Future commercial success of new nanocarbon applications will largely depend on our ability to engineer the organization of nanoparticle assemblies.

In this EPSRC first grant, we hypothesize that understanding of physical and chemical interactions between CNTs underlies the self-assembly of new material architectures with properties superior to random mixtures. More precisely, we aim at developing a methodical hierarchical manufacturing approach where nanoparticle organization is systematically optimized at nanoscale, microscale and macroscale dimensions. For this process to be successful we will first seek understanding of the physics and chemistry of inter-particle forces between CNTs. A self-assembly process will then be optimized which uses these inter-particle interactions as a driving force. More precisely, this project builds on a top-down lithographic process previously developed by the PI, and complements this with a new bottom-up self-assembly approach enabling well-defined nanoparticle organization over large substrates.

We envision that the materials developed in this project will be particularly interesting for a variety of diffusion limited processes. These are applications such as battery electrodes, water filters, and catalysis, where the performance of the device is limited by the ability of certain components to diffuse rapidely through the developed material. This can for instance be Li ions in the case of batteries, or water in the case of filters. Unique to the process developed in this project is that it allows for large scale fabrication of CNT assemblies with exceptional control of nanoscale morphology, and micorscale porosity, which is key to engineer the diffusion path. While in depth investigation of for instance battery applications is outside the scope of this project, we will perform preliminary experiments to assess the performance of the developed materials.

Planned Impact

1. Academic impact: Aspects of this research project are of interest to various fields of engineering. A first contribution of this project is determining the relative importance and magnitude of different inter-particle forces acting on CNTs. These are fundamental insights that are currently poorly understood, but which may guide the understanding and design of new nanoparticle assembly methods. This includes the formation of high quality CNT coatings as well as complex structured CNT films. We believe this is an enabling technology that may impact CNT applications such as batteries, supercapacitors, biofouling films, transparent conductors, nano-electronics, anisotropic dry adhesives, and catalysis, all topics that are being studied throughout the UK. A second, potentially even more impactful academic outcome will be the way we think about assembling nanomaterials into superstructures. One specific hierarchical CNT self-assembly process will be demonstrated in this project; however, we hope that towards the future this project may inspire other researchers to develop similar types of innovative hierarchical nanoparticle assemblies. Conferences, summer schools, open lab days, e-forums, and other academic outreach venues will be used to to spread the insights gained from this project. Finally, the research associate hired on this project will be trained in a wide variety of processing and characterization techniques at the Cambridge nanocentre. As such, we believe that this project will help him or her to develope a strong track record to either pursue an academic or industrial carreer.

2. Industrial impact: Industrial interest in CNTs has increased substantially over the past years. Due to increased production volumes, and cost reduction, these materials are no longer prohibitive for many applications. However, the industrial development of high-end CNT products requires improved nanotube assembly and processing techniques. This is the field of research this project seeks to impact. It is important to note that Europe, and in particular the UK are playing a leading role in the production of carbon nanomaterials. For instance, Thomas Swan (UK) is the world leader in the fabrication of single wall CNTs, and tools to synthesize carbon nanotubes and graphene, are manufactured in the UK by companies such as Oxford Instruments Plasma Tools, and Surrey Nanosytems. The University of Cambridge also has a strong track record in carbon nanotech spin off companies, such as Q-Flo, CamIn, and Nanoinstruments Ltd. (now Aixtron). UK Start-ups in the field of graphene include Durham Graphene and CrayoNano. Further, multinationals such as Nokia, have research centers located in Cambridge, which are active in the domain of carbon nanomaterials. Through this project, the applicant will actively seek interaction with this industry.

3. Societal impact: Carbon nanomaterials will impact society, both through high-tech applications such as flexible electronics and ultra-lightweight composite materials, as well as by contributing to societal challenges such as water filtration and energy storage. While recent advances in these fields are impressive, we believe that the hierarchical CNT organization pursued in this project will foster further improvements of these applications. Societal importance of this project is also reflected in the fact that this projects fits in many of EPSRC's portfolio activities such as "materials for energy applications", "water engineering", "Graphene and carbon nanotechnology", and "synthetic supramolecular chemistry". Finally, this project seeks to engage with the general public using science as art competitions, e-forums, popular magazines, as well as science fairs. These are activities the applicant has successfully pursued in the past, and which are described in more details in the full project description.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Title Cover art in Advanced Materials 
Description A frontispiece was created to accompany our publication in advanced materials (Flexible Batteries: Hierarchical Assemblies of Carbon Nanotubes for Ultraflexible Li-Ion Batteries). 
Type Of Art Image 
Year Produced 2016 
Impact This artwork was published in "advanced materials", a journal with extremely high visibility in the field of material science (Impact factor 19). 
URL http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/adma.201670216/full
 
Title Science as art 
Description Engaged in projects with artists on interfacing science and art with artists Simon Tegala and Les Bicknell. The former interaction was on inspirations from nanotechnology for an artistic installation for an engineering building on West Cambridge. The latter collaboration was on parallels between invisible particles and phenomena in nanotechnology and art. 
Type Of Art Artefact (including digital) 
Year Produced 2015 
Impact The outcome of one of the project with Les Bicknell was showcased at the Festival of Ideas 2015. The artefacts of this project (images and fabrics) will be put on permanent display in the Maxwell building at the University of Cambridge. 
URL http://www.nanodtc.cam.ac.uk/News%20and%20Events/nano-art/nano-art-ideas-festival
 
Description Carbon nanomaterials such as carbon nanotubes (CNTs), and graphene are entering a fascinating era where their physical properties and synthesis methods are understood well enough to attract industry's interest. The latter is best quantified by the production capacity of CNTs, which is increasing exponentially, and has now reached several thousand tons per year. The success of these materials is fueled by applications including CNT-reinforced composites, and battery electrodes. While impressive, these products typically comprise random mixtures of CNTs whose overall properties are limited compared to what is observed in the constituent individual nanotubes.

Future commercial success of new nanocarbon applications will largely depend on our ability to engineer the organization of nanoparticle assemblies. In this EPSRC first grant, we assembled CNTs in new highly organised material architectures with properties superior to random mixtures. More precisely, developed a process for fabricating hierarchical carbon nanostructures with controlled microscale geometry and nanoscale surface chemistry. For this novel process we rely on the assembly of Carbon-Nanotubes, their transfer printing on flexible substrates and their coating with metal oxide nanocrystals.

These materials are particularly interesting diffusion limited processes, and we focused particularly on the development of new battery electrodes. Particularly interesting is our development of a transfer printing process which allows fabricating extremely flexible battery electrodes. Here we show that extremely flexible batteries can be achieved by our CNT structures which decouple the stress induced during bending in the collector electrode from stress in the energy storage material (Fe2O3 anodes and LiNiCoO2 cathodes in this work). We found that this battery architecture not only imparts excellent flexibility (bending radii ~ 300 µm), but also high rate (20A/g), cycling stability (over 500 cycles at 1C with capacity retention over 70%).
Exploitation Route Unique to the process developed in this project is that it allows for the efficient fabrication of CNT assemblies with exceptional control of micorscale geometry and nanoscale surface chemistry, which is key for next generation CNT applications. The outcome of this research is currently under review in the journal Advanced Materials which has a very good visibility (impact factor 17.5). Other results achieved through this project have been published in NanoLetters (Nano letters 15 (9), 6095-6101 - Impact Factor 13.6). Further, this work will be presented at international conferences (we target MRS) to further make our findings available to others.

Our research group is already taking several aspects of this project - such as the transfer printing process - over to other projects where it is already contributing to the advancement of other battery, super-capacitor technologies and scaffolds for cell growth experiments.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Electronics,Energy,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Other

 
Description This work contributed to science as art projects described in the section on "Artistic & Creative Products" as well as the Science Festival. Further the developed work contributes to advancing the sate of the art of energy storage devices, hereby contributing to both industry and society.
First Year Of Impact 2015
Sector Energy,Environment,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Other
Impact Types Cultural,Societal,Economic

 
Title Transfer Printing of Carbon Nanotubes 
Description It is highly desirable to have Carbon Nanotube (CNT) structures transferred to flexible and conducting substrate instead of Si-wafer. Therefore, a new method for transferring carbon nanotubes onto flexible substrates is developed. This method is also applicable to transfer of complex CNT structures and transfer them onto conductive substrates. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The developed method is very important for the advancement of flexible electronics, in particular flexible batteries profit from this technology. For the first demonstration of the transfer printing method, we have developed flexible batteries utilizing where robust ultra flexibility (up to 300 micron radius of curvature) and stable performance (up to 1000 cycles of charge and discharge) with standard capacity (around 700mAh/g) is achieved. 
 
Description Collaboration in Department of Physics (Cavendish Laboratory), Cambridge 
Organisation University of Cambridge
Department Department of Physics
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The post-doctoral fellow, Dr. Shahab Ahmad, hired on the project has initiated the bi-lateral collaboration with Dr. Aditya Sadhanala, post-doctoral fellow at Optoelectronics Group in Cavendish Laboratory.
Collaborator Contribution In this collaboration the partners have provided fruitful discussion about the project and tools such as thermal vapor deposition have been shared.
Impact This collaboration was inter-disciplinary, bringing together the Department of Physics and Engineering, and it resulted in a publication in Nanoletters (Impact factor 13.6). The link to the publication is : http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/acs.nanolett.5b02369.
Start Year 2014
 
Title Flexible conducting films 
Description In this project, we have optimized the synthesis process for fabricating flexible conducting films with high electrical conductivity and flexibility. The film is fabricated as follows: 15 mg of methanofullerene phenyl C61 butyric acid methyl ester (PCBM) is dissolved in 3 ml dimethylformamide (DMF) and ultra-sonicated for 1 hour. 15 mg double wall carbon nanotubes (DWCNTs) are added to the PCBM solution and ultrasonicated for 30 minutes. A solution of polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) (300 mg in 3 ml DMF) is added as binder to the CNT-PCBM solution and stirred. Finally the PVDF-CNT-PCBM suspension is ball milled (planetary) in grinding jar (25 ml) with single metal ball for 2 hours with an interval of 30 s after every 2 minutes. The ball-milled PCP suspension is casted over clean soda-lime glass slide. 
Type Of Technology New/Improved Technique/Technology 
Year Produced 2015 
Impact As this flexible conducting film was of great importance for this project because it allows to transfer-print CNT structures, and to fabricate good excellent battery electrodes. These films can be used for various other applications, including super-capacitors and sensors. 
 
Description Huntingdonshire Manufacturers Association Lecture 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Tutorial on nanotechnology for the Huntingdonshire Manufacturers Association . The event was attended by approximately 50 attendees and the discussions afterwards indicated a very strong interest in implementing carbon nanotubes in polymer composites. It is unclear whether further steps were undertaken by the workshop participants.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
URL http://www.thehma.co.uk/
 
Description IfM Briefing Day 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact The Institute of Manufacturing Briefing Day presents research activities to senior industrialists (CEO/CTO level) and policy makers. This event typically attracts over 150 attendants with networking opportunities to explore technology transfer partnerships. A talk was delivered at this event, which resulted in a company contributing in cash to further pursue our research activities.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
 
Description Publication in the IfM Review magazine 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Published interview in the quarterly magazine, the IfM Review, which is posted to around 500 industrial contacts and emailed to a further 8000. Based on this article I was invited to deliver a talk in Cincinnati, USA.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015