Carbon/biocomposite hybrid vehicle structures for reduced weight, cost and environmental impact (CARBIO)

Lead Research Organisation: Cranfield University
Department Name: Sch of Energy, Environment and Agrifood

Abstract

Carbon/flax fibre-reinforced hybrid composites offer advantages in terms of vibroacoustic, weight and cost when compared
to conventional steel and aluminium alloys which can be related to minimisation of emissions and fuel consumption.
However, vibro-acoustic characteristics of epoxy-carbon fibres/flax hybrid composites and their co-relation to structural
strength of the composite remain unexplored and a stumbling block in the application of the material technology to
manufacture better components. The increased application of both flax fibres and carbon fibre composites in automotive
components requires proper understand of vibro-acoustic problems and their effects in structural design and
manufacturing. The CARBIO project, therefore, involve investigating the vibro-acoustic levels for selected components
/systems for determination of tuneable frequencies, determination and quantification of vibroacoustic coupling between
temperatures variations, panels architecture and body assembly contributions and noise levels benefit against
benchmarked fully epoxy/carbon fibre, steel and aluminium components.
The study stems from the fact that with increasingly stringent environmental regulations and requirements, noise and
vibration have become very important design considerations for automotive manufacturing. Modern vehicle customers are
aware of their environmental needs and therefore demand the most economical car, the most comfortable to drive and
obviously the cheapest. As a consequence, the automotive industry has become a consumer driven industry where noise,
vibration and environmental harshness has become a measure of design excellence and vehicle performance, a fact
reflected strongly in vehicle sales. A rational approach to reducing noise and vibration is to improve the damping properties
of the materials from which the car parts are manufactured. Currently, body panels are mainly manufactured from steel
and aluminium alloy in conventional vehicles and epoxy - carbon/glass fibre- reinforced composites in high performance
cars. More effective measures for noise and vibration reduction are desirable if the automotive industry is to achieve an
acceptable driving environment and comfort as vehicle structural masses are reduced in response to environmental
demands.
The project acknowledge that hybrid composites with natural fibres are a key solutions to the vibroacoustic problem since
natural fibres (flax) have much higher damping properties. In addition to the reduction of mass, composite materials offer
consistent potential advantages in terms of noise and vibrations reduction, impact resistance, energy absorption capability. They also offer advantages in the manufacturing process, such as cost reduction for producing low volume pieces and the
possibility of integration, i.e. structures which can be made with fewer sub-components. Composites also possess a unique
capability: to be tailored in order to meet design requirements which are ill-matched for conventional materials, by properly
choosing the constituent materials and the orientation of the reinforcement fibres. This is of primary importance for the
performance optimization, the target objective being a minimization of the mass and/or of stress concentrations,
guaranteeing the required performance. Use of thermoplastics and other lightweight materials also aligns UK OEMs with
the end of life vehicle EU directive in that by 2015 , vehicles must be constructed of 95% recyclable materials, with 85%
recoverable through reuse or mechanical recycling and 10% through energy recovery or thermal recycling. It is envisaged
that the proposed project will give the UK automotive industry a leading edge in global industry.

Planned Impact

Strategic impacts of the proposed project and direct expected benefits
Quantitative objectives
i) Greener production process: use of less carbon fibre with respect to current levels of production
ii) 25% production cost reduction
iii) 20% higher noise, vibration and harshness (NVH) performance
iv) New knowledge on carbon fibre/flax fibre/epoxy composites structural and damping performance
v) 20% weight reduction on
Qualitative objectives
i) Contribution to better NVH performance from cars.
ii) Overall weight reduction
iii) Reduction of other vehicle emissions (NOx, N2, hydrocarbons etc) in EU air - associated with cleaner environment,
better health and living for EU residents.
iv) Help to develop green initiatives industry in Europe.
v) Introduction of Quality control of industrial process ISO 9001.
vi) To extend these results to other applications in the field of transport (aviation and trains)
vii) Reduction of noise (pedestrian).
viii) Reduction of fuel expenses to UK residents - better fuel efficiency gives 2-3 yrs pay back).
ix) Position of UK/Europe as a leader in key areas of underpinning science and engineering for future low-CO2 vehicles.
x) Increase competitiveness of UK/EU SME and OEM whilst underpinning UK/EU automotive industry in readiness to tap
future income in low carbon vehicles and along with other applications. The upcoming markets are mainly India, China,
Brazil - 600 (India) and 500 (China) million cars on road, respectively, are expected by 2050 - while cementing low carbon
vehicle philosophy.
xi) Training of new blood- young skills at SMEs in low carbon vehicles to prepare for the future needs of the world and to
cater to a healthy local economy.
xii) Contributions to UK/EU low carbon vehicle policies.
xiii) Study and development of new industrial materials applied to the automotive industry, in special to small cars segment
which is growing very fast.
xiv) Introduction of the European regulation on the use of new materials in industry.
Environmental impacts
The manufacturers are faced with the challenge of designing systems and components that have to be safer, more reliable,
cheaper to operate, deliver better passenger comfort and have less environmental impact than their competitors. In
addition, stringent environmental constraints, increased competition and global partnering translate into difficult engineering
challenges and an ever-stronger need for collaborative design and engineering solutions. With the relatively limited resources of the companies an evolving rationale for design and development is required and a significant part of this is in
meeting environmental requirements. Within Europe SMC and BMC are the most important composite materials in terms
of industrial production. Both SMC and BMC have been manufactured with over 300,000 tons in the year 2007. Roughly
one third of this capacity was used in the automotive/ transportation market. If only 30% of this material was replaced by
SMC/ BMC derived from renewable resources, it would have a direct bearing on the ecology in two ways. Firstly, the
impact of CO2 emission on environment would drastically reduce. Additionally the SMC/ BMC coming from renewable
resources would bear lower density. Today's standard SMC has a density of 1,9 g/cm3, whereas SMC from renewable
resources could have a density of 1,4 g/cm3 or lower. This would also help to lower the weight of vehicles and lower their
CO2 emissions. Moreover, the project will narrow the bridge between the engineering and the environmental applications
aiming to encourage 'green' research activities. Reduction of emissions, lightweight construction, freedom in design,
integration of functions and reduction of costs, rank among the most important requirements of the original equipment
manufacturers (OEMs). As a consequence, light weighting is one of the major drivers for the use of composites in the
manufacturing of consumer goods., hence additional benefit

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The key findings are as follows:

1. The hybrid composites made from flax and carbon fibre can be made as stiff in terms of the flexural stiffness as carbon fibre composites.
2. The hybrid composites produced a higher loss factor (higher damping) than carbon fibre composites
3. The hybrid composites in crash / impact experiments, had specific energy of absorption similar to that of the carbon fibre composites, at a much reduced cost.

In addition to these, there have been improvements in the methodology and processes used for the characterization of the mechanical performance of hybrid flax materials.

This is an early stage in the development of hybrid composite solutions, but they show a lot of promise with the potential to reduce the carbon footprint of structures using by increasing the amount of natural fibre within carbon fibre composites.
Exploitation Route The project findings are already being taken forward by the consortium in the commercialization of the research within the automotive industry with the project partners. The Cranfield team is also developing a UK/Mexico research proposal to take the research forward by including more natural material content from waste sources.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Transport

URL http://carbioproject.com/
 
Description The findings generated to date with respect to this project have been used by the project partners and the research team at Cranfield. This has included work with Composites Evolution to develop optimum flax/carbon hybrid composite layups. We presented our work to Jaguar Land Rover and Delta Motorsports for the optimization of material cards for structural and vibration simulation. SHD and KS composites are developing a bio-epoxy matrix and our research has helped them to characterise the new resin and its effects on composites. Cranfield University held knowledge transfer sessions with Delta Motorsports in the area of composite design and FEA. These sessions helped Delta Motorsports to design the prototype manufactured in the project.
First Year Of Impact 2014
Sector Transport
Impact Types Economic

 
Description Newton Institutional links 2016
Amount £39,993 (GBP)
Funding ID 264761037 
Organisation Newton Fund 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 04/2017 
End 03/2018
 
Title Centre Impedance Method (CIM) for Hybrid composites 
Description CIM is essentially simultaneous vibration testing of two cantilever beams. The impedance head is glued at the middle of the specimen (25 mm x 300mm), using cyanoacrylate adhesive and then mounted on the shaker's moving head. The shaker is excited using a sine wave signal generator. The signal generated from the impedance head are collected from the sensor signal conditioner, which then transmits them to the signal acquisition system. DASYLab software was responsible for handling the data. The method is not new, but its use with this material is, and therefore the subsequent data analysis had to be developed specifically as part of this research. 
Type Of Material Physiological assessment or outcome measure 
Year Produced 2015 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact This research method allows us to determine the loss factor of composites. This in turn allows us to make comparative analysis of vibration damping characteristics of various materials (against the control samples) at 1st, 2nd 3rd.... etc. modes of vibration and varying frequencies. 
 
Title Development of material cards for finite element analysis (FEA) of hybrid flax carbon fibre composites 
Description FEA was used to optimise the hybrid composites, first at a coupon level and then by using generic sections (top hat, box section etc.). Tensile and flexural stiffness tests were modeled along with vibration damping tests. the validations resulted in material cards that were then used for generic sections. Dynamic analysis (FEA) was performed on the top hat sections and then validated through crash testing. 
Type Of Material Computer model/algorithm 
Year Produced 2015 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact This research database was used by Delta Motorsports (a partner in CARBIO project) to optimize the layups for the roof of a Jaguar car (also a partner in CARBIO project). In the longer term, this database is likely to be used by Jaguar engineers to design parts made from hybrid compoistes 
 
Description Further Test and Evaluation work 
Organisation Jaguar Land Rover Automotive PLC
Department Jaguar Land Rover
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Further research was conducted with JLR at Cranfield to help establish performance benchmark and new standards within JLR for the new material developed as part of the project.
Collaborator Contribution JLR funded the continuation of the research at Cranfield.
Impact Research data
Start Year 2016
 
Description NHS ambulance trust vehicle design project 
Organisation NHS England
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution The results and modelling techniques developed as part of the original grant are now being applied to the conceptual design of a future ambulance vehicle to reduce weight, achieve net zero CO2 and improve the ride quality of future vehicles.
Collaborator Contribution Vehicle supply, project guidance, attendance at project meetings. Provision of test drivers and support via ambulance crews and background information.
Impact Research at early stage and ongoing.
Start Year 2020
 
Description Professional Motorsport World Expo 2015 'Workshops' 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact A conference research paper was presented at the annual Professional Motorsport expo in Germany. The intended pupose of this activity was to introduce the Industry/business to the material technology being developed in the CARBIO project
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
URL http://www.professionalmotorsport-expo.com/english/
 
Description School lecture 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact The presentation was given to invigorate a topic being used in schools to embody the national curriculum and it sparked a considerable number of very interesting questions and discussion afterwards.

Further talks have been requested and research lab visits have been offered.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
 
Description Under graduate Internship support 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact My research team is supporting an internship from SupMeca (a Grand Ecole in France). This will involve integration within our research team working with us on crash simulation of composite structures.

The activity is ongoing, and we expect the impacts to be at the end of the internship.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014