MATERIALS 5R BY INDUSTRIAL SYMBIOSIS IN THE CEMENT INDUSTRY - UNDERSTANDING METABOLISM OF TOXIC METALS IN CO-PROCESSING

Lead Research Organisation: University College London
Department Name: Civil Environmental and Geomatic Eng

Abstract

Portland cement is traditionally manufactured by heating limestone and clay at high temperature in a kiln. On a global scale, cement production is responsible for about 7% of the CO2 emissions that we suspect of causing climate change and consumes more than 5,000,000,000 tonnes of raw materials. In recent years, there has been an increasing trend towards replacing both the fuels and minerals used in cement production with industrial wastes. This practice helps to conserve both fossil fuels and natural mineral resources.
In general, wastes now fed to the cement kiln contain mainly combustible materials and the same harmless elements that are present in natural cement raw materials, so there is no undesirable effect on cement quality or the environment. However, it has been suggested that some wastes containing toxic metals could be used in cement kilns, and we need to know more about what happens to these potential pollutants during cement production and use, to decide whether such wastes can safely be added in the cement kiln. This collaboration between researchers in Environmental Engineering at University College London in the UK and Materials Scientists at the China Building Materials Academy and South China University of Technology therefore aims to conduct a scientific study of the fate and behaviour of toxic metals from untreated wastes, through the cement kiln, to hydrated cement pastes and the environment. We will use advanced techniques for chemical analysis and materials characterisation, including x-ray absorption spectroscopy with high energy x-rays from the UK's Diamond Light Source, and the Beijing Synchrotron, to see how the form of metals changes as they pass through the kiln and when water is added to the cement, and to understand how much metal-bearing waste can safely be added before undesirable effects occur.
The new understanding gained in this work will support decision-making by industry and the government, about the use of waste in making cement.

Planned Impact

Co-processing of wastes in the cement kiln is an internationally increasing trend, motivated both by the need to conserve raw materials and energy in cement production, but also by the difficulty and expense of waste management. There is frequently a contrast between ideologies regarding proposals for utilisation of wastes, where some oppose utilisation of waste in cement on principle; on the other hand, those who want to take advantage of practical benefits may be unwilling to engage with potential environmental risks. Scientifically defensible decisions about these matters require the availability of sound technical information, such as will be generated by this research. Apart from other academics conducting research in this area, the project findings will benefit:
1) the cement industry, waste generators, and niche waste-brokering businesses, by providing crucial missing information about the safety of the practice of co-processing metal-bearing wastes, which will reduce uncertainty associated with business risk, and enable rational decision-making about acceptance of metal-bearing wastes into the cement kiln;
2) regulators, who will have a sound basis for development of environmental policy and regulations in relation to the above sectors;
3) the public, who are concerned about the potential risks of human health impacts due to emissions of toxic metals from the cement kiln, or in cement-based products;
4) the environment, where eco- and agri-systems could be negatively impacted by toxic metal loadings from unsafe practice.

The project will have a dedicated website developed and maintained by the UCL CEGE Communications Officer, with a section aimed at lay people and a discussion forum. Youtube videos will be prepared for each of the main tasks. The results of this research will be disseminated by the research team through attendance at events including academic conferences, university open days and public engagement workshops, and through the university press office. 15 conference publications and 9 publications in high impact factor academic journals are planned.

The research programme includes a plan for exchange of researchers between the UK and Chinese teams for periods between 1 and 6 months, to enable the expertise of each to contribute to the design of experiments and evaluation of results, and enhance to opportunity for co-production of knowledge and novel advanced experimental techniques. The project as a whole, and particularly the researcher exchange scheme, will also provide valuable training for younger researchers, and an opportunity for them develop their own research networks.

Dissemination of project results will also be aided by the participation of advisors from industry (Environment Agency and Mineral Products Association [MPA] in the UK, and China Resources Cement R&D Co [Yuebao/Guangzhou Heidelberg Yuexiu Cement] and the Chinese Ceramic Society-Cement Branch [CCS] in China), who will keep in close contact with the project throughout and participate in meetings and Stakeholder Workshops in each country, with an emphasis on facilitating real-world applicability of the results. The CCS will hold the Chinese Stakeholder Workshop for the project, and they and the MPA can facilitate dissemination of the result to their members and global network of trade associations (e.g., CEMBUREAU).

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The objective of the project was to investigate the fate of metals in industrial wastes that are used as raw materials in cement manufacture (known as co-processing). The research programme included 1) collection and full physical, chemical & mineralogical characterisation of three wastes (air pollution control residue from Energy-from-Waste facilities, plating sludge and Pb/Zn smelter slag), 2) production and characterisation of cement clinkers with different formulations, made with these wastes, 3) preparation of cement pastes from these clinkers, as well as blended cement pastes using the same wastes without co-processing, 4) characterisation of the clinker and paste mineralogy, and 4) testing of contaminant mobility from the cement pastes is being finalised. Four journal papers and several conference papers have been published. Seven additional journal papers are in preparation.
Exploitation Route The findings on mineralogy and metals speciation in untreated industrial wastes are essential to understanding mobility of pollutants in the environment, as well as development of treatment technologies.

Overall, the new scientific understanding gained in this project will support decision-making about co-processing of wastes containing toxic metal pollutants, and development of better technologies for immobilisation of metals in cement-based materials.

We are in dialogue with the Environment Agency and the Mineral Products Association about our findings. The cement companies also have valuable information about cycling of metals in cement kilns at full scale, which could be used to link the experimental results to full-scale phenomena. The MPA are involved in European (Cembureau) discussions about limits on metals to cement kilns, to which our results will be highly relevant.
Sectors Chemicals,Construction,Environment,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology

 
Description We have been discussing our results with the Mineral Products Association since the inception of the project, in relation to their participation in European (Cembureau) discussions about limits on metals to cement kilns. As the pressures for improved resource efficiency through Circular Economy are increasing, our results are also increasingly relevant. We have data for metal speciation in wastes, cement clinker and cement paste. It is a complex problem, and we have been expending a lot of additional, mostly unfunded effort, to interpret the results. Most of the published data so far are in relation to understanding of metal speciation in wastes, which is useful in understanding the recoverability of valuable and pollutant elements from waste. We also have several draft manuscripts that will support good practice in co-processing practice, and understanding of substance flows in the built environment.
First Year Of Impact 2015
Sector Construction,Environment,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology
Impact Types Policy & public services

 
Description Diamond Light Source synchrotron beamtime (AP17) Metabolism of Toxic Metals in Co-processing of Wastes in the Cement Kiln - Phase I
Amount £20,000 (GBP)
Funding ID SP11156 
Organisation STFC Laboratories 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 04/2015 
End 09/2015
 
Description Diamond Light Source synchrotron beamtime (AP21) Metabolism of Toxic Metals in Co-processing of Wastes in the Cement Kiln - Phases II & III Pb & Zn in Clinker & Paste
Amount £15,000 (GBP)
Funding ID SP16153 
Organisation STFC Laboratories 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 04/2017 
End 09/2017
 
Description EPSRC IAA: Secondment of Stijn van Ewijk to DEFRA 
Organisation Department For Environment, Food And Rural Affairs (DEFRA)
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Secondment involved calculating wider benefits of resource-efficient production and consumption.
Collaborator Contribution Group and individual discussions on the circular economy and resource efficiency between the secondee and Defra officials; the development of a Defra working paper written by the secondee and Lee Davies from Defra; a joint session to discuss the working paper with UCL academics and Defra officials. This session was held at UCL and combined policy experience with academic insight; the working paper was published as a Defra research report.
Impact The Defra Research Paper is used as a reading in the UCL course "Waste and Resource Efficiency" in 2017 and 2018. The experience at Defra has provided students with a more practical and real life description of how policy makers engage with this topic. The Defra experience has also informed the intern's research on material cycling and contaminant flows in cement co-processing.
Start Year 2016
 
Description EPSRC IAA: WIDENING THE UCL CircEL (CIRCULAR ECONOMY LAB) 
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC)
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution A UCL-wide workshop was held at lunch time on 19 May 2016, to publicise UCL CircEL and recruit additional research skills of interest to industry from staff across UCL. The workshop was attended by 17 staff and 15 research students. An industry-facing event focused on a Circular Economy for Timber was held on 20 July 2016, with 6 industrial speakers. It was attended by 15 representatives from industry, and 17 members of the UCL academic community. A course outline for a prospective CPD module on Resource Efficiency was created and a market assessment conducted.
Collaborator Contribution UCL is one of seven Ellen MacArthur Foundation "Pioneer" universities; we thus have a commitment to EMF for development of research and education to support the transition to a Circular Economy.
Impact Representatives of more than 20 global organisations and more than 50 SMEs have invested their time for participation in UCL CircEL workshops.
Start Year 2016
 
Description EPSRC IAA: WIDENING THE UCL CircEL (CIRCULAR ECONOMY LAB) 
Organisation The Ellen MacArthur Foundation
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution A UCL-wide workshop was held at lunch time on 19 May 2016, to publicise UCL CircEL and recruit additional research skills of interest to industry from staff across UCL. The workshop was attended by 17 staff and 15 research students. An industry-facing event focused on a Circular Economy for Timber was held on 20 July 2016, with 6 industrial speakers. It was attended by 15 representatives from industry, and 17 members of the UCL academic community. A course outline for a prospective CPD module on Resource Efficiency was created and a market assessment conducted.
Collaborator Contribution UCL is one of seven Ellen MacArthur Foundation "Pioneer" universities; we thus have a commitment to EMF for development of research and education to support the transition to a Circular Economy.
Impact Representatives of more than 20 global organisations and more than 50 SMEs have invested their time for participation in UCL CircEL workshops.
Start Year 2016
 
Description Interpretation of XAS data 
Organisation Louisiana State University
Country United States 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Co-supervison of PhD student Danting Chen
Collaborator Contribution Co-supervison (informal) of PhD student Danting Chen, through provision of advice regarding interpretation of XAS results from ~Diamond, and results generated by the LSU CAMD
Impact Co-authored publications with Professor Amitava Roy, as listed in the Publications section
 
Description Metabolism of Metals in Co-Processing of Wastes in Cement Kilns - Workshop on Energy-from-Waste Air Pollution Control Residues 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Industry workshop to disseminate project outcomes and obtain feedback.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018