Novel Manifestations of Optical Activity

Lead Research Organisation: University of Glasgow
Department Name: College of Science and Engineering

Abstract

Many molecules possess shapes that distinguish them from their mirror images, much like a human hand. These handed, or chiral, molecules are of great importance in chemistry, biology, medicine and agriculture owing to their ubiquity and the vital roles that they play in biological function. Indeed, a remarkable and important consequence of the latter lies in the fact that the mirror-image forms, or enantiomers, of a chiral molecule can interact differently with living things. For example, one enantiomer of carvone is found in spearmint leaves whereas the opposite enantiomer is found in caraway seeds, thus being associated with different aromas; one enantiomer of methamphetamine is recognised as being a harmful narcotic whereas the opposite enantiomer is used as a decongestant. Means by which to probe and utilise molecular chirality are thus highly sought after, in both academic and industrial contexts.

One of the principal approaches available to us lies in the use of light that is itself chiral. Specifically, circularly polarised light, in which the electric and magnetic fields twist, like a corkscrew, in either a left- or a right-handed manner. Naturally, a chiral molecule interacts differently with these mirror-image forms of twisting light, much as a given human hand interacts differently with left- and right-handed gloves, and these differences enable us to explore and harness molecular chirality in various ways. More generally, differences in the response exhibited by matter, including chiral molecules, to left- and right-circularly polarised light comprise the subject of optical activity, applications of which are diverse and range from the study of the structures of viruses to the operation of liquid crystal displays. Molecular chirality and optical activity thus pervade science and technology.

Lying at the heart of my proposed Fellowship research is my observation that new types of light in which the electric and magnetic fields twist in unusual ways afford the possibility of improving our understanding of molecular chirality and our ability to utilise it and, more broadly, of significantly advancing the subject of optical activity and its applications. Following this observation, I will pioneer entirely new manifestations of optical activity in the translational degrees of freedom of molecules and atoms and in the rotational degrees of freedom of molecules, enable 'dormant' manifestations of optical activity in light scattering to be exploited, for the first time, and expand upon the understanding and applications of well-established manifestations of optical activity, including circular dichroism and optical rotation. New experimental techniques and technologies based upon my research could be employed to probe the laws of physics themselves in unprecedented ways; to measure enigmatic properties of light; to gain deeper understandings of the structures of molecules and atoms, their behaviour in chemical processes and their roles in biological function; to assist in the design and manufacture of new materials, cosmetics, foods, drugs and agrochemicals and much more besides.

Planned Impact

My Fellowship will improve our understanding of molecular chirality and our ability to harness it and, more broadly, will see the subject of optical activity and its applications significantly advanced. Owing to the enormous importance of molecular chirality and optical activity in science and technology, it is difficult to overstate the potential for impact.

Anticipated outputs of my Fellowship research include: devices able to spatially separate the enantiomers of chiral molecules in a general manner using light for further applications; new and improved forms of spectroscopy with which to study the structures of molecules and atoms, their behaviour in chemical processes and their roles in biological function; advances in the design, manufacture and control of novel materials, including chiral metamaterials and liquid crystals. In addition to impacting academia as described in my 'Academic Beneficiaries' statement, my Fellowship thus stands to enhance the economic competitiveness of the UK and the health and quality of life of the general public, by servicing the many industries in which these outputs could find widespread adoption. Consider, for example:

The pharmaceutical industry
Chirality underpins biological function. Consequently, the enantiomers of a chiral molecule can interact differently with living things and, in particular, often function differently as drugs. One enantiomer of ethambutol, for example, is employed to treat tuberculosis whereas the opposite enantiomer causes blindness. Clearly, molecular chirality is vitally important in this context and, indeed, it is anticipated that nearly 95% of all pharmaceutical drugs will be chiral by 2020 [1]. Chirality and optical activity also impinge upon medical diagnostics. For example, small changes in protein level, detectable using circular dichroism, can indicate the presence of certain diseases.

The food industry
The enantiomers of a chiral molecule often taste and are metabolised differently. Sugar molecules, for example, are chiral and optical rotation is perhaps the principal means by which their concentrations are measured, with several successful UK-based companies currently manufacturing polarimeters for this purpose. Molecular chirality is also of great importance to agriculture itself, as many agrochemicals are chiral. One enantiomer of mecoprop, for example, functions as a herbicide whereas the opposite enantiomer is ineffective in this context.

The cosmetics industry
The enantiomers of a chiral molecule often smell different. One enantiomer of nootkatone, for example, smells of grapefruit whereas the opposite enantiomer smells woody. Molecular chirality is thus an important ingredient in the design and manufacture of perfumes.

The entertainment industry
Chirality and optical activity underly an abundance of high-end technologies. For example, the operation of the liquid crystal displays found in many calculators, televisions and computer screens utilises optical rotation. It has also been suggested that chiral molecular switches could form memory elements in future computers.

The global market for chiral technology, some 10-20% of which is based upon optical activity phenomena, is predicted to grow in value to £3bn by 2017, being driven largely by the increasing demands of the pharmaceutical and agrochemical industries [2]. Progress is hampered, however, by a lack of methods of general applicability and this is one of the areas in which my proposed Fellowship research shines.

[1] See, for example uk.finance.yahoo.com/news/chiral-technology-market-led-basf-000000637.html last accessed (27/01/2014)
[2] See, for example www.transparencymarketresearch.com/chiral-technology-market.html last accessed (27/01/2014)

People

ORCID iD

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description 12 research papers now in the public domain, with 4 more in preparation. 1 book chapter. UK priority patent and PCT applications filed. Ongoing collaborations with Joe Cotter (Imperial), Sonja Franke-Arnold (Glasgow), Benoit Dacquie (Laser Physics Laboratory in Villetaneuse), Joerg Goette (Nanjing), Koen van Kruining (Dresden), Cyriaque Genet / Thomas Hermanns (ISIS). 12 research talks (2 invited). 2 poster sessions. 1 public engagement talk. 1 new website with public engagement content. 1 public engagement film in production. The main NEW discoveries are (in chronological order) (i) the invention of chiral rotational spectroscopy, (ii) invention of a new molecular grating to separate molecules based on internal temperature, (iii) the discovery of Stegosaurus chirality, (iii) the identification of unusual electromagnetic disturbances, (iv) the identification of hidden momentum in atoms and molecules, (v) the development second-order linear Rayleigh and Raman scattering theory.
Exploitation Route It is my goal to see chiral rotational spectroscopy, Rayleigh optical activity and chiral molecular diffraction adopted as standard techniques. This will be realised via the many collaborations I have set up during the course of my Fellowship.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Chemicals,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology

 
Description The most obvious non-academic impact of my Fellowship has been through my public outreach activities (website, talk etc. as listed elsewhere in my summary). Note also that I a film is currently in production. Long-term, my research should lead to non-academic impacts, of course, but it is too early to say. I would like to emphasise that I have actively pursued commercialisation of my work through e.g. a patent application.
First Year Of Impact 2016
Sector Other
Impact Types Cultural,Societal

 
Description Institute of Physics Public Engagement Grant Scheme (note that these funds were pledged, but I did not use them in time - the project is now underway and I will REAPPLY for the same funds this year, 2018)
Amount £750 (GBP)
Organisation Institute of Physics (IOP) 
Sector Learned Society
Country United Kingdom
Start 01/2017 
End 12/2017
 
Description The Leverhulme Trust Research Project Grant (note that it was not possible to name me officially as e.g. a PI due to my lack of a permanent post)
Amount £286,825 (GBP)
Organisation The Leverhulme Trust 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2017 
End 05/2020
 
Title Unusual electromagnetic disturbances repository 
Description I have started a repository for "unusual electromagnetic disturbances" in support of my recently submitted research paper of the same name. See www.ytilarihc.com/ued 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2017 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact It is my hope that the database will grow into a collection of the myriad interesting forms of light that have been recognised. 
URL http://www.ytilarihc.com/ued
 
Title Method of analysing molecular properties and spectrometer for the same 
Description A new spectroscopic technique for probing the chirality of molecules, based upon the combination of optical rotation and rotational spectroscopy. The technique permits measurement of orientated chiroptical information and enantiomeric excess whilst yielding an incisive chirally sensitive signal for a racemate. It should be particularly useful for isotopically chiral molecules, molecules with multiple chiral centres and mixtures. 
IP Reference GB1519681.9 
Protection Patent application published
Year Protection Granted 2015
Licensed No
Impact 1 x Talk at DPG-Frühjahrstagung 2016. The technique has been demonstrated in the laboratory.
 
Description Mirrors, Chirality and Jeremy the Lefty Snail: a public outreach film (in production) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact PLEASE NOTE: The statistics listed are those ANTICIPATED... "Mirrors, Chirality & Jeremy the Lefty Snail" is a public outreach film written and currently being produced by me, together with help from my film-making brother and his collaborators. It will be approximately 30 minutes long, aimed at a general audience, and will cover a variety of topics under the unifying banner of chirality. To date we have filmed an interview with Dr Angus Davison, an evolutionary geneticist with speciality in chirality, and have an interview scheduled for March 10th with Prof Laurence Barron, chemist, recipient of the chirality medal and pioneer of Raman optical activity. The Institute of Physics pledged £750 in 2017 for the film (to be re-applied for this year). The film is loosely based on a public outreach talk I gave at the Glasgow Science Centre in 2016 (see "Mirrors, Chirality & Stegosaurus").
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description Mirrors, Chirality and Stegosaurus 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact I gave one of eight Spotlight Talks at the Glasgow Science Centre on the 30th of September 2016, as part of Explorathon'16.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
 
Description Public engagement website - www.ytilarihc.com 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact I have opened my own website "www.ytilarihc.com" where I write an article every month detailing an interesting piece of physics for the interested general reader. In particular, I held a competition in which I asked visitors to search for a left-handed snail, which culminated in ongoing collaborative discussions with a snail biologist (who found such a snail by chance, thus winning the competition).
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
URL http://www.ytilarihc.com