Operator asymptotics, a new approach to length-scale interactions in metamaterials.

Lead Research Organisation: University of Bath
Department Name: Mathematical Sciences

Abstract

Many real-world phenomena, such as the spread of disease or the fluctuations of stock prices, can be understood and predicted by mathematics. This is achieved by building a model, written in mathematical language, that is simple to use yet contains all the essential information required to describe the system in question. For example, imagine we wanted to model the formation of sand dunes in a desert by using the information about each individual grain of sand. This would produce a model too complicated to understand and impossible to use. Yet, to build a successful model it suffices to exploit the fact that on the scale of a dune length that is much larger than an individual grain, sand appears to behave like a continuous medium. In this example, the mathematical model addresses the phenomenon in question by focusing on a single scale, the length scale of the individual dunes. To put it another way, the essential behaviour of the system on the scale in question (length of a dune) is not dictated by the behaviour on finer scale (size of a grain). This however is not the case for many phenomena of great significance today, for example protein folding, catalytic processes or corrosion of metals, where the essential underlying behaviour spans a wide range of length and time scales.

As an illustrative example let us consider a typical Long bone in the body, whose primary function is to provide structural support under mechanical load. A particular phenomenon within Long bone is that its composition can change due to mechanical stresses applied over long time scales. This is achieved by the remodelling of bone to form patterns that are the most resistive and supportive to the changes in mechanical stress. This process begins with the mechanical load stimulating protein translation; the formed proteins then aid in the formation of vesicles and transporter molecules which finally deposit the minerals that form the bone. The complexity of the above explanation shows that for a mathematical model to successfully address the dynamical properties of bone it must include hierarchical behaviour that spans many time and length scales. This illustrates the fact that the simplest models of multi-scale phenomena are incredibly complicated and too difficult to use. The objective we face is to derive effective macroscopic models from complicated multi-scale models. This is where 'multi-scale analysis' and in particular the proposal comes in.

The project will develop new tools in the study of multi-scale models in material sciences, with a focus on a new class of artificial materials called "metamaterials". The role of these tools will be to extract macroscopic properties from multi-scale models of such materials while preserving the key information about the microscale in order to produce simple and accurate models for metamaterials. To achieve this goal I will cast the multi-scale models in question in the mathematical language of "operators" and by using recent advances in operator theory and multi-scale analysis provide a new analytical approach to describing the dominant behaviour of these operators (and, in turn, their model counterparts) resulting from the interaction of the different scales. The proposal will also make advances in the theory of homogenisation, which is a mathematical method used to find effective models of multi-scale systems. The proposal will exploit new advances in homogenisation theory to analyse a broad class of differential equations that model metamaterials.

Planned Impact

The proposed work will make advances in the context of multi-scale analysis, an area of great importance in many aspects of modern science, medicine and industry, such as in the understanding and predicting the processes in metal corrosion, catalytic mechanisms and organ function. The fundamental mathematical component of this work is to understand the relationship between microscopic and macroscopic processes that produce such multi-scale phenomena. The mathematical tools developed from this study are likely to be of interest in multi-scale modelling, as they will be able to strictly identify the dominant small-scale behaviour in a given multi-scale process and provide a simplified large-scale model with stharp information about its accuracy.

An equally crucial component of this proposal is the application of these novel tools to a class of emergent materials called "metamaterials". These man-made composites are created to have desirable macroscopic properties by specifying its microscopic structure. The tunable macroscopic properties of metamaterials has lead to metamaterial-based products which are compact, light and more energy efficient than the existing counterpart devices in the commercial, civil and defence sectors. The importance of this emerging industry is further highlighted by noting that the UK government recently began to focus on maintaining the high-level of UK-based research in metamaterials (with increased funding in the "Photonic Materials and Metamaterials" research theme of the EPSRC portfolio).

This proposal is poised to provide long-term benefits by deepening the understanding of the principles that underpin the development of metamaterials. This will be achieved by producing novel mathematical tools that accurately predict the macroscopic behaviour of a metamaterial with prescribed microstructure. Such studies will not only broaden the horizons of metamaterial applications but also provide the blueprints needed for their future synthesis.
 
Description New methods were developed that allow for one to produce error estimates for approximations to degenerate multi-scale problems. Two particularly useful methods were the method of quasi-periodic convergence and the method of error estimates using an operator theoretic version of matched asymptotic expansions.
Additionally a new type of wave was discovered to exist in composites that do not exist in homogeneous material: namely surface waves that travel below the surface of a composite without causing the boundary to move.
Exploitation Route The methods developed provide a good foundation to move from toy models to more realistic mathmematical models. Further development will be done in this direction.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Construction

 
Title New methods in asymptotic theory, particularly high-contrast variational problems 
Description We developed a novel framework to study the asymptotic behaviour of (a large class of) second-order linear elliptic PDE systems with periodic coefficients whose ellipticity constant degenerates in the limit of small period. We determine, under one-or-two readily verifiable assumptions, the leading-order behaviour of the (variational) problems and solutions with respect to the (small period) parameter. Error estimates, uniform in right-hand-side, are readily deduced in this process of determination. Spectral asymptotics with error estimates directly follow. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2018 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Controllably accurate models of composite performance with respect to physical parameters are now envisionable in a wide class of settings of modern relevance in the context of high-contrast / metamaterial-type composites. 
 
Title Composite Elastic Wave Waveguide 
Description A Composite Elastic Wave Waveguide design with significant acoustic dampening properpties is proposed. This design was based on theoretical results published in the PI's work: Cherednichenko, K., Cooper, S. (2015). On the existence of high-frequency boundary resonances in layered elastic media. PROCEEDINGS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY A, 471 (2178). 
IP Reference GB1507537.7 
Protection Patent application published
Year Protection Granted 2015
Licensed No
Impact A Composite Elastic Wave Waveguide design was proposed with significant acoustic dampening properpties. A proof-of-concept project that straddled the Engineering, Physics and Mathematics department at Bath University was undertaken; a composite proto-type was built and tested. The tests show that the composite performed as theoretically predicted and offered good quality acoustic dampening properties.
 
Description Participant of the 3rd SAMBa Integrative Think Tank. 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Integrative Think Tanks bring together students, academics and external partners over a week.
Problems are presented and students, with support from academic attendees from the Department
of Mathematical Sciences, are expected to formulate research problems and routes for solving them.
The partner organisations attending were GKN (http://www.gkn.com/), Airbus
(http://www.airbus.com/), and the UK Met Office (http://www.metoffice.gov.uk/).
Almost 90 people took part. Participants included students and academics from SAMBa, the Departments of Mathematical Sciences, Mechanical Engineering and Computer Science, and external participants from the universities of Exeter, Torino, Chalmers and São Paulo.

From the perspective of my research group, we formulated several industrial problems mathematically and have a clear outlook for the development of their solutions.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
URL http://www.bath.ac.uk/math-sci/postgraduate/samba/news-events/third-samba-integrative-think-tank.htm...
 
Description Participation in `Mathematics, Mechanics and Physics for materials of tomorrow" workshop at ICMS 26-30/10/15 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Materials science has been a flourishing field in both the theoretical and applied sciences for decades. This workshop focuses on partially ordered materials, somewhere in between the conventional solid and liquid phases of matter.


The workshop has three central themes: mathematics and modelling of:

LCs and complex fluids
bio-materials
nano-materials and new technologies


All three themes involve partially ordered materials, singularities, challenging questions in dynamical evolution and offer possibilities for synergistic intra- and inter-disciplinary connections amongst mathematicians, theoretical physicists, experimentalists and engineers in the UK and India.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
URL http://icms.org.uk/workshops/mmp
 
Description Participation in ``Computational and Mathematical Aspects of Maxwell's equations" workshop at Durham 12-20/07/2016 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact This symposium will explore the mathematical problems associated with Maxwell's equations in several modern application areas:

1) Photonics and Resonances: This looks at the propagation of electromagnetic waves in periodic structures. Mathematical questions include the study of affects on the spectrum of the underlying operator resulting from the geometry or strength of perturbations to the periodic structure.

2) Metamaterials and Cloaking: Metamaterials are usually constructed by using repeated microscopic structures to achieve properties not observed in natural materials. These properties are usually achieved in some abnormal regimes, which can only be approximated in actual production processes. This provides difficult mathematical problems, such as analysing the rate of convergence of various approximations and defining the optimal way to approximate. Mathematical techniques include homogenization theory.

3) Inverse Problems in Electromagnetism: Many (medical) imaging techniques make use of electromagnetic waves. Recently, there has been much interest in so called mixed mode or hybrid imaging. Mathematical questions include: unique reconstruction of the image, development of reconstruction algorithms and reconstruction in the presence of incomplete data. One tool used successfully in this area has been harmonic analysis.

An additional focus will be the interface between analytical questions for Maxwell systems and results obtained using numerical methods, in particular novel numerical techniques based on new mathematical analysis, e.g. multi-scale methods which exploit ideas from homogenization, special methods which capture geometric and high-energy asymptotics, as well as the use of verified computations as a constituent tool in a formal analytical proof.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
URL http://www.maths.dur.ac.uk/events/Meetings/LMS/104/
 
Description Participation in ``Metamaterials Beyond Photonics" workshop at ICMS 20-24/06/16 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact A metamaterial is a synthetic inhomogeneous material with wave bearing properties that differ significantly from those exhibited by homogeneous media, due to its complex microstructure. The idea of being inhomogeneous materials to control and guide wave propagation is well established: for example the optical fibres used in the telecommunications industry are typically constructed by placing a cladding around a core with a higher dielectric constant. The aim of this meeting are to keep the UK at the forefront of developments in this rapidly developing field and to enable young researchers to meet and interact with established international experts. The workshop will bring together mathematicians, physicists and engineers to exchange ideas and contrast their different approaches to the theoretical and practical challenges that metamaterials present.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
URL http://icms.org.uk/workshops/metamaterials
 
Description Participation in ``Operators, Operator families and Asymptotics" workshop, Bath 16-19/05/16 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The conference will make an overview of the state of the art in a rapidly developing area of analysis concerned with application of the techniques of operator theory to the asymptotic analysis of parameter-dependent differential equations and boundary-value problems. From the physical point of view, the parameter normally represents a length-scale in the situation modelled by the equation: for example, a wavelength in wave propagation, or the inhomogeneity size in the theory of periodic composites. The theory of linear operators in a Hilbert space (symmetric, self-adjoint, dissipative, non-selfadjoint), which has enjoyed several decades of outstanding progress, had been, for much of its time, restricted to abstract analysis of general classes of operators, accompanied by ad-hoc examples and applications to perturbations of the Laplace operator. The meeting is aimed at making a step-change in re-assessing the existing body of knowledge in the related areas, as a modern operator-theoretic version of the classical asymptotic analysis. This will generate new research directions in the asymptotic study of operator families, where the abstract and applied streams are aligned with each other.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
URL http://www.euro-math-soc.eu/event/mon-16-may-16-0000/operators-operator-families-and-asymptotics
 
Description Participation in ``Young Applied Analysts in the UK" workshop, Bath 26-27/05/16 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The main purpose of the meeting is to bring together early career researchers and PhD
students in the UK working in applied analysis, in particular in the area of mathematical
materials science.
This meeting aims at encouraging collaboration and networking, and at increasing the
visibility of this growing applied analysis community.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
URL http://people.bath.ac.uk/ls767/YAAUK2.html
 
Description Workshop: Recent advances in homogenisation theory 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact This event brought together UK and European-based leading experts working in homogenisation theory. The workshop emphasis was on recent advances of the field with focus on the contributions to composite material science.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL http://salcooper.co.uk/workshop-on-recent-advances-in-homogenisation-theory/