Investigating the interactions between Pt nanoparticle catalysts and their substrates

Lead Research Organisation: University of Birmingham
Department Name: Chemical Engineering

Abstract

The widespread use of platinum as a catalyst has led to wide-ranging research efforts to understand its activity, improve its effectiveness, and also to obtain similar performance from less expensive materials.This project proposes a set of investigations to better understand the way in which Pt nanoparticles interact with the carbon materials that are commonly used as a substrate to the catalyst, with the expectation that conclusions and strategies can be developed that would be applicable widely across supported metal catalysts. The Applicant has extensive experience (>20 papers) in the area of particle impact electrochemistry ("PIE"), having worked in the group that pioneered the technique, and proposes to utilise this method in this study [e.g. N.V.Rees, Electrochem. Commun. 2014,43,83]. Despite some theoretical work, there are no comprehensive studies into the control of the particle-substrate interaction - e.g. varying contact time, numbers of contacts (single vs multi-bounce), etc. Understanding of the factors that contribute to the particle-substrate interaction will have the following direct applications:
The project will consider two themes.

Theme 1: Establishing flexibility in kinetic determination
The traditional means of determining the catalytic activity of nanoparticles are becoming recognised as unreliable due to the presence of a support: the overpotential method is affected by the porosity and thickness of a support layer [Sims et al, Sens Actuators B 2010, 144, 153] and the Koutecky-Levich approach to determine kinetics via rotating disk voltammetry has also been shown to be sensitive to its surface roughness [Masa et al, NanoRes 2014,7,71].
The use of PIE, therefore, is perhaps one of the simplest means to unambiguously measure the kinetics of a catatyic process. However, in order to reliably investigate multiple electron transfers (which are commonly coupled to proton transfer), it will be necessary to have greater understanding and a degree of control over the particle-substrate collision in order to observe the sluggish reactions relevant to energy generation (e.g. oxygen reduction, alcohol oxidation).
In order to study such effects, a walljet reactor (WJR) will be designed and tested, based on an impinging jet arrangement in order to enable straightforward control over the parameters affecting the particle-electrode collision. It will also facilitate separation of reacted and unreacted particles (for theme 2). The well-defined hydrodynamics also simplify computational modelling of the NP system.

Theme 2: Developing a novel fabrication methodology
It has been shown [Y.-G. Zhou et al, ChemPhysChem 2011,12,2085; Chem.Phys.Lett. 2011,511,183] that the equivalents of monolayer and multilayer shells can be electrodeposited onto a core nanoparticle during its collision with a substrate electrode when potentiostatted in the underpotential deposition (upd) and bulk deposition regions respectively. However, no separation of reacted/unreacted particles was possible and so no physical charaterisation on the resulting core@shell particles was ever conducted.
The WJR will effect such a separation and so the homogeneity of deposited overlayers will be investigated, with frutehr work conducted to improve homogeneity where needed.
Control of the particle-substrate contact should enable a degree of control to be applied to the depositon of mulitple layers: useful for core-shell combinations where no upd region exists and where specific shell thicknesses are desired. Careful characterisation will also shed light on the homogeneity of these shell layers, and . Fabrication via PIE is in principle upscaleable via impinging jet arrangements, and work will be conducted to demonstrate and develop this.

Planned Impact

The Impact of this research will be primarily academic in the short term, but there is potential for significant wider impact in the 5-10 year horizon in the Industrial context.

1) Academic impact
This will be in two parts, linked by an increased understanding and control of the dynamic interaction of nanoparticles (NPs) with the carbon substrate.
(i) Flexibility in kinetic measurement
The kinetic processes that can be observed and quantified via particle-impact electrochemistry (PIE) are limited by the contact time of the NP with electrode. Establishing an experimental control of the contact time between NP and electrode will enable multi-electron transfer redox processes to be interrogated. At present the maximum reported is a 2 electron process, whereas for widespread use in catalysis research a higher number of electron-transfer processes are required (e.g. 4 for the full reduction of oxygen, 6 for methanol oxidation, etc).
(ii) Fabrication methodology
Control over contact time and collision parameters will also have impacts for the fabrication of core@shell architectures, for cases where either (a) no underpotential deposition region exists for the desired combination of metals, or (b) a narrow range of shell multilayers are needed. The particle-impact electrodeposition (PIED) method does not generally involve additional dispersion agents (capping agents, surfactants, etc), and can be operated in protic and aprotic solvents, inert atmospheres etc for sensitive or reactive species.

In both cases, the research will focus on Pt as the nanoparticle of interest, due to its widespread use in catalysis. However, the results are expected to be generally applicable of all conducting/semiconducting nanoparticles.
Impact will be achieved through rapid publication of results in high impact journals, and presentation at appropriate national/international conferences such as ISE 2015 (Taipei) or 2016 (The Hague), International Symposium on Electrocatalysis ECAT, ECS 2015 (Chicago).

2) Industrial Impact
Although fundamentally electrochemical in nature, this proposal has cross-disciplinary reach due to the occurrence of nanoscale charge transfer processes across the physical and natural sciences, and engineering. In principle, the methodology to be developed has application wherever a charge-transfer process (and accompanying reactions) occurs at a nanometric object or particle.
The ubiquity of charge-transfer catalysts across Industry, from synthetic applications to energy applications creates the potential for significant industrial, and economic impact to be achieved by this programme of research in the mid to long term. The global catalysis market has been estimated to be worth $19.5bn by 2016, and with a significant proportion of catalysts involved in charge-transfer reactions and processes, it is reasonable to foresee that improvements in catalytic design, fabrication or implementation arising from insights gained in the proposed research will translate into realisable economic impact.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description We have set up and characterised a jet electrode for studying nanoparticles
We have found that the nanoparticle aggregates (metal nanoparticles are known to aggregate over time) break apart in the jet stream in a way that can be described with a simple mathematical model. Some further work is underway to finalise a manuscript for publication.
We have successfully deposited an overlayer of a different metal to the metal nanoparticles (core-shell architecture) and have found that the jet-speed provides some control over the overlayer thickness. We are currently trying to image the resulting core-shell particles and will seek to publish results as soon as possible.
Some delays have been incurred due to end of PDRA's contract and no students immediately available to complete the work.
Exploitation Route Follow-on work based on our findings within this grant will form the basis of significant research within the Group in 2019-21.
In particular, preliminary results for the fabrication of core-shell particles with controlled shell thickness are highly promising, and have potentially high impact. Application has been found in the recovery of trace metal from solution as (i) a means of controlled fabrication of core-shell active particles from effluent, and (ii) recovery of valuable metals from effluent for recycling and clean-up. This work is the subject of and EPIF funded PhD student and a full grant application to Leverhulme Trust.
Sectors Chemicals,Energy,Environment,Other

 
Description The findings from this project have been slow to publish due to the need for more detailed analysis techniques - these have now become available and papers are being completed. The results have been presented at 2-3 events with Industry - directly leading to advanced discussions with the Industry leader on precious metal catalysts, as the methods researched in the project create potential solutions to several issues they wish to solve. These discussions have accelerated in late 2017/early 2018 and have directly led to (i) participation in a H2020 bid (recently submitted), and (ii) application for CASE award studentships in the past 2 months. UPdate 2019: a grant application extending this work is in final stages of evaluation by Leverhulme Trust, and a PhD student (funded via EPIF) has commenced follow-on work in Oct 2018 in collaboration with Johnson Matthey.
First Year Of Impact 2018
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink,Chemicals,Environment
Impact Types Societal,Economic

 
Description Recycling Critical Metals: Making Catalysts Directly from Waste
Amount £262,000 (GBP)
Funding ID RPG-2019-146 
Organisation The Leverhulme Trust 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country United Kingdom
Start 01/2020 
End 12/2023
 
Description UoB Institute for Strategic Metals 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Presentation to a mixed audience of academic researchers, business/law practitioners and Industry members, as part of a day workshop of critical metals. Questions and discussion followed the session, with several potential collaborators requesting further information and discussion 'off line' at a later date to be followed up.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017