Non-classical paramagnetic susceptibility and anisotropy in lanthanide coordination complexes: a combined experimental and theoretical study

Lead Research Organisation: Durham University
Department Name: Chemistry

Abstract

Rare earth elements are used widely in society and industry in the 21st century. Even your mobile phone contains up to 9 different rare earth elements, harnessing their unique magnetic and optical properties. Advances in the application of these properties requires that we understand better the physicochemical origins of their behaviour. A key part of this process is to develop new theories that test our understanding, and guide us in the design of new chemical applications.

Of particular importance is the magnetic behaviour of the rare earth elements in their chemical compounds, and the ramifications of the directional dependence of the 'paramagnetism' that arises from unpaired electron density. This behaviour has important consequences not only in the design of new magnetic materials, but also in their use in magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) where they have been used since 1988 as contrast agents to assist in clinical diagnosis of disease. For example, paramagnetic lanthanide coordination complexes are being created as proton chemical shift magnetic resonance probes, in a radical change in imaging technology that directly relates to the importance of imaging technologies in healthcare.

This multidisciplinary project brings together three teams of scientists with complementary expertise in Durham, Manchester and Southampton to develop and test new theoretical and computational approaches that will promote a better understanding of the magnetic properties of new series of rare earth chemical compounds that are directly relevant to their application in magnetism and their scope for use in MRI.

Planned Impact

The project relates to the EPSRC Physical Science capability theme, notably in the direct involvement with synthetic coordination/supramolecular chemistry. Industry in the UK has strategic interests in developing magnet technology (Oxford Instruments) and in promoting new chemical probe applications (e.g. GE-Amersham/ GSK). These companies will be made aware of the scientific advances defined in this work, either via academic channels of conference dissemination and primary publications, or by direct contact, once commercial confidentiality is properly protected. These cases will be handled by the University's Business and Innovations Service: n.b. Durham Chemistry was placed top for Impact in REF 2014, and the PI was responsible for one of the 4* case studies.

The PI and Co-I's will continue to cooperate with research groups around Europe (e.g. PI via participation in the European Society for Molecular Imaging; co-Is via their involvement with the RSC ESR Group as Secretary and as co-Director of the EPSRC National EPR Facility) exchanging information, publicising key advances and organising short-term scientific missions to selected research groups (e.g. C Faber/Munster; S. Aime/Torino), aided by the annual meetings of these cohorts.

Nationally, the background to this project links to the EPSRC Challenge theme, Healthcare Technologies (involving Medical Imaging and Biological Chemistry), creating impact by improved predictive/diagnostic capability through the development of new types of contrast agent. Since 1993, the PI has been advising two of the major European Contrast Agent/Imaging companies and so is able to contact either Bracco spa (Milano/Ivrea) and/or Guerbet sa (Paris) to assess their level of commercial interest. More recently, the PI was a key scientific adviser a multi-district litigation (4 bellwether trials, scores of cases settled out of Court in 2011/12), as a result of the poor kinetic stability of acyclic gadolinium contrast agents (e.g. Omniscan/Optimark) that were given to patients with renal failure and who subsequently developed nephrogenic systemic fibrosis. The PI has a record of assessing the impact of such work, and the need to behave cautiously when raising interest/awareness (e.g. via media releases) in considering the true prospects for such work.

Publications

10 25 50

publication icon
Harnden A (2019) Employing paramagnetic shift for responsive MRI probes in Coordination Chemistry Reviews

publication icon
Poh AWJ (2018) Aggregation of Rare Earth Coordination Complexes in Solution Studied by Paramagnetic and DOSY NMR. in Chemistry (Weinheim an der Bergstrasse, Germany)

publication icon
Senanayake PK (2017) A new paramagnetically shifted imaging probe for MRI. in Magnetic resonance in medicine

 
Description The teams at Durham/Manchester and Southampton have developed a more profound understanding of the way that small changes in the structure or solvation of rare earth coordination complexes affect both the the chemical shift of integral proton resonances or their rate of relaxation from higher to lower energy levels. Critically this shift and relaxation is dependent on the magnitude and directional dependence of the main component of the magnetic susceptibility tensor. Indeed, the position of the main component is exquisitely sensitive to small changes, meaning that the work of many others in paramagnetic magnetic resonance studies needs to be reassessed.
Exploitation Route The better understanding of the determinants of the resonance frequency of a' magnetic spin label' in a small molecule containing a rare earth ion may prove useful in developing new probes for use in vivo, where the frequency at which the probe absorbs energy (i.e. resonates) is subtly dependent on the local environment .
Sectors Education,Healthcare,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology

 
Description Non-Classical Magnetic Susceptibility Anisotropy 
Organisation University of Manchester
Department School of Chemistry Manchester
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Durham is the lead partner in a collaborative EPSRC fund 3 way grant, with the Universities of Manchester (Prof EJ McInnes, Dr NR Chilton), and Southampton (Dr I Kuprov) . The Durham team work very closely with each University and we meet x3 a year to plan work and define publications. The grant ends at the same time ±3 months at each site.
Collaborator Contribution Durham chemists make the lanthanide complexes that are studied; Manchester scientists use EPR and CASSCF calculations in tandem with magnetic susceptibilioty measurements and work with Southampton to define the magnetic susceptibility tensor for series of complexes and its sensitivity to perturbation. Thus EP/N007034/1 and EP/ N006909/1 and EP/N006895/1 are based on the same plan of work.
Impact The joint published papers are in each partner's reports.
Start Year 2016
 
Description Non-Classical Magnetic Susceptibility Anisotropy 
Organisation University of Southampton
Department Chemistry
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Durham is the lead partner in a collaborative EPSRC fund 3 way grant, with the Universities of Manchester (Prof EJ McInnes, Dr NR Chilton), and Southampton (Dr I Kuprov) . The Durham team work very closely with each University and we meet x3 a year to plan work and define publications. The grant ends at the same time ±3 months at each site.
Collaborator Contribution Durham chemists make the lanthanide complexes that are studied; Manchester scientists use EPR and CASSCF calculations in tandem with magnetic susceptibilioty measurements and work with Southampton to define the magnetic susceptibility tensor for series of complexes and its sensitivity to perturbation. Thus EP/N007034/1 and EP/ N006909/1 and EP/N006895/1 are based on the same plan of work.
Impact The joint published papers are in each partner's reports.
Start Year 2016