Nonlinear Ultrasonic Stimulated Infrared Thermography (NUSIT)

Lead Research Organisation: University of Bath
Department Name: Mechanical Engineering

Abstract

Micro-cracks in aircraft primary structures or nuclear plants can easily spread over long periods of time and, if undetected, may lead to catastrophic failure conditions. Non-destructive evaluation (NDE) techniques are a necessary tool to guarantee that a component is free of any harmful damage. Thermosonics (also known as ultrasonic stimulated thermography) is an NDE technique that uses an infrared camera to image material defects by detecting the frictional heating at crack surfaces when a part under inspection is vibrated. These vibrations are produced by a high-power ultrasonic horn being pressed against the surface of the component under investigation. Thermosonics has the advantages of being rapid, affordable and more sensitive to micro-cracks detection than traditional infrared thermography. However, the ultrasonic horn used in thermosonics is a crude means of exciting vibrations. The mechanical contact between the material and the horn typically results in an uncontrolled generation of vibrations, which makes thermosonics results non-reproducible and, therefore, this technique not reliable.

NUSIT proposes a reliable and reproducible alternative to thermosonics by developing a novel hybrid NDE inspection method, here named as nonlinear vibro-thermography, obtained by a combination of nonlinear ultrasonic techniques and thermography. Nonlinear ultrasonic methods measure the material nonlinear effects caused by the interaction of ultrasonic waves with the "clapping" motion or the frictional contact between micro-crack surfaces. As a result of this interaction, other frequency components of the single input frequency can be generated. These new frequencies indicate that a damage is present within the material. Nonlinear ultrasonic methods will provide in NUSIT a reliable means to select the input frequency that will enhance these material nonlinear effects. This will allow high sensitivity to micro-cracks detection and repeatability. Traditional thermography will be then used to image the frictional heating at the damage location. The input frequency selection process will also be optimised in NUSIT by analysing the concept of nonlinear local defect resonance for input power reduction.

This eighteen-month project will be mainly focused on assessing real-life material damage such as corrosion micro-cracks in metallic structures and impact flaws in composite materials. To accomplish these objectives, NUSIT is supported by the Nuclear National Laboratory and Rolls-Royce that are providing a set of steel nuclear storage canisters with corrosion micro-cracks and impact damaged composite aero-engine components as in-kind contribution. Nonlinear vibro-thermography will produce a step-change in the non-destructive inspection of both metallic and composite materials by ensuring rapid and affordable inspection of large areas and complex geometries, reliable excitation and high sensitivity to the presence of micro-structural flaws. The overall aim of NUSIT will be to take nonlinear vibro-thermography out of the laboratory and introduce it successfully into industry.

Planned Impact

The successful implementation of nonlinear vibro-thermography as a novel non-destructive evaluation (NDE) inspection system will ensure significant reduction in maintenance time and costs as well as the increase of safety due to the high sensitivity and reliability in detecting material defects for aeronautic, nuclear and high value manufacturing industries. The UK has 17% of the global aerospace market share with revenue of £24 billion and is responsible for 3.6% national employment. With the international civil aerospace market forecast to grow to $4 trillion by 2030, the UK market has the opportunity to grow to $352 billion by 2030. The civil nuclear industry also plays a pivotal role in the UK economy as it employs around 85,000 people of which 45,000 work at power plants and 40,000 in the supply chain. In addition, as noted by EPSRC, the development of novel material inspection techniques has been identified as a national priority area by the Department for Business Innovation and Skills. NDE techniques play a significant role in High Value Manufacturing as highlighted by Innovate UK. The UK is world-leading in NDE development having 24 of the 183 key NDE companies, with a global turnover in 2012 of about £5.6bn.

Industrial: Rolls-Royce and the Nuclear National Laboratory will benefit directly from the outcome of NUSIT. Indeed, by improving the efficiency of aircraft maintenance operation, extending the damage tolerance boundaries of aircraft components and reducing the materials usage, NUSIT will contribute to decrease CO2 emissions for commercial aircraft by 50% per passenger-kilometre. Such a reduction should enable a lighter, more fuel efficient next generation of aircraft in the next 5-20 years. This project will also contribute to reduce the operations and maintenance costs for nuclear power plants, which are usually realised during planned maintenance and refuelling outage periods and account for nearly 91% of planned energy loss. A technology live demonstrator will be built in collaboration with the Nuclear National Laboratory and Rolls-Royce towards the end of the project to showcase the proposed nonlinear vibro-thermography system. Input from both Rolls-Royce and the Nuclear National Laboratory will be available throughout the project via quarterly meetings with senior NDE specialised personnel. Ciampa will work with the University of Bath's Research Innovation Services, to conduct a review of Intellectual Property (IPs) developed in this project and, if applicable, to protect it through patent, copyright and design registration processes. Potential beneficiaries/partners will be sought through the ongoing collaborations with the Nuclear National Laboratory, Airbus, Rolls Royce and AgustaWestland UK, as well as the industrial partners of the EU FP7 ALAMSA and Horizon 2020 EXTREME projects.

Policy: The UK is committed to reduction of emissions. Results from NUSIT that enable such reductions will help deliver such commitments.

Public: The general public will see health benefits from reduced emissions and financial benefits as reduced flight costs are converted to reduced ticket prices. Lighter aircraft may also result in less powerful engines being required and subsequently a reduction of noise near airports. The technological advances of NUSIT will reflect in higher quality of structured inspection that mitigate the risk of a latent nuclear safety event and provide public risk awareness and acceptance for nuclear power. Open access publication and public data storage will ensure all information relating to NUSIT is directly available to the public and to any aerospace or nuclear related UK companies.

Staff: Ciampa and the PDRA will develop transferable knowledge of ultrasonic and thermography NDE inspection technologies and data interpretation/processing through collaborations and visits to industrial partners.

Publications

10 25 50

publication icon
Ciampa F (2017) On the generation of nonlinear damage resonance intermodulation for elastic wave spectroscopy. in The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America

publication icon
Ginzburg D (2017) SHM of single lap adhesive joints using subharmonic frequencies in Smart Materials and Structures

publication icon
Scarselli G (2017) Non-linear methods based on ultrasonic waves to analyse disbonds in single lap joints in Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part C: Journal of Mechanical Engineering Science

 
Description This eighteen-month project has led to the following research findings:
- Different material nonlinear effects were studied in this project to enhance the driving frequency selection process in the proposed nonlinear ultrasonic stimulated thermography. The second order nonlinear material effect and modulation sidebands were found the most reliable material nonlinear features for different types of damage and materials. The use of these two nonlinear elastic signatures has led to an enhancement of the acoustic energy at the damage location for the generation of frictional heat.
- A new technique called "nonlinear narrow sweep excitation method (NNSM)" was developed to efficiently excite the local resonance frequencies of the damaged region in order to give rise to the highest nonlinear elastic response in the material leading to a high heat generation at the crack surface.
- Both impact damage in aerospace composite materials and corrosion crack in steel components for the nuclear industry were detected with the proposed nonlinear ultrasonic stimulated thermography. These types of material and damage were relevant to the industrial partners of this project.
- Nonlinear ultrasonic stimulated thermography has enhanced the sensitivity of non-destructive evaluation methods to micro-cracks, which was not possible with traditional optical thermography and thermosonics.
- A new mathematical model capable of describing the generation of nonlinear elastic features associated with the nonlinear local damage resonance effect was developed. Such a model has led to a better understanding of the creation of nonlinear ultrasonic phenomena in order to enhance the sensitivity of nonlinear ultrasonic methods.
- In addition to nonlinear ultrasonic stimulated thermography, two novel ultrasonic algorithms were developed with a sparse array of surface bonded ultrasonic transducers in order to localise micro damage in composite components.
Exploitation Route The proposed methodologies developed in this project will benefit the non-destructive evaluation (NDE) and structural health monitoring (SHM) research and industrial communities, as nonlinear vibro-thermography will enhance the quantitative assessment of structural defects. This will enhance safety of both aerospace and nuclear components and the reliability in detecting material micro-damage.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Other

 
Description Over the years, the proposed "nonlinear ultrasonic stimulated thermography" has proved to enhance the sensitivity of non-destructive evaluation methods to early stage material defects and micro-cracks. It has also led to new research streams on nonlinear ultrasound in both metallic and composite materials, and to the development of novel sensing technologies by replacing contact ultrasonic transducers with airborne contactless sensors, thus achieving a fully non-contact material inspection system. This has had a dramatic impact on industrial applications (e.g., aerospace and wind energy) where it is not always possible or feasible to bond transducers and use water or other liquids as the coupling material between the sensing probe and the component under inspection. Moreover, the applied research on nonlinear ultrasonic methods and thermography proposed in this project has led to several publications in peer-reviewed international journals.
Sector Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Energy,Transport
Impact Types Societal,Economic

 
Title Nonlinear ultrasonic stimulated thermography 
Description Nonlinear ultrasonic stimulated thermography is a new material inspection technique that is capable of detecting and imaging corrosion micro-cracks in steel nuclear waste storage canisters and impact flaws in aerospace composite components. It is obtained as a combination of nonlinear ultrasonic techniques and thermography. Whilst nonlinear ultrasonic methods provide a first screening of damage by measuring the material nonlinear response, thermography is used to reveal its location and severity. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2017 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact The successful implementation of Nonlinear ultrasonic stimulated thermography as a novel non-destructive evaluation (NDE) inspection system ensures significant reduction in maintenance time and costs as well as the increase of safety due to the high sensitivity and reliability in detecting material defects for aeronautic, nuclear and high value manufacturing industries. 
 
Title Nonlinear narrow sweep excitation method (NNSM) 
Description A new technique called "nonlinear narrow sweep excitation method (NNSM)" was developed to efficiently excite the local resonance frequencies of the damaged region in order to give rise to the highest nonlinear elastic response in the material leading to a high heat generation at the crack surface. 
Type Of Material Data analysis technique 
Year Produced 2017 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact The nonlinear narrow sweep excitation method has allowed a reliable driving frequency selection process for the proposed nonlinear ultrasonic stimulated thermography. 
 
Title Nonlinear ultrasonic stimulated thermography 
Description Nonlinear ultrasonic stimulated thermography is a new material inspection technique that is capable of detecting and imaging corrosion micro-cracks in steel nuclear waste storage canisters and impact flaws in aerospace composite components. It is obtained as a combination of nonlinear ultrasonic techniques and thermography. Whilst nonlinear ultrasonic methods provide a first screening of damage by measuring the material nonlinear response, thermography is used to reveal its location and severity. 
Type Of Technology New/Improved Technique/Technology 
Year Produced 2017 
Impact The successful implementation of Nonlinear ultrasonic stimulated thermography as a novel non-destructive evaluation (NDE) inspection system ensures significant reduction in maintenance time and costs as well as the increase of safety due to the high sensitivity and reliability in detecting material defects for aeronautic, nuclear and high value manufacturing industries. 
 
Description Invited seminar at the Imperial College of London 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact I was invited for a seminar on nonlinear ultrasonic methods and thermography at the Imperial College of London on 7th February 2018. I presented most of the analytical and experimental results achieved during my EPSRC project.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018