Mapping the biomechanical properties of the sub-glottal region of the human vocal tract

Lead Research Organisation: De Montfort University
Department Name: Faculty of Technology

Abstract

Phonation, or our ability to speak, arises from the process of delivering a controlled exhalation of air across the vocal folds (often know as vocal cords). This causes the vocal folds to vibrate, at a frequency that can be controlled by our vocal muscles. The resultant airflow is now modulated and passes into our 'vocal tract', which is in effect our mouth. We then form the modulated air flow into sounds by muscular control of our tongue, lip and other vocal tract features.

The starting point for phonation therefore is the oscillation of our vocal folds. As we exhale, the moving passage of air creates a pressure drop; this in turn causes these soft tissues to rise up, until they meet. When full closure occurs the airflow ceases, and the air pressure returns to normal, causing the focal folds to fall back again. It is this cycle, repeated at audible frequencies that creates the initial modulated airflow, that we form into sounds. This process is known as the myoelastic cycle; which was first described by Ingo Titze.

Whilst visualisation of the vocal tract is readily achievable superior to the vocal folds, there is very little published data on the impact of low pressure inferior to vocal folds. Recent research has presented strong evidence that vortices form in the sub-glottal region, which will inherently aid closure by reducing the air pressure below the vocal folds.

Our recently published work, using data obtained with our partners at Wisconsin Medical Centers presented data that indicated that the elastic properties of the sub-glottal mucosa were non-linear - such that their deformation under low pressure would cause a funnel effect inferior to the vocal folds. This variable deformation could offer support for the vortex theory. The study was carried out using porcine larynges. UKE Hamburg have offered us the opportunity to repeat this study using excised human donor larynges.

The purpose of this OTG is to establish and enable the co-supervision of a Dotoral study that will measure and map the elastic properties of the sub-glottal mucosa in human tissue. This data will be made available to other international teams who are actively examining the importance of the aerodynamics of the vocal tract, and how it impacts on our ability to phonate. We will develop mathematical models to explain the data that is measured, and determine if it does support our theory that deformation of the mucosa below the vocal folds results in a funnel shape that promotes the creation of vortices. If our theory is correct then it indicates the importance of this region in giving us the ability to speak.

In order to maximise the cost effectiveness of the grant we will also carry out trials of our innovative laser speckle skin analysis device. This has been developed to investigate if laser speckle can be used to detect lesions in skin (e.g. melanoma). We will carry out a series of experiments with excised donor human larynges to determine if laser speckle could also be deployed by phonosurgeons to detect tissue damage in vocal folds that is not visible from the surface.

Other international research institutions have expressed interest in applying the laser speckle technique in new areas of research if the UKE study is successful.

Planned Impact

This research will help to develop our understanding of the importance and properties of the sub-glottal region, that is traditionally hard to visualise. The impact on a patients ability to phonate should this region be damaged will be better understood, enabling more informed choices to be made about intervention. Provision of new knowledge of the role of the deformation of the mucosa inferior to the vocal folds during phonation. This will be relevant to clinicians, medical physicists and engineers researching innovation in medical devices.

The laser speckle study is at early stages. However our initial results on skin are promising, with published results indicating that the technique is capable of visualising hidden lesions. If successful this early study could lead to the development a new diagnostic techniques and a diagnostic tool for use of vocal fold tissue, and other mucosal tissues. Thus we could lead in to a new programme with both medical and commercial impacts. Should our research be successful then will be able to take forward the development of an innovative diagnostic tool (for which a patent is being sought). This will deliver a device that will aid the early, and more precise diagnosis, of vocal fold lesions, and thus directly aid patients. The evaluation of laser speckle as the basis of a new diagnostic tool to visualise hidden lesions. This will therefore be relevant to clinicians seeking innovative diagnostic techniques. We will also be better placed to secure a business partner to commercialise the device. There is an extensive and well serviced pharmaceuticals and medical devices cluster in the East Midlands that we can use to disseminate any emerging medical device.

Finally the development of an international partnership with UKE Hamburg and the potential to develop new international collaborations in the USA and Sweden has the potential to deliver more than one new international collaboration. It will also enable us to promote any new medical device that might arise outside of the UK.
 
Description Our first paper shows that there is a variable elastic modulus of the mucosa in the sub-glottal region. This is significant, as the resultant deformation under low pressure will result in the structure narrowing to form a cone. We need to examine the aerodynamic impact of this deformed structure, but intuitively it tells us that the air flow will accelerate over a longer distance, reducing the liklehood of turbulent flow - thus assisting the delivery of laminar air flow over the vocal folds. If proven by later work then it means that scarring or resection in this region will impact on the ability of th epatient to phonate. -- NEW -- More recent work using Computational Flow Dynamics is showing that the deformation characteristics due result in more laminar flow, and this has resulted in more external interest in this project
Exploitation Route The suglottal region is hard to study due to the difficulty in visualising this region. Despite this teams in Europe and the USA are developing aerodynamic models of the airflow entering the vocal tract. These models only take account of the deformation of the voca folds, our results indicate that deformation of the subglottal mucosa also needs to be taken in to account. Our results will be used by our colleagues elsewhere. Our Reseach Gate page is collecting followers, which I hope will increase when our first journal paper is published.
Sectors Healthcare

URL https://www.researchgate.net/project/3D-modelling-of-the-vocal-tract-from-CT-scans
 
Title Initial data harvesting from human donor tissue 
Description During the second visit to UKE Hamburg data was obtained from 6 donor tissue samples. That data has been used to model the predicted deformation of the subglottal mucosa during the low presssure point of the myoelastic cycle. We have used this for our first journalpaper now submitted, and if accpeted it will also be used at the next European conference. Once accepted we will post the data on Research Gate 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2016 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact The initial data indicates that the doformationin this region will result in improved laminar flow, and a more gradual accelartion over the vocal folds. 
URL https://www.researchgate.net/project/3D-modelling-of-the-vocal-tract-from-CT-scans
 
Description Fundamental data gathering of subglottal mucosa biomechanics 
Organisation University Medical Center Hamburg-Eppendorf
Country Germany 
Sector Hospitals 
PI Contribution The project requires the development of a 3D model of the subglottal vocal tract, which will be undertaken by 2 new CIs and a PhD student based at DeMontfort. This model will be used to determine the aerodynamics of this region, and how it is affected by deformation of the mucosa during the uplif phase of the myoelastic cycle. To quanity that UKE are supporting us by providing data that maps the elastic properties of the mucos with respect to anatomical context using donor human tissue.
Collaborator Contribution UKE have provided access to human tissue, and research staff to support data gethering.
Impact Early days - forst houirnal paper from basic data now ready for submission
Start Year 2016
 
Title Laryngeal Tensiometer 
Description The LT device was originally developed to support research funded by the EPSRC & The Royal Society. It has been under constant review since then, and my work in Quantitive Latyngology has been active since by first EOSRC award in 2002. Of interest now is that we have passed the first stage of an open tender to present innovative desings for medical devies to a US based medical devices and pharma business. This will add to the impact of my oghoing research if we secure this commercial funding. Only one other device that is able to directly quantify the biomechanical properties of vocal fold tssue in-vivo has been reported. It was the first, but is difficult to set up - our design in contrast can be speedily deployed in operating theatre. 
Type Diagnostic Tool - Non-Imaging
Current Stage Of Development Early clinical assessment
Year Development Stage Completed 2009
Development Status Actively seeking support
Impact It was enhanced our reputation, and thus enabled us to work with a range of international partners.